Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect MIL to pay

235 replies

Muggymama · 01/08/2021 11:57

MIL never thought she'd have grandkids due to.my DH being lifelong batchelor but we did and she has 3; DD15, DS12 & DS10.
She never buys them anything or gives them even few pounds when they visit but is very comfortably off and currently having very extensive improvements to her house (which we have to constantly listen to hear her moaning about, mess, poor workmanship, not turning up when should yadda, yadda).
My parents on the other hand, have very little but are so kind and bring their favourite treats and contribute to trips, little luxuries, pocket money etc.
AIBU to be bit miffed with MIL?
She is from a generation when things were easier too, free higher education, good pension at very early age etc.
I know it's her money but can't help feeling she is being selfish and little treats time to time would show she cares, understands them & knows what they like/ need.

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 01/08/2021 16:25

Why? I’m a GP from a generation when many things certainly were a lot easier - house prices for one, not to mention free university fees and a cost of living grant, according to your parents’ means.

I'm a GP too, & in my teens, university was almost exclusively for the middle classes, @GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER. The working class teenagers needed to be earning a wage: their families either could not afford, or did not see the point, of further education.

Panickingpavlova · 01/08/2021 16:23

Too many Dinasour

Surely it's better to ask?

Can I get the dc anything, do you need anything, here is x amount please use it as you see fit.. Save it for them, buy school shoes if they need them, or buy a toy?

Depends on their dc circumstances but that's what I would be doing, if my dc end up well off I'll take different strategies..
If they need money I'll target that!
I won't ever foist large presents on them or buy without asking, unless it's small things that don't matter. I won't buy nothing either..

icedcoffees · 01/08/2021 16:18

@FatCatThinCat

I don't think it's greedy or grasping to be upset that grandparents don't treat their grandkids. My grandma always kept our favourite treats in her cupboard in case we popped round. My MIL brings my DD's favourite treats halfway round the world when she comes to visit and DD is only her step grandchild. It speaks volumes that the OP's MIL doesn't bother.
Not everyone express love or emotion in the same way. It doesn't mean she loves them any less than grandparents who DO choose to buy toys and treats.

She sees them weekly and has them over to her house too - presumably she provides them with food, drinks and snacks (though they may not be their favourites).

Seeing grandchildren weekly is a much bigger commitment than buying them a few presents and bunging them some pocket money.

ChargingBuck · 01/08/2021 16:15

@mayaknew

OP i know exactly what you are saying. Its not about the money its about her being good to her dgcs. It must be really upsetting watching your mum give her last penny when your MIL has plenty but can't even bother to buy her dgcs a bar of chocolate.

However, MN is really weird about things like expecting financial help from parents, free childcare from parents etc. Its bonkers. Why would you as a parent watch your children struggle financially if you could help, or let them pay hundreds of pounds a month on childcare when you could provide it for free. MN is a really weird vibe sometimes.

I am really shocked at the presumption & entitlement of this post.

Grandparents have already done their childcare, by raising (& paying for) the parent of their GC. They may not even be retired & therefore"free" to provide childcare, & if they are lucky enough to have worked at a job that provides them an adequate pension, WTF makes you feel that they should now do your childcare for you?

Do they not deserve to enjoy the free time they have worked all their lives to earn?

Maggiesfarm · 01/08/2021 16:15

Does she not buy birthday or Christmas presents?

Seeline · 01/08/2021 16:14

What is the relationship between your DH and his mum? Are they close, do they hug slot, are they telling each other they live each other? Where is FIL? I don't come from a particularly demonstrative family, but never doubted I was loved.

Bollindger · 01/08/2021 16:10

Have you ever asked her to come shopping with you?
My mum gave cash as gifts, as she could never decide, unless she stole my idea.
If you ask her to shop with you, then is the time to talk about it

Notmoresugar · 01/08/2021 16:07

She lacks kindness.
It's totally her loss.
Tightness is one of the worst traits a person can have imo.

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 16:04

YANBU OP but you cant really expect her to change now. I also grew up working class/poor and my aunts and uncles would give us loose change from their pockets if we met them unexpectedly or would bring sweets or the like if visiting. We do the same and my own DM used to be forever just picking up the odd thing when they were little or giving DC a couple of quid or whatever when visiting. As she was their only grandparent after toddler stage then she also felt a need to compensate as all her other grandchildren had another set of Grandparents. She wasn't well off and DMiL was also generous with her time and what little she had while she was alive.

I can't fathom mean-ness personally.

ChilliChoco · 01/08/2021 16:04

YANBU OP. You are neither grabby nor mean.
I think your MIL is mean spirited and a lack of generosity is something that stinks, especially when it concerns her own grandchildren.
It's the thoughtlessness that is so unpleasant; it is not to do with the amount of the gift.
I am not sure you can change her. However, your children will just recognise that your parents are the generous ones.

ChargingBuck · 01/08/2021 16:04

Our children are going to be saddled with debt on completing their education, not have the same opportunities and have to work well into their old age.

& how, exactly, is this your MiL's fault?

You do realise you chose to have children, & they are your responsibility, not your MiL's, don't you?

Maybe she isn't especially maternal.
She came from a generation when it was almost unthinkable for women not to have children. You could have chosen not to ... but you wanted them, so save up & help them out yourself, if you want them to have a university education.

FatCatThinCat · 01/08/2021 16:02

I don't think it's greedy or grasping to be upset that grandparents don't treat their grandkids. My grandma always kept our favourite treats in her cupboard in case we popped round. My MIL brings my DD's favourite treats halfway round the world when she comes to visit and DD is only her step grandchild. It speaks volumes that the OP's MIL doesn't bother.

Wtfdoipick · 01/08/2021 15:58

I'm finding this interesting and the replies, my own parents are more like your mil but I would never doubt in a million years that they adore all their grandchildren. I know that if anything was ever absolutely needed they would be there to help, their Grandchildren know it too but I don't think they've ever given spending money, provided treats etc and I wouldn't really appreciate it if they did. To me this just appears to be a complete mismatch of expectations and experiences.

TSSDNCOP · 01/08/2021 15:56

YANBU and shame on anyone who says you are!

Shame on us? For disagreeing and explaining why. For goodness sakes, have a grip.

Nancydrawn · 01/08/2021 15:51

How old is your husband, OP?

Lifelong bachelor sounds like he was 45-50 when he met you, having never had a girlfriend before. Which would mean she had almost half a century of being in her own rhythms before grandchildren came about.

Also, some people aren't overly fond of kids but are great when they get older. I had an aunt who never was particularly hands on when I was a child, but when I grew into my late teens became quite close to me and took me out to lovely fancy dinners and trips to the opera. It turns out she just didn't like kid things.

TSSDNCOP · 01/08/2021 15:45

Both my MIL and my mum are from the school of hard knocks, this sweeping generalisation that olders all had it easier really is myopic. I fall into the category of free education, they never imagined it would apply to them. They grafted for mortgages that could only be on a mans salary and lived with parents until they could afford deposits. Nothing on credit ever.

MIL has set ideas on how much should be spent on birthday and Christmas but always has the kids favourite sweets in on a visit, which is typically planned. Isn't demonstrative but is engaged and enjoys the kids progress and conversation.

My mum would give the kids the shirt off her back, finds them if they don't find her, is a joker, conspirator and would forgive them any sin. Couldn't care less about milestones or exams as long as they are happy and healthy. Has a special treat cupboard and expects them to treat her home as theirs.

The kids show no favourite, they understand each GP's ways and never criticise or big up either. My point, kids don't give a shit really, they're usually just content with their lot.

thecognoscenti · 01/08/2021 15:38

You're horribly grasping and greedy. Maybe she thinks your children are already spoilt enough and don't need her scampering out to get their favourite biscuits etc for when they come over? Perhaps she mistakenly thinks her company might be good enough?

TooManyDinosaurs1 · 01/08/2021 15:38

You sound grabby. I wouldn't expect anyone to buy my children anything grandparents or not. Personally if grandparents want to spend on the kids (I neither ask nor expect) I'd rather we chose whatever it is anyway.

My in laws spend lots on our children but insist on buying what THEY want to buy. I've asked them to either run by us what they are getting or just let us get things our children need/want but no they want to chose. What we get is piles of expensive clothes (dressed up things like shirts, fancy dresses etc that you would wear once to a wedding, not normal comfy baby/toddler child clothes), hideous outdated presents, unsuitable for age presents, duplicate presents, oversized presents that don't fit in the house or garden (they bought an outdoor play house one Xmas, no discussion about it, it had to be returned as it was a plastic monstrosity that took over the garden). I'd love it if they said "could you get the kids Xmas presents, this is the budget..."

I guess grandparents can't win whichever way they do it, someone will always complain!

Soontobe60 · 01/08/2021 15:28

@Muggymama

MIL never thought she'd have grandkids due to.my DH being lifelong batchelor but we did and she has 3; DD15, DS12 & DS10. She never buys them anything or gives them even few pounds when they visit but is very comfortably off and currently having very extensive improvements to her house (which we have to constantly listen to hear her moaning about, mess, poor workmanship, not turning up when should yadda, yadda). My parents on the other hand, have very little but are so kind and bring their favourite treats and contribute to trips, little luxuries, pocket money etc. AIBU to be bit miffed with MIL? She is from a generation when things were easier too, free higher education, good pension at very early age etc. I know it's her money but can't help feeling she is being selfish and little treats time to time would show she cares, understands them & knows what they like/ need.
I was going to agree with you up until you said this: She is from a generation when things were easier too, free higher education, good pension at very early age I too am of that generation. I went to university, didn’t leave with debt, have a pension. However, I live in a small terraced house, am still working part time as my pension isn’t enough to live on, and my daughters both live in houses that cost far more than mine; dd2 has just bought a house that’s double the cost of mine, DD1 has just bought one just short of £1mil. Both left Uni with student loans, both have worked very hard and paid most of their loans off, neither of them have expected hand outs from anyone. Their lives are far better than mine at their ages,
icedcoffees · 01/08/2021 15:28

@Panickingpavlova

Iced coffee, every friends mum has sourced toys for their grandchild at their house, that could be from charity shops, their friends where ever but they do make an effort to get their gc toys to play with.
Well, that's not my experience.

If I visited grandparents, my parents would be the ones to provide toys, colouring books etc. to keep me entertained. They may have bought stuff for me to leave at my grandparents' but it was always them who paid for them, sourced them etc.

Anyway, neither way is wrong - everyone does things differently. Grandparents who shower their grandchildren in gifts aren't inherently better than ones who don't.

Coyoacan · 01/08/2021 15:28

I was going to say that it must have been awful for your husband having a mother like that, but The children do love her very much and tell her

She must be doing something right then and that is all that matters.

The only grandmother I had I didn't love at all, but it was much worse for my mother having her as a mother.

Panickingpavlova · 01/08/2021 15:26

Dottie agree

Panickingpavlova · 01/08/2021 15:22

Op I guess you mean, she's had this sort of unexpected bounty of gc.. Who have enriched her life and she seems to enjoy but its rather one way..

caughtinanet · 01/08/2021 15:22

I'd drop little comments in front of her like 'mum always has little treats on hand for the DC when we visit, she's a very hands-on grandmother', 'my parents bought this for DC' etc

If you came to my house and said things like that I'd think you were a little deranged and feel sorry for my theoretical son who'd married you

Roomonb · 01/08/2021 15:21

I’m thinking if my DD had kids I would probably not be buying them little treats etc. Firstly she may not want them to have them and secondly I bloody hate it when people give me stuff that just means my house is cluttered with things other people like. I would most likely give her cash or lump sums if possible so she can buy what she deems to be suitable. But again I don’t think gift giving is an expression of love. I think taking your time to cook with a child or garden with them, read them a book is more valuable. But thats me. I don’t want my DD growing up thinking gifts or treats are love either, it would disappoint me if she measured love like that.