Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People talking to you in public

330 replies

Mummybasketball · 01/08/2021 01:10

I was eating a breakfast by myself, head buried in my phone and someone comes up to talk to me as e cafe had been done over and looking posh.

Aibu by thinking he’s a rude one?

OP posts:
lannistunut · 01/08/2021 06:25

Not a friendly thing to interrupt someone eating and start an uninvited conversation, that is just rudeness. I'm a queue chatter but this is not that, it was much ruder.

He was lonely/bored and thought you looked like you would go along with it.

I don't care if other doormats people think it rude of me, I'm allowed to say 'I'm just reading my book thank you'. If I am the odd one out, then no doubt the next person they speak to will be delighted to chat Wink

Mummamama · 01/08/2021 06:25

This is the best thing about northeners! We're friendly! Go back down south if you want to pretend other people don't exist. Up here we like to return small talk with people who are most likely lonely. I once got trains from London to Liverpool and it was striking how in London everyone on the train ignored each other and didn't dare make eye contact but on the liverpool trains strangers dared sit near each other and give people the time of day. There was an older couple sat near two youngish lads headed on a night out and they were all having a right laugh. You never know what good you can find in other people if you never talk to anybody!

ThorsLeftNut · 01/08/2021 06:24

[quote BasicDad]@Wingedharpy I'd chat to ya 😀

Had a good 10 minute conversation with a 55-60 year old lady that started with an outspoken grumble (from me) about a brand of tortilla wrap looking smaller than normal today in morissons.[/quote]
How dare you talk to a stranger! Haven’t you learnt from this thread that it’s not allowed? Grin

YABU op.

MrsDThomas · 01/08/2021 06:22

Remember #bekind?

So many miserable people out there.

doudouchouchou · 01/08/2021 06:22

@minatrina

Aw this makes me sad Sad of course you're within your rights to not want to chat with strangers I suppose

But this is one of the reasons I love living in the north and have found it depressing and miserable when I moved down south for a few years. I really love talking to random people on the bus, in cafes, etc., especially if they're older as I always find they have something interesting to say. Also there's a chance that they're just lonely and I'd hate to ignore someone who felt like that.

Tbf, I'd probably not start a conversation myself unless there was a specific reason to, but I love chatting with random people (and both men and women do it, so I'm confident it's not just an Annoying Man Thing - although yes they exist too but it's not hard to tell the difference usually? Especially if you're as attractive as some of the PP's are proclaiming to be lol, surely you've been flirted with enough times to be able to tell the difference?). I agree with previous posters, just be polite and then find a way to say "well, if was nice speaking to you" with a smile and there you go, conversation ended. Yes sometimes you might get someone who is really going on and not taking a hint - I would just excuse myself to make a phone call normally and just ring my husband or my mum for five minutes.

My husband also seems to attract a lot of random people who want to chat to him, usually older men, so in my experience it's really not a gendered thing. I'm not disputing that men trying to harass women is absolutely a common thing, but I think you can tell the difference between someone being creepy and someone who is just looking for human contact. I also find the creepy harassing men are not stopped by being down south where random conversations aren't the social norm, so I don't think it's the same issue.

This! One of the things I really appreciate is the friendliness of people. And often people of an older generation may be lonely. They are not any less of a person because of the time they have spend on the planet.

OP, (hopefully) you will age and when that time comes, I hope that others will be kind and chat to you.

Also, rating yourself out of ten is just hilarious. Based on what you have written, I would choose that person over you any day

Sittingonabench · 01/08/2021 06:20

You sound friendly Confused

nettie434 · 01/08/2021 06:19

@ChittyChittyBangBangChicken

I guess that less attractive women, 6/10 and below, are more desperate for attention and might stoop to speaking to random old codgers in a cafe. ConfusedGrin
Grin ChittyChittyBangBangChicken

I laughed at the OP rating herself as 8/10 but the man was only described as 'about 60'. The implication being that he was so horrifically old, he obviously could not even qualify for a rating. George Clooney is 60. If he can advertise Warburton's, then he might not be above nipping into a Morrison's cafe.

If he carried on talking when you clearly weren't interested, then YANBU but to object to a bland sentence about the cafe decor seems a bit extreme.

Flak · 01/08/2021 06:18

Yanbu Brew

PoorCatto · 01/08/2021 06:16

I'm a northerner. I will chat to randos. But I know the times not to. Someone enjoying their breakfast and playing on their phone/reading a book, leave them in peace. Someone at a bus stop panicking they lost something, I take a calm practical approach and try and help.

One of my biggest pet peeves however when people try to sit on my table in cafes. I once told an old lady to stfu because I was trying to read my book in a cafe on holiday and she'd decided I was going to listen to her woes. She took no hints. I asked her to sit somewhere else and she refused. Luckily covid means a little clearing of the throat and people back away now.

chaosrabbitland · 01/08/2021 06:12

it really dosent cost much to say a few banal words and say yes i agree it does look much improved or similar and go back to what you were doing . im not cold or unfriendly in this way to people , but then iv worked in retail since i left school so an well used to having to be sociable and make conversation even if my minds on other things

daisypond · 01/08/2021 06:08

I don’t really see any difference between having a chat with a stranger in a cafe or a pub. It’s not necessarily a male/female thing. It’s that they are social spaces where strangers interact. It’s fine to not want to chat, but it’s also fine to strike up a conversation.

Faevern · 01/08/2021 06:07

@Wingedharpy

Was it up North? They're like that up there - the women as well.Wink
Smile I was just coming on here to say OP must be a Southerner
minatrina · 01/08/2021 06:05

Aw this makes me sad Sad of course you're within your rights to not want to chat with strangers I suppose

But this is one of the reasons I love living in the north and have found it depressing and miserable when I moved down south for a few years. I really love talking to random people on the bus, in cafes, etc., especially if they're older as I always find they have something interesting to say. Also there's a chance that they're just lonely and I'd hate to ignore someone who felt like that.

Tbf, I'd probably not start a conversation myself unless there was a specific reason to, but I love chatting with random people (and both men and women do it, so I'm confident it's not just an Annoying Man Thing - although yes they exist too but it's not hard to tell the difference usually? Especially if you're as attractive as some of the PP's are proclaiming to be lol, surely you've been flirted with enough times to be able to tell the difference?). I agree with previous posters, just be polite and then find a way to say "well, if was nice speaking to you" with a smile and there you go, conversation ended. Yes sometimes you might get someone who is really going on and not taking a hint - I would just excuse myself to make a phone call normally and just ring my husband or my mum for five minutes.

My husband also seems to attract a lot of random people who want to chat to him, usually older men, so in my experience it's really not a gendered thing. I'm not disputing that men trying to harass women is absolutely a common thing, but I think you can tell the difference between someone being creepy and someone who is just looking for human contact. I also find the creepy harassing men are not stopped by being down south where random conversations aren't the social norm, so I don't think it's the same issue.

KTB19 · 01/08/2021 06:05

Why are women always taught to be friendly and accommodating?

Why shouldnt the OP be able to have breakfast outside in a cafe, to be able to use her phone, enjoy her meal and generally just do her thing, without having to converse with a strange guy?

I am done with being nice and friendly. I will acknowledge someone politely but after that I will get back to enjoying my own personal space.

Twelveisthebestnumber · 01/08/2021 06:01

I don't know what's worse. Some old guy wanting to have a quick chat which might be the only human engagement he has all day or you scoring yourself 8/10 Hmm

lifehappened · 01/08/2021 05:55

Us pesky friendly northerners 😉

Turtletotem · 01/08/2021 05:40

I wonder how you'd feel if you read on the news today that the man had done something awful to himself because of how lonely he was and he'd tried chatting to someone to pass the time of day etc?

Lemonsandlemonade · 01/08/2021 05:12

Just out of curiosity if it was woman who approached you would you have been so bothered?

Lemonsandlemonade · 01/08/2021 05:07

@RLOU30

I can’t move past the fact that you just scored yourlsef out of 10 Hmm would it have been ok if you were a 6/10 and he spoke to you ?
So glad it wasn’t just me.
ThumbWitchesAbroad · 01/08/2021 04:52

Standard behaviour from some males though.
They just see a woman/girl on her own and think "oh she must be in need of male company, I shall talk to her and relieve her loneliness, poor lonely female person! She will be so grateful that I, a Male person, have noticed her!"

They're wrong of course. But it happens SO much - on public transport, in cafés or similar, in parks - it's almost as though they're offended that a woman can be self-sufficient!

Dinosaurballoon · 01/08/2021 04:32

Yanbu I HATE this

ChittyChittyBangBangChicken · 01/08/2021 04:31

I guess that less attractive women, 6/10 and below, are more desperate for attention and might stoop to speaking to random old codgers in a cafe. ConfusedGrin

AtticusHoysAnus · 01/08/2021 04:28

8/10 😂

QueenBee52 · 01/08/2021 04:16

The cafe has been refurbished and is looking smart.

Ooh I see 🤣 thank you 🎉

RLOU30 · 01/08/2021 04:15

I can’t move past the fact that you just scored yourlsef out of 10 Hmm would it have been ok if you were a 6/10 and he spoke to you ?