Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think family money is a curse?

213 replies

BeatieBourke · 01/08/2021 00:24

Of course, if your landed gentry and have trust funds coming out of eyeballs there might be more autonomy and independence than the rest of us have...

Similarly, if you're absolutely struggling to feed your family, you'll understandably put up with all sorts for the sake of feeding your kids. I've been there.

But otherwise, being beholden to the dangled carrot of an inheritance, not being able to plan your own future, knowing that other people have the power to make or break your financial security? Nah, you're alright ta. I'll take staying in rented accommodation my whole life and live without holidays/decent cars/other keeping up with the Jones' stuff with whatever tiny buffer I can manage to scrape together from one month to the next and a degree of dignity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
BananaSnowman · 01/08/2021 08:00

@robotcollision it's not just about a future bulk inheritance though as much as our current lifestyle. At the moment DH works for one of the family businesses, we live in one of the family houses and our expenses like kids schooling are paid for by FIL. We could both get jobs on our own but we wouldn't be able to afford to do anything like what we can at the moment. Theres a reason people say wealth lasts three generations - the first generation makes it, the second is beholden by the first to maintain it and then the third is allowed by the second to have everything they didn't have and spend it frivolously whilst doing what they enjoy. We're the second generation.

FIL is not mean spirited or selfish but he is pragmatic. If we wanted to do our own thing we could and he'd help us get set up but we wouldn't enjoy the future benefits of his business/investments. That's what he says anyway.

VeganCow · 01/08/2021 07:58

@BananaSnowman

YANBU but I think a lot of people won't understand. My in-laws are very wealthy and it does dictate our lives somewhat. FIL is very clear that if we want to share in the wealth he has created we need to learn to do it properly so that a legacy can be continued for his grandchildren (fair enough). So DH does what FIL tells him to do re where he lives and works. At the moment we are living pretty far away from all our family, DH doesn't really like the work, I can't work... it's just not somewhere I'd choose to live. But we stay here because of the future security we'll hopefully have.

But then there's a lot that could go wrong like if key investments fail plus inheritance is never a certainty anyway. So it's difficult and a gamble and sometimes I worry that it's not worth it or won't pay off. I recognise we're really lucky to have this as our main problem though.

How awful, living a bargained life that is someone else's vision and not your own. The way you describe it, it's like prostituting yourselves for the life you MAY one day have. Imagine if FIL decides you haven't danced properly to his tune and leaves his son nothing?

Why can't he work and live where he wants? Does he have to work in the family business? What if he told his father he is going to leave and get work doing what he would really want?

Angelofchaos · 01/08/2021 07:58

This is more about family relationships and personalities than anything else.

I am in line to inherit a large sum from my parents. It doesn't factor into my financial planning at all. I have stopped speaking to my parents when we had a serious fall out. If they disinherited me and died, while we weren't speaking, that's what would have happened. End of.

It might all go on care fees or dad might die and mum my splurge it all. It is not part of any plan that I have and I hope to be very old myself when if I get anything.

On the other hand mu brother and his wife are obsessed and do plan their life round it. She just inherited about 100k from her father. They renovated their house and frittered the rest. She expects to inherit from her mother (which will be more complicated as the mother is remarried). They also bring up, to my parents about how much they would be getting from them. Alot. And actually it's sil that brings it up the most. To the point mum gets upset. Dad has ended up having a go at them both and so have I.

Their whole life is planned round how much they will get from each party and life is passing them by.

Theres absolutely no expectation from my parents at all, they just want a quiet life and to see their grandkids. That's it. They don't hold it over us. They discussed their will when it was done. And that's it.

In general, both my brother and his wife, act as though they are owed something in general. I have my theories to do with our upbringing but just theories.

This situation with them occurred because of their personalities. Not because there's, potentially, inheritance.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/08/2021 07:57

I know my mum stole our money.I can’t prove it so there’s nothing i can do.......I’m not going to lie, I could do with the money and also feel it’s mine and my DC’s money morally.*

Are you bloody kidding? They were here parents to inherit from. God the greediness on here is astonishing.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 07:55

And yes @Bluntness100 you are here a lot 😆

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/08/2021 07:55

I honestly never count on inheriting money, do people really do this?!

Neither of my own parents inherited until they were in their 60s and retired themselves. It is in fact possible to buy your own home without inheriting money - by the time my parents inherited (not a huge amount in either case) they didnt need it anyway.

For most young people today, as people are living longer and longer, we will be rather old ourselves before we inherit, it's not money that will do us any good during our working lives anyway. Forget about it.

Meruem · 01/08/2021 07:55

In my family it has been. My GP’s were born and lived in a different European country, my mum was also born there. When they died they had no money according to my mum. Yet she bought herself a house shortly afterwards! My GPs were always so sensible with money, I know they didn’t die as paupers.

I know my GPs wanted money to go me and DSis and the grandchildren as I remember them asking me for the correct spelling of my DCs names for their will. I’ve tried getting a copy but haven’t been able to, they don’t have copies held anywhere in that country like they do here.

I know my mum stole our money. I can’t prove it so there’s nothing I can do. My mum claims she bought the house with money from a friend of hers who died but I know that’s a lie. Now she tries to hold it over me that I’ll supposedly get half the house when she dies. I’m not going to lie, I could do with the money and also feel it’s mine and my DC’s money morally. So I’ve then felt I’ve had to maintain at least a low contact relationship. But I’ve had enough now. She’s always been a shit mum. She’s only early 70s and healthy so could live for another 20 years. By which time I’ll be 70 myself! I think going NC now would be far healthier for me than hanging on for money I may well not receive. It’s just so hard to take knowing it is money that was stolen from my family in the first place.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 07:54

I didn't say I see people living their life in anticipation of an inheritance. I said I see many posters assuming they will get one.

user1471505494 · 01/08/2021 07:54

I don’t know people who have had threats or strings attached to inheritances and my DHand I haven’t made any I knew the contents of my parents will. There were never string or threats. I am very grateful for the help these inheritances gave me but I still father have my parents

Mintjulia · 01/08/2021 07:53

What an odd thought. In a society where care costs for the elderly are high, and life expectancy is 80+, expecting an inheritance is a bit of a pipedream for anyone except the super-rich.

Those with any common sense concentrate on building their own careers and their own assets, and assume they won't receive anything as a bequest. And being pressured with a promise of a future bequest is ridiculous. When the dead person reneges on the promise, they can hardly be taken to court. Smile

If someone inherits some money, then that's a bonus but should never ever be relied on.

Bluntness100 · 01/08/2021 07:52

@saywhatn

I see on MNs all the time I will inherit X so plenty have the assumption.
Really? I’m on here a lot and very seldom see folks living their life in anticipation of an inheritance
PyjamaFan · 01/08/2021 07:49

Neither my DH or I waited for our inheritance, or lived our lives differently in any way.

We quite like the £1m plus that he inherited though, and the house and land it has given us.

Although sorting out probate, 90 years worth of possessions and 2 properties for sale, then paying a massive chunk of tax was a bit of a pain. Grin

Camomila · 01/08/2021 07:48

I don't really think about inheriting, DH and I hope to be 50/60+ when the parents and inlaws die.

datepanic · 01/08/2021 07:47

I just think its weird to build your life around the assumption that you might recieve something one day. And I know people who worry about whether they will or they won't

I don't think many people do this. I certainly didn't and have since inherited a reasonable amount of money when the last of my parents died. I assumed it would all be eaten up by living costs for my Dad in his retirement and then possible care home fees. He died before he had to go into a care home and unexpectedly so a lot younger than I might have thought. If he'd lived another 7 or 8 years there would not have been a penny left.
I actively told him to buy whatever he wanted and spend whatever he wanted on whatever he wanted. That was his money and he shouldn't be saving it for me.

I don't know if you're talking about people who have toxic relationships with their parents. The parents hold the inheritance over them in order to manipulate their adult children to do what they want? The whole relationship has been toxic anyway and constant belittling makes people feel like they aren't capable of making their own way.
Do you mean something like that`?

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 07:46

I see on MNs all the time I will inherit X so plenty have the assumption.

SushiGo · 01/08/2021 07:46

The thing about inheritance (if I get one, and it doesn't all go on care home fees etc) is that I'd probably by 50/60 even 70 by the time I got it - this is true for most people.

At which point I'll be well past the most expensive part of my life, and it would just be bonus money. Nice of course, but absolutely not worth rearranging my life for in the hope that we'll be quids in.

Much better to just crack on doing our own thing and making our own financial plans, and to encourage our parents to spend the money they have on care when they need it.

SisterAgatha · 01/08/2021 07:45

I don’t see how it’s bitter either, I am probably going to receive a fairly nice inheritance but I didn’t live my life waiting on it, I just bought my own house anyway. No need to spend your time hand wringing and being a slave to anyone for what is essentially just a bonus - I have plenty of friends without any parents who would feel like I’d kicked them and was being entitled if I said any of what OP had said.

Guestdressquery · 01/08/2021 07:43

I am in line to receive a chunky inheritance. But I have lived my life as if I will receive nothing. I am trying to encourage my father to spend as much of it as he can on having a wonderful and comfortable retirement.

I earn well and am well-off in my own right (am mid-30s). If I inherit nothing I will still earn well and be very comfortable, with everything I could possibly want.

robotcollision · 01/08/2021 07:43

@BananaSnowman - that is a perfect description of what I'd never do. Really, can't you rethink? Get jobs you both love in an area you love. You have no idea whether such a capricious, bullying person will change their mind and leave it all to the black sheep of the family who did their own thing. Don't live your lives enslaved to the whim of the generation before you.

robotcollision · 01/08/2021 07:40

It's only a curse if people are daft enough to rely on it. A long long time ago I decided I'd never assume we'd inherit family money, partly after an inheritance due to DH got sidelined by an uncle who then left it all to a mate of his. We might inherit a bit of money but I assume we won't and make plans for this.

Anyone unlucky enough to have a family that dangles the inheritance like a whip to beat them into behaving a certain way should just walk off and make their own way in life.

Wanttocry · 01/08/2021 07:40

@BananaSnowman

YANBU but I think a lot of people won't understand. My in-laws are very wealthy and it does dictate our lives somewhat. FIL is very clear that if we want to share in the wealth he has created we need to learn to do it properly so that a legacy can be continued for his grandchildren (fair enough). So DH does what FIL tells him to do re where he lives and works. At the moment we are living pretty far away from all our family, DH doesn't really like the work, I can't work... it's just not somewhere I'd choose to live. But we stay here because of the future security we'll hopefully have.

But then there's a lot that could go wrong like if key investments fail plus inheritance is never a certainty anyway. So it's difficult and a gamble and sometimes I worry that it's not worth it or won't pay off. I recognise we're really lucky to have this as our main problem though.

I don’t think you sound lucky tbh. I wouldn’t live like that, in a location I didn’t like, where I’m unable to work, with my DH doing a job he doesn’t like either.
DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 01/08/2021 07:39

We've just carried on living our lives on the assumption that we won't get anything. I theoretically will inherit quite a lot of money. But I might not, you never can assume anything nowadays with nursing home fees etc. At 100k a year the money can dwindle to nothing PDQ.
I look after my parents because I want to, not because of what money I might get out of them at some point in the future.
If we do get money then we will decide then what we'll do with it, but it certainly doesn't factor in our plans because you just can't rely on it.

GlamourSpider · 01/08/2021 07:37

I think it comes down to the people involved rather than the inheritance itself, I have never expected to receive anything (quite the reverse as it wouldn't be a lot and I've been encouraging my parents to spend the money they've worked for). It's also feasible for your parents to outlive you, my parents are only 20yrs older than me so should I be waiting until I'm 60 to start my life? crazy.

alwayswrighty · 01/08/2021 07:37

My parents (70s) have estate planned. They currently look after my 95 year old nan. They are discussing paying off my mortgage when she passes but I'm not going to bank on it, I'll do what I've always done and plough as much money into my pension, savings and mortgage as I can each month.

Trouble is with inheritance is that it can be eaten by care fee's and then you're 60 with no pension for yourself.

AnyOldPrion · 01/08/2021 07:35

Sorry, I see I’ve strayed away from your actual question, OP. And no, if someone wanted me to jump through hoops in order to secure a theoretical inheritance, I don’t think I could do it. I’m very lucky my parents are wholly reasonable people and would never use their money as a lever to control me, which I see is what you’re talking about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread