Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think family money is a curse?

213 replies

BeatieBourke · 01/08/2021 00:24

Of course, if your landed gentry and have trust funds coming out of eyeballs there might be more autonomy and independence than the rest of us have...

Similarly, if you're absolutely struggling to feed your family, you'll understandably put up with all sorts for the sake of feeding your kids. I've been there.

But otherwise, being beholden to the dangled carrot of an inheritance, not being able to plan your own future, knowing that other people have the power to make or break your financial security? Nah, you're alright ta. I'll take staying in rented accommodation my whole life and live without holidays/decent cars/other keeping up with the Jones' stuff with whatever tiny buffer I can manage to scrape together from one month to the next and a degree of dignity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Bluethrough · 01/08/2021 08:49

I was left the family house, my siblings got nothing, i cared for my mum over several years and we had a wonderful relationship, my siblings moved abroad and little to do with her.

They found out the provisions of the Will before she died (i also didn't know what my mum had done) and all hell broke lose, including trying to change the Will as she lay dying, the solicitor refused to do it as she was too ill, it was terrible, my mum was so distressed, even the hospital tried to stop them visiting.

I would have agreed to some changes to appease them but they weren't interested - they wanted it all.

So we now have no contact and never will, so yes inheritances can certainly be a curse, i wish it had never happened.

oblada · 01/08/2021 08:48

[quote BananaSnowman]@EllieQ yes, I like the lifestyle. That's why it's kind of a curse. Would we be happier if we'd done our own thing? Maybe. Is it easy to give all this up? Nope.[/quote]
That's interesting and I kind of get it. But no way would i lead my life based on someone else's whims for any amount of money. we only live once.
My parents are probably between your parents and in law's in wealth's terms but even if they earned loads more i still wouldn't do anything different. I enjoy the stress free fancy holidays at their houses every so often but that's it.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 08:47

Lots of people buy houses and have holidays etc with their own earned money.

Tbf it's not weird to have help to get on the ladder either deposit help, special mortgages or living at home to save.

LuaDipa · 01/08/2021 08:47

I’m expecting a good inheritance. Not because I’m grabby or beholden, but because both my dm and pil have explained to all of their dc what they can expect to receive.

It hasn’t made a jot of difference to our lives. We have earned well and been successful regardless. We’re not waiting on anything and we certainly don’t need the money. And given my experience of losing a parent early in life I would far rather have their presence. But I can completely understand why people are keen to prepare for their demise and leave their families provided for. It’s certainly something that has been at the forefront of my mind since I had dc.

BananaSnowman · 01/08/2021 08:46

@Angelofchaos of course it's a choice, that doesn't mean it's not a curse to have this choice to make though, in the colloquial sense that the OP meant it. Things would be simpler without the family wealth and resulting choices to be made, definitely.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/08/2021 08:46

This is really weird. Lots of people buy houses and have holidays etc with their own earned money.

I thought that too. I'm only 35, haven't inherited anything. We own a house, have holidays etc, paid with from our own salaries.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/08/2021 08:45

Mereum

Do you really know that's what they wanted? They may have had every intention of leaving money to their own daughter, while hoping she would choose to pass some to you. I've seen that a lot, where grandparents hope what's left will get spread around. Sometimes it happens, sometimes it doesn't. It would unusual to completely disinherit your own daughter in favour of grandchildren, absent a very bad relationship. Most grandparents just hope their beneficiaries will share the money around.

Angelofchaos · 01/08/2021 08:43

[quote BananaSnowman]@EllieQ yes, I like the lifestyle. That's why it's kind of a curse. Would we be happier if we'd done our own thing? Maybe. Is it easy to give all this up? Nope.[/quote]
But it's not a curse. It's your choice.

BananaSnowman · 01/08/2021 08:41

@EllieQ yes, I like the lifestyle. That's why it's kind of a curse. Would we be happier if we'd done our own thing? Maybe. Is it easy to give all this up? Nope.

budgun · 01/08/2021 08:41

But otherwise, being beholden to the dangled carrot of an inheritance, not being able to plan your own future, knowing that other people have the power to make or break your financial security? Nah, you're alright ta. I'll take staying in rented accommodation my whole life and live without holidays/decent cars/other keeping up with the Jones' stuff with whatever tiny buffer I can manage to scrape together from one month to the next and a degree of dignity.

This is really weird. Lots of people buy houses and have holidays etc with their own earned money.

EllieQ · 01/08/2021 08:39

[quote BananaSnowman]@robotcollision it's not just about a future bulk inheritance though as much as our current lifestyle. At the moment DH works for one of the family businesses, we live in one of the family houses and our expenses like kids schooling are paid for by FIL. We could both get jobs on our own but we wouldn't be able to afford to do anything like what we can at the moment. Theres a reason people say wealth lasts three generations - the first generation makes it, the second is beholden by the first to maintain it and then the third is allowed by the second to have everything they didn't have and spend it frivolously whilst doing what they enjoy. We're the second generation.

FIL is not mean spirited or selfish but he is pragmatic. If we wanted to do our own thing we could and he'd help us get set up but we wouldn't enjoy the future benefits of his business/investments. That's what he says anyway.[/quote]
But you don’t have to do that, do you? You could get different jobs, pay for your own house, pay for your children’s’ school or send them to state school. You just don’t want to because it would mean a lower standard of living.

Personally, I don’t know anyone who is planning their life around waiting for an inheritance from their parents. Most of my friends (late 30s/ early 40s) have parents who are still healthy and enjoying retirement. Several of them have had money given to them for house deposits (sometimes from their parents inheriting money from their parents), and that has contributed to the housing market inequalities someone mentioned above - they can buy a bigger house despite earning the same as us, they have more disposable income, that kind of thing.

My mum was in a care home for the last years of her life, so the house was sold for care home fees and I inherited ~£5k after she died. That will be the reality for a lot of people, especially as people live longer but need more care at the end of their lives.

Cam77 · 01/08/2021 08:33

Thats about having manipulative, controlling relatives though, not about the money.

Yep

Watchingyou2sleezes · 01/08/2021 08:29

Inheritance from parents anyway, should come at a time in life when you don't really need it.
I'm doing the opposite with my own brood in that I'm assisting them financially until they're 25 to get their lives established and it's upto them then where life times them for there. I've them not to be of the mindset of getting a great chunk in later life when we pop our clogs.

BananaSnowman · 01/08/2021 08:28

@oblada see I'd say my parents are wealthy. My dad earns a lot, my parents have a really nice house and they obviously don't worry about money. With them my attitude is the same as most people on this thread. If I inherit from them then that's great but the thought of it doesn't affect my relationship with them or how I live my life. But with my in-laws it's different - the sheer amount of money and how they made it. I think that's the difference between family wealth vs the expectation of a good inheritance.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 01/08/2021 08:27

Surely depends on whether your relatives are the type who use the lure of an inheritance as a carrot (or stick).
TBH I’ve heard of the odd case where the carrot was used, and someone had been very good to whoever it was, only to find that the devious old sod/sodette had left it all to someone else anyway - someone who hadn’t given a shiny shite about them.

I’m glad to say that in this family, any inheritance has been a strings-free gift we’ve been very thankful for.
And whatever we hope to leave to dds will be the same.

oblada · 01/08/2021 08:17

[quote BananaSnowman]@robotcollision it's not just about a future bulk inheritance though as much as our current lifestyle. At the moment DH works for one of the family businesses, we live in one of the family houses and our expenses like kids schooling are paid for by FIL. We could both get jobs on our own but we wouldn't be able to afford to do anything like what we can at the moment. Theres a reason people say wealth lasts three generations - the first generation makes it, the second is beholden by the first to maintain it and then the third is allowed by the second to have everything they didn't have and spend it frivolously whilst doing what they enjoy. We're the second generation.

FIL is not mean spirited or selfish but he is pragmatic. If we wanted to do our own thing we could and he'd help us get set up but we wouldn't enjoy the future benefits of his business/investments. That's what he says anyway.[/quote]
Honestly that sounds awful. In your shoes no way would i live my life based on what may happen depending on the whims of someone else.
We're definitely the second generation too, my parents are very wealthy but it wasn't passed to them by their parents, they created that wealth. I'm not beholden to them in any way. They have helped us buy our house, given us some not insignificant cash gifts at various points over the last 20yrs but it was never expected or conditional. We live abroad and live the life we want.
I do expect my children will benefit from their wealth more than me but who cares!

Sally872 · 01/08/2021 08:16

Most people I know are the same position as me. Likely to inherit family home, don't rely on it, and aren't threatened with it either. We don't talk or think about it because the conversation would be about the loss of parents which would be the key point, not any financial gain.

RavenclawesomeCrone · 01/08/2021 08:15

My mum inherited from her mum. Allowed her to buy her business premises (previously rented) and when she retired, the sale of that premises allowed my parents to pay of their mortgage and move to a lovely bungalow by the sea and have money in the bank.
My dad got nothing from his parents and they had to pay for his dad's funeral because he had literally about 10 quid in the bank.

My dad passed away in 2017, and my mum passed away suddenly last year. I will inherit about 200K in a few weeks once probate is done. I'd rather have my mum back.

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 01/08/2021 08:15

I know exactly what you mean. We were offered money to buy a house recently, with heavy hints that it was to be within a mile of the in laws house. We said thanks, but no thanks.

Echobelly · 01/08/2021 08:15

I'd agree with @EmergencyHydrangea - very much depends on family dynamics. Some use it as a tool of control, also depends on the size of your family and how many ways it goes. We actually as a family agreed to slightly redistribute part of a large inheritence after one party was disappointed, but I think there are not many families who'd do that without a row, but we all get on well and felt it the fair thing to do. There were only 4 of us involved as well, which helped.

I never built my life around expectation of receiving it, though I had hopes it would pay off our mortgage (it will); I always reminded myself that nothing was guaranteeed and maybe it would be less than I thought and so on. But maybe that was easier in our case as we are effectively pretty well off, in national terms, to start with and everyone concerned was already a home owner - it was always going to be something that would make our lives easier but nothing that would change our plans or lifestyles.

Thewinterofdiscontent · 01/08/2021 08:05

I get you Op. My DH is hanging out a bit for the inheritance although he does very well on his own.
He’s not particularly great with his parents so part of me hopes they’ll donate it all to a worthy cause. It’s just a bit spoilt to expect the proceeds of your parent’s efforts.

mustlovegin · 01/08/2021 08:04

I just think its weird to build your life around the assumption that you might receive something one day

Nobody is forcing them to do this.

Gladioli23 · 01/08/2021 08:03

I agree you have to be careful not to live your life in thrall to a possible future inheritance. But equally if you can manage to gather together two generations worth of wealth then there's the possibility of making everyone's lives easier for a long time. If the family can get to the point where the inheritance you receive essentially comes from grandparents then that is likely to happen while you're still young enough for it to not be bonus money - and avoid tainting family money by it coming alongside a parents death. Obviously there are still risks around care homes etc and it is reliant on at least fairly functional family relationships.

Meruem · 01/08/2021 08:03

They were her parents to inherit from

Who had their own wishes that should have been respected. It’s not about greed. She stole money that wasn’t hers. She’s the greedy one!

VeganCow · 01/08/2021 08:02

@Meruem

In my family it has been. My GP’s were born and lived in a different European country, my mum was also born there. When they died they had no money according to my mum. Yet she bought herself a house shortly afterwards! My GPs were always so sensible with money, I know they didn’t die as paupers.

I know my GPs wanted money to go me and DSis and the grandchildren as I remember them asking me for the correct spelling of my DCs names for their will. I’ve tried getting a copy but haven’t been able to, they don’t have copies held anywhere in that country like they do here.

I know my mum stole our money. I can’t prove it so there’s nothing I can do. My mum claims she bought the house with money from a friend of hers who died but I know that’s a lie. Now she tries to hold it over me that I’ll supposedly get half the house when she dies. I’m not going to lie, I could do with the money and also feel it’s mine and my DC’s money morally. So I’ve then felt I’ve had to maintain at least a low contact relationship. But I’ve had enough now. She’s always been a shit mum. She’s only early 70s and healthy so could live for another 20 years. By which time I’ll be 70 myself! I think going NC now would be far healthier for me than hanging on for money I may well not receive. It’s just so hard to take knowing it is money that was stolen from my family in the first place.

There must be some way to look into this and see the will?
Swipe left for the next trending thread