Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think family money is a curse?

213 replies

BeatieBourke · 01/08/2021 00:24

Of course, if your landed gentry and have trust funds coming out of eyeballs there might be more autonomy and independence than the rest of us have...

Similarly, if you're absolutely struggling to feed your family, you'll understandably put up with all sorts for the sake of feeding your kids. I've been there.

But otherwise, being beholden to the dangled carrot of an inheritance, not being able to plan your own future, knowing that other people have the power to make or break your financial security? Nah, you're alright ta. I'll take staying in rented accommodation my whole life and live without holidays/decent cars/other keeping up with the Jones' stuff with whatever tiny buffer I can manage to scrape together from one month to the next and a degree of dignity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 12:50

Capital gains tax?

Not on a primary residence. And of course there’s such a thing as road tax, it just happens to be called vehicle tax - which you know perfectly well.

GnomeDePlume · 01/08/2021 12:48

@MyMabel this is part of why I want to stop DB's Trust Fund King ambitions in their tracks. I can see it all going wrong.

I also dont like the idea of grown adult DCs having to go cap in hand to their weird uncle to get access to money which they have inherited.

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 12:32

(no such thing as road tax!)

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 12:31

@Blossomtoes

It's already been taxed once

All money is taxed numerous times. We pay income tax, then VAT, petrol tax, road tax, council tax ... It’s the only time the increased value of residential property is taxed.

Capital gains tax?
Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 12:29

It's already been taxed once

All money is taxed numerous times. We pay income tax, then VAT, petrol tax, road tax, council tax ... It’s the only time the increased value of residential property is taxed.

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 12:26

@Blossomtoes

Also the tax on it is absolutely bizarre, how someone’s does, leaving their own money and possessions to their children and the tax man takes nearly half of it. Absolutely diabolical and an insult to the dead.

The first £325k is exempt so I can’t summon up much sympathy. The living pay IHT not the dead.

It's already been taxed once
Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 12:25

Also the tax on it is absolutely bizarre, how someone’s does, leaving their own money and possessions to their children and the tax man takes nearly half of it. Absolutely diabolical and an insult to the dead.

The first £325k is exempt so I can’t summon up much sympathy. The living pay IHT not the dead.

GnomeDePlume · 01/08/2021 12:22

Families? Bloody nightmare

Totally agree with that!

Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 12:21

I think it's odd that people lives lives are governed by something so beyond their own making/choosing

I’d agree with you if it was true. I always knew I was the only beneficiary of my parents’ wills. I never gave it a moment’s thought until they died.

IcedSpice · 01/08/2021 12:16

@AdoptedBumpkin

My views on inheritance are rather controversial, so I'll keep them quiet, but I am inclined to agree at least in theory. Smile
Why vague post though ? Hmm
LipstickLou · 01/08/2021 12:01

@MyMabel

The friend is a bit of a fantasist. She inherited £300k three years ago. All spent!
Recently asked me for money, said i will pay you back when i get my inheritance. I wouldn't be surprised if the mother skips a generation. She is a shrewd old lady and knows her daughter is a spendthrift.

MyMabel · 01/08/2021 11:56

@LipstickLou you’re friend doesn’t work because she knows one day she’ll inherit 1m.. possibly 40% less after tax? -depending on her age, does she realise how much you would need to stop working? It’s a lot more than 1m 😂 I think she’ll have a bit of a shock coming to her.

MyMabel · 01/08/2021 11:52

My dad is going through similar with his siblings. The trust fund, valuables and inheritance of their mother is just causing stress and conflict between everyone. It’s painful to watch and listen. Also the tax on it is absolutely bizarre, how someone’s does, leaving their own money and possessions to their children and the tax man takes nearly half of it. Absolutely diabolical and an insult to the dead.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 01/08/2021 11:52

@SushiGo

The thing about inheritance (if I get one, and it doesn't all go on care home fees etc) is that I'd probably by 50/60 even 70 by the time I got it - this is true for most people.

At which point I'll be well past the most expensive part of my life, and it would just be bonus money. Nice of course, but absolutely not worth rearranging my life for in the hope that we'll be quids in.

Much better to just crack on doing our own thing and making our own financial plans, and to encourage our parents to spend the money they have on care when they need it.

Exactly this - if I do inherit then I will spend part of it in a property for DD so she doesn't have to wait for us to fall off our perch to enjoy the family wealth
bettyboodecia · 01/08/2021 11:48

Not for me and my siblings. We've received 'advanced' inheritance of about £400k each, in stages over 20 years. No advance expectations or strings attached on either side. In my case, it's paid for a chunk of house equity, a post grad degree, a holiday of a lifetime and a big wedding. And a continuing sense of financial security. It's been a blessing to be honest, we're so lucky. I hope to do the same for my kids.

ssd · 01/08/2021 11:45

@middleager

Nice problem to have. I come from a world without inheritance and it was only coming on here that I realised how common it seems with many MNetters who don't seem to get it isn't a 'thing' for many of us.
Totally. Posters here dont understand you can have no parents alive and no inheritance either. Its nit always a given.
Meruem · 01/08/2021 11:41

Mandalay246

I think you may have missed the part where I said this all happened in a different country where things work differently, and that I have tried unsuccessfully to get a copy of the will. It’s not that I am not willing to go into the backstory, more that it is of no interest to anyone. I mentioned it because it related to the thread title in that it has been difficult and I wish my GPs had just spent all their money and this issue never came up. My mum could just easily prove things by providing a copy of the will, which she must have as she dealt with the funerals etc, but as she won’t then of course I’m going to believe the worst.

LipstickLou · 01/08/2021 11:22

@GnomeDePlume

Interesting. My siblings have all paid off their mortgages. We have not due to having to stop work for parental care. They all took their overseas holidays just before my father died. One asked to delay the funeral.
My sister objected to my father paying anything towards living costs when he came to live with us. In all it cost us at least at £100k in lost income and extra space. He did leave me a painting and she can sue me for it!
Interestingly her adult children back me and remain in my life.
Tbh my sister was nasty to me as a child and hasn't changed. One of my brothers is terminally ill and she isn't going to what may be has last birthday party. My late parents would have been appalled. Families? Bloody nightmare.

Mandalay246 · 01/08/2021 11:19

@Meruem - as I said in my post if your mother has "stolen" your inheritance then how did she do it? An executor has to abide by the terms of the will, if they haven't then you need to address it. I appreciate that you don't want to go into it all on MN, but if there is some backstory that you aren't willing to divulge then why mention it at all Confused

LindaEllen · 01/08/2021 11:13

It sounds like there's a backstory here, and some ill feeling between you and your parents from whom you may inherit.

IMO you should NEVER 'rely' on inheritance. Earn your own money, live your own life. If it comes, it comes, but don't assume.

My mum's friend basically waited for her mum to die for 40 years (she died at 104!!) to inherit her savings and £500,000 home. She ended up being in a nursing home for the last 25 years of her life and there wasn't a penny left. Mum's friend now lives in a caravan.

GnomeDePlume · 01/08/2021 11:07

@LipstickLou thank you. If ever I think my blood pressure is getting too low then I think about this stupid situation and it pops right back up again Grin.

It is a fairly recent phenomenon of lots of people having significant estate to leave. Since home buying became widespread across income levels.

My DM is the first person in her family to have an estate to leave. Previous generations have only had the odd stick of furniture and a bit of jewellery. Unfortunately this has gone to her head a bit. She sees her relatively small estate as a lot of money. The reality is that divided up between her now adult GCs it is a decent house deposit but no more.

Trust Fund King DB also has funny ideas about DM's estate. In his mind it is DF's money (DF has been dead for more than 25 years) and therefore must not be squandered and should be left intact. Left to his own devices the GCs would have to justify to him why they should have access to any part of what is their inheritance. He would then veto any spending plans which didnt conform with his narrow views of how the money should be spent.

Needless to say, I have not said any of this to my own DCs but have made sure that other DB (parent of profoundly disabled DC) is aware.

Holly60 · 01/08/2021 10:53

@BeatieBourke

There's nownt to take here. Our mothers funeral wiped us out. Just an observation.

Don't know what the "rest of us" is referring to. I suppose you might be neither landed gentry nor struggling and have an inheritance that is freely given or no strings. It doesn't seem to work that way from what I can see. Maybe it's just the company I keep.

…it’s the company you keep Hmm
FootballFacedOrang · 01/08/2021 10:51

My DH has an inheritance 'dangled'. All advice/guidance/help (eg babysitting) from his parents comes with a side of "remember we'll be able to help you out one day if you do XYZ". This has influenced what job DH does, where we live and countless other decisions. The one day keeps changing. When we got married, when we relocated back to his parents home town, when we had DC etc, we're all times when this help was going to be forthcoming but never was.

It's not about money, it's about control. He now tells his DP to stop when they start talking like this, and makes it clear he doesn't want anything from them. He doesn't care about the money, but he does resent the drawn out, manipulative attempts to control his life.

Meruem · 01/08/2021 10:49

Mandalay246

And you’re making assumptions based on what I’ve written. I could write a whole lot more on why I have come to this conclusion but A) who would even be interested and B) it’s not my thread or the point of the thread. Hence why I’ve kept it somewhat brief. I genuinely wish it weren’t true. It’s shit thinking your parent has stolen from you, on top of all the other crap she’s done to me. More so I’m sad for my own DCs. I haven’t just wildly jumped to conclusions, I’ve done a lot of research which backs it up. But anyway, as I say, it’s not my thread so will leave it there.

Ideasplease322 · 01/08/2021 10:46

@Mandalay246

What a load of rubbish. Most people I know will probably receive some sort of inheritance - they certainly don't "build their life around it" and I doubt they give it much thought. Confused
This

I think OP has some odd view. She is basically saying that she is happy in rent accommodation etc becaus the alternative is family money which is always beciase.

Ignoring the vast majority of people who make their own money, and ignoring the vast majority of people who don’t inherit until they are close to retirement and who have a lovely normal family dynamic.

But if it makes op feel superior she can knock herself out

Swipe left for the next trending thread