Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think family money is a curse?

213 replies

BeatieBourke · 01/08/2021 00:24

Of course, if your landed gentry and have trust funds coming out of eyeballs there might be more autonomy and independence than the rest of us have...

Similarly, if you're absolutely struggling to feed your family, you'll understandably put up with all sorts for the sake of feeding your kids. I've been there.

But otherwise, being beholden to the dangled carrot of an inheritance, not being able to plan your own future, knowing that other people have the power to make or break your financial security? Nah, you're alright ta. I'll take staying in rented accommodation my whole life and live without holidays/decent cars/other keeping up with the Jones' stuff with whatever tiny buffer I can manage to scrape together from one month to the next and a degree of dignity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
21Bee · 01/08/2021 16:37

@IcedSpice it isn’t really, every ten years the trust pays a charge, from memory it’s around 6% of the total value of the trust. Over time they pay a lot of tax, it is just sustainable. This is to prevent what happened in the 50s where many people went bankrupt and knocked down country houses that now be of national value and listed (literally thousands of buildings were destroyed). This is available to anybody in the UK who wants to pay tax in an efficient way. The 100% agricultural property relief and business property relief is also available to anybody.

The Duke also paid for and built a hospital which he gifted to the nation out of his own personal money.

Cocomarine · 01/08/2021 16:29

I may or may not inherit £100K. Most probably will. If I do, who can say when? But most likely is when I’m 60.

I don’t think of it at all. It has no hold over me. No-one tries to use it to have a hold over me. It’s possible I’ll give a lot of it to a sibling to increase their share for personal reasons - also the view of another sibling.

I never plan against anything that isn’t certain, or as near as it can be.

So my retirement, prioritising pension over luxuries now (and lucky to be able to do so) just continues as if it doesn’t exist.

If I ever get it will - circumstance and emotions aside - be like winning on the lottery. It will just enhance my retirement provision, or be gifted on to my children.

I think the majority of people are like me, not OP’s friends. Drama free.

IcedSpice · 01/08/2021 16:26

thanks @21Bee that is outrageous!!

21Bee · 01/08/2021 16:16

[quote PegasusReturns]@IcedSpice do you know why that was? Assume complex trusts but I’m curious.[/quote]
They were allowed to set up the trusts and it was successfully ruled that the 4th Duke died of a war wound. Those who die of war injuries do not have to pay any inheritance tax. All of the family estate was then put into trust.

LimitIsUp · 01/08/2021 16:14

I doubt my (older) dc will agree with you op. They don't have to jump through hoops or toe the line to receive financial support from us. They don't demand or expect it but we will help them out because we love them, and we can

21Bee · 01/08/2021 16:11

@IcedSpice You are misunderstanding how trusts work though. The trusts pay tax every ten years based on the value. It’s more efficient this way as the Duke obviously doesn’t have 8 billion in cash so the tax can be planned. Lots of the land owned by the family also attracts 0% inheritance tax as it is farmland.

The late Duke of Westminster famously wasn’t supposed to inherit and didn’t want it, he had to give up his planned life to take on the estate and later suffered from a breakdown as a result of the pressure.

LipstickLou · 01/08/2021 15:49

Well I didn't get that. But I got two happy parents who loved us and tried their best. We have all done well. They had 9 grandchildren who still talk about their caravan holidays and learning to cook. I grew up in the 1970s when we had strikes and food shortages. My 'lady' mother was disinherited, she cared not. She was fearless, a bit mad but she loved us. I have a few things from her smart family but you know what? My ordinary dad taught me more. If you inherit, good for you.

Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 15:33

My understanding is that if you inherit a house you weren't living in, it forms part of the estate and is subject to IHT

If a house is left to children or grandchildren it adds another £175k to the tax free allowance. Hence a couple having £1 million between them.

LipstickLou · 01/08/2021 15:31

@CounsellorTroi
Yes living in the family home. Married three times. Very chequered history.

CounsellorTroi · 01/08/2021 15:22

[quote LipstickLou]@CounsellorTroi

The family home is worth £750000 which i believe will not attract inheritance tax. The rest is stocks. I find the waiting for her life to start bewildering. She is already 60. She is planning a big house purchase. Her mother does hold the carrot![/quote]
Is she living in the family home? My understanding is that if you inherit a house you weren't living in, it forms part of the estate and is subject to IHT.

DemBonesDemBones · 01/08/2021 15:19

I got a big inheritance. Would rather have my family member back than the money, but I have spent it in ways that I know she'd approve of and would make her proud of me.

DeathByWalkies · 01/08/2021 14:48

[quote MyMabel]@Blossomtoes

Can you find a house for £50k?[/quote]
If you want a doer upper in a deprived part of the South Wales valleys then yes.

Not in most parts of the country though, and not places where jobs actually exist

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/111223556

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/103068401

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/108003914

EmergencyHydrangea · 01/08/2021 13:53

[quote MyMabel]@Blossomtoes

Can you find a house for £50k?[/quote]
Maybe not in mumsnet land but you can where I live

IcedSpice · 01/08/2021 13:47

[quote PegasusReturns]@IcedSpice do you know why that was? Assume complex trusts but I’m curious.[/quote]
Something like that I imagine - when they talk about raising taxes for the rich all the time, they would be better off just making the rich PAY their taxes!

Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 13:45

[quote MyMabel]@Blossomtoes

Can you find a house for £50k?[/quote]
No but then I don’t think owning one outright is a right. It’s a healthy deposit.

MyMabel · 01/08/2021 13:42

@Blossomtoes

Can you find a house for £50k?

Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 13:41

[quote MyMabel]@Blossomtoes

The kind of person who that is split between multiple siblings, that is on the absolute breadline and is about to lose their house, the tax and the split between siblings means she won’t actually pocket much in the way of re-building her life at all.

Some people have money, some people don’t - I just don’t find it fair to dictate what you can and can’t take from whats left by the deceased. It seems cruel.[/quote]
There would have to be a huge number of siblings for this to be the case. Even if there were ten, they’d end up with at least £50k - that’s not peanuts in anyone’s world.

Completely agree @IcedSpice. It’s scandalous.

PegasusReturns · 01/08/2021 13:39

@IcedSpice do you know why that was? Assume complex trusts but I’m curious.

IcedSpice · 01/08/2021 13:37

Had the Grosvenor estate bequeathed to the new Duke of Westminster been liable for 40% inheritance tax, the amount owed to the Treasury would have been not far off the government’s entire death duty take for the last financial year.

IcedSpice · 01/08/2021 13:36

[quote MyMabel]@Blossomtoes

The kind of person who that is split between multiple siblings, that is on the absolute breadline and is about to lose their house, the tax and the split between siblings means she won’t actually pocket much in the way of re-building her life at all.

Some people have money, some people don’t - I just don’t find it fair to dictate what you can and can’t take from whats left by the deceased. It seems cruel.[/quote]
so the tax is on amounts OVER the specified amounts? why not tax it?

THIS is what makes me crazy "The heirs of the late sixth Duke of Westminster paid no inheritance tax on the bulk of his £8.3bn family fortune following his death in 2016. Probate records show that Gerald Cavendish Grosvenor, who died aged 64 in August 2016, left a personal estate of £616,418,184 after payment of debts and liabilities."

MyMabel · 01/08/2021 13:25

@Blossomtoes

The kind of person who that is split between multiple siblings, that is on the absolute breadline and is about to lose their house, the tax and the split between siblings means she won’t actually pocket much in the way of re-building her life at all.

Some people have money, some people don’t - I just don’t find it fair to dictate what you can and can’t take from whats left by the deceased. It seems cruel.

Blossomtoes · 01/08/2021 13:18

[quote MyMabel]@Blossomtoes

I don’t understand what you mean? No sympathy because it’s over 325k of money left to family members?

So if I was a smaller amount of money you’d sympathise? It’s not anyone fault they’ve got a substantial amount of money that’s been left to them. I still think it’s pretty poor to tax any money at 40% that’s been earned and left to someone’s children.[/quote]
You understand perfectly well what I mean, I suspect. IHT applies to the proportion of an estate that exceeds £325k. If a residential property forms part of it, it increases to £500k. In what world would anyone reasonable object to paying tax on an unearned windfall of more than half a million?

MsAwesomeDragon · 01/08/2021 13:07

Dh's uncle left everything to him when he died. There had never been an expectation of an inheritance at all, and DH certainly didn't feel beholden to him.

My parents have a will that says everything they own will be split 3 ways between my brother, sister and me. I'm not actually expecting anything because I'm fairly certain it'll all be eaten up by care fees. I see/help out my parents because I love them, not because I'm thinking about an inheritance.

Dh's parents are unlikely to leave us anything. Mil because she doesn't have anything to leave, she's in a council flat and relies on her state pension with a little top up from her late husband's work pension. Fil has more assets, but they will probably go to his step children because he actually sees them, whereas he's only seen DH twice in the past 15 years (once was our wedding)

MyMabel · 01/08/2021 13:01

@Blossomtoes

I don’t understand what you mean? No sympathy because it’s over 325k of money left to family members?

So if I was a smaller amount of money you’d sympathise? It’s not anyone fault they’ve got a substantial amount of money that’s been left to them. I still think it’s pretty poor to tax any money at 40% that’s been earned and left to someone’s children.

IcedSpice · 01/08/2021 12:55

@Bryonyshcmyony

(no such thing as road tax!)
"Road tax implies you are being taxed to use the roads and the money goes back into the roads - that's not correct." The DVLA - rebuked for an advert calling for people to pay their road tax - now calls it vehicle tax. The Post Office calls it car tax.15 Aug 2013

Even so, why do people say that? it is a bloody road tax, you're not allowed on the road without it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread