Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?

420 replies

BendyTrendy · 31/07/2021 22:38

Tricky one because our state pensions are lower than the rest of the EU, but also the largest area of welfare spending (at about 42% of the welfare budget).

Still, on balance, I think it's reasonable to break the triple lock under the circumstances of both Brexit and Covid recovery.

Can the country justify an 8% rise to the state pension under the circumstances? Is the triple lock on pensions sustainable? I feel mean even asking the questions, but tough choices must be made.

Boris Johnson signals 'triple lock' on pensions could be broken amid estimates of 8% rise

State pension predicted to rise by 8%

Rishi Sunak hints at suspension to pension triple lock

Tough one.

OP posts:
saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:42

@Bryonyshcmyony what solutions would you favour?

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 11:41

The solution might be that the (wealthier) pensioners start showing more empathy and support for those less privileged than themselves. Will never happen. That would require humility

Showing humility and empathy doesn't seem to be your forte.

Roussette · 01/08/2021 11:40

The solution might be that the (wealthier) pensioners start showing more empathy and support for those less privileged than themselves. Will never happen. That would require humility

FFS what tosh. How do you know this? We are relatively comfortably off pensioners compared to some, and you have no idea what we do to help others. As do many people I know.
I am continually thinking and actioning ways to help others, with anything from an 18 year record of voluntary work (not just a once a week thing, but a serious commitment that rules my life) to making donations, and being aware of how lucky we are and how others need help within my community and elsewhere.

You sound very unpleasant OP. You obviously don't like anyone who is old, you resent them, and you wish they'd die off (you insinuated that in one of your posts).
Shock horror, you'll be old one day and watch out for those younger than you treating you with derision and dislike.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:40

@PlasticEgg nor did the furloughed

Fluto · 01/08/2021 11:39

I just feel there’s little evidence that pensioners are speaking up for other vulnerable groups or supporting other groups in receipt of the welfare budget. As the biggest receivers of the welfare budget, why are pensioners not speaking up for other groups? Is it just about them getting their triple lock pension and scared about sharing?

I have to say that I find this point of view very odd, that pensioners should be 'speaking up' for recipients of benefits, shouldn't we all? Pensions come out of the welfare budget because of the illogical way they have been set up, but if you have paid your stamps which means you've made at minimum x contribution, it's an entitlement not a claim. Just as those who now get a state pension paid for others when they were working.

A lot of ignorance being spouted, and to be frank some really deplorable comments. People can retire in their 60s, the fact some people seem to think that means they have lived their life at somepoint is baffling.

I'd rather we fought to pay all of those who need it a fair amount rather than dragging one group down because others also get screwed by the Tories.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:37

@DancesWithTortoises was it low in comparison to living costs? Today's is means tested & in my opinion pretty low, no one is having lots of kids for £14 a wk.

DoubleTweenQueen · 01/08/2021 11:36

@PlasticEgg Star

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:35

I have been poor and very comfortable in my life.

Adjust their lives and expectations accordingly.

I didn't think then that the rich owed me to come out of poverty

By that logic are you saying it's ok to for pensioners to be poor? Or that if pensioners are thrown into poverty as as a result of loosing the triple lock it's because they didn't save accordingly & make the right choices?

I disagree.

DancesWithTortoises · 01/08/2021 11:33

[quote saywhatn]@DancesWithTortoises so was it means tested for those subsequent dc?
and what happened after 1977?[/quote]
After 1977 all children qualified for the benefit. It was very low, as I remember. It wasn't means tested but it should have been.

PlasticEgg · 01/08/2021 11:32

Agree that this is divide and rule.

Industry closed initially because of the pandemic. But it remained closed for a long time and closed a few times more because the government failed to deal effectively with the pandemic. They even created a new social class - "the vulnerable" - so called because government failure to deal with the pandemic rendered regular society dangerous for this class of people.

"We" didn't do anything to protect them. They were effectively removed from society. The government's advice that they remove themselves was an admission that they had failed to provide a safe environment for this group of people.

The prolonged industry shut down, the repeated lock downs ofc damaged the economy. But had the government got a proper handle on numbers this wouldn't have happened. We too could have been like much of Asia, where economies have after initial interruption been merrily ticking along for a year now. We certainly had the tech and comms to do the same. But we didn't.

So now the economy is fucked. And we're being told to look at each other for where the blame lies. Don't fall for it. Pensioners didn't cause the economic situation we're in now.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:31

@vivainsomnia you didn't explain how to tackle wage stagnation & less generous private pensions?

DancesWithTortoises · 01/08/2021 11:31

As the biggest receivers of the welfare budget, why are pensioners not speaking up for other groups?

What makes you think they aren't? All those I know do speak up and donate to charity and foodbanks locally.

It doesn't suit your argument, though, does it?

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/08/2021 11:31

Family allowance is too high these days for a benefit that almost everyone gets

If they scrapped it, there would be a very decent amount to help offset the debt we have incurred or to improve health and education services.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:30

@DancesWithTortoises so was it means tested for those subsequent dc?
and what happened after 1977?

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:29

The biggest mistake young people make currently is to decide to have children before getting on the ladder. That alone makes it so much harder to do so. When they go on to have two or more children, it becomes almost impossible.

Are we just going to ignore that the age of mothers & first time buyers has increased & people are having less children in general?

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 11:29

It also means vulnerable groups
To me, vulnerable groups are those who can't or have much fewer options to change the position they are in. People who don't want to work more hours because they want more time with their children don't fall into that category.

DancesWithTortoises · 01/08/2021 11:28

Do you mean child benefit which is now means tested and the equivalent which used to be available to all families?

It used to only be available to second and subsequent children until 1977. Plenty of pensioners raised their families without it.

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 11:27

The poor are screwed in favour of the rich

I believe "poor" people are also entitled to a pension.

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 11:27

*How do you know that pensioners weren’t stay at home parents once too?
They might have been indeed, but that was at a time they were told that they would definitely get a state pension in retirement and occupational pensions were almost non existent, specially for the low paid. Nowadays, it's a legal requirement, so quite a different situation.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:26

Shouldn't we, as a society, be demanding that our taxes are used to support all the vulnerable groups?

I agree hence why all taxes need to be looked at.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 11:26

@SecretSpAD

Will that change things? There are not enough young people, the median age is 40.5 & obviously kids can't vote.

The younger age groups are always the ones who are least likely to turn out at an election.

While there is a general ageing of the population the 18-59 age groups are still n the majority ffs.

I do think that younger people calling for reductions in state pensions are potentially shooting themselves in the foot for their future. Shouldn't we, as a society, be demanding that our taxes are used to support all the vulnerable groups? Shouldn't we also demand that employers pay an actual living wage so people can live on what they earn rather than rely on top ups?

Or is it just easier to bash pensioners for daring to want to eat and heat their houses - and yes, many do live on the breadline and many do face that choice.

Yea, it’s fair that there’s a bigger issue of inequality. We should as a society support each other and our most vulnerable groups. It also means vulnerable groups must support each other rather than play into the hands of divide and rule.

I just feel there’s little evidence that pensioners are speaking up for other vulnerable groups or supporting other groups in receipt of the welfare budget. As the biggest receivers of the welfare budget, why are pensioners not speaking up for other groups? Is it just about them getting their triple lock pension and scared about sharing?

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 11:24

The poor are screwed in favour of the rich
It is so pointless to discuss these as it there were just static inheritant status.

Some people who are rich or poor started in the exact same position but made different choices. Some people started poor and ended up rich and vice versa. Some poor people have options to come out of poverty, some wealthier people could lose it all in a matter of months or even weeks.

I have been poor and very comfortable in my life. I wasn't a different person when I was poor. I didn't think then that the rich owed me to come out of poverty, not do I think now that all poor people are so because of their own doing.

you didn't explain what the young can do about house prices, wage stagnation etc?
The same previous generations did when they faced the same issues. Adjust their lives and expectations accordingly. The biggest mistake young people make currently is to decide to have children before getting on the ladder. That alone makes it so much harder to do so. When they go on to have two or more children, it becomes almost impossible.

DancesWithTortoises · 01/08/2021 11:24

The solution might be that the (wealthier) pensioners start showing more empathy and support for those less privileged than themselves. Will never happen. That would require humility.

Untwist your knickers, OP, you are looking like a spiteful child stamping your feet.

Pensioners are propping up most charities with their donations. As a group they give more than any other age group. Hardly lacking in empathy.

That's something you are certainly lacking.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:23

While there is a general ageing of the population the 18-59 age groups are still n the majority ffs

who denied that @SecretSpAD I was specifically talking about young people.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 11:22

What is there to not understand? I don't know how many people are having babies to live off the state but I do know that people are very lazy about contraception as can be seen on this forum on a daily basis. Why should the rest of us pay for their stupidity?

You literally answered your own question. You don't know how many but we are all paying for them.

Family allowance is too high these days for a benefit that almost everyone gets. It should only go to those in need. And maybe they should get more.

Do you mean child benefit which is now means tested and the equivalent which used to be available to all families?

Swipe left for the next trending thread