Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?

420 replies

BendyTrendy · 31/07/2021 22:38

Tricky one because our state pensions are lower than the rest of the EU, but also the largest area of welfare spending (at about 42% of the welfare budget).

Still, on balance, I think it's reasonable to break the triple lock under the circumstances of both Brexit and Covid recovery.

Can the country justify an 8% rise to the state pension under the circumstances? Is the triple lock on pensions sustainable? I feel mean even asking the questions, but tough choices must be made.

Boris Johnson signals 'triple lock' on pensions could be broken amid estimates of 8% rise

State pension predicted to rise by 8%

Rishi Sunak hints at suspension to pension triple lock

Tough one.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 17:02

I just said you can't generalise and say young people have choices & pensioners don't
No you can't say that all young people have options and no pensioners do. I actually said that already if you read properly. You can however say that comparing the two, the former do have more options than the latter. It is a bit pointless to try to discuss each and everything individual specific circumstances.

And many of the people receiving this are in genuine need and vulnerable with no choices. But you are suggesting in many of your posts that this is for lazy people who have choices, and pensioners don’t
Talk about twisting words!! I mentioned the issue of tax credits as a response to a poster who was stating that young families never get a look into. They do and this is evidence that they are. I am in no way making assertions that it wasn't justified. Twisting things to suit your agenda doesn't help the discussion.

VickyEadieofThigh · 01/08/2021 17:01

My Dad is 88 lives in a council bungalow because he never earned enough to buy a house. He has (a) never voted Tory in his life, (b) voted Remain, (c) relies on the state pension, (d) now has to pay for his TV licence since the free licence was taken away by the Tories.

Does he deserve the "karma" of Covid, which has effectively marooned him in his house since March 2020?

@BendyTrendy - you have a lot of opinions about the lack of 'worthiness' of the elderly as an amorphous mass. You might like to remember that 'age' is a protected characteristic...

ShortBacknSides · 01/08/2021 16:56

Most people don’t pay in anywhere near as much as they take out.

I remember reading somewhere that actuarially, anyone who has a child takes out more than they put in. So the system works by that child putting in, and so on ...

MadinMarch · 01/08/2021 16:54

Bold text fail, but hopefully you get the gist!

MadinMarch · 01/08/2021 16:53

@MarianneUnfaithful
Just for the record, you do realise that I didn't make the comment below?

This is an unpopular view, but it is factual that the elderly are also in the group most likely to die. They’ve had their time. Covid just speeded up the inevitable process. Maybe nature had a way of telling us that we can’t continue living unnaturally long lives anymore. It’s unsustainable for the planet, it’s resources and the welfare budget*

I merely responded to it to say it was disgusting and truly vile.

user1497207191 · 01/08/2021 16:52

@ShortBacknSides

but some views on this thread are really grim. The karma one is appalling, I can't believe that's okay but other posts and threads get taken down for a lot less

Indeed @Floralcoral I was appalled & then furious when I read @BendyTrendy's post about karma. I was going to report it, but then I thought - let others see just how utterly lacking in imagination & empathy the OP is.

I really cannot understand why all the young 20s/30s posters on this thread cannot have the empathetic imagination - or the basic intelligence - to imagine themselves in 40 or 50 years' time. Will they be talking about COVID as karma for the elderly?

It is appalling, that there's a generation of parents thinking like this.

If the @BendyTrendy were really concerned about fairness, she'd be thinking about this:

  • the UK is one of the richest countries in the world;
  • the issue is not of lack of funds, it's about distribution;
  • it's also about not taxing people/corporations who make a shedload of money in the UK:
  • it's about politics:
  • things like "austerity" were a choice a political ideological choice.

The OP might want to think about this, rather than attack her fellow citizens.

The uk isn’t one of the richest. We have crippling debt and are paying more in interest on that national debt than we spend on education. We’re just borrowing to maintain the illusion we’re rich.
user1497207191 · 01/08/2021 16:50

[quote Floralcoral]@user1497207191 that's not loads of people, but it's mainly women. Do you think they shouldn't be eligible because the burden of childcare often falls to them? Or if they're lower earners? Within that bracket are many who have caring responsibility for disabled children who cannot work as employers don't allow the flexibility and/or childcare and educational settings can't always provide a safe and appropriate setting for them. Do you feel they should miss out on a state pension? Confused.[/quote]
No I’ve no problem with it at all, just pointing out that not everyone has paid years of NIC to get their state pension and it’s more common than you think.

ShortBacknSides · 01/08/2021 16:48

but some views on this thread are really grim. The karma one is appalling, I can't believe that's okay but other posts and threads get taken down for a lot less

Indeed @Floralcoral I was appalled & then furious when I read @BendyTrendy's post about karma. I was going to report it, but then I thought - let others see just how utterly lacking in imagination & empathy the OP is.

I really cannot understand why all the young 20s/30s posters on this thread cannot have the empathetic imagination - or the basic intelligence - to imagine themselves in 40 or 50 years' time. Will they be talking about COVID as karma for the elderly?

It is appalling, that there's a generation of parents thinking like this.

If the @BendyTrendy were really concerned about fairness, she'd be thinking about this:

  • the UK is one of the richest countries in the world;
  • the issue is not of lack of funds, it's about distribution;
  • it's also about not taxing people/corporations who make a shedload of money in the UK:
  • it's about politics:
  • things like "austerity" were a choice a political ideological choice.

The OP might want to think about this, rather than attack her fellow citizens.

Floralcoral · 01/08/2021 16:33

@user1497207191 that's not loads of people, but it's mainly women. Do you think they shouldn't be eligible because the burden of childcare often falls to them? Or if they're lower earners? Within that bracket are many who have caring responsibility for disabled children who cannot work as employers don't allow the flexibility and/or childcare and educational settings can't always provide a safe and appropriate setting for them. Do you feel they should miss out on a state pension? Confused.

Roussette · 01/08/2021 16:33

You get “credits” on benefits and when a stay at home parent

For those of us who are now receiving a pension, that is just not true. That did not apply 30 years ago (the age of my youngest)

Maybe you are now in an enviable position then compared to us now on a state pension

lazyarse123 · 01/08/2021 15:59

@Pattypan Er, well lockdown was primarily to protect the elderly…
Plus I really don’t fancy paying more tax to pay for old people when 15% of my income goes on student loan repayments…
And yes I’ve voted in every single election since I came of age!
No it wasn't it was to protect the nhs. It was your choice to go to uni so it's your debt. Pensioners have already paid in for upwards of 40 years and for those who are now well off presumably they have been forward planning as you did by going to uni. Are you saying you won't want a state pension because your graduate job with private pension will be enough for you? Let's hope so eh.

user1497207191 · 01/08/2021 15:59

@Floralcoral

Lots of people can get full state pension without paying any NIC at all!

That's not true.

Yes it is.

You get “credits” on benefits and when a stay at home parent.

You also get credits if your wages from each job are above the lower earning threshold but below the next threshold where nics are payable, I,e. One or more part time jobs each earning between £8-£9k per year.

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 14:22

While talking about how people should have empathy. 🙄

Roussette · 01/08/2021 14:19

I am reeling from some of them

So am I.

We should just die off when we get to pensionable age obviously.

Floralcoral · 01/08/2021 14:14

Lots of people can get full state pension without paying any NIC at all!

That's not true.

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 14:13

I do agree that it shouldn't be 8% necessarily, but some views on this thread are really grim. The karma one is appalling, I can't believe that's okay but other posts and threads get taken down for a lot less

I am reeling from some of them.

DGRossetti · 01/08/2021 14:12

@jasjas1973

Amzing! argue amongst our selves on which vulnerable group should take a financial cut, whilst the number of millionaires and billionaires increase in the UK.
One of the best memes I've seen recently said that if Billionaires really wanted to go somewhere they'd never been before, they'd visit the tax office before outer space.
user1497207191 · 01/08/2021 14:11

@worriedatthemoment

Just increase as promised it may be a large amount of our welfare budget but to be fair already paid foe by these people, if only previous goverments had left the money in the pension pots
Most people don’t pay in anywhere near as much as they take out. Lots of people can get full state pension without paying any NIC at all!
Floralcoral · 01/08/2021 14:06

@Hardbackwriter

But why do people say pensioners not getting the 8% would mean their income was being cut? They wouldn't be getting a big bonus from other people's incomes going down due to covid but that's not the same thing at all. Or are people assuming the choice is between going with the statistical anomaly and giving an 8% rise or freezing pensions - I don't see why they should be the only choices? You could just make it double lock of CPI or 2.5%, whichever is higher, this year so pensioners wouldn't lose out, they just wouldn't actively profit from covid.
I do agree that it shouldn't be 8% necessarily, but some views on this thread are really grim. The karma one is appalling, I can't believe that's okay but other posts and threads get taken down for a lot less.
Hardbackwriter · 01/08/2021 14:04

But why do people say pensioners not getting the 8% would mean their income was being cut? They wouldn't be getting a big bonus from other people's incomes going down due to covid but that's not the same thing at all. Or are people assuming the choice is between going with the statistical anomaly and giving an 8% rise or freezing pensions - I don't see why they should be the only choices? You could just make it double lock of CPI or 2.5%, whichever is higher, this year so pensioners wouldn't lose out, they just wouldn't actively profit from covid.

jasjas1973 · 01/08/2021 13:57

Amzing! argue amongst our selves on which vulnerable group should take a financial cut, whilst the number of millionaires and billionaires increase in the UK.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 13:50

@Daphnise

It's always easy to have views on proposed cuts to people's income when it's others, not you, who will be the losers.

There is one cut I really wish would happen though: to MPs' salaries.

This is true. Much needed perspective. Thanks.

We’ve had austerity for over a decade now. Not easy.

OP posts:
Rainy365 · 01/08/2021 13:49

I despair at the supposed logic of some posters supporting the state funding an 8% pension increase to significantly wealthy pensioners because they’ve worked their whole lives but support cutting universal credit to genuinely vulnerable adults and families because a small proportion of people may be lazy and claim UC instead of working, or increasing their hours or “getting a better job”.

I’m actually on the fence about the 8% in itself. If they weren’t cutting the UC uplift it would feel a tad more reasonable. It’s just completely disproportionate compared to every other state benefit or public funding. But i can’t begrudge the extra money to pensioners who are genuinely desperately in need. I can begrudge it for the wealthy ones though.

Daphnise · 01/08/2021 13:32

It's always easy to have views on proposed cuts to people's income when it's others, not you, who will be the losers.

There is one cut I really wish would happen though: to MPs' salaries.

Rainy365 · 01/08/2021 13:25

@Bryonyshcmyony

Not all young people do. Some young people (ones with severe disabilities for example) have much fewer choices and are much more vulnerable than some pensioners

I'm willing to bet there are far more pensioners who can't work due to ill health than there are young people with disabilities so severe they can never work.

I’ve no idea but what’s the relevance even if it’s true?

The point I’m making is both groups have vulnerable people that have no choices regarding work/income but many seem to think it only applies to pensioners, and that’s why they are worthy of an 8% increase. The working age group should still have the £20 uplift stopped because the majority of working age have choices. Despite the fact there are working age people who also have no choices.

We should be protecting all vulnerable people not just pensioners. Either we have better systems in place to focus on only the truly vulnerable or we accept that when it’s more universal we will also be paying for people who don’t really need it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread