Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?

420 replies

BendyTrendy · 31/07/2021 22:38

Tricky one because our state pensions are lower than the rest of the EU, but also the largest area of welfare spending (at about 42% of the welfare budget).

Still, on balance, I think it's reasonable to break the triple lock under the circumstances of both Brexit and Covid recovery.

Can the country justify an 8% rise to the state pension under the circumstances? Is the triple lock on pensions sustainable? I feel mean even asking the questions, but tough choices must be made.

Boris Johnson signals 'triple lock' on pensions could be broken amid estimates of 8% rise

State pension predicted to rise by 8%

Rishi Sunak hints at suspension to pension triple lock

Tough one.

OP posts:
pantsdants · 02/08/2021 20:10

look at Russian/Chinese money in the London property market (and other areas)

And again people like property prices going up. God knows why as it just makes it more difficulty to climb the ladder & for their dc but it makes people feel rich. Hence all the gov props.

pantsdants · 02/08/2021 20:08

@Boarderingmadness most people won't vote for more tax though. People who earn over 50k already pay 40% & freezing of the bands for 5 yrs is income tax rises by stealth.

Increasing BTL taxes, IHT, CG etc are a way of targeting the wealthy but your average person won't vote for that because it either impacts them or they aspire such that it will.

Boarderingmadness · 02/08/2021 19:52

@pantsdants

If you think means testing will make people hide savings & commit fraud what do you think taxing higher earners will do?
Whatever the tax rate, the wealthy do that, its basic human greed.

But if governments wanted to, they could crack down on tax avoidance/evasion, its just that they don't want too - look at Russian/Chinese money in the London property market (and other areas)

Sunak is a multimillionaire, his in laws even richer, why would he do anything to make these sorts of people pay more tax?

justasking111 · 02/08/2021 18:59

How many pensioners died due to covid, now are in private care thus creating employment. You can bet someone in Whitehall has done that sum

pantsdants · 02/08/2021 18:41

I think they should pause the triple lock this yr & reinstate.

Why do people act like pensions are a homogenous group? Some are wealthy, some were higher rate tax payers pre retirement, some were on benefits & worked p/t before retirement etc.

pantsdants · 02/08/2021 18:39

If you think means testing will make people hide savings & commit fraud what do you think taxing higher earners will do?

Viviennemary · 02/08/2021 17:39

I don't agree with the state pension being means tested. They can tax everyone in the higher tax brackets more then the better off pensioners will pay more tax. Means testing will mean people hiding savings or putting them in somebody elses's name. Nobody could live of the basic state pension alone in any case.

DynamoKev · 02/08/2021 16:56

@SimonJT

The state pension is already low, plus a lot of people, particularly women don’t get the full state pension. Pushing those people further into poverty is wrong, we need to increase taxes for higher earners and greatly improve pension provision in the UK, both state and private.
Exactly - once Rees-Mogg, Amazon et al start coughing up we can look at the other end of the scale, not now.
DynamoKev · 02/08/2021 16:54

@ginghamstarfish

Problem with discussions on this subject is that the word 'pensioner' conjures up an image of a poor elderly person living in near poverty. In reality that age group is I believe the wealthiest. Yes, those relying solely on a state pension will need that increase, but many others have good pensions and are very comfortably off. For example, my FIL retired at 50 on a large private pension, and at 85 has spent longer retired than he worked. Those of us yet to reach the ever increasing pension age can only dream of such a thing.
And he will have been continuing to pay income tax in that case, so in sense he has been means tested.
DynamoKev · 02/08/2021 16:52

There is no unlimited pot of money- we are already spending more than we bring in and borrowing to cover the deficit.
Overly simplistic "economics" of the patronising type favoured by the rich to excuse them always getting richer whatever else happens.

Future generations will have to pay that back.

The ordinary drones may have to - the Rees-Moggs and other trust fund tax-dodgers won't.

Tinpotspectator · 02/08/2021 16:45

*A means tested pension sounds more reasonable.

Take away the entitlement from those who don’t need the state benefit and there’s more to go around to those who do need it.*

Sod that. We PAID for that, with decades of national insurance.

worriedatthemoment · 02/08/2021 12:22

@CayrolBaaaskin you can get jsa even if not always paid in but just in another way
Pensions are generally paid into and money should of beeb out aside
I know many pensioners and not many are rich , I think thats a myth that so many are

CayrolBaaaskin · 02/08/2021 11:58

@lazyarse123 - pensions are a benefit. There are other benefits too that are contribution based and available without means testing (JSA for example). However these benefits have generally been cut back because they are expensive. State pensions are not paid out of some pot of money saved up by current pensioners- they are paid out of the treasury and from borrowing by current and future taxpayers.

It’s absolutely unfair that some of the wealthiest people in society are getting an 8% increase in benefits while others are having their income cut back. Each individual pensioner is not wealthy of course but pensions are not means tested and many pensioners are very wealthy indeed (in fact as a whole current pensioners are wealthier than working age households). If any of the previous posters were really concerned with pensioner poverty rather than their own self interest, why not suggest means tested benefits for pensioners?

I will absolutely be a pensioner in a few years but I don’t consider opposing something that I consider grossly unfair as “shooting myself in the foot”. I may benefit financially from a universal state pension with over inflation increases on top of my private pension and investments but I don’t think that’s right. I want fairness for my dds generation too and the ones to come after that.

As for those saying well we should increase everyone’s income- emm finances don’t work like that. There is no unlimited pot of money- we are already spending more than we bring in and borrowing to cover the deficit. Future generations will have to pay that back.

Ultimately this huge increase is way above inflation. It’s way above rises in other benefits (which are in fact being cut) which go to people much more in need. It’s way above increases in public sector wages including NHS. it’s absolutely unfair and completely unaffordable considering we are currently borrowing to fund our level of public spending. The reason for this is to win votes. Totally wrong imo.

Zombiemum1946 · 02/08/2021 11:45

Simonjt is right. There has been a high profile legal battle for women to receive the full pension.

Timperleybell · 02/08/2021 11:30

@Mintjulia

Imagine being in a 76 person residential home and having 19 of the other residents die.
The sad truth is that the average life expectancy in a care home is approx. 24 months and less in a nursing home. So in a normal year it would be expected that around half the residents would die. While the mortality rate was very high for a short period and must have been frightening the overall impact wasn't that huge.
SimonJT · 02/08/2021 10:59

The state pension is already low, plus a lot of people, particularly women don’t get the full state pension. Pushing those people further into poverty is wrong, we need to increase taxes for higher earners and greatly improve pension provision in the UK, both state and private.

ginghamstarfish · 02/08/2021 10:36

Problem with discussions on this subject is that the word 'pensioner' conjures up an image of a poor elderly person living in near poverty. In reality that age group is I believe the wealthiest. Yes, those relying solely on a state pension will need that increase, but many others have good pensions and are very comfortably off. For example, my FIL retired at 50 on a large private pension, and at 85 has spent longer retired than he worked. Those of us yet to reach the ever increasing pension age can only dream of such a thing.

puffyisgood · 02/08/2021 10:30

For the state pension we should be thinking about, in terms of weekly penspions, what's necessary, what's affordable, and what's fair.

Thinking in terms of annual increases only is daft because it glosses over the question which matters, namely the whether the state pension at its current level is adequate or not.

Zombiemum1946 · 02/08/2021 10:27

As opposed to pension focus,how about focus on tax dodgers and employers who enjoy the luxury of the state subsiding their wage bill.

DynamoKev · 02/08/2021 10:22

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

A means tested pension sounds more reasonable

Surely that just punishes those that worked hard and saved/bought assets.

Much better to link to contributions, would encourage people to work more when they can to ensure a better retirement.

Means testing is expensive and complex and it can be exclusionary for some people. Having a decent State Pension for all is a good way to have a decent society - although judging by a lot of comments on MN, I am starting to doubt if society gives a shit about older people.
vivainsomnia · 02/08/2021 10:18

For example, most people realise their assets will be counted if they need social care later in life. They don’t just sell up their nice house and leave the job they enjoy
But in your example, it's not a given that people will end up having to sell their house to pay for social care, not even given that they will need social care. Even so though, many to opt to gift the house to their kids hoping not to require care for 7 years, so people do take it into consideration.The state pension is a given though as much as state pension in on the cards, so totally different.

It also comes down to how much they will be due to receive with their occupational pension. Those due to get a very good pension will probably just accept it, its those whose occupational pension will be hardly better than the state pension who will think 'why bother paying 100s every month if ultimately, I'll end up not much better enjoying that money each month and getting the full state pension in the end due to low income'.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 02/08/2021 10:15

A means tested pension sounds more reasonable

Surely that just punishes those that worked hard and saved/bought assets.

Much better to link to contributions, would encourage people to work more when they can to ensure a better retirement.

DynamoKev · 02/08/2021 10:12

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

If you are fortunate to have additional income you do get taxed on it the same as anyone else.

But no NI.

I don't think there's any justification for having taxes which only apply to people of working age. I think employee's NI should be abolished, and the income tax rates adjusted to make up the difference. No matter what age you are, if your income is high enough to pay tax, you pay it at the appropriate rate, and if you don't, you don't.

NI contribution years could easily be calculated by looking at income tax records and setting an appropriate threshold.

I'd keep employer's NI though.

You are utterly correct - having NI as a separate tax is stupidly complex.

It will never happen though as no party will upset HMRC (who would need fewer employees) or the electorate (who would see the actual tax rates they are paying).

DynamoKev · 02/08/2021 10:10

[quote BendyTrendy]@WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld I agree they’re low, which is why it’s tricky. The problem is that we can’t afford a triple lock under the circumstances. Can we?[/quote]
Of course we can afford it.

Austerity and all this bollocks about borrowing is just patronising rhetoric to explain why the small number of very rich people must always get richer at everyone else's expense including pensioners.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/08/2021 10:03

A means tested pension sounds more reasonable.

Take away the entitlement from those who don’t need the state benefit and there’s more to go around to those who do need it.

No doubt that would hit people like DH and I. I'm 46, he's 66 and has a state pension and I'm working full time so I presume his state pension would be reduced. My job is reasonably well paid but we'd struggle if his pension was reduced as he's now winding down his business to allow him to retire properly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread