Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?

420 replies

BendyTrendy · 31/07/2021 22:38

Tricky one because our state pensions are lower than the rest of the EU, but also the largest area of welfare spending (at about 42% of the welfare budget).

Still, on balance, I think it's reasonable to break the triple lock under the circumstances of both Brexit and Covid recovery.

Can the country justify an 8% rise to the state pension under the circumstances? Is the triple lock on pensions sustainable? I feel mean even asking the questions, but tough choices must be made.

Boris Johnson signals 'triple lock' on pensions could be broken amid estimates of 8% rise

State pension predicted to rise by 8%

Rishi Sunak hints at suspension to pension triple lock

Tough one.

OP posts:
lightand · 01/08/2021 09:03

You wouldnt feel mean op, if inside you, you know you are wrong.

lightand · 01/08/2021 08:59

It actually is a clear indication of how this government, maybe country, thinks about its' elderly.
Not that we needed more, after the covid fiasco of how it treats the elderly.

StrawberryPuff · 01/08/2021 08:57

Divide and rule at it’s finest. Get everyone riled up about the possibility that someone else is gaming the system and see them rip one another to shreds. Meanwhile, the real problems go unaddressed- things like tax evasion and corruption in government.

After all the country needs a new whipping boy. It was immigrants and the EU for a long time.

But the unicorn filled sunlit uplands of Brexit have solved all that of course and now it must be the case that some other section of society is the greedy ne’erdowells spoiling it for everyone else.

lightand · 01/08/2021 08:57

No brainer. Give pensioners the money.
The government pension is an embarassment and a pittance.

Badbadbunny · 01/08/2021 08:53

@Caffeinemonster

Yes I’m serious *@ActonSquirrel*. There are plenty of pensioners doing just fine. They don’t all need an 8% increase. I’d much rather see more means testing for payments to pensioners, such as winter fuel allowance.
Yes, either means testing, or national insurance on occupational pensions.
Badbadbunny · 01/08/2021 08:52

@Mintjulia

Imagine being in a 76 person residential home and having 19 of the other residents die.
Yeah, and a whopping pension increase will really make up for that won't it!!
Badbadbunny · 01/08/2021 08:52

@echt

Pensioners have contributed to the community more than any other group

Tough to make that argument after a pandemic where key workers have put themselves at risk and young people have given up their freedoms to protect the elderly

No it isn't, t's a statement of fact. And last time I looked the elderly also gave up their freedoms during the pandemic.

The elderly didn't give up any income. Unless the 3 million excluded self employed/freelancers who lost their business income and got no support. Unlike furloughed workers who suffered a 20% reduction in income. Unlike those working in the worst affected industries who've lost their jobs/careers.
Mintjulia · 01/08/2021 08:49

Imagine being in a 76 person residential home and having 19 of the other residents die.

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 08:47

@MsMoody

Imagine having 1000 friends and every single one of them died from covid! That would be very shocking…
😁 Well yes, but you get the idea!
MsMoody · 01/08/2021 08:46

Imagine having 1000 friends and every single one of them died from covid! That would be very shocking…

Bryonyshcmyony · 01/08/2021 08:37

[quote Mintjulia]@londonmummy1966

'I also feel that the older generation have not been that affected by the pandemic when compared with under 25s. '

...apart from watching 1,000s of their friends and loved ones die ! Hmm[/quote]
Amazing how people forget!

TheGoogleMum · 01/08/2021 08:35

Raise nhs pay by the same amount Smile

Mintjulia · 01/08/2021 08:31

@londonmummy1966

'I also feel that the older generation have not been that affected by the pandemic when compared with under 25s. '

...apart from watching 1,000s of their friends and loved ones die ! Hmm

Caffeinemonster · 01/08/2021 08:29

Yes I’m serious @ActonSquirrel. There are plenty of pensioners doing just fine. They don’t all need an 8% increase. I’d much rather see more means testing for payments to pensioners, such as winter fuel allowance.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 08:13

@ActonSquirrel “I'll get flamed for this but there are also loads of people on benefits who aren't working but could be and just don't want to. Pensioners can't work anymore and don't have a choice.”

The issue is that the pensioners are the largest expense of the welfare budget already. They cost about £111 billion or 42% of yeh budget. In comparison the ones on benefits who aren’t working but could be are in a minority.

Welfare spending

OP posts:
ActonSquirrel · 01/08/2021 07:51

@NakedAttraction

If we can only afford to award nurses a 3% pay rise then we definitely can’t afford to be giving pensioners an extra 8%.
You're not serious are you?

State pension is £137.60 per week. That's £7155.20 a year. 8% is a rise of £572 a year.

There are over 300,000 nurses on salaries of tens of thousands a year with an 8% rise each and you think that is affordable.

The starting salary for a brand new nurse is £24,907 so they are all on salaries of tens of thousands each. An 8% rise for 300k employees on starting salaries of £25k and you think that is a comparison to the state pension. 🤦🏼‍♀️

I'll get flamed for this but there are also loads of people on benefits who aren't working but could be and just don't want to. Pensioners can't work anymore and don't have a choice

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 07:39

@atlastifoundit

“Pensioners cannot go out and earn more money, they can't get a second job, they are likely to have health issues which would prevent them from earning any money to top up their pensions. How are you expecting them to be able to manage?”

Do you say the same about the severely disabled group of people? Looking at the data they can’t just go out and top up their incomes either, but are expected to survive without the triple lock protection.

Maybe it’s self interest not altruism that’s driving the triple lock as well.

OP posts:
Oldsu · 01/08/2021 04:12

@londonmummy1966

I'd like to see the triple lock broken and the main state pension frozen for higher rate tax payers. It is ridiculous that my DP who are on 100K plus index linked pensions from work get so much in bus passes, winter fuel etc and the triple locked state pension. I think that it would be better to freeze the pension and then add a top up benefit for those who need it rather than doling it out to all and sundry.

I also feel that the older generation have not been that affected by the pandemic when compared with under 25s. We have screwed the economy and stuffed our young people's education to protect the elderly and perhaps they should also bear the burden?

Just because you have relations that don't need is not a valid point, top up benefits are means tested many pensioners on a fairly low pension have only a few £s over the pension credit amount so dont get it

TAX, your DPs on a pension of 100k will be paying a lot of tax, tax that goes towards working age peoples benefits including the furlough pay and UC that helped them through the pandemic, why didn't you mention that?? is it because you didn't know (which I am sure you did) or because you don't think it matters.

As a working pensioner any increase I get just increases my tax, the last pension rise was swallowed by tax, my pay rise and bonus from work was affected by the extra tax that I pay due to my state pension but just because any rise wont really give me much does not mean I want other pensioners not to have the benefit of a pension rise.

HandlebarLadyTash · 01/08/2021 04:05

Mortgage free does not mean maintenance free
Cost of necessitys in old age.. health care equipment etc does not mean costs go down
State pension needs protecting & if anything needs increasing to a cost of living pension (I can dream)
Private sector pensions for the very averagly paid are are not good. Low.penstons will just equate to a swath of people reliant on top up benifits.

echt · 01/08/2021 03:44

Pensioners have contributed to the community more than any other group

Tough to make that argument after a pandemic where key workers have put themselves at risk and young people have given up their freedoms to protect the elderly

No it isn't, t's a statement of fact. And last time I looked the elderly also gave up their freedoms during the pandemic.

MercyBooth · 01/08/2021 02:34

Maybe you need to watch Daniel Hewitts recent very big expose on social housing before you make those assumptions. I said the community rhetoric and civic duty crap only counts when its Covid related. And that we would soon be back to the default setting. I didnt expect to be proved right so quickly. But then the vaccine uptake has been very successful so i guess ppl feel safer to cry for the old status quo to return.

MercyBooth · 01/08/2021 02:28

and even those that don't own homes outright are far more likely to have rent and secure tenancies covered by benefits than working age people

Except pensioners with a younger partner who were hit by the changes back in May 2019. I wonder how many of them got sick from Covid after their younger partner brought it back from the workplace.

mantlepiece · 01/08/2021 02:24

Surely they can recalculate the figure taking the anomaly into account.
The statisticians must be able to identify the reason the figure is over inflated (if it is).

The State Pension does seem to be low. The triple lock was probably introduced to address this. I don’t think the government thinks pensioners on basic state pensions will be booking holidays in the sun because of it. More likely they realise the State Pension barely covers basic bills.

Lovelydovey · 01/08/2021 02:04

@milian

Given the 8% average earning growth is an obvious anomaly caused by a large number of (working) people being on 80% or less of their normal salary last year and mostly back at normal levels this year, I think it would very reasonable to drop to a “double lock” of inflation or 2.5% for this year.
This. The 8% is a quirk of the furlough interacting with the calculation method.
Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/08/2021 02:03

@sopositivelynegative

As much as I don't want to pay extra taxes, most pensioners cannot increase their income. I can seek a better paid job.

It's not fair to go after our pensioners. Those of us of working age need to foot the bill.

Not everyone can just seek a better paid job for many reasons. Those minumum wage jobs have to be done by somebody. Bit hard to expect someone to foot the bill when their wages are so low they rely on UC top ups.