I don’t know whether the narrative of what’s ‘affordable’ helps these discussions. Obviously governments have to prioritise spending, but running an economy isn’t like running a household or even a business - there are costs and benefits to all spending, whether public sector pay, pensions, benefits, etc.
I don’t think pensioners should get an anomalous 8% rise, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the triple lock should be broken once and for all.
Inflation will hit pensioners hard.
I would be in favour of freezing the state pension for higher rate taxpayers as pp suggested. Also introducing a mechanism whereby better-off pensioners can waive their winter fuel allowance or withdrawing it from higher rate taxpayers, and potentially also a mechanism for better-off pensioners to waive their right to free prescriptions.
Although Labour are in a right mess, demographics overall aren’t moving in the Tories’ favour and if I was them I’d be wondering whether it was worth the risk of breaking the triple lock, on the basis that their core elderly supporters are unlikely to vote for another party any time soon. However I wouldn’t do that and decimate planning regulations
There is a discussion to be had about the future of the state pension with a growing elderly population and some radical thinking about how things might look in the not too distant future.