Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?

420 replies

BendyTrendy · 31/07/2021 22:38

Tricky one because our state pensions are lower than the rest of the EU, but also the largest area of welfare spending (at about 42% of the welfare budget).

Still, on balance, I think it's reasonable to break the triple lock under the circumstances of both Brexit and Covid recovery.

Can the country justify an 8% rise to the state pension under the circumstances? Is the triple lock on pensions sustainable? I feel mean even asking the questions, but tough choices must be made.

Boris Johnson signals 'triple lock' on pensions could be broken amid estimates of 8% rise

State pension predicted to rise by 8%

Rishi Sunak hints at suspension to pension triple lock

Tough one.

OP posts:
saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:08

We have decades of low interest rates to prop up the housing ladder but that makes saving so much harder.

Crowsaregreat · 01/08/2021 10:08

If they keep the triple lock then they need measures that will target more affluent pensioners. A fairer way of taxing property, for a start.

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 10:07

Also, it is fair to count pension credits, as many are entitled to claim this in addition to the state pension.

talkingdeadscot · 01/08/2021 10:06

@BendyTrendy

Of course there's a problem, I'm not denying that. We did have more of a means tested system where there was the state pension which everyone paid for and got when they retired. There were different rates, like the married woman who paid a lower stamp got a smaller pension. If you were a couple, then you got the couples rate however much you paid in. Poorer pensioners then claimed pension credit on top of their basic state pension.
It's only in the last couple of years this has changed so that there's one basic state pension. You get the full pension with 35 years of stamps, it's reduced if you didn't pay the full 35 years, right down to nothing if you paid less than 10 years. So we did have more of a means tested system until a couple of years ago.
Not only that, but the age of retirement has moved, for women it's moved 7 years and is set to move further. For men it's moved 2 years and set to move further.
Where has all the money already 'saved' gone? I'm 59 and already have 40 years contributions. There are many like me.
Whether or not pensions are means tested, cut or we're made to wait longer will make no difference to anyone else at all.
The poor will still be poor (because that's the system) work will still pay sh*t wages, housing will still be expensive and there will always be someone better off than you.
They've already cut sickness benefits, unemployment benefits, in work benefits and child benefit. Has any of that made anyone better off? Has the govt suddenly announced that we've all paid enough and our sacrifices have meant we no longer have to cut any more? No. Because the point is to decimate the social security system like every other service we had in order to create instability and to make sure we accept whatever crumbs crap jobs offer rather than claim benefits. Then we end up knackered and probably sick, looking forward to a few measly years on a measly pension. We truly are part of the US if this is the best we can do.

MsMoody · 01/08/2021 10:06

Workplace pensions were also much more generous back in the day. I get a letter every two years about how mine is being slashed a bit further! Defined benefit and final salary schemes are as rare as hens teeth now. Auto-enrolment and those GOV.UK adverts says it all about how we are expected to provide for our own retirements.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:05

Why? Young working families have control over increasing their income. Two people working FT will earn enough to have a decent life. They might struggle for a couple of years before childcare heps kick in, but if they stop at 2 kids, it will be manageable.

what control do you people have over higher housing costs, higher pension costs & wage stagnation?

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:03

good point @CayrolBaaaskin I also believe we should make all subsidies eg prescriptions, travel etc means tested eg for those who get pension credit.

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/08/2021 10:01

Also our pensions are not particularly mean by european standards if you look at the minimum contributions required and years paid. Ireland for example has a requirement for 48 years contributions for a full pension (only 35 in Uk) and their pension is only a little more than the uk state pension.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:00

It's a very difficult situation.

Yes state pensions are very low compared to other countries but private pensions are higher. Although that will be changing.

We can't really burden more tax on the younger population but I believe pensions costs are supposed to be unsustainable with the ageing population. We need to look at other tax revenue but everyone wants someone else to pay.

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/08/2021 09:58

I agree that it’s an excessive rise op and I don’t feel mean about it. No one else is getting such a huge rise and this is not the time for it when we are effectively borrowing to fund it.

Pensions are universal benefits so there is no argument that pensioners are poor or especially deserving. State pensions are not means tested so a lot of this money is going to those who are already pretty wealthy in terms of both assets and income. All sorts of people who receive state benefits have paid into the system and/or are still paying into it so that’s not an argument either.

Basically the tories are attempting to win votes by giving borrowed government money to elderly people, many of whom are very wealthy indeed. This debt will need to be paid back by future generations with interest.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 09:57

[quote DoubleTweenQueen]@BendyTrendy There's a flaw in the clarity of your voting preferences!
Is it AIBU to feel mean, or AIBU to think the triple lock should be disregarded?[/quote]
AIBU for feeling mean.

The issue about triple lock is the discussion issue

OP posts:
DoubleTweenQueen · 01/08/2021 09:55

@BendyTrendy There's a flaw in the clarity of your voting preferences!
Is it AIBU to feel mean, or AIBU to think the triple lock should be disregarded?

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 09:53

I’d rather the money went to younger working families than pensioners
Why? Young working families have control over increasing their income. Two people working FT will earn enough to have a decent life. They might struggle for a couple of years before childcare heps kick in, but if they stop at 2 kids, it will be manageable.

Most pensioners have no option but to accept their fate. Some do continue to work, some by choice because they can and enjoy the interaction, but some don't have a choice and it seems so wrong.

I would definitely rather my taxes to go to them than young working families where only one partner works or work PT by choice.

As for making it mean tested, that's what will happen before you know it. It does hurt to think that my OH and I have worked FT all our lives, paid a lot in NI all this time and we will likely get nothing from the state pension, when those who have opted for a much easier life will get the reward, but that's how it is.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 09:44

@talkingdeadscot

Nice. How about you all think about the fact that after a lifetime of work pensioners deserve a decent pension. It may be the largest slice of the social security budget but it's the benefit that you pay for. All your working life. If you don't have 35 years of contributions then you get a reduced pension. And on the new way of calculating, if you get the full state pension of £179pw then you don't get any pension credit. It's paid for. The age to qualify has already been moved several times. It's taxable income. If you have to get a job to top up your pension then you still pay your tax and NI. I can't believe people are saying that pensioners shouldn't have a decent income. You must have realised by now, that if you take from one group of poor people the resulting 'savings' do not ever go to another poor group. Take money from those at the top, stop spending billions on war and vanity projects and we might get some semblance of society back. But take from pensioners? No.
@talkingdeadscot you can’t deny there’s a problem that needs solving. The triple lock is unsustainable for an ageing population.

A means tested pension sounds more reasonable.

Take away the entitlement from those who don’t need the state benefit and there’s more to go around to those who do need it.

Judging from DM: many well-to-do pensioners are anti-benefits so I’m sure they will be happy to put their money where their mouth is.

OP posts:
talkingdeadscot · 01/08/2021 09:36

Nice. How about you all think about the fact that after a lifetime of work pensioners deserve a decent pension. It may be the largest slice of the social security budget but it's the benefit that you pay for. All your working life. If you don't have 35 years of contributions then you get a reduced pension. And on the new way of calculating, if you get the full state pension of £179pw then you don't get any pension credit.
It's paid for. The age to qualify has already been moved several times. It's taxable income. If you have to get a job to top up your pension then you still pay your tax and NI.
I can't believe people are saying that pensioners shouldn't have a decent income. You must have realised by now, that if you take from one group of poor people the resulting 'savings' do not ever go to another poor group.
Take money from those at the top, stop spending billions on war and vanity projects and we might get some semblance of society back. But take from pensioners? No.

rainraingogo · 01/08/2021 09:35

Agreed @ChiefInspectorParker

My ILs have multiple buy-to-lets and FIL receives a final salary pension the likes of which will never be seen by my generation or others.

I really don't understand why they receive benefits (and all the other stuff like winter fuel allowance) when the squeeze is on UC, NHS pay etc.

Surely the place to start is identifying who doesn't actually need this support?

There is no way they'd vote anything other than Tory Wink

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 09:23

@ChiefInspectorParker

I don’t know whether the narrative of what’s ‘affordable’ helps these discussions. Obviously governments have to prioritise spending, but running an economy isn’t like running a household or even a business - there are costs and benefits to all spending, whether public sector pay, pensions, benefits, etc.

I don’t think pensioners should get an anomalous 8% rise, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the triple lock should be broken once and for all.

Inflation will hit pensioners hard.

I would be in favour of freezing the state pension for higher rate taxpayers as pp suggested. Also introducing a mechanism whereby better-off pensioners can waive their winter fuel allowance or withdrawing it from higher rate taxpayers, and potentially also a mechanism for better-off pensioners to waive their right to free prescriptions.

Although Labour are in a right mess, demographics overall aren’t moving in the Tories’ favour and if I was them I’d be wondering whether it was worth the risk of breaking the triple lock, on the basis that their core elderly supporters are unlikely to vote for another party any time soon. However I wouldn’t do that and decimate planning regulations Smile There is a discussion to be had about the future of the state pension with a growing elderly population and some radical thinking about how things might look in the not too distant future.

That’s more sensible.

Child benefit stopped for higher earning families because they were deemed to not need it as much.

Same should apply to pensioners.

This Tory government can afford to upset this demographic and make sound arguments based on the setback caused by the plague. The triple lock is unsustainable for an ageing population.

OP posts:
ChiefInspectorParker · 01/08/2021 09:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 09:18

@jasjas1973

“But i think the biggest scandal is cutting UC by £20 per week, thats going literally going to kill people.”

I wonder how many pensioners supported the UC £20 per week cut, but will moan about losing the 8% increase in state pension?

Pensioners cannot reasonably expect compassion on the triple lock front if they don’t speak up about others such as the UC £20 cuts.

It does feel like divide and conquer politics, but there needs to be some balance.

OP posts:
MrsSchadenfreude · 01/08/2021 09:15

I’d rather the money went to younger working families than pensioners. And I’d be happy for an increase in my tax to pay for it.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 09:12

@VariantL1130

The wealth distribution in this country is massively skewed towards pensioners. They certainly don't need an 8% payrise.

I'm in social services and we've had no payrise this year despite working to keep vulnerable people safe throughout the pandemic. Frankly, the triple lock is an insult.

Agreed.

Pensioners are protected for political reasons. It’s not sustainable.

Covid came along and didn’t give two hoots about politics.

OP posts:
jasjas1973 · 01/08/2021 09:11

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

If we can't afford to pay a pension high enough that pensioners can all afford food and heating, we need to look at how to raise tax take. Not cut pensions.
^This.

The UK has one of the highest number of millionaires, just behind Germany, US and Japan.

There is no shortage of money here.

But i think the biggest scandal is cutting UC by £20 per week, thats going literally going to kill people.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 09:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

VariantL1130 · 01/08/2021 09:05

The wealth distribution in this country is massively skewed towards pensioners. They certainly don't need an 8% payrise.

I'm in social services and we've had no payrise this year despite working to keep vulnerable people safe throughout the pandemic. Frankly, the triple lock is an insult.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?
FreakinFrankNFurter · 01/08/2021 09:05

You're not serious are you?

State pension is £137.60 per week. That's £7155.20 a year. 8% is a rise of £572 a year.

There are over 300,000 nurses on salaries of tens of thousands a year with an 8% rise each and you think that is affordable.

The starting salary for a brand new nurse is £24,907 so they are all on salaries of tens of thousands each. An 8% rise for 300k employees on starting salaries of £25k and you think that is a comparison to the state pension. 🤦🏼‍♀️*

Have you even bothered to complete the calculations on those figures you're hunting at.

There are 8.5 million pensioners so giving nurses 8% is a lot more affordable than giving pensioners 8%. Hmm