Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel mean thinking it's reasonable for the pension triple lock to be broken?

420 replies

BendyTrendy · 31/07/2021 22:38

Tricky one because our state pensions are lower than the rest of the EU, but also the largest area of welfare spending (at about 42% of the welfare budget).

Still, on balance, I think it's reasonable to break the triple lock under the circumstances of both Brexit and Covid recovery.

Can the country justify an 8% rise to the state pension under the circumstances? Is the triple lock on pensions sustainable? I feel mean even asking the questions, but tough choices must be made.

Boris Johnson signals 'triple lock' on pensions could be broken amid estimates of 8% rise

State pension predicted to rise by 8%

Rishi Sunak hints at suspension to pension triple lock

Tough one.

OP posts:
talkingdeadscot · 01/08/2021 10:39

@saywhatn

Where has all the money already 'saved' gone? I'm 59 and already have 40 years contributions. There are many like me. Whether or not pensions are means tested, cut or we're made to wait longer will make no difference to anyone else at all.

Your pensions are not put into a pot & saved for you. You can pay for those above you & those younger than you pay for yours.

I'm in my 30s & have paid NI since I was 17, I can't stop paying at 52 & no doubt my pension age will move further out.

No, of course not. I know current workers pay for the ponzi scheme. The point is that the issue of an ageing population has been known about for decades but the only solution presented is to continually cut what social security pays out rather than deal with the actual issue. Continually cutting hasn't solved anything. Cutting pensions won't solve anything. And once everything has been cut that can be, what then?
Starfleck · 01/08/2021 10:39

[quote BendyTrendy]@Starfleck you’re right I’ve made assumptions, but only because I’ve seen no evidence from that demographic speaking up against the UC cuts. Their silence is telling. The comments on the DM are also telling.[/quote]
Where would you expect to see evidence of them speaking up about it? Using DM comments as proof of anything is ridiculous.

JulesCobb · 01/08/2021 10:39

This is an unpopular view, but it is factual that the elderly are also in the group most likely to die. They’ve had their time.
Wow.

Using an argument that some pensioners are not living in poverty is an awful argument.

And the people wanting more money for low paid workers now will be the same ones needing a state pension.

Viviennemary · 01/08/2021 10:38

Pension credit is not much compared to what families get. Its next to nothing.

SerendipityJane · 01/08/2021 10:36

Remember the Lib Dem’s said they wouldn’t raise student tuition fees. Then they got a taste of power…

But they were the tail to the Tories dog.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:36

I mentioned pension credit because often people say means testing is inefficient & costs more but we already do it for pension credit. That's not to say the eligibility criteria shouldn't be looked at.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 10:35

@Starfleck you’re right I’ve made assumptions, but only because I’ve seen no evidence from that demographic speaking up against the UC cuts. Their silence is telling. The comments on the DM are also telling.

OP posts:
LarryTheLurker · 01/08/2021 10:33

This is no better than generation baiting.

Our state pension is indeed among the worst in Europe, and there's no point in quoting £179.60/week as only pensioners currently under 70 (men) or 68 (women) can get that much. The basic state pension is £137.60/week and not every pensioner even qualifies for that. We have 2.5 million pensioners who are so poor they claim pension credit, and an estimated 1.5 million who qualify but don't claim. You also need to factor in the cost of living, which is high in the UK.

And if we can afford to dole out foreign 'aid', we can afford 8% for our own pensioners.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:33

@Oldsu I know when free prescriptions start & think it should be raised. Life expectancy is 79 I think so it's not sustainable.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:30

There's a weird narrative on here that all pensioners are swimming in property, private pensions and disposable income- that isn't true.

No one is saying that but for the richer pensioners they have seen much faster growth than the poorer ones, there is huge inequality.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 10:29

@SerendipityJane

Wasn't it a manifesto promise to keep the triple lock ? Not that it counts for anything.
Political, again.

Remember the Lib Dem’s said they wouldn’t raise student tuition fees. Then they got a taste of power…

Seriously, who speaks for the youth?

Covid earned the title of “Boomer Remover” at the start of the pandemic. Admittedly very distasteful, but it signalled how the youth were feeling.

What Is 'Boomer Remover' and Why Is It Making People So Angry?

We can’t support pensioners who’ve had their time at the expense of the youth who are yet to have theirs. It’s not natural or right. There needs to be more balance between demographics.

OP posts:
Oldsu · 01/08/2021 10:29

@saywhatn

good point *@CayrolBaaaskin* I also believe we should make all subsidies eg prescriptions, travel etc means tested eg for those who get pension credit.
But until the difference between the basic state pension and pension credits is only £2 a week (for a single person) , are you seriously saying that someone who only gets £2 a week more than someone on pension credit should pay for everything, that £2 a week isn't going to last very long is it? , I would imagine the first bus fare will take care of that. BTW (in case you didn't know) free prescriptions start at age 60 not pension age
CayrolBaaaskin · 01/08/2021 10:29

@FangsForTheMemory - are you suggesting pensioners would starve to death if they didn’t get an 8% increase? That’s a bit ridiculous imo.

Also successive conservative governments have increased the state pension despite it being hugely expensive to get more votes and to reward pensioners (who are the most likely age group to vote for them).

ActonSquirrel · 01/08/2021 10:26

How the tides have changed.

Not long ago people were screaming granny killer to any alleged breach of covid lockdown. Now you're all happy for them to starve and freeze.

Nice.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:24

Rishi's income tax freezes for 5 yrs means workers will be paying more tax by stealth.

Starfleck · 01/08/2021 10:24

[quote BendyTrendy]@jasjas1973

“But i think the biggest scandal is cutting UC by £20 per week, thats going literally going to kill people.”

I wonder how many pensioners supported the UC £20 per week cut, but will moan about losing the 8% increase in state pension?

Pensioners cannot reasonably expect compassion on the triple lock front if they don’t speak up about others such as the UC £20 cuts.

It does feel like divide and conquer politics, but there needs to be some balance.[/quote]
I'm guessing you have zero idea how most feel about it, but you're assuming that for some reason they'd be against it, very odd.

I don't think it should be cut, no, and despite some posters whataboutery, I think that those on disability benefits should also receive an increase and a guarantee for the future; there is the money, it doesn't have to be an either or as the government make people believe. There's a weird narrative on here that all pensioners are swimming in property, private pensions and disposable income- that isn't true. There weren't the same opportunities to pay into pensions as there are now, especially for women, and the opportunity for social mobility wasn't as great when many started their careers as it is now, or access to further education. Why they should be dipped into poverty because of the mismanagement of money by the government is anyones guess. Also to the 'they've had their time' brigade, you can retire in your 60s which I wouldn't say was over the bloody hill.

JeepersCreeping · 01/08/2021 10:22

Absolutely in favour. My elderly relatives are the ones who have paid in nowhere near the same level as us (working as a part time shop assistant for 2 years, getting married, then having a 35 year "retirement" in 1 in laws case!). I love them but they have loads of outdoor space, disposable income etc, and a quality of life we can only dream of.

My dad retired at 55 from what is essentially a minimum wage job having supported us and my nonworking mum - we have so little family time and quality of life compared to them at their age, it's a joke. And uni debt and awful defined contribution pensions in comparison.

The working poor cannot bail them out from a lifetime of privilege - the stereotype of an elderly starving cold pensioner isn't one I've seen in my social circle. Of course they exist, but so do lots of benefits claimants like disabled people, for whom they haven't gotten enough raises. I would prefer to pay out benefits to the needy whomever they are and whatever their age - not elderly folk with assets and incomes higher than a lot of working families! It should be more needs based, not simply age entitlement.

rwalker · 01/08/2021 10:22

They can keep it for me and if they have a private pension to top it up it's because they worked for it .

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:22

It's also unlikely that the NHS will be free at the point of care for everything in the next 20 yrs.

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/08/2021 10:20

Pensioners also get about double the guaranteed income of the rest of society via pension credit even if they have never worked a day in their lives.

I don't begrudge pensioners a fair share of National resources but a huge increase like this is not a fair share.

FangsForTheMemory · 01/08/2021 10:19

'Tricky', OP? You mean old people starving or freezing to death would be . . . awkward?

We could afford to give people decent pensions were it not for successive Conservative governments screwing the economy to suit their cronies.

SerendipityJane · 01/08/2021 10:19

Wasn't it a manifesto promise to keep the triple lock ? Not that it counts for anything.

BendyTrendy · 01/08/2021 10:16

@vivainsomnia

I’d rather the money went to younger working families than pensioners Why? Young working families have control over increasing their income. Two people working FT will earn enough to have a decent life. They might struggle for a couple of years before childcare heps kick in, but if they stop at 2 kids, it will be manageable.

Most pensioners have no option but to accept their fate. Some do continue to work, some by choice because they can and enjoy the interaction, but some don't have a choice and it seems so wrong.

I would definitely rather my taxes to go to them than young working families where only one partner works or work PT by choice.

As for making it mean tested, that's what will happen before you know it. It does hurt to think that my OH and I have worked FT all our lives, paid a lot in NI all this time and we will likely get nothing from the state pension, when those who have opted for a much easier life will get the reward, but that's how it is.

Families with children are providing for the next generation. Do you disagree with that?

Money going towards younger working families is investing in the future of the country, which in turn supports the welfare budget (of which pensioners benefit the most from).

I appreciate it must feel unfair if pensions becomes means tested, but life is not fair. A lot of people are poor out of circumstances, not choice. Check your privileges.

It’s insulting to think a partner working PT is just for choice. If they have children it is reasonable that those children get quality time with their parents. That’s important for the nurture and health of our future generations. Money is important, but it’s not all about money either.

The current favouritism for pensioners is political. Covid has perhaps shown that it’s not natural or healthy for civilised society. Nature has pretty much told us that we are prioritising the wrong demographic in society, just for political reasons. We will inevitably lose the fight against nature.

Our youth feel the most neglected, because they’re not as useful politically.

If pensioners reading the DM spoke up against the injustices done to the youth, like cutting the UC by £20 a week, then they might earn some compassion for losing their triple lock.

Pensioners can’t on one hand complain that they’ve lost their triple lock if on the other hand they’ve supported other demographics losing their support income or stood by and done nothing.

OP posts:
newnortherner111 · 01/08/2021 10:15

Perhaps inflation would be less if the government acted to stop those increasing prices or having rip-off extra charges.
Perhaps inflation would be less if there were not shortages of some things because of difficulties in having enough HGV drivers and people in agriculture, because of Brexit.
Perhaps any pension rise would be easier to fund if tax avoidance by large transnational companies especially in tech was stopped.
Perhaps any pension rise would be easier to fund if the government clawed back profits made from Covid such as on the wasteful inefficient track and trace scheme.

saywhatn · 01/08/2021 10:11

Where has all the money already 'saved' gone? I'm 59 and already have 40 years contributions. There are many like me. Whether or not pensions are means tested, cut or we're made to wait longer will make no difference to anyone else at all.

Your pensions are not put into a pot & saved for you. You can pay for those above you & those younger than you pay for yours.

I'm in my 30s & have paid NI since I was 17, I can't stop paying at 52 & no doubt my pension age will move further out.