Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
woodhill · 01/08/2021 17:56

@ErrolTheDragon

What proportion of Brits go on holiday to China?

However, it might be worth asking what proportion of tourists to the U.K. might in future be Chinese, and whether mandarin might be useful for some people in the tourist industry. Though chances are most who visit the U.K. will have some level of English.
Nevertheless... Latin is always going to be to a large extent an elite, academic subject. Whereas functional MFLs may be more useful to those aiming at travel and tourism.

It is a difficult language to learn but a good idea as well. I know the local school introduced it a while backs - language college status
ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 01/08/2021 17:51

@KeflavikAirport

It just seems madness to me that we have literally millions of bilingual kids in the country already and that resource is going wholly untapped. You could do so much to foster language awareness using heritage languages kids already speak.
Indeed some parts of the UK is multilingual but I think as much as the Welsh and a few Scots use Welsh, Celtic and Scots it is not very prevalent given the dominance of English particularly as the American variant is widely used internationally too. Cornish has pretty much disappeared as far as I understand. These heritage languages are important but tend to be forgotten these days among Brits.
Intercity225 · 01/08/2021 17:49

A better solution would be to use the money to make class sizes smaller, buy back sports fields (sold off by the tories), give ALL children exciting extra-curricular activities. Sod Latin.

All that for £4 million?

ErrolTheDragon · 01/08/2021 17:43

What proportion of Brits go on holiday to China?

However, it might be worth asking what proportion of tourists to the U.K. might in future be Chinese, and whether mandarin might be useful for some people in the tourist industry. Though chances are most who visit the U.K. will have some level of English.
Nevertheless... Latin is always going to be to a large extent an elite, academic subject. Whereas functional MFLs may be more useful to those aiming at travel and tourism.

KeflavikAirport · 01/08/2021 17:34

It just seems madness to me that we have literally millions of bilingual kids in the country already and that resource is going wholly untapped. You could do so much to foster language awareness using heritage languages kids already speak.

KeflavikAirport · 01/08/2021 17:32

Not to mention that the Confucius institute offering Mandarin lessons in schools is well dodgy: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Confucius_Institutes

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 17:30

Don't get me wrong btw - I'd absolutely love to learn Mandarin. But I'm a mad-keen linguist, and even I wouldn't have any use for it!

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 17:29

I must say, I think teaching Mandarin is a bit daft too really. As has been repeatedly pointed out, it's hard enough to get kids to a decent standard of spoken French or Spanish. The uptake is often low at GCSE and very low to non-existent at A Level. How many will make it to a vaguely competent standard in a language with a different script and virtually no similarities to any language they've ever even heard irl? And what proportion will ever use it? At least people who don't use their French or Spanish for a career might get to use a bit of it on holiday if they want to. Or choose to brush it up on Duolingo and use it later in life. What proportion of Brits go on holiday to China?

Butchyrestingface · 01/08/2021 17:23

Seen quite a few people online expressing the view that British Sign Language would be a more useful language to learn. Esp with moves to bring to introduce a GCSE in the subject.

Sunbeam61278 · 01/08/2021 17:20

I heard some European schools are offering Mandarin

ErrolTheDragon · 01/08/2021 17:18

Isn't there a move to remove as much Latin as possible from the law moving forwards ?

It's rather astonishing this wasn't done around the same time as English translations of the Bible, and the creating of the Book of Common prayer. Surely it's centuries overdue?

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 16:54

It doesn't start at secondary. It is compulsory in English primary schools at Key Stage 2. However, there is no set curriculum and it's often taught by tye normal class teacher, not a linguist.

MoaningMeowing · 01/08/2021 16:50

I’ve not read the whole thread and I reckon it’s already been mentioned but why does MFL start at secondary. Surely it would be much more unlawful from year 1/yr 3?

DGRossetti · 01/08/2021 16:46

@CaveMum

DH did a law degree and commented on hearing this news that if he’d already had a basic grasp of Latin on starting the course it would have helped him enormously!

I imagine the same could be said of medicine and veterinary studies, as well as other languages.

Isn't there a move to remove as much Latin as possible from the law moving forwards ?
IsThePopeCatholic · 01/08/2021 16:43

I did 5 years of Latin at school - can’t remember a thing. Why are state schools forced to ape private schools? A better solution would be to use the money to make class sizes smaller, buy back sports fields (sold off by the tories), give ALL children exciting extra-curricular activities. Sod Latin.

Floralcoral · 01/08/2021 16:35

@Darbs76

My kids state school teaches Latin. Have to say I wonder what the benefit of it is.
Plenty of examples on this thread.
CaveMum · 01/08/2021 16:34

DH did a law degree and commented on hearing this news that if he’d already had a basic grasp of Latin on starting the course it would have helped him enormously!

I imagine the same could be said of medicine and veterinary studies, as well as other languages.

Darbs76 · 01/08/2021 16:29

My kids state school teaches Latin. Have to say I wonder what the benefit of it is.

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 16:25

something they have any intention of doing if they're English anyway.

Sadly true. Still more likely than them using Latin for anything except maybe recognising the root of the occasional unfamiliar word, with which French or Spanish (or possibly German) would help them just as effectively. Or doing the Times crossword.

EBearhug · 01/08/2021 16:22

I did Latin to A-level at a state comprehensive. I enjoyed it (mostly...) I learned French from 11, and st 13, we could choose Latin or German as a second foreign language - I took Latin, because I figured it would be easier to pick up German outside of school (and I have since done German to AS level at evening classes.)

Having Latin did mean I picked up the concept of different cases quicker than the rest of the class when I later learned German. It means I can often get the gist of Spanish, Portuguese and Italian. I have a pretty large English vocabulary compared many others I know. Latin has helped with all that, but then so did coming from a family which looked up the etymology of words a lot and read a lot. I now work in IT - but I don't know that I learnt logic from Latin; I enjoyed Latin partly because my mind can be very logical. (My A-level Latin teacher slso taught computer studies.)

I think Latin is worth studying, but I don't think it's essential. I'm glad it's still being taught in state schools, but I wouldn't make it a priority over other subjects. People can learn about grammar in modern languages (even English, let alone foreign languages.) They can learn about logic without Latin. You don't need Latin as a background to sciences (arguably German US more sensible for chemists, with Natrium and Kalium making more sense to the periodic table than sodium and potassium.) Having a background in it can make it easier to pick some things up, but you can do it without, there's always more than one way.

This has far more to do with Boris's own background and pandering to the sort of voter who wants "traditional values" and all that sort of thing. More Latin isn't a bad thing, but it's definitely not where education funding should be getting prioritised, nor the first issue that needs sorting out.

Extra languages, whether Latin, Greek or an extra MFL, were almost always only offered to top sets, so Latin has never been a subject that was universally available. Making it more available is partly to counter that, but it is mostly ideological, rather than practical or necessary.

DGRossetti · 01/08/2021 16:22

Besides, for most people, learning to ask for a beer, what time the next train is, or where to find the loo is not

something they have any intention of doing if they're English anyway.

DGRossetti · 01/08/2021 16:20

Well, I'd be all for teaching world literature in translation in schools.

I wonder what people think the Bible and Koran are ....

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/08/2021 16:19

Many thanks for the correction squid, I didn't fact check, it was late and my recollections were 'tainted'. But even if it's all Greek, the use of sympathy and empathy are in common, current usage in the English Language, often incorrectly interchangeably because they mean different, albeit [OE], similar 'feelings'.

So maybe offering a combined Latin/Greek curriculum might be quite a good idea, because it might also provide inspiration for other academic disciplines too.

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 16:17

There really would be less point in learning Latin if that were true. As a classics prof, I'd say that Latin does help with understanding certain types of linguistic structure and getting a jump on vocabulary of the European romance languages, but it's also about engaging with fantastic literature

It's hard enough to engage many secondary school pupils with much literature that's very modern, or a hundred years old! I have very bad memories of slogging through Sallust's Jugurthine War...

Also...how would Latin help you get a jump on Spanish vocabulary more than French would (or vice versa)? I've asked this one a few times, but nobody seems to have an answer!

Besides, for most people, learning to ask for a beer, what time the next train is, or where to find the loo is not a tedious thing you have to muck about with instead of reading Proust. It's one of the main points of learning a language, and one you're much more likely to get to use!

KeflavikAirport · 01/08/2021 16:07

Well, I'd be all for teaching world literature in translation in schools. No need to learn a dead language to engage with fabulous literature - you could teach kids about languages well beyond Europe, too, and really make an asset of multilingual kids whose home languages don't carry much cultural capital. There are some fabulous initiatives in this line now that could use those four million quid to much better ends IMO.

Swipe left for the next trending thread