Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
PippiStocking · 01/08/2021 21:31

@Newrumpus

Not having Latin available at state schools in discriminatory. It makes it more difficult for those not accessing a private education to compete in certain fields. It is a source of cultural capital. I studied Literature at Cambridge University and remember the crippling inferiority I felt when I realised that there were cultural references that I didn’t understand which my peers did. This isn’t just Latin but Classics, more widely. Latin should be available for all not just the elite.
I hear what you are saying but I think the Latin is just a detail here – if Latin became universally available and widely taught, there would absolutely be another signifier of privilege that would ensure just as effectively that a state school pupil felt out of their depth among private-school–educated students in the way you describe. The point isn’t that they don’t get Latin, the point is that they don’t get it.
Novelusername · 01/08/2021 21:09

@DGRossetti

At the end of the day it's all about whether you believe in learning for learnings sake ... personally I do - it shouldn't be the privilege of the few.
I've always believed in learning for learning's sake. From a working class background myself, my parents chose all my options for me. I didn't get a choice, and whilst I would have liked to have studied art and music, I was made to do supposedly more 'practical' subjects. Nonetheless, I went on to study Literature. I think I would have enjoyed Latin and it would have helped with my degree in terms of understanding the allusions being made. That said, the majority of working class comp students probably don't want 'learning for learning's sake' and can be very difficult to engage with already if they feel the education they're being given has no relevance to them. In my experience, the one-size-fits-all educational approach does not work, and we should have a system in place whereby there is more streaming. Kids who are more hands-on should learn more practical skills and trades in school. Not every kid is academic, they will struggle with Latin, won't enjoy it and it won't confer them any practical skills they can use in the real world. Many of them will be disruptive and prevent the kids who do want to learn from progressing. Latin might serve Literature students well, but in addition to this as an option, I'd like to see other more practical options.
Piggywaspushed · 01/08/2021 21:05

good thread from Michael Rosen

threadreaderapp.com/thread/1421714469139402753.html

ErrolTheDragon · 01/08/2021 21:04

@DGRossetti

At the end of the day it's all about whether you believe in learning for learnings sake ... personally I do - it shouldn't be the privilege of the few.
Yes. So... less tunnel visioned focus on exam results? More access to 'lifelong learning' . There's that old saying education is wasted on the young - some of the more cultural elements may be appreciated much better with a bit of maturity.
Piggywaspushed · 01/08/2021 20:59

@BackforGood

I've just found out that Gav has also - apparently with no sense of irony whatsoever - said, in the same statement that 'All schools MUST give homework' and 'All schools MUST instil a love of learning'
You WILL love learning. I insist!
Piggywaspushed · 01/08/2021 20:58

That's true. Although that depends on how much you think Chris Whitty etc are atm.

noblegiraffe · 01/08/2021 20:54

But the CP Snow thing doesn't work anywhere else these days

Not many scientists among the people who run the country tbf.

DGRossetti · 01/08/2021 20:54

At the end of the day it's all about whether you believe in learning for learnings sake ... personally I do - it shouldn't be the privilege of the few.

Piggywaspushed · 01/08/2021 20:53

But the CP Snow thing doesn't work anywhere else these days where views seem so utilitarian : can't do it unless it's useful sez Gav.

I think kids should have access to all sorts of opportunities and subjects. And sate schools should offer as many as they can. But this is a half baked and not fully explained or justified plan.

BackforGood · 01/08/2021 20:52

I've just found out that Gav has also - apparently with no sense of irony whatsoever - said, in the same statement that
'All schools MUST give homework' and 'All schools MUST instil a love of learning'

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/08/2021 20:49

Presumably everyone saying Latin was great for them were able to read/write in English too? The number of children moving up to secondary who are unable to is shocking. Priorities.

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 20:36

It's also very divisive along the lines of what CP Snow called The Two Cultures. Where knowledge of the classics is valued over knowledge of the Laws of Thermodynamics in certain circles and for no good reason other than it's a class signifier.

Yes. I was pretty much steeped in that kind of attitude until teaching in state schools knocked it out of me. I kind of slightly miss the comfortable certainty I used to have about the higher value of the type of education I had, if I'm honest. Blush

PippiStocking · 01/08/2021 20:34

@noblegiraffe

Having done Latin is usually (not always, obviously) an indicator that you came from advantage, not a way of conferring it.

It's also very divisive along the lines of what CP Snow called The Two Cultures. Where knowledge of the classics is valued over knowledge of the Laws of Thermodynamics in certain circles and for no good reason other than it's a class signifier.

Yes, I think part of its appeal in certain circles is precisely that it is of less practical use than other subjects.
Piggywaspushed · 01/08/2021 20:34

I love words and languages. Loving words helps me to explain often where words come from. I had a whole juggernaut conversation with DH on Sat night during Millionaire. This doesn't come specifically form having done Latin, French, German or Anglo Saxon. I think learning any language is good for the brain. if anything, doing my English degree was most helped by German A Level as it supported Old English and Anglo Saxon, and French A level for Middle English. I do think I like words more than most of my colleagues, and know more classical allusions. But that is mainly voracious reading and not basic Latin.

But I don't think medical people and lawyers etc 'need' Latin. They just need to know the terms. I love that I can work out what lots of them actually mean (and names of pasta!)but I just want a doctor to know what a scapula is, frankly.

However, I still think axing arts funding is unforgiveable whilst talking up Latin.

And people who bang on about Cultural Capital really need to read up on their Bourdieu!

ErrolTheDragon · 01/08/2021 20:32

If you had studied maths, you'd have found your lack of classics knowledge no hindrance at all.

Even though it's stuffed with Greek letters.Grin

Newrumpus · 01/08/2021 20:31

@noblegiraffe

I didn’t mention religion at all

No, I know you didn't. But a good knowledge of it would be an advantage in studying a literature degree, yes?

Thing is, only very few people end up studying literature degrees. If you had studied maths, you'd have found your lack of classics knowledge no hindrance at all.

So in that scenario I might not have made use of my opportunity to study it but chosen a different route instead.
lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 20:31

Classics enables a greater understanding of much literature and art. Hence my peers who had had the opportunity to study classics having a greater understanding of some English literary texts than I had. That is one example of how it was advantageous.

Ok fair enough... sort of. In my experience it's not until you get to Latin A Level tyat you get much of a real grounding in anything that would give you extra insight into wider literature. And I can't say that doing Latin ever gave me any insight into art at all.

noblegiraffe · 01/08/2021 20:29

Having done Latin is usually (not always, obviously) an indicator that you came from advantage, not a way of conferring it.

It's also very divisive along the lines of what CP Snow called The Two Cultures. Where knowledge of the classics is valued over knowledge of the Laws of Thermodynamics in certain circles and for no good reason other than it's a class signifier.

Newrumpus · 01/08/2021 20:28

@lazylinguist

Did you read the example I gave up thread?

No. I've just looked back 5 pages and I can't find where you gave an example of exactly how Latin confers an advantage, beyond you saying it somehow enables them to 'hold their own' at elite universities or 'compete on a level with their private school peers'. How does it do that really?

As someone who went to Oxbridge, knows quite a lot of classicists and has taught state and private school pupils, some of whom in both sectors did Latin and some of whom (mostly the private school ones) went on to elite universities, I disagree that Latin inherently confers an advantage.

Upthread, I gave a specific personal example.
noblegiraffe · 01/08/2021 20:27

I didn’t mention religion at all

No, I know you didn't. But a good knowledge of it would be an advantage in studying a literature degree, yes?

Thing is, only very few people end up studying literature degrees. If you had studied maths, you'd have found your lack of classics knowledge no hindrance at all.

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 20:26

But how do Classics confer any genuine advantage? Isn’t it what they signify rather than their actual usefulness or application?

Bang on. Having done Latin is usually (not always, obviously) an indicator that you came from advantage, not a way of conferring it.

PippiStocking · 01/08/2021 20:26

@Newrumpus

Classics enables a greater understanding of much literature and art. Hence my peers who had had the opportunity to study classics having a greater understanding of some English literary texts than I had. That is one example of how it was advantageous. It is an opportunity that all should have access to. That is not to say that other opportunities should not also be available or that all pupils should be forced to study it but as part of a broad curriculum it should be offered.

Pupils sometimes ask what is the point of studying Shakespeare. That is similar to your question about usefulness. It completely misses the point of education which is not just about practical application but about learning, thinking and broadening the mind.

I wouldn’t suggest there’s no benefit to studying Latin – there’s value in studying anything. However I think there’s a distinction between benefit and advantage. Advantage implies an edge over others. I’m still not quite sure what particular advantage it is you think Latin confers to students over other subjects?

I studied Latin at school and also studied Literature at university (along with a modern language) and I honestly wouldn’t say it was of any particular use in either area of my degree.

Would be really interested to find out more about how it enhanced your peers’ understanding of art and literature. That’s not to cast doubt on what you’re saying by the way! It’s just not clear (to me) exactly what you’re getting at.

Newrumpus · 01/08/2021 20:25

@noblegiraffe

It is an opportunity that all should have access to.

But that goes for many subjects, but students cannot have access to them all.

My DH and I went to the Vatican. He did Latin so could translate inscriptions however in the Vatican it was I, without Latin, who was at an advantage. I could explain all the art, the people (ooh, that’s Saint Sebastian) and fixtures because I was raised Catholic.

There are many times in art, film and literature when my knowledge has come in useful and he has needed me to explain things.

Are you suggesting that because it would be of benefit to a Literature or Art degree that everyone should have the opportunity to be immersed in Catholicism?

I didn’t mention religion at all but no I would not suggest ‘immersion in Catholicism’ but definitely an adequate knowledge of Christianity in terms of its cultural influence. Often even at GCSE pupils have to recognise religious allusions but don’t appreciate them as they have so little understanding of their own cultural heritage.
lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 20:23

Did you read the example I gave up thread?

No. I've just looked back 5 pages and I can't find where you gave an example of exactly how Latin confers an advantage, beyond you saying it somehow enables them to 'hold their own' at elite universities or 'compete on a level with their private school peers'. How does it do that really?

As someone who went to Oxbridge, knows quite a lot of classicists and has taught state and private school pupils, some of whom in both sectors did Latin and some of whom (mostly the private school ones) went on to elite universities, I disagree that Latin inherently confers an advantage.

noblegiraffe · 01/08/2021 20:18

It is an opportunity that all should have access to.

But that goes for many subjects, but students cannot have access to them all.

My DH and I went to the Vatican. He did Latin so could translate inscriptions however in the Vatican it was I, without Latin, who was at an advantage. I could explain all the art, the people (ooh, that’s Saint Sebastian) and fixtures because I was raised Catholic.

There are many times in art, film and literature when my knowledge has come in useful and he has needed me to explain things.

Are you suggesting that because it would be of benefit to a Literature or Art degree that everyone should have the opportunity to be immersed in Catholicism?