Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 02/08/2021 11:36

@EBearhug

Can't they just Google the Latin motto these days?
Of course but that does not mean learning Latin and any other language is not important. Technically one could Google most things but that does not mean learning and university is of less value. Latin is useful but not as useful as many more widely used modern global languages. Not learning Latin in not a detriment but British pupils need to improve English (and some their heritage Welsh, Celtic or Scots) and all other useful languages such including Spanish for ease of learning or if capable even Chinese or Arabic for global trade etc.
Serenissima21 · 02/08/2021 11:32

What do you mean by professional linguist btw? Just curious!

Serenissima21 · 02/08/2021 11:31

The literature is also boring AF
Shock No, it's not. My ds is not a keen reader but really enjoys what he studies in Latin.

PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 11:25

I am a professional linguist and did Latin GCSE along with 2 other modern FLs.

Latin was a total waste of time as my goal was to actually speak foreign languages, not read comic strips showing Romans conversing in a dead language. The literature is also boring AF and hasn't remotely helped in my adult life.

Yes, Latin helps with the origin of words but so does Google.

Russian, Arabic, Chinese, IT, extra English, extra FL conversation lessons so the kids can actually speak the language fluently... there are so, so many more valid and relevant options.

Intercity225 · 02/08/2021 11:18

@noblegiraffe

My DH and I went to the Vatican. He did Latin so could translate inscriptions however in the Vatican it was I, without Latin, who was at an advantage. I could explain all the art, the people (ooh, that’s Saint Sebastian) and fixtures because I was raised Catholic.

This is because he studied Latin from a different period! It’s like complaining that history undergraduates, who spent all their first year studying ancient history, know nothing about the Russian Revolution say, and therefore history is no good!

I did Classical and Medieval Latin - from the 4th century BC up to the 15th century. It was the Church, and the Catholic Church was the only one in Western Europe at that time (bar the schisms), who kept education and Latin alive through the Dark Ages, the 12th century Renaissance up to the Renaissance. By its very nature, we had to read all the Vulgate, be very familiar with the Catholic Church service, and read Latin by the leading figures of their day such as St Augustine, Charlemagne, Gregory the Great, Erasmus, Galileo, etc and there were allusions to the Church service in much Latin literature. We also studied the history, art and philosophy including the Greeks from Classical times up to the Renaissance, and the influence of the Moors, coming into Spain; so yes, we had to know for instance that St Peter was often depicted with keys; and the visual references to other saints in art, which illiterate congregations in those days, would have recognised.

Piggywaspushed · 02/08/2021 11:16

Firstly, Latin should be for all. Nowhere has the government said it is only for the bright children. In my school it is offered to, and enjoyed by, a diverse range of students.

Secondly, cultural capital is a Marxist term. This makes me much amused when Gav and the dfe use it. As someone pointed out, once Latin becomes available to the masses, the elites will find something else to keep us all out.

PippiStocking · 02/08/2021 11:13

@Intercity225

those of us, not deemed up to 4 A levels, S levels and Oxbridge entry

Really? At a grammar school?!

Intercity225 · 02/08/2021 10:58

Presumably everyone saying Latin was great for them were able to read/write in English too? The number of children moving up to secondary who are unable to is shocking. Priorities.

Yes, because I went to a forward thinking grammar school - which did believe in increasing our cultural capital, and in the 6th form on top of A levels, we also had to do art appreciation, music appreciation, design appreciation, extra PE, civics, Use of English and RE. So, I don’t understand all this talk about where would the time come from in the curriculum, when those of us, not deemed up to 4 A levels, S levels and Oxbridge entry, had to do 3 A levels and another O level, plus the above compulsory subjects.

I had appealed to the SEN Tribunal three times and initiated judicial review twice, before DD reached the age of 11. The highest reading age she ever achieved, was age 7 by 18; and she never could remember the basic arithmetic operations. I worked for 20 years for charities, supporting parents of children with SEN and seeking better provision for them.

However, as Special Needs Jungle reported in an article on DfE SEND funding

www.specialneedsjungle.com/dfes-send-funding-safety-valve-collision-schools-families/

The DfE has increased the High Needs Funding block (the financial pot for high needs SEN) by £1.5 billion since 2019; they have put £300 million into SEN capital spend this year, and plan to increase the High Needs Funding block by around £780 million next year. LAs’ deficit on their SEN spending is around £1 billion - which will have to be paid back eventually.

Even so, it would take billions to put right the SEN system; because all the problems with it now, are really because its never been funded properly.I also think its not just about money; there needs to be a sea change in attitudes to ensure all children have functioning literacy and numeracy before they leave primary school (except those not capable of it, due to severe SEN).

The government does not have the political will to put those billions into SEN; nor are they going to put billions into reducing class sizes; the capital spending programme needed for the problems in obsolete school buildings, no longer fit for purpose; etc.

Those of you, who want more spending on SEN, fight for it tooth and nail, but £4 million would go nowhere - it would probably get swallowed up in reducing the LAs deficits; the children would never see it!

However, I think its good for once, the government are willing to spend some money on the bright children, as pp have said to increase their cultural capital - learning for learning’s sake.

Piggywaspushed · 02/08/2021 10:13

I worked out the Birmingham one last week with basic normal English vocabulary*. But Bridgen is obviously dim..

*per ardua ad alta

ErrolTheDragon · 02/08/2021 09:54

It now has a link from the wiki page to a handy list of Latin phrases

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ListoffLatinphrasess

I do like this one
parturiunt montes, nascetur ridiculus mus

ErrolTheDragon · 02/08/2021 09:50

I'm pretty sure my uni simply provided the translation, though it was pretty easy to work out. Not that it actually mattered one iota. Confused

EBearhug · 02/08/2021 09:29

Can't they just Google the Latin motto these days?

Piggywaspushed · 02/08/2021 07:44

Loving Andrew Bridgen weighing in on this :

In one Tweet he says Latin is great because when he went to university he needed public school educated people to translate the university motto for him and apparently learning Latin at school would save us all such dreadful humiliations (think how useful this would be at every football stadium too, Andrew!)

And then , later:

working class people shouldn't go to university. We have a shortgae of lorry drivers and it is all Tony Blair's fault for making them think they could get an education at unis with Latin mottos

TrickyD · 01/08/2021 23:24

@ivykaty44

Those that think that Latin isn't worthwhile or shouldn't be introduced - did you learn latin at schools yourselves? just curious to hear from someone that learnt latin and didn't see the point?
I did Latin and Greek at state school and my degree is in Classics.

I think there are far more worthwhile ways of spending the money.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 01/08/2021 23:22

So essentially a one size fits all is not compatible with the wide diversity of pupils.

As much as many in education attempt with some ambition to raise the overall level especially as schools are as more ranked and rated by their success of overall educational grades attainment than other less measurable metrics including general pupil social and personal development.

The smarter alternative would be to cater for those more able and more suited to further challenge deeper greater learning so that these higher capability pupils are not held back, bored or suffer unfulfilled potential.

Those less able at the other end will likewise require extra tutoring to accommodate at their pace of learning.

The majority of the class would be in the medium cohort and achieve expected academic standards.

All pupils are different and not robots and so this must be accommodated appropriately to realise the potential of each pupil. Some will be more capable and academic, others more suited to develop their other talents be it artistic or sporting or practical as in applying their ability to learn a trade and manual skills which other pupils are not as well suited.

However as there are particular schools to accommodate pupils with specific needs there needs acknowledgment that there should be schools to cater for all three general abilities as well as these specific needs schools where these pupils will be better safeguarded with specific specialist teachers trained to have specific skills as required and bring out the potential of these pupils too.

Should pupils progress above and beyond the likely expectation - the system should be flexible to accommodate movement between these categories of schools. Indeed conversely if a pupil initially recognised as advanced struggles in due course - this pupil will again be better served in an alternative more suited school for that level of educational attainment.

This above would be a modern more flexible version of selective grammar schools, comprehensive academies and specific needs schools.

This is a reflection of further advance studies at university with some better suited to higher attainment students and not so much elitist but reality and a reflection of diversity. You cannot expect all pupils to be identical nor want to study the same subjects nor do as well academically.

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 23:04

I don’t believe there are kids who don’t want to learn - just kids who present as such at times, usually (but not always) because they are terrified of failure.

Plenty of kids don't want to learn simply because they find a subject boring and/or pointless and don't particularly care whether they do well in it or not. Plenty of kids don't want to learn because they'd rather muck about with their friends, and the importance of school work for their future hasn't really sunk in yet (and in some cases never really does).

Novelusername · 01/08/2021 22:33

@Newrumpus

Teaching a broad curriculum is not incompatible with setting for ability. I don’t believe there are kids who don’t want to learn - just kids who present as such at times, usually (but not always) because they are terrified of failure.
That's a nice sentiment, but in reality those kids are sabotaging the education of kids who are well-behaved and those kids matter too. I agree it's a fear of failure, and sometimes that fear is justified because they simply are not good at certain subjects and never will be and forcing them to continue down a path where they're going to do badly surely isn't the best thing for them and their self-esteem. We all have different strengths and weaknesses, I think the education system should be more flexible to cater to these differences, but again I don't have the answers in reality as to how that would play out.
Novelusername · 01/08/2021 22:26

I also think that under the more 'practical' banner could be a range of subjects such as Business Studies, not just trades. Many kids might not be keen on academia, but they may be money motivated instead, or just need subjects where the learning is more rooted in applied knowledge. I think everyone should have access to an academic education, but some people will never engage with the arts, philosophy etc, it's not what moves or motivates them and that's just the way it is.

Newrumpus · 01/08/2021 22:23

Teaching a broad curriculum is not incompatible with setting for ability.
I don’t believe there are kids who don’t want to learn - just kids who present as such at times, usually (but not always) because they are terrified of failure.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/08/2021 22:22

Kids who are more hands-on should learn more practical skills and trades in school

Up to a point... in addition to nobelgiraffe's comments, it's also something of a false dichotomy. Practical skills are needed across the board.

Is learning an MFL 'academic' or a 'practical skill'? Some of the sciences and technologies can cover a range of abilities, from mostly 'practical' to highly theoretical and mathematical- with some people needing both Hard Maths and delicate manual skills. And then there's music, art, drama ... These have wrongly been pushed out , they can also be a mix of 'academic' and practical and lead to 'trades'.

Novelusername · 01/08/2021 22:17

Everyone should have access to a decent broad curriculum which is flexible enough to accommodate a range of needs without being punitive.
I agree, but what you get in classes with mixed abilities is the kids who don't want to learn or who simply have a lower level of ability with the subject preventing those who have more aptitude from progressing. It makes perfect sense to stream, it's done all the time with language classes. You would have a class for beginners and a different class for those who are more advanced. It makes the learning a lot more efficient if everyone in the class is roughly at the same level. It's ridiculous to assume all kids are going to be at the same level in every subject simply because they are of the same age. Similarly, it's ridiculous to make all students study the same narrow range of subjects. It's also not necessarily going to hold anyone back if a kid can learn to be a plumber on an apprenticeship for example, where they can earn a good wage and feel a sense of purpose and pride in what they're doing. It's absolutely demoralising and terrible for self-esteem to be forced to study something you have no aptitude for and that's why kids become disruptive.

Newrumpus · 01/08/2021 22:04

‘disadvantaged kids who end up being found to be more 'hands-on' and suited to the trades where the kids of the middle classes are found to be 'academic'. Vocational and academic streaming from early on perpetuates social inequity’

I agree. Everyone should have access to a decent broad curriculum which is flexible enough to accommodate a range of needs without being punitive.

Novelusername · 01/08/2021 22:03

Ultimately, I believe kids will be most advantaged by having parents who take an interest in their education and preferably also have some money to throw at it - all those extra-curricular activities that look so good on UCAS applications. Latin is neither here nor there. I guess initiatives to get parents more involved in their children's education may be the most productive way to address this inequality, but some parents - like mine - don't give a sh*t and there's nothing you can really do about that.

Novelusername · 01/08/2021 21:56

@noblegiraffe

Yep, if every private school started teaching Morris Dancing, that would suddenly be v important to emulate.

Kids who are more hands-on should learn more practical skills and trades in school

Whenever this is implemented, it is always the disadvantaged kids who end up being found to be more 'hands-on' and suited to the trades where the kids of the middle classes are found to be 'academic'. Vocational and academic streaming from early on perpetuates social inequity (v few FSM kids at grammar schools, for example).

I understand your concern as I would definitely have been pushed into doing something more 'practical' by my parents. Streaming worked well for me in my school, though. My classes that weren't streamed were disrupted by the kids who didn't want to learn running amok, and there was a world of difference in the classes that were streamed. I just don't think academia is something that can be enforced. Kids who are from backgrounds where their parents are involved in their education will always be at an advantage, and this is more likely to be the middle class kids. I don't pretend to have all the answers here.
noblegiraffe · 01/08/2021 21:40

Yep, if every private school started teaching Morris Dancing, that would suddenly be v important to emulate.

Kids who are more hands-on should learn more practical skills and trades in school

Whenever this is implemented, it is always the disadvantaged kids who end up being found to be more 'hands-on' and suited to the trades where the kids of the middle classes are found to be 'academic'. Vocational and academic streaming from early on perpetuates social inequity (v few FSM kids at grammar schools, for example).