Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 02/08/2021 20:54

Translation is an art, not a mechanical exercise. The literal meaning of almost any foreign phrase sounds ridiculous unless you "transcreate", so put it into a form that sounds plausible and meaningful to the target audience

I've noticed a few slips in the subtitles for Inspector Montalbano where the translation - while correct - doesn't actually convey the sense of what was said.

PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 17:27

@ErrolTheDragon Translation is an art, not a mechanical exercise. The literal meaning of almost any foreign phrase sounds ridiculous unless you "transcreate", so put it into a form that sounds plausible and meaningful to the target audience. The mottos of many universities were chosen at a time when Latin was the lingua franca among "educated" people, in a similar way to English today.

Surely, 500 years on, it is time to update?

DGRossetti · 02/08/2021 17:24

@ErrolTheDragon

Do the Latin phrases used by lawyers make sense as such, or is their legal meaning something specific and not necessarily a literal translation? I.e would a non lawyer who knew Latin necessarily correctly discern their legal meaning? Or is some of it truly jargon?

What prompts this question is mild amusement at the motto of the university of Cambridge and its literal and non literal translations.(I suppose the 'draughts' is a drink rather than wind or checkers but still quite funny)

Motto*
Latin: Hinc lucem et pocula sacra
Motto in English
Literal: From here, light and sacred draughts. Non literal: From this place, we gain enlightenment and precious knowledge.

I refer you to the "Romanes Eunt Domus" clip above. You have 5 noun forms (each with singular and plural, so 10 in all) for every noun. Each one telling you what that word is doing in the sentence.

There's also various flavours of idiom you can throw in.

It also helps to have an insight into the ancients mindset (which is where you learn they were absolutely no different to us) just to pick up the double-entendres they liked to smuggle in.

EBearhug · 02/08/2021 17:22

Yes, but you don't have to learn Latin in order to learn terminology for a job! You can just... learn the terminology!

This. Most fields (and employers - goodness knows mine loves a bit of internal jargon!) have their own specialist vocabulary and you have to learn it. Sometimes it's even based on English, but that still doesn't necessarily help you.

Piggywaspushed · 02/08/2021 17:02

Yeah, Wiki's 'translations' are sometimes a bit odd!

ErrolTheDragon · 02/08/2021 16:58

Do the Latin phrases used by lawyers make sense as such, or is their legal meaning something specific and not necessarily a literal translation? I.e would a non lawyer who knew Latin necessarily correctly discern their legal meaning? Or is some of it truly jargon?

What prompts this question is mild amusement at the motto of the university of Cambridge and its literal and non literal translations.(I suppose the 'draughts' is a drink rather than wind or checkers but still quite funny)

Motto*
Latin: Hinc lucem et pocula sacra
Motto in English
Literal: From here, light and sacred draughts. Non literal: From this place, we gain enlightenment and precious knowledge.

DGRossetti · 02/08/2021 16:17

I loved Juvenal - especially his takedown of lawyers ...

PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 15:59

Hi @KeflavikAirport 🙂. (Had to google where that was, as well).

lazylinguist · 02/08/2021 15:19

when you are reading cases and judgments at law school and counsel's advices, they are full of words and phrases in Latin

Yes, but you don't have to learn Latin in order to learn terminology for a job! You can just... learn the terminology!

KeflavikAirport · 02/08/2021 14:32

translator high five @PartridgeFeather Smile

PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 14:28

@KeflavikAirport

when you are reading cases and judgments at law school and counsel's advices, they are full of words and phrases in Latin

Again, one wonders how people manage to successfully become lawyers without ever having been near a Latin class Hmm

They have to stuff their briefs full of Latin phrases so they can justify charging ££££££££££££ for their esoteric wisdom and for pretending there's some subtle nuance that can't be expressed any other way. I like to piss them off by translating them into plain English.
PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 14:20

@VeryQuaintIrene

The literature is also boring AF

Did you get stuck with the Gallic Wars or something?!

@VeryQuaintIrene fuck knows, I revised before the exam then pressed my mental Delete button. Got an A, which just proves why there's so much that needs changing about the education system.
PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 14:16

@Intercity225 Each to their own, personally I think secondary school is far too short for there to be time for Latin, when you need a lot of practical nouse and vocational skills to get a job, and when the UK population's language speaking ability is so very far behind the rest of Europe's.

I'm glad I know nothing about Catullus... Was already up to my eyeballs in Rabelais, Chaucer, smutty Shakespearean comedy and, on the other end of the spectrum, the equally boring AF Jane Austen, whose yawnfest Persuasion turned me off English Lit for life.

But then I am not very good at being middle class, really. Private school in my experience was all about studying the "right" subjects for Oxbridge and feeding the results factory to keep the parents paying.

I learned no real-world skills, and this unfortunately is exactly the case 30 years later at my son's Continental state grammar (he insisted on doing the Latin stream in fact, but has just given it up in favour of IT - his choice).

The point about language is that it only works in context. Studying its evolution/dead forms might be interesting for some, but it's far too niche for a "general" cert of secondary education.

KeflavikAirport · 02/08/2021 14:15

when you are reading cases and judgments at law school and counsel's advices, they are full of words and phrases in Latin

Again, one wonders how people manage to successfully become lawyers without ever having been near a Latin class Hmm

VeryQuaintIrene · 02/08/2021 14:04

The literature is also boring AF

Did you get stuck with the Gallic Wars or something?!

Serenissima21 · 02/08/2021 13:49

@partridgefeather Thanks. I'm a teacher and translator but I think I prefer professional linguist. Grin I didn't learn Latin at school but seeing as I translate mainly from Italian, it would probably have helped!

PartridgeFeather · 02/08/2021 13:45

@Serenissima21

What do you mean by professional linguist btw? Just curious!
I'm a translator. Can honestly say that Latin didn't help me learn languages, it just made me wish I'd opted for Russian instead.

Having 5x the number of native-speaker conversation and listening lessons would have helped the speed of my language uptake enormously, though.

Oneearringlost · 02/08/2021 13:08

@ActonSquirrel

Really...I ended up a solicitor

Latin

Affidavit - he has sworn
bona fide - in good faith
Bona vacantia - ownerless goods
Caveat - may he beware
Certiorari - to be apprised - in practice a type of writ
de minimis - about the smallest things
doli incapax - incapable of guilt
ex parte - from one party
in loco parentis - in place of the parent
inter alia - among others
mens rea - guilty mind
obiter dictum - a thing said in passing
prima facie - on the face of it

Ex turpi causa non oritur actio - a legal doctrine which states that a claim will not succeed if it arises in connection with the claimant's own illegal activities

Volenti non fit iniuria - to a willing person, no injury is done - a defence to Negligence claims that the party consented to the risk of harm

That is just a small selection of Latin terms used in law.

I mean when you are reading cases and judgments at law school and counsel's advices, they are full of words and phrases in Latin.

Law is a pretty common degree choice. What the heck use would Spanish have been to me?!

Mea Culpa? Great post. I agree, I taught 2 out of three of my DCs Latin up to GCSE level ( the third rebelled!). My only worry is that there needs to be so much time applied to the PHSE which is so important that I would be wary of taking time out of that. But I love Latin, and agree with many posters, of it's value
Piggywaspushed · 02/08/2021 12:32

Yes, yes he did... but if Big Friendly and Loaded Americans come and put new studios in Hertfordshire , he can make it look like he made it happen and the Home Counties might like him again.

noblegiraffe · 02/08/2021 12:19

Didn’t he just cut arts funding?

Intercity225 · 02/08/2021 12:19

The literature is also boring AF and hasn't remotely helped in my adult life.

You clearly did not read the right stuff; or at least like the passer poems of Catullus, nobody told you what it really meant! (Pornography is not my thing, but there was plenty of it - which gave a real insight into life in those days for the upper classes.)

  • Post edited at OP's request
Piggywaspushed · 02/08/2021 12:19

Yes, I think that's exactly what I am saying. If the government had just done this, with no fanfare and no fuss, all would be fine. It's their desperate insistence on making it part of their so called 'levelling up' that is just laughable.

Meanwhile, today, Boris has said with a straight face today :

The creative industries are at the heart of our plans to build back better

PippiStocking · 02/08/2021 12:05

@Piggywaspushed

Firstly, Latin should be for all. Nowhere has the government said it is only for the bright children. In my school it is offered to, and enjoyed by, a diverse range of students.

Secondly, cultural capital is a Marxist term. This makes me much amused when Gav and the dfe use it. As someone pointed out, once Latin becomes available to the masses, the elites will find something else to keep us all out.

Exactly - the whole point is that it’s a form of social and cultural currency based on its exclusivity in association with a certain group or strata, and if everyone does Latin (for eg) its cache will soon be lost.

That’s not to say it’s not worthwhile studying for other reasons!

Intercity225 · 02/08/2021 11:59

Not learning Latin in not a detriment but British pupils need to improve English (and some their heritage Welsh, Celtic or Scots) and all other useful languages such including Spanish for ease of learning or if capable even Chinese or Arabic for global trade etc.

I dare say people do succeed in becoming fluent Mandarin speakers in this country, but its not an easy language for us to learn. DD did Japanese at university, and did some Mandarin and Korean. She had no problem, learning to read and write the Chinese characters in Japanese, but found Mandarin as a tonal language much harder than Japanese, Korean, French, Spanish and German - and she had the advantage of a boyfriend, who first language is Mandarin.

I learnt some Cantonese in my 20s, but there was the odd word I never said, because I knew if my pronunciation came out wrong, then I could be saying a very rude word to them!

Intercity225 · 02/08/2021 11:55

Really? At a grammar school?!

Yes, my school was a 3 form entry - classes of 36. By the time of the 6th form, there were iirc 96 in my year. Only 11 were chosen to be put forward for Oxbridge entry and S levels. I can't remember how many did 4 A levels, but I would say the majority did 3 A levels, an O level, and as I said, we all had to do Use of English and all the appreciation subjects, Civics, RE, PE etc. However, they probably prioritised those doing medicine or veterinary science, etc, to get 3 As at A level to get in, rather than 4 Bs - over stretching themselves to do 4. We were only pushed to do academic subjects at the traditional universities - polytechnics did not enter the thinking of my school, afaik.