Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 04/08/2021 18:29

Also, while I sympathise with your son getting bored with the MFL curriculum (I do too, and I teach it!) surely the better answer to that is to change the MFL curriculum rather than teach a language nobody speaks. Our reputation for being unwilling and incapable foreign language learners is embarrassing and surely just confirms what everyone must think of us wrt Brexit.

lazylinguist · 04/08/2021 18:24

Given that many of our politicians, judges etc, started off with a classics degree, isn't it a good thing to be introducing these subjects to the widest range of children?

I don't think that follows tbh. The fact that many of our judges and politicians have a Classics degree is in large part an indicator of the types of schools and universities they went to, rather than an indicator that classicists necessarily make the best politicians and judges. I strongly doubt that teaching Latin in state schools will result in a rebalancing of the proportion of state school and private school educated politicians and judges.

Couchpotato3 · 04/08/2021 18:11

My son loved Latin and hated modern languages. He found the subject matter deadly boring in French and Spanish (endless iterations of what we had for breakfast, my day at school etc etc). Cambridge Latin Course was much more interesting - robbers and fighting, arson and innuendo as I recall! Given that many of our politicians, judges etc, started off with a classics degree, isn't it a good thing to be introducing these subjects to the widest range of children?

VeryQuaintIrene · 04/08/2021 18:06

interfector/interfectrix fili!

PartridgeFeather · 04/08/2021 17:33

Go on then, what's "Thread Killer" in Latin?

Piggywaspushed · 04/08/2021 17:20

Oh , I won't mediate again then. Mea culpa and all that. Pax.

DGRossetti · 04/08/2021 17:18

@PartridgeFeather

No, it was aimed at the person who posted it, who told me in Latin that my head was up my arse (unless I'm mistaken, which is very possible in this heat) and I think a person with socialist leanings might've concurred with my sentiment that it is in fact GW's head up his respective arse and then suggested possible solutions for removing him from post, instead of bantering at me in a dead language that GW wants everyone to learn because his mate Boris can quote it.

Whatever, it is wine o'clock here, ciao.

I was pointing out your Latin was erroneous as far as I could see. You were talking about the head of an arsehole, not having your head up your arse.

I refer you to Romanes eunt domus upthread.

One of the first programs I wrote (in Apple BASIC) formed the endings for any given noun. Because I was doing Computer Science and Latin O Levels.

PartridgeFeather · 04/08/2021 16:54

No, it was aimed at the person who posted it, who told me in Latin that my head was up my arse (unless I'm mistaken, which is very possible in this heat) and I think a person with socialist leanings might've concurred with my sentiment that it is in fact GW's head up his respective arse and then suggested possible solutions for removing him from post, instead of bantering at me in a dead language that GW wants everyone to learn because his mate Boris can quote it.

Whatever, it is wine o'clock here, ciao.

Piggywaspushed · 04/08/2021 16:37

I think the your was a reference to Gav and Co, as in one's Tory mates....

DGRossetti · 04/08/2021 16:19

[quote PartridgeFeather]@DGRossetti Quite possibly, but at least my crappy opinions are limited to this forum and won't be adversely affecting the nation's young people. Unlike those of your Tory mates. [/quote]
What on earth makes you think I have Tory mates ? Regulars to these boards will know very well I have a deeply socialist streak.

Or was it just because I've still got some Latin from my local comprehensive schooling ?

Getawaywithit · 04/08/2021 14:13

The GCSEs have just been reformed. I don't teach MFL but I know it is considered much harder

There has been a recent consultation for re-reform. I don't know about harder. It's more challenging. If they stopped the deliberate attempts to mislead and accepted a more straightforward approach to questioning, it would be easier for the majority. As it stands, they learn so, so much and then get caught out by unnecessary twists and turns which make things so frustrating for them. I am fluent in two MFL's and sometimes need to listen to a question twice or re-read something several times before I realise what they're getting at. It shouldn't be that complex at that level.

PartridgeFeather · 04/08/2021 13:40

@DGRossetti Quite possibly, but at least my crappy opinions are limited to this forum and won't be adversely affecting the nation's young people. Unlike those of your Tory mates.

Piggywaspushed · 04/08/2021 13:00

The GCSEs have just been reformed. I don't teach MFL but I know it is considered much harder.

EBearhug · 04/08/2021 12:41

I find that weird, having done French A level, where we studied the literature like Moliere, Camus, Racine, Gide, etc and it was assumed we knew the grammar by then; and Spanish to 1st year university standard!

I was the first year of GCSE - in my first A-level French class, we did a past O-level paper - and some of the grammar, we hadn't done it, as it wasn't in the GCSE syllabus. I did have an advantage there, also doing Latin - I just needed to learn the French patterns, but I understood what the subjunctive was, as it was in the Latin GCSE syllabus.

I agree with the German system of different types of secondary school

Which works better than the old grammar school/secondary modern system, where we had a two tier system more than a parallel system. We're not very good st looking st other countries' examples for better ways of doing things, though.

QueenBee52 · 04/08/2021 12:35

No £4million should not be spent on Latin.

Intercity225 · 04/08/2021 12:15

Many European students are studying literature in English at their equivalent of A-Level and we're still trying to teach ours the basics of the subjunctive and how to buy train tickets in Madrid.

I find that weird, having done French A level, where we studied the literature like Moliere, Camus, Racine, Gide, etc and it was assumed we knew the grammar by then; and Spanish to 1st year university standard!

However, having spent 20 years coming across children, who struggled with reading and writing in English (due to SEN); there needs to be more of a conversation about what children should be taking a MFL. Likewise, DH is quite bright, a graduate; but had no interest in MFL because he can't understand a language, with different sounds to ours (music is a horrible noise to him, so clearly some kind of auditory processing problem) and he made no effort whatsoever to learn any French, beyond bonjour! Forcing him to do O level, was a complete waste of everybody's time!

I agree with the German system of different types of secondary school - where one type is for children, say having done a broad national curriculum up to 14 (because we don't want to be accused of just producing factory fodder), to do a more technical, vocational curriculum, which includes basic finance, self care (to stop people turning up at A & E with minor conditions like sun burn, or acid reflux), child care and development, IT skills and then whatever else - which would be more useful in adult life.

DGRossetti · 04/08/2021 12:14

@PartridgeFeather

Sorry OP if it went s bit off-topic. Anyway getting back to the original point, message to Gav (still in a job?!?) "Caput tuum in ano est"/your head is up your arse. Lots more where that came from, but possibly not the return on investment he was envisaging.
caput tuum usque asinus tuus

surely ?

PartridgeFeather · 04/08/2021 11:42

Sorry OP if it went s bit off-topic. Anyway getting back to the original point, message to Gav (still in a job?!?) "Caput tuum in ano est"/your head is up your arse. Lots more where that came from, but possibly not the return on investment he was envisaging.

knitnerd90 · 04/08/2021 07:25

I think Latin is great, but it shouldn't be a priority over MFL. Government policy on language teaching has been appalling for a decade--they should never have made it optional. Anglophones in general are really appalling at foreign languages and resort to "but everyone speaks English" and "well, there's always going to be a native speaker who's bilingual, so there's no point in me speaking it imperfectly." (Exception: Canadians in French Immersion.)

I took both Spanish and Latin, and I do use my Spanish a lot more, but I live in the USA now. There are some schools here that offer a bilingual curriculum in primary and the children actually do come out speaking very well; the problem is that not all are supported to continue their learning after. You need to start teaching young and you need to push it. Many European students are studying literature in English at their equivalent of A-Level and we're still trying to teach ours the basics of the subjunctive and how to buy train tickets in Madrid.

newnortherner111 · 04/08/2021 07:04

Although not the purpose of the thread I started, I have to agree that translation is an art, and one which has sometimes amused me for languages I understand reasonably well.

Interested in the responses I have read, certainly those who want Latin to be offered have an unexpected range of arguments in favour.

OP posts:
Intercity225 · 03/08/2021 20:25

Would someone who understood Latin deduce what that phrase represents in law?

I think you can. When I had a disabled child, I needed to empower myself, by studying the law of education, and later community care, the Mental Capacity Act, DOLS, continuing healthcare funding, the Human Rights Act, The Equality Act, etc and when I came across the term “Mandamus”, knowing what it meant literally, enabled me to work out what it meant in law.

I also realised the professionals, who assess children with SEN, deliberately wrote reports and talked to each other in jargon, so that parents couldn’t understand them. So for instance, they would put in a report

“Fred Bloggs has a standard score of 65 on receptive language, and 65 on expressive language….”

They could have put it more intuitively obvious as

“Fred Bloggs has a severe receptive and expressive language disorder, he is on the first percentile for both - ie if you took 100 children, he would be the worst one….”

But they didn’t want parents saying:

“Doesn’t a disorder mean Fred is not going to just grow out of it; and if his problems are that severe, do you think he should be in a language unit?

There was intense pressure already on language unit places, just for those children put forward by the speech therapists; never mind making it worse by alerting parents to the real extent of their child’s problems and them asking for a place!

I needed to understand the reports, how the test scores work, etc. I had to do A-level psychology to get the basic concepts and relearn all the statistics, but after that I could read at degree level text books for abnormal psychology, speech and language therapy, dyslexia, etc - because the vast majority of the jargon is based on Greek and Latin. I might never have come across the term “proto-imperative pointing” before, but I could work out what it meant literally.

Or, reading the report of DD’s MRI scan of her brain, when it started talking about the sulci; I knew it meant furrows in Latin - so it was obvious, what part of her brain, they were talking about. Likewise, I could read academic medical articles on her health problems, beyond the limits of my knowledge, because I could understand what the medical jargon meant literally underneath.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/08/2021 08:53

I knew Greek was common especially in the Hellenic eastern half, and increasingly as 'Rome' moved to Byzantium), but that's rather besides the point. Would someone who understood Latin deduce what that phrase represents in law?

DGRossetti · 03/08/2021 07:47

@ErrolTheDragon

Those comments are true enough but not quite what I was driving at. If a Roman read the phrase 'Habeas corpus', would he be likely to understand what it might mean in English law?
You need to remember that most "Romans" spoke Greek in the first instance. Latin was the lingua franca of it's day.
ErrolTheDragon · 02/08/2021 22:30

Those comments are true enough but not quite what I was driving at.
If a Roman read the phrase 'Habeas corpus', would he be likely to understand what it might mean in English law?

KeflavikAirport · 02/08/2021 21:09

Well, subtitles have massive constraints on character counts to match on-screen action so will often give you a gist translation rather than a full run-down of what has been said.