Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
bumblingbovine49 · 31/07/2021 22:16

Learning a language at GCSE is frankly a bit dull as it does require a lot of repetitive rote learning ,at first anyway. It is primarily learning how to use a tool so I didn't find languages at O' level ( that dates me!) that interesting . Certainly not as interesting as English Language, History Geography or even the sciences where I had a lot more 'ah ha that's interesting' moments. And I was pretty good at languages and got 3 O Levels in French, German and Italian.

Once you have enough ability, of course it gets more interesting but learning a language is hard work and pretty dull, unless you have a knack for them and I say that as someone who didn't find them too hard. I think Latin would definitely have been more interesting to learn l.

JoborPlay · 31/07/2021 22:00

I learnt Latin in school (state, optional extra GCSE) and it MASSIVELY helped my understanding of MFL, of which I only took GCSE French (very reluctantly) but can make a very decent stab at reading most European languages because of Latin.

Intercity225 · 31/07/2021 21:50

Not really helpful if you're learning German, Finnish or Russian.

German and Russian are both case languages like Latin - it’s something we have to learn to understand as English is the opposite. I did German for 2 years and never had a clue what the cases meant. Once I did Latin, it all became clear, because the grammar teaching was just at another level!

JudgeJ · 31/07/2021 21:46

@MrsSkylerWhite

Alternatively, ensuring that an huge number of children, thought to be in six figures, don’t leave primary school unable to read English may be a plan?
That figure, from wherever it is plucked, reflects largely the lack of interest many parents take in their child's education, or life in general. After conception it's all down to the state to raise their progeny.
woodhill · 31/07/2021 21:45

Er ok,ChunderConfused

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 21:44

[quote lokomojo]Proto Indo European is the root of (most) European languages. Latin, Greek, Germanic, Keltoi, Balto-Slavic --- these are all from this root. (As are Sanskrit, Persian, Hindi etc.)

Latin is the root of Romance languages and a huge influence on English, which is fundamentally Germanic.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Indo-European_language[/quote]
Latin is the root of Romance languages and a huge influence on English, which is fundamentally Germanic

This is disingenuous. We have a lot of words that have Latin roots because the Norman invasion swelled our vocabulary by approximately 100%.

Our grammar and syntax and language structure is NOT based on Latin. It developed separately and in tandem.

Latin didn't 'influence' English. It influenced romance languages, one of which (Norman French) in turn increased our vocabulary.

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 21:39

@woodhill

The Germanic languages have links with Latin German grammar and sentence structure for example.
Oh my. German and Latin grammar are very different. You really don't know what you're talking about. Because Latin is now dead I think that people believe it's some sort of 'father of all language'. It's not. Germanic languages are not based on Latin. They developed separately. Look up Indo-European languages on wiki as a good starting guide.
CaptainThe95thRifles · 31/07/2021 21:39

To be fair, people are responding to the OP's idea that Spanish is more useful than Latin or, that any funding should be directed to MFL rather than classics.

That's not the same as thinking this is a meaningful and useful policy, or that it's an appropriate use of this particular funding.

lokomojo · 31/07/2021 21:36

Proto Indo European is the root of (most) European languages. Latin, Greek, Germanic, Keltoi, Balto-Slavic --- these are all from this root. (As are Sanskrit, Persian, Hindi etc.)

Latin is the root of Romance languages and a huge influence on English, which is fundamentally Germanic.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Indo-European_language

pollylocketpickedapocket · 31/07/2021 21:34

@chunderwunder

Why not spend the £4m making sure the poor kids aren't too fucking hungry to learn properly.
If only it was that simple.
OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 31/07/2021 21:33

Language provision in the uk is abominable, too little too late. As someone said upthread if it was better then the addition of Latin would be great, but it isn’t. And when we have a huge lack of send provision, kids coming through with terrible literacy and numeracy, not to mention the damage Covid has done to their resilience and mental health it does strike me as a bit of performance politics.

CoffeeWithCheese · 31/07/2021 21:32

I chose to do Latin to GCSE at school (mainly cos I found languages quite easy and the teacher was a softie) and actually it's been incredibly useful for me in terms of the linguistics modules I've had to do at university. Plus I just enjoyed it - and as I've got older I've got more and more into things like language change and sociolinguistics and the like anyway as a bit of a geeky source of enjoyment (and don't get me started on what a beautiful concept the IPA chart is - despite the two years of hell it's put me through!).

Ecce Romani can fuck off though!

mumsneedwine · 31/07/2021 21:31

Money for SEN, CAHMS and glue sticks would be more useful.

dalismoustache · 31/07/2021 21:29

@chunderwunder Have you studied Latin? It's pure logic and the logical thinking you need to apply would be useful for coding.

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 21:29

@lannistunut

All these people saying Latin is marvellous - that it not the point. Surely you are not so silly as to think this is a meaningful measure?

40 schools - it is a tokenistic bit of nonsense so you all go 'how marvellous, they are giving us so much!'

Why do people fall for this utter shit? Schools are really really struggling, this is just a bit of gold leaf on a turd, and everyone is clapping their hands in glee.

I learnt Latin myself, that really is not the point. We need a properly funded education system, not pointless gimmicks that will change NOTHING.

I agree. My state school taught Latin. Probably still does. Apparently around 10% of the 3,000 or so already do.

But let's all wank ourselves stupid over some performative bullshit whilst ignoring the real problems in education.

If you fall for this crock of shit you're a twat.

BlueorOlive · 31/07/2021 21:27

There should be money for MFL and Latin.

Getawaywithit · 31/07/2021 21:27

Latin is the root of all European languages so has benefits in terms of understanding the linguistic principles underpinning all languages.
Added to which it is a portal into learning about ancient civilization, literature, and a whole world of culture different from our own. Nothing at all to do with going to mass! Surely you can see there is value in academic studies for how they encourage you to think, rather than just practical application?

Not sure it’s the root of all European language, but everything else….the timetable is packed to bursting with so many subjects, schools already on 2 week timetables to fit it in. We have a long, long history of a shortage of MFL teachers across the country. The teachers we do have are leaving en masse. If you want a subject taught properly, you need an expert teaching it or at least someone with some prior learning of the subject themselves.

So where are the teachers coming from? How is timetabling going to work with that one - because what will amount to one lesson a week for top sets does not a timetable create. What do you propose is dropped from the curriculum if Latin makes a serious return? How would you faze it in?

Just a ridiculous vanity project, trying to appeal to some cohort amongst the electorate, no doubt.

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 21:26

Why not spend the £4m making sure the poor kids aren't too fucking hungry to learn properly.

lannistunut · 31/07/2021 21:25

All these people saying Latin is marvellous - that it not the point. Surely you are not so silly as to think this is a meaningful measure?

40 schools - it is a tokenistic bit of nonsense so you all go 'how marvellous, they are giving us so much!'

Why do people fall for this utter shit? Schools are really really struggling, this is just a bit of gold leaf on a turd, and everyone is clapping their hands in glee.

I learnt Latin myself, that really is not the point. We need a properly funded education system, not pointless gimmicks that will change NOTHING.

woodhill · 31/07/2021 21:25

The Germanic languages have links with Latin German grammar and sentence structure for example.

LeithLinks · 31/07/2021 21:23

Of course but the stuck up private school bastards have absolutely no idea how the education system, nor the real world, actually works.

But GW should, his DF is a state school governor in a deprived coastal area.

Anycrispsleft · 31/07/2021 21:23

I'd be very surprised if you couldn't get the same perspective and language learning skills from learning a modern language. And with modern languages there's also the massive advantage of having access to newspapers, film, TV, and to native speakers.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 31/07/2021 21:23

I’m undecided whether I think this is a good idea or not. I wish I’d had the opportunity to learn Latin at my (private!) school, but then I love languages. I do wonder what lesson will have to be removed from the timetable to accommodate Latin lessons - further reduction of modern foreign languages?
And maybe existing teachers will be able to teach Latin basics, but I can see logistical issues with that one too.
On balance, YANBU OP. I think it will largely be a vanity project.

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 21:23

@mathanxiety

I agree with *@GreenestValley*.

Plus Latin is a very hravily inflected language.

It's an ideal foundation for coding.

I've heard it all now. I spent 20 years as a coder, interviewing them too. Latin was mentioned zero times. By anyone.
Whatelsecouldibecalled · 31/07/2021 21:23

I’m 32 and did Latin at school in a rough as comprehensive school. We did Latin as an addition if you were in top set languages to help with language aquarium and structure. All European languages stem from Latin. Our teacher was amazing he was like our grander. Retired teacher that just kept coming back for more. Brilliant guy

Swipe left for the next trending thread