Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
Novelusername · 31/07/2021 22:57

lazylinguist I agree with your post. When I was at school teaching English Grammar was not in vogue, and this meant that when I was taught Grammar in French or German I had no idea what was going on. I think it's absolutely shocking that we never learned English Grammar, really put my generation at a disadvantage. I didn't even know what any of the terminology meant. It's really not possible to learn a foreign language without understanding what grammatical terms are referring to, not as an adult at least. I don't know how different things are now.

lazylinguist · 31/07/2021 22:56

The main reason Britain struggles with MFL is because we start far too late.

It is taught in primary schools, just badly and with no continuity. It's often just the primary class teacher slinging them whatever bits of French he/she remembers from school.

lazylinguist · 31/07/2021 22:52

Exactly, PedalPushers. I'd genuinely like to understand how, for example, starting Latin and French simultaneously at age 11 (or probably starting some French in primary school, then starting Latin in secondary) provides any kind of Latin 'springboard' to learning French or Spanish.

  1. Children need to be taught English grammar properly and sensibly from primary school and continuing into secondary school. An understanding of the grammar of their own language is absolutely key to being able to start learning a foreign language properly.

  2. The MFL curriculum and methodology need a complete overhaul. There needs to be continuity between primary and secondary, plus a budget for qualified MFL teachers to teach in primary schools. It's ridiculous that it's compulsory to teach a modern language at KS2 in England, but that there is no primary MFL training or a proper curriculum! MFL are treated as low priority by the government, schools, parents and pupils. Adding Latin is going to do nothing whatsoever to help with that, and if it takes curriculum time away from MFL it will make matters worse.

Novelusername · 31/07/2021 22:52

@BashfulClam

Latin is useful for law and medicine. My chemistry teacher had studied Latin and said it really helped him with his chemistry degree…,spanish probably would be less useful to him. My best friend is a lawyer and uses Latin terms daily.
The majority of kids at my comp were never going to go on to be scientists or lawyers, that's just the way it is. I think it would have been fine as an option for those who wanted it, making it a compulsory subject would be ridiculous.
Novelusername · 31/07/2021 22:48

bonbonours I 100% agree with your post. MFL should start to be taught in primary school until age 16, only then would it be possible for kids to leave school with a decent ability to speak a foreign language. A couple of hours a week for three years in secondary was all we had at our school. Having studied foreign languages further as an adult, I realise that this is nowhere near enough.

BashfulClam · 31/07/2021 22:47

Latin is useful for law and medicine. My chemistry teacher had studied Latin and said it really helped him with his chemistry degree…,spanish probably would be less useful to him. My best friend is a lawyer and uses Latin terms daily.

Pedalpushers · 31/07/2021 22:43

Plus the fact that language education includes cultural education, learning Latin will not give you any knowledge of the current globe.

noblegiraffe · 31/07/2021 22:43

He has just dropped in this culture war bullshit to make sure that people are talking about this and not the fact that he has just scrapped level 3 BTECs.

bonbonours · 31/07/2021 22:41

@Anycrispsleft

I'd be very surprised if you couldn't get the same perspective and language learning skills from learning a modern language. And with modern languages there's also the massive advantage of having access to newspapers, film, TV, and to native speakers.
Exactly, I'm with you @Anycrispsleft

Rather than wasting years on a language nobody speaks, because it makes learning other languages easier, why not spend those years becoming proficient in a languages you can actually speak to people and learning about countries you can actually visit and experience the culture?

The main reason Britain struggles with MFL is because we start far too late. Teaching 11 year olds Latin is not suddenly going to make them better at learning French and Spanish. Introducing foreign languages at a young age, infant school or even nursery is proven to make it easier to learn other languages later on. By secondary school age your brain has already lost a huge amount of ability to learn to pronounce new sounds.

Other countries know this and teach MFL as a priority from very young. Hence why in some countries eg Netherlands it is not uncommon for people, even those with no higher education, to speak English, French and German fairly fluently.

I know several children aged 3-5 who speak 3 languages because it is relatively effortless at that age to pick it up. It gets so much harder the older you get.

Pedalpushers · 31/07/2021 22:40

I didn't learn Latin at school. I did learn French, German and Spanish and got the same result everyone here is claiming Latin gave them, being able to engage with most European languages, with the added bonus of language skills I could immediately use.

lazylinguist · 31/07/2021 22:38

Latin is the root of all European languages so has benefits in terms of understanding the linguistic principles underpinning all languages.

I did French, German and Latin at the same time and learned Spanish later. All three of my initial languages helped me learn linguistic principles. Latin only helped me with the others in the sense that you learn tons of grammar even pretty early on, because grammar and vocabulary are all you need to make time for in Latin - no lesson time devoted to listening, speaking etc! But it is not necessary to learn Latin to learn grammar when you could instead give more time to MFL and teach it better! Incidentally, it is my French that has made it massively easy for me to learn Spanish, not my Latin.

Teaching Latin for its own merits is all well and good, but I think its benefits as an aid to learning other languages are wildly overstated and kind of an illogical arse-about-face principle.

ilovesooty · 31/07/2021 22:37

@Odisia

I did Latin at secondary school for 3 years. It's stood me in great stead when learning other European languages.
Same here.
Pedalpushers · 31/07/2021 22:36

Both sides are correct. Learning Latin, like learning most things, can be very useful. There are also many more things in an underfunded system that are probably more important right now.

DdraigGoch · 31/07/2021 22:35

Latin is not a "dead language". It lives on (albeit heavily evolved) in the form of Spanish, French, Italian, Portuguese, and Romanian. Latin acts as a good springboard for learning modern languages.

Raggletaggles · 31/07/2021 22:33

I wish I’d had the opportunity to learn Latin at my state grammar school. It would’ve been incredibly helpful with the Latin-based modern languages I went on to learn later, with history and archival research… I love this scheme!
I’d much rather my kids learned Latin than modern languages. It’s a brilliant starting point for so much.

Novelusername · 31/07/2021 22:30

Whilst I've got nothing against the teaching of Latin per se, I would much prefer if Modern Foreign languages were taught to a decent level in UK schools. I did both French and German and gained high grades, but GCSE levels are pretty much only Beginner level in these languages and won't get you any further than ordering something in a shop or commenting on the weather. Meanwhile, on the continent, kids leave high school with fluent English and often another foreign language to their own. There's really not much point in learning a foreign language in school unless you can become nearly fluent, otherwise it's only going to be of use for buying something on holiday, hardly enhancing job prospects. I've lived abroad and been at a serious disadvantage for my lack of foreign language skills. I think I would have enjoyed learning Latin, but I imagine to most of my classmates at my run of the mill comp it would have been seen as hellish and pointless.

womaninatightspot · 31/07/2021 22:28

@GreenestValley

Totally disagree, Latin is the root of all European languages so has benefits in terms of understanding the linguistic principles underpinning all languages.

Added to which it is a portal into learning about ancient civilization, literature, and a whole world of culture different from our own.

Nothing at all to do with going to mass! Surely you can see there is value in academic studies for how they encourage you to think, rather than just practical application?

This it's very useful in law, medicine , horticulture etc. I went to the Sinai mountain in my younger backpacking days and found it fascinating. Greek orthodox monastary at the home of the biblical burning bush in what is now a predominantly muslim country. Clearly my education was lacking as I had no idea how that happened. If only I'd studied latin in school I might of had a bit more appreciation for ancient civilisations :) I did learn a bit of latin then. I learnt some ancient greek when studying byzantine law too.
lazylinguist · 31/07/2021 22:28

*private Hmm

AntiWorkBrigade · 31/07/2021 22:28

@bumblingbovine49

Learning a language at GCSE is frankly a bit dull as it does require a lot of repetitive rote learning ,at first anyway. It is primarily learning how to use a tool so I didn't find languages at O' level ( that dates me!) that interesting . Certainly not as interesting as English Language, History Geography or even the sciences where I had a lot more 'ah ha that's interesting' moments. And I was pretty good at languages and got 3 O Levels in French, German and Italian.

Once you have enough ability, of course it gets more interesting but learning a language is hard work and pretty dull, unless you have a knack for them and I say that as someone who didn't find them too hard. I think Latin would definitely have been more interesting to learn l.

I enjoy learning languages, and for me starting out in a new one is hard to beat because you go from nothing at all to building up knowledge quickly. I hated GCSE German, however. We didn’t learn about how the language worked at all. Instead, we were given sentences with blanks and lists of words that could be swapped in and out. Talk about dull and robotic. Grammar was not in vogue educationally at the time!
Intercity225 · 31/07/2021 22:27

Latin didn't 'influence' English. It influenced romance languages, one of which (Norman French) in turn increased our vocabulary.

That is one part of the development of English; but Latin was the common language of educated people all over Europe and England, because it was the language of the Catholic Church and it’s scholars at least upto the time of Thomas More. Look at the Carmina Burana, some of Petrach’s sonnets, the writings of the Venerable Bede, the story of Heloise and Abelard, Thomas More’s Utopia to name but a few - all in Latin. If all educated people wrote in Latin (and right upto Victorian times well to do boys would have studied Classics), then they are bound to have adopted some Latin vocabulary into their thinking and vernacular - such as technical language in medicine, science, law…Why do we talk about videos, television, super novas - not because these words came from Norman French!

LittleOwl153 · 31/07/2021 22:27

As we seem to have a board full of Latin lovers and some Latin Teachers to boot .... can anyone e suggest a self teach Latin course for my yr7 daughter. She excels in Spanish and is decent in French - despite struggling in other areas so language is her thing... and Latin might just help!
I did latin as well as French and German at school. I hated latin but still think it was useful!

lazylinguist · 31/07/2021 22:27

Thing is, a good grounding in Latin will help immeasurably with a number of other languages, including Spanish of course.

Sorry, but this is a silly argument. Why would anyone think that the best way to help with modern languages is to learn a dead one? Teach Spanish and it helps with French. Or vice versa. Teach native English speakers the grammar of their own language properly and it helps with learning any other language. You don't need to know the roots of a language to learn it.

The answers to the problems in state education do not lie in trying to emulate private schools. What makes private schools do well is money and bright and privileged cohorts of students. Most state school pupils (and indeed private school ones) will gain little from Latin that they would not gain from a properly taught modern language (or two) with sufficient lessons per week. Latin may take away MFL curriculum time.

And I say all that as an MFL teacher who did Latin A Level and with two family members who did Classics degrees, one if whom teaches Latin and Greek at a pruvate school. Latin is interesting and fun for those who take to it. But it is not useful for the vast majority of people.

Getawaywithit · 31/07/2021 22:24

Learning a language at GCSE is frankly a bit dull as it does require a lot of repetitive rote learning ,at first anyway. It is primarily learning how to use a tool so I didn't find languages at O' level ( that dates me!)

Yes, it dates you. The content of the GCSE today vs pre 1988 O level is very far removed. Do you teach? Why write off a while subject today based on your learning which is a minimum of 30 years out of date?

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 31/07/2021 22:21

Nuntium mira Latine pro omnibus

trimbletramble · 31/07/2021 22:20

@chunder the point about Latin and coding is the logic and the puzzling out of things.

If you're a coder, I bet you'd actually love Latin.

Better get your hands on a Cambridge Latin Course...

Canis est Cerberus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread