Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £4m on Latin lessons should be spent on a modern foreign language

487 replies

newnortherner111 · 31/07/2021 19:58

www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/latin-state-schools-england-williamson-b1894202.html

Latest idea from the Education Secretary. Given that the Prime Minister has been in a Catholic church at least once, did he not tell Gavin Williamson that the Catholic Mass is usually in the local language now, and has been for over 50 years?

Encouraging learning Spanish for example would be much better and actually have a use in real life.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 08:08

@lazylinguist - it's definitely not being taught in all primary schools. My children have been to three. In their first, there was no MFL taught at all

That's not good. It is supposed to be compulsory. I have taught MFL at 5 primary schools. Some primaries get someone independent in (like me) or some secondaries do outreach to their feeder schools by sending an MFL teacher once a week. Although once a week isn't great - language needs to be little and often.

A pp was right that it would be virtually impossible to achieve continuity in MFL from primary to secondary even if you had the available teachers. The only way to do it would be to have a blanket national policy where all secondary schools started with one language (I'd argue for Spanish), then add a second of their choice if appropriate.

lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 08:00

I love language and if you know Latin you can very quickly pick up a lot more languages.

If you know Spanish you can quickly pick up a lot more languages. If you know German you can quickly pick up a lot more languages. It is the process of learning a language thoroughly and then learning other ones with similarities that makes it easy, not something magic about Latin.

And what Latin doesn't do for you, which modern languages all do, is give you the vital listening and speaking skills which actually allow you to communicate (rather than just being good at decoding texts and memorising verb endings).

CounsellorTroi · 01/08/2021 07:59

@MySecretHistory

Caecilius est in horto
Barbillus est vir dives.
lazylinguist · 01/08/2021 07:54

Perhaps people who have not studied latin lack the understanding of its importance.

I did it to A Level. It was interesting. It waa useful for the linguistucs module I did at university on the transition from Late Latin to Old Early French. It did not, however, help me learn French, German or Spanish.

newnortherner111 · 01/08/2021 07:53

@SimonJT you must have been at school at around the time I was, as we had no lessons on structure of the English language, indeed I learnt more about language structure in French lessons.

The lack of interest in modern foreign languages generally that one of the responses on this thread mentioned does concern me. I take great pride in not being the typical Brit abroad and speaking some of the local language, and it does avoid being asked immediately for my views on Brexit.

OP posts:
RBKB · 01/08/2021 07:09

^^ this

LynetteScavo · 01/08/2021 07:08

One of my DC left primary school barely able to read, but able to say several sentences in Latin. She's forgotten them now, but has learned to read. totally misses point of thread

SimonJT · 01/08/2021 06:45

Latin was compulsory in year 7 and 8 at my secondary school, so we spent an hour a week on it, however we spent 0 hours on the structure of the English language.

Latin hasn’t been useful to me, instead it was a wasted hour every week. I speak a bit of German and I’m learning Swedish, for those who think Latin is the source of all European languages, it really isn’t.

If the fund is limited to mfl it would be better spent overhauling how mfl is taught in England, at the moment its absolutely shocking (not the fault of teachers).

Gufo · 01/08/2021 06:45

I have a languages degree and doing Latin GCSE is on my bucket list for all the valid reasons listed upthread.

If money were no object, I'd support bringing Latin back to schools, but surely priorities should be getting the basics right - teacher retention, send provision, school funding - and then adding options like Latin as the cherry on top.

Sometimesonly · 01/08/2021 06:42

I think Latin is a useful subject to study but it has to be taught well and by teachers who have actually studied it themselves! It sounds like this is not going to happen.

sandgrown · 01/08/2021 06:32

I studied Latin many years ago and hated it . Maybe because it was all Friday afternoon . It must have sunk in because my ex was always impressed at my ability to get the gist of words in other languages that I had never been taught. It’s a great basis for other languages. We had a story book called Fabulae Antiquae I think.

lannistunut · 01/08/2021 06:30

Perhaps people who have not studied latin lack the understanding of its importance.

Hmm Hmm Hmm

lannistunut · 01/08/2021 06:30
Hmm

Yes, the plebs are too fixated on trivial matters like school buildings falling down and kids being educated in the basics, they don't understand the value of 40 schools (only 40!) teaching a small number of pupils Latin.

This policy has been designed to appeal to snobs. It is clearly working.

I learnt Latin, btw.

NewNeighboursRequest · 01/08/2021 06:20

I studied Latin at school. Originally because I wanted to study law. But the benefits of studying Latin based languages (Romance languages - French, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish) was the real benefit. Latin is also the international language of certain sciences. Perhaps people who have not studied latin lack the understanding of its importance.

Anycrispsleft · 01/08/2021 06:14

@BashfulClam

Latin is useful for law and medicine. My chemistry teacher had studied Latin and said it really helped him with his chemistry degree…,spanish probably would be less useful to him. My best friend is a lawyer and uses Latin terms daily.
I'm a chemist. I have a PhD I'm chemistry. There is some Latin terminology in chemistry, particularly in organic chemistry for the position of chemical groups on molecules, but the meanings are so specific to chemistry that I don't think it would have made much difference to me to have known the English translations.
lannistunut · 01/08/2021 06:14

If you fall for this crock of shit you're a twat agree with this sentiment from @chunderwunder

lannistunut · 01/08/2021 06:07

@noblegiraffe

He has just dropped in this culture war bullshit to make sure that people are talking about this and not the fact that he has just scrapped level 3 BTECs.
Thank you, someone else who sees through this garbage.

Why don't parents engage with what is happening to schools more generally?

AgentJohnson · 01/08/2021 05:24

In the Netherlands (where I live) it is taught in state schools to the most academically gifted (private and independent schools aren’t a thing here). DD has just switched to the non Latin and Greek version of the education stream (Atheneum instead of Gymnasium) because on top of learning English, Dutch, French and German it was too much and would have come at the expense of other lessons later on.

The idea of bringing Latin and Greek to mainstream education is laughable and just shows how deluded and shortsighted the Tories really are. For those screaming that Latin and Greek are gateways to learning other languages etc, if it is taught, it will be an either or situation.

Maggiesfarm · 01/08/2021 03:25

Latin was always taught in years gone by and not at the expense of any other subject. It's extremely useful being the basis of all European languages, is helpful in the sciences too.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 01/08/2021 02:10

A good education is very important so don't slate it.

Bit hard to get with a government deliberately underfunding education and teachers leaving the profession due to the contempt they are often shown.

A good education is very important so don't slate it.

Latin lessons being more important than a guaranteed meal?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 01/08/2021 02:07

Is it just me or do some of those supporting this Latin lessons idea come across as bots? Ive just RTFT and some responses really stick out, and with others it comes across as an older demographic with no idea how schools are now going with the 'we did it in our day' narrative

Probably the most useful subject I learned

Really PP, more useful than Maths, English, MFL, science? A 'dead' language was the most useful Hmm

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 01:59

Totally disagree, Latin is the root of all European languages so has benefits in terms of understanding the linguistic principles underpinning all languages.

This. Think of it as an English extension course. Knowing the origins of words is very helpful in problem solving and communicating, and so many origins are in the Latin language.

quizqueen · 01/08/2021 01:41

If everyone had been fortunate enough to have been taught Latin at school then the standard of writing on this forum and on other social media would probably be a lot better because, quite honestly, it's often appalling. A lot of people who post online have very poor spelling and an even worse understanding of grammar. 'Would of ' comes to mind, no idea of the difference in usage between 'there, their and they're' and don't start me on the need to proofread before posting.

A good education is very important so don't slate it.

MoominFeatures · 01/08/2021 01:29

Latin is brilliant. I use it or transferred skills (or both) every single day. @GreenestValley has it down.

Shoot me for the view but I’d vote for it, and for widening participation to try to help smash some of the misinformed societal perceptions (which, disappointingly, are evident even on here).

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/08/2021 01:00

Sorry for double posting.

As long as they've binned "Caecilius et Metella" and their fecking atrium as part of any curriculum, then classical languages might stand a chance.

Listening to Caecilius and/et Metella talking about being beautiful (ego sum pulchra) in or out of their bloody atrium was enough to put me off.

Thankfully I found being a dustman made me much more appreciative than if I'd followed the expected doctor route.