Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?

410 replies

PollyPopa · 31/07/2021 19:30

She's biologically male obviously but also hasn't got as good a personal best as some of the other (biologically female) competitors

Just wondering, that's all! I don't agree she should be in that competition either by the way but nothing to say she will win since her personal best isn't as great as some of the others

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
DrSbaitso · 01/08/2021 13:11

A woman who had the same level of testosterone as Hubbard would be disqualified for doping.

334bu · 01/08/2021 13:11

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone.

I think the poster means that they have lowered their level to the level required by the IOC; a level 10 times higher than the average woman's level.

LH still has a male body though , giving them huge advantages in strength etc over women.

FourTeaFallOut · 01/08/2021 13:10

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone. This is heavily tested before competing

Bullshit. The level of allowed testosterone for a man to compete as a woman in the Olympics is of such a level that were a woman to take testosterone to the same level they'd be immediately jettisoned for cheating.

Wh0Knew · 01/08/2021 13:10

@catfunk - that is totally untrue. LH DOES benefit from elevated testosterone against the natal women LH competes against. LH had to reduce their testosterone intermittently to around 10, which is still degrees higher than natal women possess. If a natal woman recorded the testosterone levels LH did, they would be done for doping….

BlueLobelia · 01/08/2021 13:09

and also because LH;s current permitted testosterone levels is so much higher than a biological woman that if a bio woman had the same she would be disqualified for doping?

You are really quite wrong.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 01/08/2021 13:08

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone. This is heavily tested before competing.

It might be heavily tested but, as far as I’m aware, LH’s test results are way above what a natal woman’s testosterone would naturally be. In fact, if a natal woman had the same testosterone levels as LH, she’d be hauled up for doping.

At least the IOC have recognised that the current rules are not fit for purpose because a) they allow a higher level of testosterone than would be permitted for a natal woman and b) they don’t take account of the increasing amount of research that shows other physical advantages from going through a male puberty.

LostDonkey · 01/08/2021 13:08

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone. This is heavily tested before competing.

Could you explain how LH, a biological male who has gone through male puberty, has not benefited from testosterone?

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 13:08

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone. This is heavily tested before competing.

I think what you mean is that he is not currently benefiting from testosterone by having taken blockers or balancing hormones to ensure that he is within the guidelines. That doesn't remove the fact that testosterone has contributed to the current muscle make up of his body and given him an unfair advantage.

LizzieW1969 · 01/08/2021 13:07

Laurel has taken a place from a young, NZ woman of colour who should rightfully be at the Games. Laurel simply shouldn’t be there.

^That is the main issue here. It makes no difference whether or not Laurel wins any medals, it isn’t the point.

Littlekittyscupcake · 01/08/2021 13:05

She shouldn’t be in the competition. She has a male body which puts her at an unfair advantage against her fellow female bodied competitors.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 01/08/2021 13:05

I hope he win gold and smashes records. People might just see how ridiculous this is.

OneTC · 01/08/2021 13:02

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone.

U wot?

catfunk · 01/08/2021 13:01

@Vanishun

Somewhere out there, an actual woman who has probably trained relentlessly hard for years (without any benefits of testosterone etc) has lost out on her chance.

That's not okay. It's cheating and it's shit behaviour in the name of validating someone's feelings about themselves.

Just in case posters aren't aware, LH is not benefiting from testosterone. This is heavily tested before competing.
TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 01/08/2021 12:59

[quote TooWicked]@clickychicky Up until about a year ago I also thought all transwomen had had surgery i.e. had their penis ‘removed’ (inverted). I also thought they were probably on a cocktail of drugs to alter their hormones. Now I know the majority do not and are not.[/quote]
Indeed, mainly because many of the drugs used reduce their performance. Because biological males require their natural hormone levels for things like bone density.

So they stay as biological males, avoid the medication and just say I'm a woman...look I grew my hair long and have some lippy on 🙄

This is the tip of the iceberg IMO.

Sneak one or two substandard ones in, see how it's received make sure it fly's under the reader then Paris 2024 sneak a few more in to the "other sports" boxing, rowing, sailing then 2028 swimming and track as the TWAW mantra has had over a decade to brainwash the population.

Be interesting to see the winter Olympics. Can't see many transwomen signing up for the figure skating pairs....

RadandMad · 01/08/2021 12:52

@FannyCann

This has all been carefully planned and orchestrated. It is part of a very long game with vast amounts of money behind it.

I thoroughly agree. They will not do spectacularly well and the BBC will not show the event or pay scant regard to it. Consequently the whole thing sails nicely under the radar paving the way for Next Time.

Has anyone wondered why we haven't seen a man in a short skirt and frilly knickers blasting the female tennis players off the court? The huge amounts of prize money must make it a very tempting proposition.

Imo the sports people are less interested in are the advance party, paving the way. Tennis is way too obvious and a partisan audience inclined to cheer for the underdog cannot be controlled. "They" want to sneak it in under the radar, before advertising themselves to the world. I give it two - three years, maybe one of the men in their early twenties who can see that they are never going to break through to the top ten or even the top fifty.

Yes, I was wondering this too the other day. I think Wimbledon would be too conspicuous, as the matches are well attended, televised and attracted huge audiences. They couldn't control the booing.
BrightYellowDaffodil · 01/08/2021 12:51

Funny how there are no trans women in…dressage

A side issue, it wouldn’t matter if someone was trans in equestrian sports as men and women compete equally. There would be no advantage for someone male bodied to identify as female, they’d still be in the same category.

Back to the main issue in hand, threads like this - where there are posters saying “I didn’t know trans women don’t have to physically transition to compete” or “I didn’t realise other people feel the same way as I do on this” is why threads on this subject belong in subforums other than just FWR. @mnhq please note!

334bu · 01/08/2021 12:50

You could see how much his strength was helping him but still couldn't turn it to his advantage

So basically a crap fighter relying purely on brute strength.

Taoneusa · 01/08/2021 12:49

@Kittii

This is just one of the many consequences of asserting that a man literally turns into a woman just because he says he feels like one.

It's a total fantasy and I can't understand how anyone can possibly accept it.

Agreed. I think it’s temporary lunacy that will, over time, correct itself. It’s absurd.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/08/2021 12:47

Why are the Russians still allowed to compete if many of them were systematically cheating?

You may well ask Hmm Because the doping was a state-sponsored thing, the excuse is that the ROC athletes aren't competing for Russia at all but as individuals - though any fool knows that's hardly how Russia will present it internally

To my mind if you're out you're out (though copious bungs may well have got in the way) and if that's unfair on whatever few weren't drugged up then they can take it up with their own sporting bodies

OneTC · 01/08/2021 12:46

*advantage even

OneTC · 01/08/2021 12:45

Fallon Fox, having been through puberty, will have a punch around 160% harder than a woman's I believe. I will find the link.

He got massacred against Ashlee Evans Smith though which was a delight to see

You could see how much his strength was helping him but still couldn't turn it to his assistant

Chickenyhead · 01/08/2021 12:44

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/02/200205132404.htm

162%

Chickenyhead · 01/08/2021 12:41

@AfternoonToffee

I read the other day that everyone is making a big fuss about Fallon Fox and it is all part of the scene to talk like they do.

I think some 'supporters' are coming from a viewpoint of being inclusive to children, but with the current trend to block puberty it is probably unlikely these children will be achieving world standards.

Fallon Fox, having been through puberty, will have a punch around 160% harder than a woman's I believe. I will find the link.

Quite a big difference on a contact sport.

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 12:40

[quote TooWicked]@clickychicky Up until about a year ago I also thought all transwomen had had surgery i.e. had their penis ‘removed’ (inverted). I also thought they were probably on a cocktail of drugs to alter their hormones. Now I know the majority do not and are not.[/quote]
And it really doesn't matter if they do, they still have a genetic advantage of extra muscle. There will always be advantage and disadvantage from a physical point of view even in amongst athletes of the same sex. It's not all about how hard someone works, however the ones who make it to the top all work hard. Some might be able to gain more muscle than another, some might have longer legs or better weight to strength ratio or whatever, but the paying field is generally more level. As soon as you bring in someone with that great a physical advantage then the minor differences amongst the rest doesn't matter anymore.

AfternoonToffee · 01/08/2021 12:38

I read the other day that everyone is making a big fuss about Fallon Fox and it is all part of the scene to talk like they do.

I think some 'supporters' are coming from a viewpoint of being inclusive to children, but with the current trend to block puberty it is probably unlikely these children will be achieving world standards.