Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?

410 replies

PollyPopa · 31/07/2021 19:30

She's biologically male obviously but also hasn't got as good a personal best as some of the other (biologically female) competitors

Just wondering, that's all! I don't agree she should be in that competition either by the way but nothing to say she will win since her personal best isn't as great as some of the others

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BrozTito · 01/08/2021 15:34

Its funny seeing opponents of this called far right. The Morning Star and Communist party are gender critical ffs

DepressedDD · 01/08/2021 15:32

@BlueLobelia

and also because LH;s current permitted testosterone levels is so much higher than a biological woman that if a bio woman had the same she would be disqualified for doping?

You are really quite wrong.

I don’t think they are wrong.

In 2015, the IOC ruled that transgender athletes who identify as female could compete on female teams if their testosterone levels were below ten nanomoles per liter for at least 12 months before the competition. In 2019, World Athletics lowered the maximum level to five nanomoles per liter. By comparison, most cisgender female athletes have testosterone levels between 0.12 and 1.79 nanomoles per liter.

www.forbes.com/sites/kimelsesser/2021/07/27/what-makes-an-athlete-female-heres-how-the-olympics-decide/?sh=5b7f69ca4f9c

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 15:15

I realise now why there is no debate from the other side. Because there are no real arguments as to why this is ok. So they shout down and intimidate instead of rational discussion, they hurl insults and call us bigoted and hateful for asking questions. Nobody wants to be labelled a bigot, so it's very effective in shutting people up.

Exactly, if you are not on board with all of this then you are labelled, transphobic or racist or whatever. I know not every argument needs to come back to the nazis, but this is how such things come to being, because dissenters or those who see the emperor is naked, or see the squirrel that is sent to distract are shut down and made to feel as if they are in the wrong.

I don't have daughters, but i have myself and my sisters and my nieces to consider here. And actually also my sons who have been very much raised that women are equals and to treat people with respect etc. who are now expected to participate in hogwash or face a lot of backlash. I don't really care about my career as I'll be retiring soon, so it's easy for me just to ignore instructions to add my preferred pronouns to my email footer. Not so easy for anyone starting out to also do so.

Caliexpidocioussuper · 01/08/2021 15:02

It’s the advantage of the third leg for balance.

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 01/08/2021 15:01

[quote clickychicky]@Mulletsaremisunderstood oh no need to apologise I am very open to having my views challenged and this thread and others have already made me think I need to read up more. I had no idea the permitted testosterone levels were so much higher than for an average woman and that alone has made me a bit uneasy so who knows how I feel when I read further.[/quote]
I predict you will get very angry, like many of us have gotten when we realised how far this has gone down the rabbit hole, and what the effects are and will be on women and girls.

Young teenage girls (many of whom are lesbians and/or autistic and struggling with their identity) are being pushed down a road of surgery (removing their breasts) and testosterone, which has all sorts of health implications and can affect their fertility later in life.

This is because they are struggling with body image, depression etc. But their distress is not being explored in a therapeutic way, they are simply 'affirmed' as being gender dysphoric and referred to a gender clinic. Some of these girls only have one or two sessions before they are referred. See the Kiera Bell case.

I realise now why there is no debate from the other side. Because there are no real arguments as to why this is ok. So they shout down and intimidate instead of rational discussion, they hurl insults and call us bigoted and hateful for asking questions. Nobody wants to be labelled a bigot, so it's very effective in shutting people up.

There is a worrying agenda behind this, that actually has little or nothing to do with genuine trans people, and everything to do with powerful lobby groups.

Since pulling back the curtain on this I am so so angry at what is being done in the name of being 'kind and progressive'.

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 15:00

@334bu

*For fucks sake! Any idea where Scottish Rugby are on it?*

Unfortunately, not on the side of women.

Great - not!
ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 14:59

It's perfectly possible to be aware and accepting without engaging in this horseshite.

BrozTito · 01/08/2021 14:59

Not sure if its been said but we know whos place she took-a young maori woman from poverty

334bu · 01/08/2021 14:57

For fucks sake! Any idea where Scottish Rugby are on it?

Unfortunately, not on the side of women.

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 14:56

DH is a lifelong rugby fan as he is a borders man and was delighted when I said about the world rugby stance. Who in their right mind thinks this is okay? Better to be seen to follow the woke crowd rather than engage your brain cells for a minute though.

VladmirsPoutine · 01/08/2021 14:55

Clearly the woke would rather see women injured.

I'm woke. I didn't realise being aware of social and racial injustice and inequality was a terrible trait.

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 14:54

[quote Theeyeballsinthesky]@ElephantOfRisk except both England & welsh rugby have decided to ignore what works rugby said and allow TW to play women’s rugby

www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/49298550

The coach joked that they had a great future provided they could stop ‘her’ injuring the other players in training - oh how we all laughed 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️[/quote]
For fucks sake! Any idea where Scottish Rugby are on it?

clickychicky · 01/08/2021 14:53

Yes thank you I have already had a couple of threads there highlighted as a good place to start.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 01/08/2021 14:53

@ElephantOfRisk except both England & welsh rugby have decided to ignore what works rugby said and allow TW to play women’s rugby

www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/49298550

The coach joked that they had a great future provided they could stop ‘her’ injuring the other players in training - oh how we all laughed 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

RadandMad · 01/08/2021 14:32

@ElephantOfRisk

Good for Rugby. Clearly the woke would rather see women injured.
@ElephantOfRisk Yup. Looking at you, Rugby England.
ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 14:32

Good for Rugby. Clearly the woke would rather see women injured.

RadandMad · 01/08/2021 14:27

Obviously World Rugby got denounced for being transphobes for pointing this out.

RadandMad · 01/08/2021 14:26

Contact sports are where the rubber really hits the road. Which is why World Rugby is against trans women playing in women's teams. They have reviewed all the evidence and concluded it is highly unsafe for women.

Kittii · 01/08/2021 14:24

@clickychicky what a mature and honest response. I wish more people were able to have such intellectual integrity. I suggest reading some threads on the sex and gender board. It really opened my eyes too.

clickychicky · 01/08/2021 14:14

@Mulletsaremisunderstood oh no need to apologise I am very open to having my views challenged and this thread and others have already made me think I need to read up more. I had no idea the permitted testosterone levels were so much higher than for an average woman and that alone has made me a bit uneasy so who knows how I feel when I read further.

Snugglepumpkin · 01/08/2021 13:34

It used to be legal to rape your wife & beat your children.

Do you think that means all those raped women & beaten children should just think it was okay it happened to them & give accolades to the men who did it because 'it was allowed'?

Is the fact that those men wanted to do it, thought they were entitled to do it & were permitted in 'the rules' to do it a good enough excuse?

Or are some things deeply wrong no matter what the 'rules' say?

I don't care if Hubbard goes out drinking all the night before & comes last, they are still abusing women by taking what should be theirs. (The place, the ability to say they were on the Olympic team, the chance to maybe win).

Nobody is entitled to be 'included' in the Olympics, nobody gets to expect to be in the Olympic team & that includes elite athletes who have trained their whole lives to have a chance to be.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 01/08/2021 13:27

So in the final end game with all this inclusive woke nonsense only the strongest men will “complete” in all events and claim they identify as a woman if not strong enough to beat other men. Not sport but just a mockery of cheats gaming a material differential advantage against innocent fair play level playing field athletes. This will be the sad end of sport as we still know it.

We have already fluid nationality rules with sports immigration giving an advantage to multinational teams including Team GB and especially USA who can simply import talent whether just competitors or their world class coaches too. So when one views the current Olympic medals table - some counties with indigenous athletes born, trained and crafted their sport within their origin nation or those that use their sporting ability to immigrate to another nation. In that light the Chinese at the top and Japan near the top of the table are all the more credible with only internal and less or none international athletes and coaches. Many of the USA unlike China, Japan or RussIa etc originally developed their sporting powerless overseas and now represent their new Olympic colours. Here is an extensive list of international sports migration or representation for more than one nation. This makes a mockery of the international medals table too.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sportspeople_who_competed_for_more_than_one_nation

ElephantOfRisk · 01/08/2021 13:25

Agree @Mulletsaremisunderstood, similar situation in Scotland where SNP have declared that a board made up of half men and half transwomen is sex balanced.

Anyway we digress. As long as it isn't done in order to take some advantage over women i'm much the same as you, surgery and hormones then crack on with however you want to be. Not for children and preferably after mental health treatment. How we allow people to mutilate their bodies for a mental health condition I don't know, but we are where we are.

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 01/08/2021 13:14

[quote clickychicky]@Mulletsaremisunderstood well.. I thought surgery and hormones would be enough for me but this thread is making me reconsider.[/quote]
Sorry clickychicky I wasn't getting at you specifically, just frustrated at the concept of a woman costume being all it takes.

I was where you are a few months ago, wondering what all the fuss was about. I genuinely thought if these people were struggling and in so much distress with their bodies that they would go through extreme surgery, then we should help them and feel sorry for them.

I still think that about people genuinely suffering from gender dysphoria. The problem is that in the last few years, what 'trans' is has changed massively. Hormones and surgery are no longer required. Anyone can be trans if they simply declare it.

I live in Ireland, where Self ID is now in law. This means that any man can fill out a form, pay a small fee, and be legally declared a woman, for all purposes. It was brought in without public discussion about what this would do to women's places and spaces in society.

This has lead to male rapist being put in the women's prison. These males 'identify' as women (whatever the hell that means) but have their genitalia fully intact. That is horrific, and it's happening in lots of places.

The media are not fully reporting on this. They will report crimes committed by TW (self declared, no surgery/ hormones required) as being committed by a woman. How is fair and transparent reporting?

Even MN doesn't really want us talking about this, which is why we have been mainly shunted off the the Feminist board (not even the main one anymore) and people complain if anything is mentioned on other parts of the site. Even though this is something that affect women hugely.

NeedNewKnees · 01/08/2021 13:12

[quote clickychicky]@LostDonkey if he doesn't even identify as a woman then no he shouldn't be winning awards for women. I am surprised he accepted it.[/quote]
Bounce insisted on being in the women’s category. Bounce is Hubbard in a desk job.