Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?

410 replies

PollyPopa · 31/07/2021 19:30

She's biologically male obviously but also hasn't got as good a personal best as some of the other (biologically female) competitors

Just wondering, that's all! I don't agree she should be in that competition either by the way but nothing to say she will win since her personal best isn't as great as some of the others

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Greencharge · 02/08/2021 07:35

Well articulated @NotBadConsidering

LostDonkey · 02/08/2021 07:12

The State Media have just uploaded a video focusing on the Olympic Games and their decision to include Laurel Hubbard in the women's category.

Floisme · 02/08/2021 07:09

@Porcupineintherough

Dont agree *@Floisme*. If the female athletes affected by these decisions dont speak up, their silence reads like consent. Yes there is a price to pay but this issue is crucial to the future of women's sport. No use hoping others will speak for you.
I would be absolutely thrilled if one of them did Porcupine, but it would be at such a high personal cost, and I don't feel comfortable sitting on my sofa and asking that of them. As I've said, I honestly believe viewers, spectators, customers, supporters of grassroots sport, could together stop this tomorrow if we put our minds to it. (Ok maybe tomorrow's an exaggeration.)
Theeyeballsinthesky · 02/08/2021 07:04

What NotBad said with bells on!! Men, no matter how they present, are not women and I will not use female pronouns for them.

fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/

NotBadConsidering · 02/08/2021 05:52

using preferred pronouns a basic courtesy which harms no-one.

Of course it does. It harms everyone. It’s how we bloody got here in the first place. We didn’t jump from women’s competition for women to women’s competition for women and certain males overnight. The gradual erosion of boundaries that has led to males competing in women’s competition started with “be nice” and “it doesn’t harm anyone”. When a male is referred to as “she” it confounds people’s natural inclination to marry the two notions together in their heads. If the sex of the person being referred to matches the sex of the subject, people don’t think there’s a problem and aren’t challenged. For example:

“Should she be allowed in women’s competition/prison/refuge?”

The average person who isn’t aware just thinks, “of course, why wouldn’t she?Confused”

Now insert the correct sex-based pronoun:

“Should he be allowed in women’s competition/prison/refuge?”

Instantly there is a challenge to a person’s thought process. We have the pronoun for a male and a subject for females. Straight away the truth is seen for what it is and a more accurate assessment of the situation is able to be made.

This is why there has been a strong concerted push to make pronouns seem benign, not that important, just “being kind”. This is why it’s seen as hateful to use the pronoun accurate for a person’s sex, because it means people don’t really think about what they’re agreeing to.

Incorrect pronouns for a person’s sex cause huge harm to women and girls and I will not comply.

PickAChew · 02/08/2021 00:02

Well, yeah, they are a mediocre male weightlifter but still have a biological and physical advantage over most female weightlifter.

SpringCrocus · 02/08/2021 00:00

Cis an offensive term, please stop using it

rattusrattus20 · 01/08/2021 23:42

@MiladyBerserko

Calling males 'she' reads like consent.

It is not 'kind' to females. It is being complicit in this bullshit.

using preferred pronouns a basic courtesy which harms no-one.

allowing her into a sporting competition that was invented for biological women, in which only three medals are up for grabs is something else entirely.

and it's beyond farcical in a sport that's so overwhelmingly strength based that it has seven different Olympic weight categories.

"it wouldn't be fair to allow a 100lb woman to compete with a 108lb woman, they need to be in different competitions".

"it wouldn't be fair to allow a 108lb woman to compete with a 120lb woman, they need to be in different competitions".

"it wouldn't be fair to allow a 120lb woman to compete with a 130lb woman, they need to be in different competitions".

"it wouldn't be fair to allow a 130lb woman to compete with a 141lb woman, they need to be in different competitions".

etc

etc

etc

and then:

"would it be fair to allow a cis woman to compete against a woman who was until very recently a man, a hulking six foot something brute with a rather noticeable cock and balls bulging out of her leotard? errrrr, yes, I think it would be, provided she takes these pills every day".

SpringCrocus · 01/08/2021 23:41

Oh, it was a rhetorical question.
We shouldn't.

Porcupineintherough · 01/08/2021 23:41

@ErrolTheDragonyes give some examples from history of when one group has campaigned and sacrificed to liberate another.

Floisme · 01/08/2021 23:37

I think the people best placed to speak up are the customers, consumers, supporters and nurturers of sport.
That includes us.
I don't think grassroots sport would survive for long without the invisible day to day support of women.
I said this on the other thread but I honestly believe we have more power than we think - the question is whether we're prepared to use it.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/08/2021 23:35

[quote Porcupineintherough]@SpringCrocus because this is an issue which affects primarily them. If they wont, why should anyone else?[/quote]
Basic human decency?

Porcupineintherough · 01/08/2021 23:28

@SpringCrocus because this is an issue which affects primarily them. If they wont, why should anyone else?

MiladyBerserko · 01/08/2021 23:26

Calling males 'she' reads like consent.

It is not 'kind' to females. It is being complicit in this bullshit.

SpringCrocus · 01/08/2021 23:18

Why do women have to speak up and risk losing jobs, funding etc?
This is just madness, why do women have to risk their livelihood?

rattusrattus20 · 01/08/2021 23:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Porcupineintherough · 01/08/2021 23:00

bell the cat.

Porcupineintherough · 01/08/2021 22:59

I'm not denying they may personally suffer @FrippEnos, that's par for the course. Look at the American civil rights movement, look at the Suffragettes, look at the resistance to Apartheid.

But if all the people who think this is wrong spoke up, rather than ducking for cover and hoping someone else will act, then this would be sorted within the year. The majority of people do not think humans can change sex, or that its fair that tw compete in the women's events in the Olympics. But yet we all sit round and hope someone else will be the cat.

FrippEnos · 01/08/2021 22:42

@Porcupineintherough

Dont agree *@Floisme*. If the female athletes affected by these decisions dont speak up, their silence reads like consent. Yes there is a price to pay but this issue is crucial to the future of women's sport. No use hoping others will speak for you.
The bigger problem is that if they do speak up they will lose sponsorship due to being "transphobic" as the Trans lobby has cancelled many people.

Just look at those in academia that have lost jobs or been forced out.

Porcupineintherough · 01/08/2021 22:34

Dont agree @Floisme. If the female athletes affected by these decisions dont speak up, their silence reads like consent. Yes there is a price to pay but this issue is crucial to the future of women's sport. No use hoping others will speak for you.

Lordamighty · 01/08/2021 22:27

@Ritasueandbobtoo9

I think the true losers here are the genuine trans people who really struggle with their identity.
No, the true losers are the female athletes deprived of their rightful place at the Olympic Games.
FrankButchersDickieBow · 01/08/2021 22:06

Yes. It's interesting to hear from older transwomen

Hubbard is an older transwoman. Hubbard is 40 odd.

There are no 40 something bio women competing because their strength is incomparable to bio women in their 20's when they are at their peak.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 01/08/2021 21:57

I think the true losers here are the genuine trans people who really struggle with their identity.

Floisme · 01/08/2021 20:47

Sharron Davies - who knows a thing or two about being cheated is another who speaks out.

Delphinium20 · 01/08/2021 20:41

Good for you Daley Thompson

Even the trans woman golfer in the Fail yesterday participates as a male She came across really well

Yes. It's interesting to hear from older transwomen. The ones who are the realists seem much more comfortable in their lives and it shows in their confidence to be themselves while playing men's sports. Frankly, they are trailblazers for men because they show men there's no one way "do masculinity or do femininity."

Swipe left for the next trending thread