Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?

410 replies

PollyPopa · 31/07/2021 19:30

She's biologically male obviously but also hasn't got as good a personal best as some of the other (biologically female) competitors

Just wondering, that's all! I don't agree she should be in that competition either by the way but nothing to say she will win since her personal best isn't as great as some of the others

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BlueLobelia · 02/08/2021 11:42

Thanks for timing. Sadly I do not have Discovery so will keep an eye out on the Beeb otherwise youtube.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/08/2021 11:28

I think LH is competing at 11:50am - so says the Indy. Hope someone uploads it to Youtube soon after. I'm assuming the Beeb won't show it? And don't you need a subscription to Discovery??

334bu · 02/08/2021 11:12

As far as I am aware this athlete has undergone no surgery but has fulfilled the iOC rules by lowering testosterone levels.

"Those who transition from male to female are eligible to compete in the
female category under the following conditions:
2.1. The athlete has declared that her gender identity is female. The
declaration cannot be changed, for sporting purposes, for a minimum
of four years.
2.2. The athlete must demonstrate that her total testosterone level in serum
has been below 10 nmol/L for at least 12 months prior to her first
competition" IOC guidelines

Interesting that there is only a requirement to say that you are a woman for 4years and then it is quite acceptable to go back to living and competing as a man[confusedHmm

puffyisgood · 02/08/2021 10:45

@littledrummergirl

The news channel have just reported on it. They said they will be watching it. Also had fallon saying it was fair as no physical differences. HmmConfused
well, i can think of a couple of fairly obvious physical differences straight off the bat.

seriously though, heightwise LH is the tallest competitor by a distance & presumably has correspondingly larger hands, feet, wrist width, bone thickness, etc etc etc.

Hugefanofcheese · 02/08/2021 10:16

littledrummergirl I'm not surprised. This Fallon seems quite hard of thinking and to have some misogynist tendencies. I'm not a great sports fan and happy to be corrected here. I know boxers trash talk each other, it's part of the game. However I've never heard a male boxer rejoicing about breaking another male boxer's skull during a fight such as Fallon did about a woman opponent. And tried to make it some sort of political victory rather than a male born adult beating up a woman and breaking her skull.

littledrummergirl · 02/08/2021 10:07

The news channel have just reported on it. They said they will be watching it.
Also had fallon saying it was fair as no physical differences. HmmConfused

DuncinToffee · 02/08/2021 10:07

@BlueLobelia

Just looked at todays BBC Olympic schedule and they do not seem to be covering it (on BBC One anyway). Does anyone know?

I know that a pp suggested we watch it on youtube but if it is on the regular channel then more likely to expose people to whom the issues are brand new.

It will be live on Discovery

BBC are only allowed to show the Olympics on 2 channels so have limited coverage and focus more on live competitions with British athletes.
It will be shown at some time today on the BBC.

Triphazards · 02/08/2021 10:01

Is it today?

Hope he doesn't burst his puddings!

Ponoka7 · 02/08/2021 10:00

Laurel might not win but you can bet in eight years time, there will be biological men winning the women's events. Across the US there's biological men already taking advantage of their biology and winning women's sports.
Unless changes are made we'll only have gymnastics.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/08/2021 09:54

@VladmirsPoutine

In my experience when I speak to others about this they seem to understand the (blindingly obvious) issues but fear repercussions so would rather not speak about it or even post about it on social media. The end result really might be someone screen-shotting your tweet and forwarding it to your employer with an e-mail along the lines of

"Dear company X, do you condone your employee Ms.X making publicly transphobic comments online? Is this in line with your company's values."

This. And the further down the food chain women are, the less able they are to challenge the removal of sex segregated spaces and awards for female achievement being presented to male advantaged individuals.

The women most disadvantaged by employers rushing into inclusivity for one group without an Equalities Impact Assessment are always those already disadvantaged.

Its unsurprising that women then fear to speak out in many places and rely on relatively anonymous forums.

Snoozysnoozy · 02/08/2021 09:32

Just looked at todays BBC Olympic schedule and they do not seem to be covering it (on BBC One anyway). Does anyone know?

Red button?

FluffyBattleKitten · 02/08/2021 09:25

Well colour me shocked 🙄😉

BlueLobelia · 02/08/2021 09:12

Just looked at todays BBC Olympic schedule and they do not seem to be covering it (on BBC One anyway). Does anyone know?

I know that a pp suggested we watch it on youtube but if it is on the regular channel then more likely to expose people to whom the issues are brand new.

334bu · 02/08/2021 08:28

If you’re so convinced you’re a woman, why on earth would you want a penis??

Not all transgender people suffer from gender dysphoria. In fact to be transgender it is no longer considered to be necessary to be unhappy about your physical body . Some TRAs consider it to be more about " widening the bandwidth of womanhood" and are more than happy to demonstrate this explicitly on social media.

TidyDancer · 02/08/2021 08:27

Is anyone watching this today? Don't know if I can bring myself to do it.

MNHQ are now removing posts that refer to this person as what they are btw (in case anyone hasn't noticed). You should be ashamed of yourselves but I suspect are not.

334bu · 02/08/2021 08:19

The number of transwomen who actually have sex reassignment surgery is very small, less than 20% I believe.

Whatwouldscullydo · 02/08/2021 08:14

Tbe simultaneous push for children to access medication whilst adults can just self identify is also food for thought.

bellinisurge · 02/08/2021 08:10

Most transwomen with a gender recognition certificate keep their dick. That was the thing that completely altered my view on this issue. With self-ID transition, even more will keep their dick.
Knowing that changes everything. Hubbard still kept their dick after transition as photos have shown while they have been in competition.

LimeRedBanana · 02/08/2021 08:05

It’s a total given that removal of your penis still does not entitle you to compete against women (or claim you are a women).

It’s just really … um … interesting that so many trans women need to get their tackle intact.

Lockdownbear · 02/08/2021 08:02

@lightnesspixie
Even if a male has sex changing surgery, he / they still have the advantage of a male body, bigger, bigger lung capacity, more muscle mass, the legs set into the pelvis at a different, stronger angle.

So no sex change athletics should remain in the male category. Clean and simple, males compete with males, this avoids the argument about what happens with people who are going through the process.

LimeRedBanana · 02/08/2021 08:01

If you want to be a woman then get your tackle removed. I don't understand why some (read most) trans women keep themselves intact. To me that doesn't make sense.

I don’t understand this either, but we’ll be accused of being obsessed with people’s genitals and to get our noses out of people’s pants. 🤢

If you’re so convinced you’re a woman, why on earth would you want a penis??

Many actual women would be a lot more accepting of transwomen if they were actually willing to take this seemingly small but crucial step.

Vanishun · 02/08/2021 08:01

You also just can't remove being male from a body. It affects everything - body shape, bones, lung capacity.

There is no way to just make it fair.

Vanishun · 02/08/2021 07:59

I can understand why someone would want to avoid potentially painful surgery which is easy to botch - there are many horrible nightmare stories on Reddit about it all - it's all irreversible damage and if you have a neovagina, you have to constantly maintain it as it's essentially a wound which the body keeps trying to heal. There are horrible realities behind what sounds like simple surgery.

But even if they did all have surgery, a woman isn't just a man without a penis - men who are accidentally castrated don't become female. And there are more ways than one to sexually assault someone.

So I don't think those who have had surgery are any more entitled to female spaces than those who haven't. Especially when their femaleness is based on sexist stereotypes or sissy porn habits.

lightnesspixie · 02/08/2021 07:46

And sorry am I missing something here? I'm all for trans inclusion generally - but if a woman is trans then at least insist they have had gender reassignment surgery before letting them compete with natural born women (I refuse to say cis) - not just reduce their testosterone. If you want to be a woman then get your tackle removed. I don't understand why some (read most) trans women keep themselves intact. To me that doesn't make sense.

Whatwouldscullydo · 02/08/2021 07:46

I wish people would stop deciding what a harness basic courtesy or not.

Correct pronouns can't simultaneously be a small basic courtesy and literal violence if not done.

Something that changes the entire meaning of everything is a huge deal.

And I find not being able to say what I see, and having my language coerced extremely harmful. I wouldn't that abuse from a partner let alone a.comete stranger.

We owe them nothing.

And we do not consent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread