Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?

410 replies

PollyPopa · 31/07/2021 19:30

She's biologically male obviously but also hasn't got as good a personal best as some of the other (biologically female) competitors

Just wondering, that's all! I don't agree she should be in that competition either by the way but nothing to say she will win since her personal best isn't as great as some of the others

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Delphinium20 · 03/08/2021 06:01

My understanding of Semenya is the same. Male due to DSD

EdgeOfACoin · 03/08/2021 05:45

@FluffyBattleKitten

Sorry polka, not being goady but I was under the impression that Caster is an individual with xy chromosomes dsd. Is that not the case?
That Semenya is a biological male was my understanding too - I thought 5ARD was a dsd only found in males? I thought it was a case of the external genitalia not developing normally (thus giving the impression of being female) but the inner reproductive system is male. Certainly the testosterone levels for Semenya are in line with that of the average man, not merely on the high side for a woman.

Is my understanding incorrect?

I admit that I struggle to perceive Semenya as having female biology when I watch this interview:

FightingtheFoo · 03/08/2021 04:44

FYI there are people who identify as trans species https://www.vice.com/en/article/yvwknv/what-does-it-mean-to-be-trans-species

NotBadConsidering · 03/08/2021 01:46

Further, Caster Semenya, in a case I've followed for many, many years, is the case of a woman with very unusual biology (please don't point out the basics as I've studied this for years myself) who has been treated appallingly by the IOC. Seems that if she were a man who then became female, they'd have let her get on with it. Which is appalling misogyny in my book.

@Polkadots2021 what absolute guff. If you’ve studied the Semenya case for years you would know Semenya is male, with 5 alpha reductase deficiency. They DID let Semenya get on with it for ten years, depriving women of medals, prize money and sponsorship opportunities. That’s the misogyny, not stopping a male from competing against women finally.

TableFlowerss · 02/08/2021 22:04

@Kittii

It is the logical next step though. If you accept that a man becomes a woman just because he says so, anyone can become anything just because they say they "feel" like that thing. What is the difference between e.g. a man saying he is actually a woman because he wants to be a woman and someone saying they identify as a different race/ethnicity/age/species?

Or me saying I feel like was always meant to be a rich person so it's OK if I go and steal other people's stuff as that validates my identity as the rich person I should have been born as. What is the difference? It's all based on feelings, is unquantifiable and assumes an entitlement to something you weren't born with.

That’s mental…. Yet you’re example is absolutely spot on.
LimeRedBanana · 02/08/2021 21:35

What is the difference between e.g. a man saying he is actually a woman because he wants to be a woman and someone saying they identify as a different race/ethnicity/age/species?

There is no difference to anyone who hasn’t thrown their brain out the window and/or has a functioning set of eyes.

Delphinium20 · 02/08/2021 20:33

@FluffyBattleKitten

Roviel Detenamo. Remember her name. Post to social media if you can do. Fucking outrage.
Can't agree more.
Chickenyhead · 02/08/2021 20:30

I identify as being on the IOC anyone care to join me?

Kittii · 02/08/2021 20:29

It is the logical next step though. If you accept that a man becomes a woman just because he says so, anyone can become anything just because they say they "feel" like that thing. What is the difference between e.g. a man saying he is actually a woman because he wants to be a woman and someone saying they identify as a different race/ethnicity/age/species?

Or me saying I feel like was always meant to be a rich person so it's OK if I go and steal other people's stuff as that validates my identity as the rich person I should have been born as. What is the difference? It's all based on feelings, is unquantifiable and assumes an entitlement to something you weren't born with.

erinaceus · 02/08/2021 20:25

I am trying to work out whether her performance was staged somehow, there was something about it that did not look authentic.

Antwerpen · 02/08/2021 20:13

@ElephantOfRisk

Self identifying as either a 10 year old or maybe disabled? Or maybe they could self identify as a medal winner and just go straight to the award ceremony?
Genius Grin
Arrowheart · 02/08/2021 18:51

Hubbard is a disgrace. Walking off smiling. How on earth does she think her piss poor performance looks to the woman whose place she took??? Entitled and shit at weightlifting as a man and as a woman. An absolute disgrace.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/08/2021 17:57

That was me, Samphire, and thank you for replying

I sort of gathered LH would have been busy lobbying, and it's why I said they seem to have forgotten the word "No"
Still don't quite see why the IOC couldn't have got their act together though - as I also said, it's not as if gender issues are anything new

CuriousaboutSamphire · 02/08/2021 17:11

Sorry, that was supposed to be a reply to the poster who asked why the ire at Hubbard and not the IOC!

CuriousaboutSamphire · 02/08/2021 17:10

@BrozTito

Saw an artticle saying sex is non binary just now. When TF did they start sneaking that in? Are chromosomes transphobic?
Because it was Hubbard who lobbied them and forced a decision. One they have already said will be re visited as it is not fit for purpose, out of date.

Who knows how they will revise it, and Hubbard will be very aware of that!

GrouchyKiwi · 02/08/2021 16:39

C8H10N4O2 Rather like here, the media is complicit, for whatever reason. I don't understand it.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 02/08/2021 16:19

Laurel will pretend they are blind next to get in the para olympics. Apologies if you feel I am being harsh I just can’t stand blatant unfairness.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/08/2021 15:43

Most Kiwis are disgusted by it, but the sporting bodies don't give a toss. They've forgotten about the fair play they drummed into us at primary school

How is that demonstrated though? Are organisations like SaveWomensSport getting any traction or is it like here where the media seem terrified to offend anyone and so say little or nothing about women's sport?

There are some sports where men and women already compete on equal terms, others where it makes absolutely no sense. There is room for an evidence based discussion on each sport but I'm not seeing much evidence of the evidence!

Its notable to me though how many die hard anti-religion pro-science "skeptics" are sticking their fingers in their ears on the subject of data driven decision making when it comes to women.

GrouchyKiwi · 02/08/2021 15:33

@shallIswim

What are the kiwis saying about this? And LH's apparent couldn't care less attitude? I thought they were a proud sporting nation. I'd be interested in some insight.
The NZ Olympic Team doesn't let people comment on its LH posts on Facebook, but most of the reactions to LH's progress in this competition are laughing faces.

Most Kiwis are disgusted by it, but the sporting bodies don't give a toss. They've forgotten about the fair play they drummed into us at primary school.

shallIswim · 02/08/2021 15:16

What are the kiwis saying about this? And LH's apparent couldn't care less attitude? I thought they were a proud sporting nation. I'd be interested in some insight.

FluffyBattleKitten · 02/08/2021 15:15

@Lordamighty

Caster Semenya is not a woman with unusual biology, Caster Semenya is a male with unusual biology.
Thanks for the clarification. That's what I understood it to be.
Lordamighty · 02/08/2021 15:12

Caster Semenya is not a woman with unusual biology, Caster Semenya is a male with unusual biology.

Janaih · 02/08/2021 15:11

A true athlete would be mortified with such a poor performance and full of apologies towards the rest of their team and country. Never in my life have I seen someone walk away laughing because they ballsed it up. Disgusting and a sad day for women's sports.
Huge applause for the brave women and men who stick their head out the parapet and publicly state on record what a farce this is.

FluffyBattleKitten · 02/08/2021 15:06

Sorry polka, not being goady but I was under the impression that Caster is an individual with xy chromosomes dsd. Is that not the case?

Polkadots2021 · 02/08/2021 15:01

*male not make

Swipe left for the next trending thread