Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?

410 replies

PollyPopa · 31/07/2021 19:30

She's biologically male obviously but also hasn't got as good a personal best as some of the other (biologically female) competitors

Just wondering, that's all! I don't agree she should be in that competition either by the way but nothing to say she will win since her personal best isn't as great as some of the others

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
DottyHarmer · 01/08/2021 11:45

I thoroughly agree. They will not do spectacularly well and the BBC will not show the event or pay scant regard to it. Consequently the whole thing sails nicely under the radar paving the way for Next Time.

clickychicky · 01/08/2021 11:45

@LostDonkey if he doesn't even identify as a woman then no he shouldn't be winning awards for women. I am surprised he accepted it.

FannyCann · 01/08/2021 11:44

I know this thread is about LH but for anyone in doubt about the differences in speed between the men and the women I suggest taking a look at some of the new mixed relay events where you can see real time top women against top men.

This photo alone speaks volumes.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?
endofthelinefinally · 01/08/2021 11:42

This has all been carefully planned and orchestrated. It is part of a very long game with vast amounts of money behind it.
My personal opinion is that LH will get bronze and this will be the justification for saying that transwomen have no advantage.

BlueLobelia · 01/08/2021 11:42

Anyway, this is probably too conspiracy theorist but I have wondered if Gavin chose the name Laurel because they had the Olympics in sights. (The Olympic Laurel being so significant).

FluffyBattleKitten · 01/08/2021 11:41

I'd just like to remind people that if you are angry about it do not watch the official coverage.
People tuning in to this will increase the view that it's good for getting people watching sports.
Tune out and watch later on YouTube. I guarantee it will appear there very quickly.

vixeyann · 01/08/2021 11:40

I would really love to see the athletes boycott this event. I know that's nigh on impossible when it's the Olympics and culmination of their training but acceptance is only going to make this more commonplace. If she were to get on the podium, I hope the others refuse to stand on it.

LostDonkey · 01/08/2021 11:40

@VladmirsPoutine

Has the idea of a separate trans category ever been floated or not? That way everyone would be happy, it would be inclusive and there wouldn't be any to-ing and fro-ing about what constitutes a woman or fiddling about with hormone levels.
Of course, the idea has been brought up repeatedly. But this is primarily about male validation not gaining fairness in sport.

For a large proportion of these men it is not a case of severe body dysphoria (very rare) that has led to their public transition. It is a case of another condition which often leads to thread deletions whenever it is discussed: autogynephilia.

DuncinToffee · 01/08/2021 11:39

And it would take away their advantage, having to compete against other transwomen rather than women. Unless it would be transwomen against transmen

Biology.

clickychicky · 01/08/2021 11:38

@Mulletsaremisunderstood well.. I thought surgery and hormones would be enough for me but this thread is making me reconsider.

DrSbaitso · 01/08/2021 11:31

@VladmirsPoutine

Has the idea of a separate trans category ever been floated or not? That way everyone would be happy, it would be inclusive and there wouldn't be any to-ing and fro-ing about what constitutes a woman or fiddling about with hormone levels.
It would not make people happy because it wouldn't pander to the validation of a feminine identity, whatever that means, in absolutely every sphere without exception.
pigsDOfly · 01/08/2021 11:30

I don't watch the Olympics as have zero interest in sport.

But my god, I just can't imagine how bloody soul destroying and heart breaking it must be for the women who have trained and pushed themselves for years to get to the point where they are at the pinnacle of their sport only to find that the goalposts have moved and instead of competing against other women they're also competing against men who claim being a woman is a 'feeling'.

I feel so sorry for the women in that situation.

What do they do? Do they just give up and stop competing or keep trying to win again someone with superior body strength against whom they haven't a hope in hell of winning?

Makes a complete mockery of the whole Olympic if this is allowed to continue.

Canigooutyet · 01/08/2021 11:30

At the age of 43, women in weightlifting would have already retired.

You would think that lessons would have been learned after Fallon Fox broke someone's skull. The fight lasted 2 minutes and caused significant damage to Tamika Brents who was unaware that Fox was born a man.

www.sportskeeda.com/mma/news-when-transgender-fighter-fallon-fox-broke-opponent-s-skull-mma-fight

Fox was hailed bravest athlete in history. Personally that should have been said about the females who were brutally beaten.

www.breitbart.com/sports/2020/01/22/transgender-mma-fighter-who-fractured-womans-skull-named-bravest-athlete-history/

Lots of fighters protested that Fox should not have been allowed to compete as a women but the rules allowed it.

LH should have respected sportswomen and not even bothered to try out for the Olympics. Or when they won the place said no actually I proved to myself I could get a place but I don't deserve it. If I was born a woman I wouldn't be allowed to compete as my levels are around 10, and women would have been disqualified with those levels due to cheating.

Whatwouldscullydo · 01/08/2021 11:29

Whether these gender issues are cheating or not I believe rules need to accommodate and prevent athletes gaming the system to their advantage using sexual identity which suits their cause. Perhaps there should be an open event for all so a fair level playing field where sex is not the concern but simply being the best what ever gender, former gender or transitional gender etc

So we have mens , mens and mixed then.

Barring maybe horseriding and a couple of other often mixed sex sports let's not pretend that women/females will be adequately represented.

We have such an obvious solution. It just involves telling men /males. No.

VladmirsPoutine · 01/08/2021 11:27

Has the idea of a separate trans category ever been floated or not? That way everyone would be happy, it would be inclusive and there wouldn't be any to-ing and fro-ing about what constitutes a woman or fiddling about with hormone levels.

LostDonkey · 01/08/2021 11:26

Probably a good time to bring up Philip/Pippa Bunce who came 32nd on top 100 women in business. This is someone that identifies as "gender fluid" not even as a woman and has taken a place off a woman that deserves this award.

For those who don't know, Bunce switches between Philip or Pippa on different days of the week. A senior director at Credit Suisse, Bunce sometimes goes to work in a wig and dress as Pippa for part of the week, the other half in a suit and tie as Philip.

Bunce decided "I’d reached a point in my life where I thought, It’s really silly me hiding this, why am I putting on this facade and keeping all this hidden at work."

Oddly Philip only decided to introduce Pippa to his working life after he'd climbed the corporate ladder as Philip.

After having reached the top of his career as a man, switching to spend half the working week as a woman allowed him to come 32nd on the FT's list of 100 female business champions.

Anothing moving story of a man bravely facing adversity and flourishing.

To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?
To ask why people this Laurel the weightlifter will win?
ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 01/08/2021 11:25

Whether these gender issues are cheating or not I believe rules need to accommodate and prevent athletes gaming the system to their advantage using sexual identity which suits their cause. Perhaps there should be an open event for all so a fair level playing field where sex is not the concern but simply being the best what ever gender, former gender or transitional gender etc.

GrouchyKiwi · 01/08/2021 11:25

Hubbard is a cheat. The IOC is terrible and should be ashamed. Women are losing out because of their craven stance, ignoring the science and listening only to the loud voices of biological males.

NZ sport has lost its fair play credentials over this, and it makes me so mad and embarrassed.

And as PPs have said, it doesn't matter whether Hubbard wins or comes last; Hubbard has taken a woman's place to be on the team. Hubbard has used Daddy's money to get medals at competitions despite being completely mediocre before transition.

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 01/08/2021 11:19

@BlueLobelia

'''Woman' is not a feeling or a costume for men to try on if they are uncomfortable being men.''

But this is exactly what being a woman is for some men. LH included.

Either that or it is a costume for a man to try on when he fails at his chosen sport AS a man. LH included.

Yes, indeed. Unfortunately, the 'grown ups' in the room, i.e. the IOC, governments, media, medical establishment etc. Are all just blithely accepting this. And calling it progressive Angry.
Mulletsaremisunderstood · 01/08/2021 11:15

@FrankButchersDickieBow

Hubbard won't win. Hubbard could, if Hubbard wanted to, but Hubbard won't even get a medal.

All eyes are on this and there would be too much of a furore.

This is paving the the way for more biological males to enter women's sports.

This is a 'see, we won't take your medals' exercise, which will make women's sports a free for all for mediocre bio males.

Yes I think this is what might happen. As much as I would like him to win to show up this farce for what it is, I'm starting to doubt whether it will actually make a difference.

There has been many times over the last few months where something happened, and I thought 'this will be what makes people see what's really going on here'. But it didn't. And the next thing didn't either.

It brings to mind the quote that there are none so blind as those that will not see.

For some people, they don't want to see the problem here. Either because they have an agenda, or they just don't care. It's depressing.

BlueLobelia · 01/08/2021 11:12

'''Woman' is not a feeling or a costume for men to try on if they are uncomfortable being men.''

But this is exactly what being a woman is for some men. LH included.

Either that or it is a costume for a man to try on when he fails at his chosen sport AS a man. LH included.

ItsSnowJokes · 01/08/2021 11:11

@shallIswim

Probably already been said but I'm waiting to hear of an example of a trans man competing in the Olympics.
Quinn is a transman, but plays on the women's team. Quinn would have no chance of playing on the mens team as biology matters and Quinn knows that.
Mulletsaremisunderstood · 01/08/2021 11:10

@clickychicky

Oh! I assumed they needed to have made some sort of irreversible commitment to being a woman
What does 'being a woman' even mean though really? I'm not being facetious, I'm genuinely curious what you think it takes to be a woman.

A commitment to being a woman is some sort of nonsense that simply panders to that person's view of themselves. It has no bearing on the reality of actually being a woman and experiencing the world they way we do, and the limitations we face because of our biology.

Is it wearing women's clothes, or having long hair and wearing make up? I know plenty of women who don't wear make up and wear jeans and workboots. Are they not women?

To me it's my biology, which is immutable and unchangeable, no matter how much I would like to be able to change it sometimes.

I'm not trying to have a go at you, I just genuinely don't understand how someone can become a woman if they are not already one. 'Woman' is not a feeling or a costume for men to try on if they are uncomfortable being men.

RadandMad · 01/08/2021 11:10

@FrippEnos

KohlaParasanda

You're not alone. A lot of people are unaware of how little a man has to change to be allowed to compete as a woman and therefore don't understand why some of us get so angry.

Probably a good time to bring up Philip/Pippa Bunce who came 32nd on top 100 women in business. This is someone that identifies as "gender fluid" not even as a woman and has taken a place off a woman that deserves this award.

Pips Bunce - peaking people everywhere since 2018. We should give him a medal.
Porcupineintherough · 01/08/2021 11:08

@Ritasueandbobtoo9

Winner = white male Losers = women everywhere
Would it be ok if Laurel was black? No. Are all trans women white. No.

This is about sex, not race.