Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that parents who stare at their phone and completely blank their children are a bit shit really.

264 replies

gingganggooleywotsit · 31/07/2021 12:14

Ok I am being judgey and I know I’m only seeing a snapshot of someone’s life but it’s really upsetting me. I’ve been sitting in a coffee shop for a couple of hours doing a bit of work and there is a couple there with a 5 year old boy and they are literally glued to their phones. He’s having to hit them round the head practically to get them to look at him. He has nothing to play with keeps nearly running in the traffic and they will not look up from their phones. Little boy looks really upset. Yeah they might be working too I’ve been there wiith my kids but give the boy something to do or at least make eye contact occasionally! It’s like he’s invisible. 😞

OP posts:
IHateFlies · 01/08/2021 10:03

The only person there was the op and she felt strong enough about it to post. I don’t know why people are are having a go at her when we all know that plenty of children are ignored and have parents who aren’t able to parent well, whatever their circumstances.
The op is saying she saw parents on a phone for two hours and a child desperately trying to get attention and continually ignored.
When this happens, it’s a form of psychological withdrawal and is difficult to witness.
No one is saying that parents should never be on their phone but this seems to be have been upsetting for the op to witness. Maybe for good reason.
There’s a reason why people are doing studies on this.

GoldBar · 01/08/2021 09:55

Get off your phone, explain to your child that they must sit quietly whilst in my room.

Maybe the parents had taken their DC out for 'sitting quietly' practice?

Maybe this is a new thing to teach self-control and delayed gratification. I might try it with my 3yo. A sort of variation on 'sleeping lions'. How long can they sit quietly in their chair? If they can manage it for 5 minutes, they can have a chocolate...10 minutes, 3 chocolates...

My mother is a teacher and has issues with children who can't sit quietly when they're not the centre of her attention.

BillyWhozz · 01/08/2021 09:50

@gingganggooleywotsit

I knew the thread would go this way, don’t know why I bothered posting. Thank you to those who tried to understand what I meant.
And yet didn't stop to try and understand why the person in the cafe was on their phone. Hopefully the dozens of potential reasons from PP will help you be aware of a potentially bigger picture in future.
enoughforme · 01/08/2021 09:43

*If you follow the parents all day and notice this is a theme throughout then yes, it’s shitty parenting. If it’s just a snapshot of someone’s day then you’re being a judgmental twat.

For all you know they’ve taken them out for the day and answered their 100000 questions about dinosaurs and space and poo and now they’re completely exhausted so just want to sit on their phone for a bit.*

Exactly this you're being judgemental OP and you should concentrate on your own parenting.

Those parents have been with the kids 24 hours how do you know they've not been engaging with the kids the other 23 hours (with the exception of sleep time) and this was the one hour of the day when the child is engaging themselves.

Why has 21st century parenting turned into a thing where parents think paying child attention 24/7 is a positive thing?

It baffles me - do you not think children should be able to keep themselves occupied as that would be a useful skill for them to develop?

What happens when they grow up and have to be alone and then start getting anxiety because they always had attention and now that attention is gone?

There's two sides to this argument and there's a balance - but now where is paying children attention all the time good parenting. In fact, I'd say that's the shittier parenting option actually certainly in the long term.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 09:42

@StrangeToSee great post.

This having to account for children's every nanosecond is a relatively new thing, I wonder if the 'upset' (lol, get a grip) posters here realise that children have been ignored by parents in favour for newspaper reading, gardening, cleaning etc for generations before them?

I'm a teacher but I work through the summer on lesson prep and safeguarding issues. I've been working on my phone a bit this week while looking after the kids, in public too. Liaising with colleagues and child services over something that a pupil is going through that is ACTUALLY upsetting, actual abuse, and guess what - it's not "being ignored by their parents". So judge away if you see me on my phone - I'm trying to help another child settle into her new home where she isn't being sexually abused every day. That's more important than saying "oh wow!" Whenever my 5yo DS telling me he's seen a plane.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 09:33

@Guineapigbridge lol do you think parents who do on their phones NEVER let their kids be free to explore the outdoors 😂 what a bizarrely narrow minded view.

Breaking news: maybe they do both? Mind. Blown.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/08/2021 08:56

This.

Aibu to think that parents who stare at their phone and completely blank their children are a bit shit really.
3scape · 01/08/2021 08:53

You're totally right. There's plenty of time when they're engaged in something, or simply in bed to waste time zombie like with a phone.

3scape · 01/08/2021 08:52

They're on MN innit Wink

Hemingwaycat · 01/08/2021 08:50

If you follow the parents all day and notice this is a theme throughout then yes, it’s shitty parenting. If it’s just a snapshot of someone’s day then you’re being a judgmental twat.

For all you know they’ve taken them out for the day and answered their 100000 questions about dinosaurs and space and poo and now they’re completely exhausted so just want to sit on their phone for a bit.

StrangeToSee · 01/08/2021 08:46

Kids have the worst of all possibilities now: they're not allowed to be free to explore the world outside and yet, when they're required to be inside with their parents they're not getting quality interaction. Chucked in front of a screen or mum and dad distracted on a screen

Most kids I know (mine included) have plenty of quality interaction with their parents. And outdoor time, creative time, exercise. But not every hour of the day. They need to entertain themselves too.

For many parents work doesn’t just stop when the school holidays start. Even if you secure wfh days and flexi hours there will be times when your children have to entertain themselves, while parents use screens to work.

Is it such a bad thing for children to entertain themselves while parents work or make calls? Or should we insist they go to holiday club even if they don’t want to?

I remember my childhood holidays and weekends (pre-smart phones) consisted mostly of entertaining ourselves. Eg my dad would be busy gardening or watching cricket and not want to be disturbed, my mum would often be marking schoolwork (teacher) so although we were allowed to be near our parents we had to be quiet. Of course we interacted but a couple of hours without parents talking to us was normal. Constant interaction from parents wasn’t expected.

My DC have a variety of toys, books, craft and art stuff at home, plus free range in a secure garden so I don’t feel guilty if I don’t look up every time they’re chattering at me. And yes they have screens but screen time is limited and they don’t seem particularly interested in it.

If you interact with them every time they want to talk about their latest Lego creation or favourite colour they expect all adults to do the same.

My parents would often tell me not to interrupt if they were reading a book or writing a letter. The fact parents tend to read and write on their phones or tablets nowadays doesn’t mean they’re addicted to screens!

Guineapigbridge · 01/08/2021 08:26

I think phone addiction is the worst thing that's ever happened for children's brain and social development. Kids have the worst of all possibilities now: they're not allowed to be free to explore the world outside and yet, when they're required to be inside with their parents they're not getting quality interaction. Chucked in front of a screen or mum and dad distracted on a screen.
Wasn't there a study done recently where they asked kids, what do you want daddy and mummy to do more? And the majority of kids said they want their parents to not be on their phones all the time. I'll try to dig it out.

Chouxchou · 01/08/2021 08:16

@IHateFlies I just don't think people should judge when they don’t have the full story, and observing people for a short time (2 hours sounds like an exaggeration to me) doesn’t tell you much

Onlinedilema · 01/08/2021 08:04

Lots of excuses on here.
The parents are working - serioisly? What both of them, without laptops, in Costa Coffee with a child! No that's bullshit.
More likely they are amongst the realms of parents addicted to their phones. Ignoring their child for 2 hours, both of them in an obviously adult space. Costa Coffee is not a creche.
We sometimes get this at work. I work in a legal area. We see customers regarding legal issues. We are not there to speak to your child or engage with them. We are incredibly busy. We sometimes get parents they scroll through their phone whilst I am speaking to them, totally rude. Then the child will misbehave because surprise surprise they want attention. The parents then have to apologise for their child 's behaviuor. Get off your phone, explain to your child that they must sit quietly whilst in my room. If the child asks a question answer them then explain that you are talking to me and must listen.
Invariably it's the clients who have been scrolling through their phone whilst in an appointment who then phone up to say something is wrong with their paperwork. No shit Sherlock.

HarrisMcCoo · 01/08/2021 08:01

[quote nimbuscloud]@StrangeToSee
Wtf ? A 5 year old should bring his own toys, books and people watch?
And if you read the op’s post his parents were on their phones for a couple of hours - not 30 minutes.[/quote]
Exactly. My 5yo would run amok and can't be trusted in a shop to people watch. He is a flight risk and you can't relax with a coffee in his presence. I don't look at my phone when out and about with him for this very reason. Complete opposite of family OP is describing! I would love to trust mine to do just that but it seems he isn't capable due to additional needs.

AutumnLeafDance · 01/08/2021 07:51

I think as a parent you should model the sort of behaviour you want to see from your child later on. I certainly wouldn't want my child glued to their phone, refusing to engage in conversation with me (or anyone else for that matter) at the dinner table in the future, so I'm very mindful of my own phone usage in front of them now. These parents will just have to reap what they sow later on - and maybe they couldn't care less because they'll still be glued to their own phones?

newnortherner111 · 01/08/2021 07:45

People engaged in their phones instead of doing something else such as having a conversation is not just confined to those out with young children.

I remember a cafe on the Isle of Skye that was proud to note that they did not have wifi, so as to encourage conversation and admiring the beautiful view.

IHateFlies · 01/08/2021 07:45

@Chouxchou be honest. Do you you think those kind of parents would spend 2 hours ignoring their child?
I think the op picked up on exactly what was going on.

Chouxchou · 01/08/2021 07:41

You don’t know their whole life. They could have spent several hours taking them places and playing with them and just needed a break. At the moment almost every children’s activity needs to be booked online in advance so I spend a lot of time doing that.

Onlinedilema · 01/08/2021 07:38

I agree with Ihateflies

IHateFlies · 01/08/2021 07:37

I knew you’d get a hard time on this op. A couple of hours and the child has nothing to do does sound rubbish. This is totally different to soft play or the park where the children are playing and having fun or in a cafe where the mum is occasionally look up but doing something on the phone while everyone is having a break.

The truth is, there are so many parents addicted to their phones and there are many parents who ignore their kids. They exist and it’s far from ideal.

StrangeToSee · 01/08/2021 07:16

I saw one today with their phone fixed to the pushchair handle playing a cartoon for the baby

You would have judged me then 😂 I used to let my toddler have a rubber-coated tablet to play sorting games on when I had to navigate. So I’d be pushing the buggy with one hand to follow google maps on my phone with the other, and toddler had a tablet!

StrangeToSee · 01/08/2021 07:08

I was last year on the train back home, 2 hours journey. 4 seats facing. A mum was there with her boy who looked about 5, whose was on his first train journey. For more than 1/2 hour, he kept saying 'mum, mum, mum, look there's a horse, look mum, there's a tractor, mum, where do you think the other train is going. Mum, why did we stop'. He was adorable, so excited, so engrossed

How do you know it was his first journey?

It sounds far from adorable to me. It sounds annoying and if he were my 5 year old I’d be shushing him and encouraging him to think in his head not aloud (because it’s annoying for most people around you to hear a running commentary about what he can see, he’s 5 not 2). And many people use train journeys to work. I take my kids on the train a lot, as babies and toddlers I interacted with them but at 5 I’d expect some peace and quiet, no raised voices etc.

The parents in the cafe may have been trying to work or reply to their boss or sort out important admin or doctors appointments. Before you turned up they may have been having a chat with their son then reminded him not to interrupt them for a bit as they had important work to do. If he kept trying to get their attention why would they keep making eye contact and giving it to him? Some kids get more persistent if you look at them. They need to understand parents can be physically present but not constantly available for interaction.

When we go out my DD (5) has her own backpack that she stuffs full of toys, books, colouring stuff. Because she knows there might be an hour of 2 when she has to entertain herself eg if we’re having lunch with friends or catching up on work. (To be fair I gave her the backpack as I got fed up of my handbag being crammed with dinosaurs, dolls and crayons!) For all you know they could have told him to bring some toys and he refused or threw a strop about having to carry his backpack.

I remember going to my mum’s keep fit classes age 4-5. I had to sit for an hour very quietly without disturbing her, as did any other kids who came. I always took my colouring. Often I was the only child there.

At 5 most kids are in school (with 2 adults to 30 kids) and don’t need constant attention.

For all you know the boy had been acting up all day and ignoring him was a strategy to de-escalate him. Unless you stared at them unblinkingly for 2 hours it’s impossible to know if they made eye contact or spoke to him at any point.

I get your point about it’s sad when kids are ignored for hours because the parents are on social media all day. But what you saw was a tiny snapshot of their day.

Perhaps they thought a cafe might be more entertaining for him than being stuck at home?

Oceanbliss · 31/07/2021 23:06

@gingganggooleywotsit Another way to look at it is the parents may have been using a behaviour guidance strategy where you ignore misbehaviour and reward good behaviour. I have heard both parents and teachers claiming that it is very effective.

I’ve tried it but I’m not very good at it.

Queenie6655 · 31/07/2021 22:54

You never ever know

I would have had moments of sitting staring at my phone when I fled DV with a young daughter

Emailing people
DV advisors , MET police for the investigation etc

So someone looking in may think wow there's a shit parent

Really I was trying my best to get by and sort things out

Swipe left for the next trending thread