Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that parents who stare at their phone and completely blank their children are a bit shit really.

264 replies

gingganggooleywotsit · 31/07/2021 12:14

Ok I am being judgey and I know I’m only seeing a snapshot of someone’s life but it’s really upsetting me. I’ve been sitting in a coffee shop for a couple of hours doing a bit of work and there is a couple there with a 5 year old boy and they are literally glued to their phones. He’s having to hit them round the head practically to get them to look at him. He has nothing to play with keeps nearly running in the traffic and they will not look up from their phones. Little boy looks really upset. Yeah they might be working too I’ve been there wiith my kids but give the boy something to do or at least make eye contact occasionally! It’s like he’s invisible. 😞

OP posts:
FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 16:00

@vivainsomnia as someone pointed out earlier maybe those parents are Trying the tactic of kg print pestering/bad behaviour.

I mean does it really impact you so much?

LindaEllen · 01/08/2021 15:56

I agree. My friend's wife is on her phone ALL the time (to the point he thinks it's an addiction) and her daughter is currently in counselling and it's come up that she thinks her mum loves her phone more than her.

I used to be quite close to her and go out for lunch etc but she would just get her phone out and ignore me, so I don't go out with her anymore.

feelingmehtoday · 01/08/2021 15:55

Does anyone really think the OP was watching this family's every move and interaction for hours? I mean, for a start, she said she was sitting "doing a bit of work". She can't have been working that hard if she was able to study these parents and their behaviour solidly for hours... not to mention the sheer oddness of doing that. Confused

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 15:51

Balls, it's the summer holidays. I've got three under six and im doing it alone. If I find a chance to sit and zone out for a few minutes I will and I'll enjoy it
There is a big difference between a few minutes and a couple of hours as per the OP!

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 15:49

Of course I know these sad situations exist. But I come back to my point - you can't possibly infer any of that from a brief snapshot of a parent's day. So I'd err on the side of minding my own business and assume most parents are just doing their best with the resources they've got at any given moment, rather than making assumptions such as these
I think you can infer. I think there are signs that makes interaction from these mums very different to the mums who indeed had a bad day, need a bit of time for themselves. I do agree that you can't be sure, we can never be sure of anything anywhere, and indeed, that's why, as already said, I would never say anything or challenge. But yes, I do think that there is a good chance in some specific instances that the mum in question might very well be one of those mums who just doesn't engage much with her children on a daily basis.

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 15:45

They’d say ‘I need to work for a bit now’ or ‘I’ve got a headache let’s talk about this later’
But again, we are not talking about these parents, those who DO communicate with their kids, if it is to say that they can't/don't want to at this moment. We are talking about parents who ignore the kids. Who don't even say the above, who don't say to their kids they can talk later, but those parents who just seem totally oblivious for a long time of their kids' presence.

feelingmehtoday · 01/08/2021 15:26

@iamtheoneandonlyyy

Balls, it's the summer holidays. I've got three under six and im doing it alone. If I find a chance to sit and zone out for a few minutes I will and I'll enjoy it. I hope the woman in the post enjoyed it

3 under 6 by yourself. You're a hero! Sending wine .... Wine😂

iamtheoneandonlyyy · 01/08/2021 15:02

Balls, it's the summer holidays. I've got three under six and im doing it alone. If I find a chance to sit and zone out for a few minutes I will and I'll enjoy it.
I hope the woman in the post enjoyed it

Echobelly · 01/08/2021 14:59

I have no problem with people being on them at the park while their kid is entertaining themselves nearby; being at the park is pretty boring, a parent may be there day in day out, and we wouldn't judge (I imagine) one reading a book instead.

I think it's poor form generally to be on your phone for any length of time when you're with someone else in a restaurant, be that a child or an adult, although for somewhere informal like a cafe I would cut slack for, say, an adult with a small child who might just need a change of scene and be tired out!

feelingmehtoday · 01/08/2021 14:46

@vivainsomnia

I'm just being an average mum and doing what is required to parent my child. I think the point is that it reflects a reality for many parents as opposed to intending to convey that you've gone above and beyond and been perfect It reflects the reality for the majority of mums who are good mums. Can't you see that sadly, some kids don't have the chance to have a mum who does all those things with them? That some mums never play with their kids? That some mums rarely engage in conversation with their kids but to give them orders?

That some mums don't even know how to do these things because their mum never did with them.

Of course I know these sad situations exist. But I come back to my point - you can't possibly infer any of that from a brief snapshot of a parent's day. So I'd err on the side of minding my own business and assume most parents are just doing their best with the resources they've got at any given moment, rather than making assumptions such as these.

00100001 · 01/08/2021 12:32

@OhGiveUp

It just makes me wonder what they would have done back in the days before mobiles and internet. Why take your child to a cafe or a restaurant etc if you're not going to spend that time with them. How are you going to teach them social manners if you're glued to your phone? You can do your online shop and bookings when at home and they're in bed or watching TV. Sad that many parents prefer their phone over their children. Not a popular view I know, but there we go.
Didn't go out as much. There wasn't the coffee shop culture.

But, otherwise, the same as now, tell them to be quiet/sit down - the adults are talking.
give them something to occupy themselves with.
Let them run wild etc.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 12:32

We've all been there indeed, but in this instance, this usually result in a 'darling, I've spent the last 3 hours talking to you about dinosaurs, mum is tired now and need a bit of peace and quiet, can you just look at the window, around you, talk in your head.... etc.... rather than blankly ignoring them or telling them to shut up.

Lol because this always works 😂
And while you think this is a good tactic another person might say it's shutting them down and stifling their creativity and expression 🤷‍♀️

Bottom line - mind your own business, you do you and don't worry about what other people are doing

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 12:29

For a start, it's a bit concerning that you would making such safeguarding calls in a public area!

I didn't, this is all being done electronically.

Yes, but he does use the word 'demonstrably' which changes everything

Exactly! And an opinion that someone is 'shitty' based on a blind assumption that they must be browsing Facebook rather than doing something important is demonstrably stupid

eightyfourandahalf · 01/08/2021 12:24

@OhGiveUp

It just makes me wonder what they would have done back in the days before mobiles and internet. Why take your child to a cafe or a restaurant etc if you're not going to spend that time with them. How are you going to teach them social manners if you're glued to your phone? You can do your online shop and bookings when at home and they're in bed or watching TV. Sad that many parents prefer their phone over their children. Not a popular view I know, but there we go.
well, we wouldn't have taken them on holiday and days out in the first place because we would have been restricted to the office 🤷
StrangeToSee · 01/08/2021 12:21

And to learn to think, they need stimulation

Yes. But not constant stimulation all day long. A 5 year old will have to think at school without talking all the time. A train journey is stimulating enough, they don’t need to share every discovery with their parent.

As long as they get plenty of interaction with parents at other times, there’s nothing wrong with expecting them to be quiet for a couple of hours.

And people do work on trains, in libraries and cafes. Including parents.

OhGiveUp · 01/08/2021 12:18

It just makes me wonder what they would have done back in the days before mobiles and internet.
Why take your child to a cafe or a restaurant etc if you're not going to spend that time with them. How are you going to teach them social manners if you're glued to your phone?
You can do your online shop and bookings when at home and they're in bed or watching TV.
Sad that many parents prefer their phone over their children.
Not a popular view I know, but there we go.

StrangeToSee · 01/08/2021 12:13

Do you have an issue with adults having a quiet conversation too? There is nothing wrong with a conversation between an adult and a 5 year old when the adult teach the child to do so in a quieter voice. It doesn't have to be for the full journey either

Of course there’s nothing wrong with it if the parent (or two adults) want to have a quiet conversation. But if one adult is busy working, or wants some quiet, you wouldn’t carry on demanding their attention would you? They’d say ‘I need to work for a bit now’ or ‘I’ve got a headache let’s talk about this later’.

If my child is quietly engaged in colouring or reading I wouldn’t keep disrupting her or demanding she look at things I find interesting. Or keep up a running commentary to interrupt her focus eg ‘what a lovely day, what pretty clouds, look how the sun gleams on that lake. Oh DD did you see that horse in the field? Look did you see the swan? Oh we’re going into a tunnel how exciting, look DD, look!’

Children above toddler age need to learn when chattering at a parent is appropriate and when it’s disruptive. They wouldn’t interrupt their teacher constantly so why should their parent respond to their every word?

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 12:11

How do you or OP know whether something like this was or wasn't said to the child?
The examples I'm thinking of is places like doctors waiting rooms, trains and train stations, buses, airports, places where everyone sit and wait and you get plenty of time to observe from the time the family comes in the vicinity.

I don't automatically make an assumption because indeed, you never 100% know and I would certainly never say anything, but there are certain characteristics you notice, and yes, I have felt quite sorry for the children who seem to get so little attention and their behaviour seem to reflect it.

Children need to learn to think rather than express a stream of consciousness verbally And to learn to think, they need stimulation.

A train, library and cafe are not places to work, indeed, libraries have places that encourage interactions and places to work quietly. Once again, it's not about kids being able to be loud and the centre of attention, it's kids needing interaction to learn.

PollyPaintsFlowers · 01/08/2021 12:08

YABU I'm disabled and suffer hugely from fatigue every moment of every day. I stare at my phone as it stops me falling asleep so I CAN take my children out of the house

Don't judge, not every disability is visible

Nc123 · 01/08/2021 12:07

Like others have said. It’s a snapshot.

Also, maybe that’s their break. It’s significantly easier to be a great parent if you have a big active support network and family nearby who give you regular breaks. If you don’t have any other opportunity to rest, zonking out on your phone for a bit isn’t the worst way to get one.

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 12:02

I'm just being an average mum and doing what is required to parent my child. I think the point is that it reflects a reality for many parents as opposed to intending to convey that you've gone above and beyond and been perfect
It reflects the reality for the majority of mums who are good mums. Can't you see that sadly, some kids don't have the chance to have a mum who does all those things with them? That some mums never play with their kids? That some mums rarely engage in conversation with their kids but to give them orders?

That some mums don't even know how to do these things because their mum never did with them.

StrangeToSee · 01/08/2021 11:59

Wow this country hates children so much. We have all the time in the world to be boring adults. To suppress a 5 year old child's curiosity, joy and wonder at the world, and desire to share it with you, for your own peace and quiet is just depressing

Far from it. Nobody is suppressing the 5 year old’s curiosity, joy and wonder about the world. Just encouraging her to experience these things in her head without a running commentary or expecting the parent to keep validating that she’s seen a cow out of the window.

Children need to learn to think rather than express a stream of consciousness verbally. This is vital to learning and social interactions, classroom behaviour. There are places and times parents share that joy and wonder with them. A train, library, cafe or other ‘quiet’ place where people are working isn’t an appropriate place for a 5 year old to think out loud all the time or demand attention from adults.

iklboo · 01/08/2021 11:53

My god people can everyone please stop using the word 'judge' the whole time as though it's a brand knew word and concept.! It's such a ridiculous Americanisation of our language.

It's in the fecking BIBLE.

AnxiousWeirdo · 01/08/2021 11:43

I wouldn't do it in a cafe or such like but at the park etc then yes, you'll see me zoning out for a while on my phone. What you don't see is the constant attention and running around after my daughter all day, every day, 6:30-8:30 and sometimes beyond, plus all the other mentally taxing crap I have to do on a day. I'm entitled to a mental break for half an hour. If you want to judge me as a bad mother for that snippet of a day you're seeing then judge away tbh.

feelingmehtoday · 01/08/2021 11:40

@vivainsomnia

For all you know they’ve taken them out for the day and answered their 100000 questions about dinosaurs and space and poo and now they’re completely exhausted so just want to sit on their phone for a bit We've all been there indeed, but in this instance, this usually result in a 'darling, I've spent the last 3 hours talking to you about dinosaurs, mum is tired now and need a bit of peace and quiet, can you just look at the window, around you, talk in your head.... etc.... rather than blankly ignoring them or telling them to shut up.

How do you or OP know whether something like this was or wasn't said to the child? Unless she was staring at them intently for the entire time and watching every little interaction (or lack thereof allegedly) - which let's face it would make OP a little bit odd - how on earth does she know what was or wasn't said? That's the whole point, isn't it. You don't know. Hence why I like to refrain from judgement in these situations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread