Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that parents who stare at their phone and completely blank their children are a bit shit really.

264 replies

gingganggooleywotsit · 31/07/2021 12:14

Ok I am being judgey and I know I’m only seeing a snapshot of someone’s life but it’s really upsetting me. I’ve been sitting in a coffee shop for a couple of hours doing a bit of work and there is a couple there with a 5 year old boy and they are literally glued to their phones. He’s having to hit them round the head practically to get them to look at him. He has nothing to play with keeps nearly running in the traffic and they will not look up from their phones. Little boy looks really upset. Yeah they might be working too I’ve been there wiith my kids but give the boy something to do or at least make eye contact occasionally! It’s like he’s invisible. 😞

OP posts:
eightyfourandahalf · 02/08/2021 12:13

It's MN bingo as usual on this thread,

either you are a helicopter parent suffocating your kids with performance parenting,

or you are a neglectful selfish lazy parent,

Thankfully in the real world, most parents manage to find a healthy middle ground. Telling the judgemental interfering busy bodies to fuck off is allowed.

Spanielstail · 02/08/2021 12:09

No absolutely not interfering but just watching them from a distance so they know you are interested. It's much more subconscious that you all took it.

Oceanbliss · 02/08/2021 12:06

@00100001 Grin

Oceanbliss · 02/08/2021 12:03

@Spanielstail Finally I think it's really sad that people are not watching their child lay at the park and interacting with them. Yes you may be tired but you are showing your child you are not interested.

Really? Maybe you should read a bit about how helicopter parenting is interfering with children’s development and learning.

Children not being able to play at the playground with their peers without an adult taking over or directing their play is sad. Are children only allowed to have that freedom in the school playground on their lunch break?

I’m so glad that I grew up in an era where parents weren’t pressured to hover over their kids and engage in performance parenting.

We got to have real and genuine relationships with our parents without judgmental busybodies trying to dictate how we should interact. So sad for kids today growing up in a society of bullies.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 02/08/2021 11:52

@00100001 🤣🤣🤣

If I did try and doing Perfect Mummy Interaction withmy 9yo in the park, she would likely do the whole "mum, could you PLEASE stop embarrassing me" chat which seems to becoming more and more common these days BlushGrinGrin

When do these Perfect Parents stop the 100% focussed interacting? When their kids are 13? 18? 30?

00100001 · 02/08/2021 11:45

[quote FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop]@Spanielstail my kids are 5 and 9, I take them to the park often and we often stay for 4/5 hours. Am I supposed to be staring and grinning at them for those 5 hours? Or getting involved in their playtime? They'd absolutely hate that! I mostly go on my phone and read my book and check regularly that they haven't broken their necks. I'm sure it's all very distressing for them 😂 OR they will see me relaxing enjoying myself and realise how important that is too[/quote]
You, of COURSE should be going "wow where, what a big jump!" And "Ooh, look a ship, shall we pretend to be pirates?" And lead a pirate raid to the climbing frame

Otherwise...do you even love your kids?

00100001 · 02/08/2021 11:43

@Spanielstail

Look up the "still face" experiment and you can then see what not looking at your child when they want your attention does to them.

It's different you working at home and them being off playing but them sitting bored in a coffee shop whilst you are on your phone teaches poor social skills.

Also the number of people that are surprised their child "misbehaves" when ignored is unbelievable.

Finally I think it's really sad that people are not watching their child lay at the park and interacting with them. Yes you may be tired but you are showing your child you are not interested.

Err.... with regards to the last paragraph...No you're encouraging independent play. It's not absolutely essential that you interact with them in every single activity.

They shouldn't be playing because you're interested. They should be playing because they want to play. There's absolutely no need to be interacting with them every single moment of the day.

How often do you take your kids to the park? We used to go pretty much every day, sometimes twice....some days we spent all day "parking". We'd go to three or four different ones in a day.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 02/08/2021 10:57

@Spanielstail my kids are 5 and 9, I take them to the park often and we often stay for 4/5 hours. Am I supposed to be staring and grinning at them for those 5 hours? Or getting involved in their playtime? They'd absolutely hate that! I mostly go on my phone and read my book and check regularly that they haven't broken their necks. I'm sure it's all very distressing for them 😂 OR they will see me relaxing enjoying myself and realise how important that is too

Spanielstail · 02/08/2021 10:37

Look up the "still face" experiment and you can then see what not looking at your child when they want your attention does to them.

It's different you working at home and them being off playing but them sitting bored in a coffee shop whilst you are on your phone teaches poor social skills.

Also the number of people that are surprised their child "misbehaves" when ignored is unbelievable.

Finally I think it's really sad that people are not watching their child lay at the park and interacting with them. Yes you may be tired but you are showing your child you are not interested.

Oceanbliss · 02/08/2021 00:24

For those posters who think that it’s okay to judge parents as shitty parents over a tiny snapshot of their day, have you considered that you might be hurting that child when you look at their parents with contempt or shake your head in disapproval or scowl at them or stare at them?

There have been times where my child has noticed people judging me harshly, judging other parents harshly, tut tutting and making their disapproval blatantly obvious to everyone around them. It upsets my dd. She loves me and I love her. She has told me that those people must be bad people.

This parent shaming, attacking parents, undermining them and writing them off as shitty is distressing and damaging to the children. And I really can’t abide by it.

There is a real cultural shift towards parent shaming that is really not about helping or protecting children at all because it achieves the complete opposite.

feelingmehtoday · 01/08/2021 21:43

@EmmaOvary

Things were much better in the Seventies when nobody judged your parenting because they couldn't see your kids sitting in the back seat of the car in the pub car park with a can of pop and some crisps while you were drinking in the pub.

Oh, the good old days...

😂
EmmaOvary · 01/08/2021 21:34

Things were much better in the Seventies when nobody judged your parenting because they couldn't see your kids sitting in the back seat of the car in the pub car park with a can of pop and some crisps while you were drinking in the pub.

Oh, the good old days...

thepeopleversuswork · 01/08/2021 19:35

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4311699-to-think-that-middle-class-parents-get-away-with-murder

This one.

I do think there's a big class element to the modern day neurosis about going on your phone. Similar to the way previous generations over-reacted to their kids watching TV and going way back hand-wringing about young women reading too many novels.

Of course its addictive and done too much is antisocial but intrinsically its no different from anything else that people do which takes their focus. But because its ubiquitous its seen as an unacceptable form of distraction.

enoughforme · 01/08/2021 19:06

There's a thread running here atm about how working class families are far more likely to have run-ins with social services for behaviour which would be tolerated in middle class ones.

Agree with this, it plays out in the media frequently.

Take Madeline McCain for instance - her parents got hardly any stick purely because they were doctors.

Had it have been a working class factory worker and cleaner, they'd have never loved it down.

Disgusting how money/class can change peoples judgement of one another

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 18:38

@thepeopleversuswork could you link me to that thread please? I work in a private school and I think that's absolutely true

AnotherMarvellousThing · 01/08/2021 17:49

Good post, @thepeopleversuswork.

thepeopleversuswork · 01/08/2021 17:40

I do think there's a lot of thinly veiled snobbery at work here. You wouldn't judge someone who was ignoring their child because they were reading a book or a newspaper. But because its a phone it seems to trigger a sharp intake of judgy breath and its not terribly rational.

Clearly totally ignoring your children when they need your attention isn't good. And phone addiction is a thing. But there's some additional level of judgement at play when its a phone which isn't there in other settings. If we really unpick this I can't believe that being distracted by a phone is any worse than being distracted by anything else.

Also a phone is just a medium: the person in question could be reading Fermat's Last Theorem or putting together a Gantt chart. Or playing a very difficult game of chess. People are very quick to assume its snapchat.

There's a thread running here atm about how working class families are far more likely to have run-ins with social services for behaviour which would be tolerated in middle class ones. I think there's a fairly heavy degree of this going on here: scrolling phone while with child attracts a degree of opprobrium that reading the Guardian with child wouldn't.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 17:23

@BastardMonkfish same here, 80s/90s childhood and 1 of 4. We weren't allowed in the kitchen after 4pm (fuck knows why) on Formula One days my parents literally locked themselves in the living room and we were not to be disturbed unless, and I quote, "we were on fire or actually dead" Grin kicked out every sunny day of the summer holidays so mum could get a break. The butthurt of this thread would be horrified!

I also agree things are too child centered these days. Our local farm park offer a free admissions to mums on Mother's Day/dads on Fathers Day. I thought what a shit day out isn't it meant to be about the parents not the kids?!

BastardMonkfish · 01/08/2021 17:13

Oh god really? My parents certainly weren't at my beck and call all day every day when I was a child. For most of my childhood I wasn't even in the house let alone getting their undivided attention. They certainly didn't spend their time gazing at me and waiting for my scintillating conversation when I was 5.

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 16:55

I think the trend for everything to be so goddamn child focused these days is ridiculous
I definitely think the two extremes exist. Both are not doing the children any favours.

vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 16:54

I mean does it really impact you so much?
Of course not, wasn't thinking about it at all since I saw this behaviour, last time probably being before covid! Only sharing my opinion on this thread like everyone else.

Ultimately, whether I've witnessed this behaviour or not, we know it does exist and it is very sad for the children affected.

opalescent · 01/08/2021 16:34

Whilst I do think the dependance that most of us have on our phones these days...(myself included) is negative...

I think the trend for everything to be so goddamn child focused these days is ridiculous. Children literally rule most households. Most of is are trying so hard to keep all the balls in the air and plates spinning. Parenting (especially in the holidays) is fucking graft. The little boy will not be harmed by spending a couple of hours trying to get some attention. For all you know they had just come from the park. He will be fine 🙄

iamtheoneandonlyyy · 01/08/2021 16:25

@feelingmehtoday many thanks, much neededGrin

feelingmehtoday · 01/08/2021 16:14

No, I think she's exaggerating by about 90 minutes

Grin I did think similar...

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 01/08/2021 16:02

@feelingmehtoday

Does anyone really think the OP was watching this family's every move and interaction for hours? I mean, for a start, she said she was sitting "doing a bit of work". She can't have been working that hard if she was able to study these parents and their behaviour solidly for hours... not to mention the sheer oddness of doing that. Confused
No, I think she's exaggerating by about 90 minutes
Swipe left for the next trending thread