Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog outside all night

59 replies

Generalpost · 31/07/2021 11:23

I have a German Shephard. And she stays/sleeps in the back garden all night I have a dog flap that is left open all night so she can come in and out of she wants to . I'm guessing this ok but I feel like I'm allowing a small child to stay out in the dark all night Confused

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhatAShilohPitt · 31/07/2021 22:38

I think that the main thing is that she has a choice. My dogs would scrape at the door or whine to get in and yours seems totally content to be outside. The police force have lots of working alsatians and their handlers have them outdoors overnight in kennels - yours just doesn’t seem to want one! So if she’s happy, no problems!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 31/07/2021 19:59

We had larger dogs, including Bernese. There was no way they would sleep in a bed with us😂
They did try sometimes to fot on a chair with us😂 They were lovely. Such a nice characters

Candyapple49 · 31/07/2021 19:57

My jack Russell was born in a barn as the pup of a working dog and did not go into a house I brought her home . Her parents seemed as happy and healthy as can be . However , my dog pulls me back to the house if we are in a walk and there is a single drop of rain and she doesn’t like wind either so I guess all dogs are different . Mine chooses to spend the night in my double bed - I like to think to protect me !

CHISistoast · 31/07/2021 19:47

She's probably just cooler outside. She's a GHD, big strong girl and if she's happy, it's fine!

XelaM · 31/07/2021 18:10

@TiredSloth "This makes me so sad. So in the pouring rain or freezing winter the dog isn’t allowed in the house? That’s awful. Why have a dog if it isn’t going to be a part of the family?"

I completely agree with you and have always felt very sorry for the dog, but he has shelter outside and is walked regularly and appears fine, so what do I know.

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 14:56

Would you have a member of your family sleep in the garden? Your dog is part of your family

The dog is a dog. It is not human and is only 'part of the family' because we now anthropomorphise dogs. Much to their detriment often.

icedcoffees · 31/07/2021 14:54

If he's happy and not making a nuisance, I don't see a problem with it.

Mrsjayy · 31/07/2021 14:41

12:34CaffeineAndNicotine

Outs loves being outside at night. He wont come in. Sometimes we have to try and roll him in

This is what we had to do with ours he then dug himself a den at the back of the shed and we had to brush him out Confused he was a bugger but miss him

JayAlfredPrufrock · 31/07/2021 14:19

I think it’s lovely that he’s protecting you.

My useless Spaniel gets the arse if I stay up too late. He likes me to be in bed. With him.

FizzyTango · 31/07/2021 14:12

I have a long haired German shepherd. I’m certain he would sleep outside all night if I let him. I just worry about leaving him out there so I bring him in. He’s two and I’ve only just started letting him sleep outside during the day as long as I can keep an eye on him. But I can tell he loves sleeping outside or just sniffing the air and guarding! It must be a GSD thing!

RandomMess · 31/07/2021 13:31

You need a princess dog like mine 😂 she only ventures into the garden when it's over 20 degrees, dry and glorious sunshine!!!

It's barely tolerated at toilet time and refused when raining 🙄

Flipflopfoodle · 31/07/2021 13:30

We used to have a dog door and 3 dogs. One always slept outside unless it was raining very badly, slight drizzle didn't bother him. The other two slept in front of the Aga, belly up, balls in the air. It's just what each one preferred.

Generalpost · 31/07/2021 13:27

@JaniieJones

Seems odd to me. If it was crated or in a kennels in the garden fine but to have it roaming about in and out would be irritating, dogs really do need a bit of supervision. Doesn't it bark and don't the neighbours mind?

Plus don't be deluded about 'who would try to get past an alsation', surely any sensible intruder would just take a massive bone or steak to keep a dog occupied while they wriggle through the mahoosive and extremely convenient 'dog flap'.

I think its very unlikely that someone would walk about with a lump of meat . They would have to climb several fences to get to my garden . Then choose the one with the big dog In it. They would not get to the dog flap in the first place. Neighbours have never said a word about it . The garden is secure .
OP posts:
Nutsabouttopic · 31/07/2021 13:23

Our retriever sleeps outside it's his choice. He has a kennel with carpet and duvets in it but he prefers lying in the barn and the cats and one of our chickens sleep in the kennel. When we try to get him to sleep inside he will whimper until he is let out. The vet told us that he considers himself on duty at night and is guarding us all. We live in the country. He will happily sleep in his bed in the kitchen during the day

BeeDavis · 31/07/2021 13:12

@ohthatbloodycat

This doesn't apply to you OP, but I don't see why someone would get a dog as a family pet, only to not allow it to live indoors Confused
I don’t understand why people are so ignorant about this subject. I had 2 dogs that chose to live outside. They had a kennel that was full of straw in winter and carpet in the summer. One of them had been born outside and it’s just what he preferred and the other wanted to be with them as they were inseparable. They hated being inside, as soon as they heard the central heating come on they’d want to be outside. Just because they were outside did not mean they were any less part of the family, they were bloody spoilt probably more than some dogs that are just left inside all day. We lost them both in 2018 12 weeks apart aged 12 and 14 and honestly it was the most devastating thing to happen.
WaltzingToWalsingham · 31/07/2021 12:40

I think this is just the nature of the pastoral breeds...your dog is trying to guard its herd (your family!) and feels better able to do so outside. They are bred to spend a lot of time outdoors and cope with the elements. I think your dog will be fine and quite content outside, but I would suggest a kennel. Although she can go into the house for shelter, it sounds like her desire to guard is so strong that she would not leave her post at night, so an outside kennel would allow her to do her job and keep dry if the weather is bad.

RandomMess · 31/07/2021 12:37

Friends GS absolutely loved the rain and would not come inside if it rained 🤷🏽‍♀️

CaffeineAndNicotine · 31/07/2021 12:34

Outs loves being outside at night. He wont come in. Sometimes we have to try and roll him in Grin

Thecathouse · 31/07/2021 12:33

@JaniieJones

Seems odd to me. If it was crated or in a kennels in the garden fine but to have it roaming about in and out would be irritating, dogs really do need a bit of supervision. Doesn't it bark and don't the neighbours mind?

Plus don't be deluded about 'who would try to get past an alsation', surely any sensible intruder would just take a massive bone or steak to keep a dog occupied while they wriggle through the mahoosive and extremely convenient 'dog flap'.

Still a stupid thing to do, my german shepherd doesn't care what gifts you bring, if he doesn't know you he won't take it and definitely doesn't want you in his garden. The resulting barking would wake up anyone in a 3 mile radius

A lot of dogs of this breed are not food focused, we couldn't use food during training because he literally didn't give a rats arse what you were offering, what he wants is me to tell him he has done a good job and give him an ear scratch, german shepherds are all about their family and praise from them as a general rule

Neverrains · 31/07/2021 12:29

If he’s happy, can get inside if he wants to and doesn’t bother the neighbours then there’s no issue.

SueSaid · 31/07/2021 12:26

Seems odd to me. If it was crated or in a kennels in the garden fine but to have it roaming about in and out would be irritating, dogs really do need a bit of supervision. Doesn't it bark and don't the neighbours mind?

Plus don't be deluded about 'who would try to get past an alsation', surely any sensible intruder would just take a massive bone or steak to keep a dog occupied while they wriggle through the mahoosive and extremely convenient 'dog flap'.

Planty13 · 31/07/2021 12:23

I’d only worry about theft

LakieLady · 31/07/2021 12:21

SIL's labrador would sleep outside most of the year if she was allowed to.

She prefers lying on the patio to lying on her bed or on nice soft carpet, the daft animal.

AlCalavicci · 31/07/2021 12:19

It would seem a bit odd to me but then my x Shepard hated the rain .

I would get yours a big enough kennel* for her to stand up and stretch in with a raised floor , or rest it on some pallets and some old towels / blanket .

  • It may be worth looking at a small shed instead and adapting that , they usually work out cheaper and bigger.

But if she is happy out there and can come in if she wants then I dont see the issue , as pp said I would have her in before I go to bed and then she can go out if she wants or come to bed with you

SchrodingersImmigrant · 31/07/2021 12:16

@MotionActivatedDog

Well how often does uk go to these temperatures.... I said from the beginning "with a shelter". Of course we provided heat when temps could go down to minus 20 there... That's not needed here though

I’m sure we’re getting crossed wires here. You say they’re fine with a shelter, which proves my point that they’re not fine just being outside which is what a PP claimed.

I take outside as not in a house, so yeah probably crossed wires