Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use this name

59 replies

gerbilfur · 31/07/2021 09:56

Genuinely willing to be told if I'm being u.

Nc as outing.

I have a best friend, for the last 30 years. She has 2 ds and is pregnant with her 3rd ds. He will be her final dc. I have 1 ds.

There is a girls name she's always really liked, she said she'd use it if she ever had a dd. It also happened to be the favourite name of my late grandmother, who was pretty much my best friend.

I'm getting a puppy soon, and it's a girl. I want to use the name for the pup, however my friend I'd really hurt that I took her dd name. I said I thought it would be OK as she will not be having a dd.

Am I being insensitive? Should I change puppy name? I honestly only wanted to use it as name reminds me so much of my nan but my friend is more important and I don't want to hurt her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 19:57

Ahhhh. You're the poster that thinks fine because it's the same as someone who rode your horse then calling their child the same thing.

It's about respecting the feelings of a mother coming to terms with a child they will never have. A completely different scenario.

TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 19:55

Even with the child free poster who said that her sister would likely be honoured if she used the name for her dog

I'm not sure where you've got your wires crossed but I said categorically it would be different if a sister had a child and used the name as a middle name as a respectful tribute within their family in honour of a child that was very wanted, but wasn't to be. But absolutely not for a friend to deliberately name a puppy!

LimeRedBanana · 31/07/2021 19:44

Just a reminder that this is a puppy we’re talking about. A puppy’s name. A puppy who could be called literally anything else in the world. I mean, puppies aren’t even limited to human names. The choice actually is endless.

The day a puppy’s name becomes more important than a good friend’s feelings is the day you become a bit of an arsehole. Even if you think the friend is being a bit silly. If you prioritise a puppy’s name over the good friend’s feelings, there is no avoiding the ‘arsehole’ label.

The reason for this is quite simple: most people like their friends, and so, act accordingly.

NormanStangerson · 31/07/2021 15:31

The more I think about OPs scenario, the more insulted I'd be

Yes we can tell. You keep posting about it.

Even with the child free poster who said that her sister would likely be honoured if she used the name for her dog, you somehow agreed with that too.

TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 14:25

I think my sister would take it more that we were honouring her choice of names were we to do this, but it's slightly different when it's 'in the family' - i.e. a way of remembering/ keeping a name alive in the family - rather than a friend.

I very much agree with this. DD has a middle name that is her grandmother's. It was definitely in tribute to her. Plus, this is another child. Within our family. Calling your son, "Henry Jack Smith" would be a nice, and poignant, recognition, perhaps even Jack as a first name if your sister saw it as a positive tribute and not a painful reminder.

That's completely different from your sister's best friend buying a dog and calling it Jack, because her Nan had said she liked the name.

The more I think about OPs scenario, the more insulted I'd be. My best friend of 30 years, saying, "I know there's no chance of you having your son, Jack, now... guess what I'm calling my dog"

Nengineer · 31/07/2021 14:23

I have a kitten called Jessica after my sister! I don't see her often and live thousands of miles away though.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 31/07/2021 14:13

@TwinsandTrifle

My sister and I are childfree/childless (my sister not by choice) and I know exactly what my sister would have called a girl or a boy if she'd been able to carry a pregnancy to term. I also know what names my mum would have used if we'd been boys.

Good example. So your sister is not childless by choice. You know if she had a much wanted little boy, she'd call him "Jack". But that's not what life has dealt her. And now, she's at the point where she's discovered that "Jack" will never be. You're close, you know what it means to her.

So you pop out, buy a dog and call it Jack

I think my sister would take it more that we were honouring her choice of names were we to do this, but it's slightly different when it's 'in the family' - i.e. a way of remembering/ keeping a name alive in the family - rather than a friend.
TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 14:08

My sister and I are childfree/childless (my sister not by choice) and I know exactly what my sister would have called a girl or a boy if she'd been able to carry a pregnancy to term. I also know what names my mum would have used if we'd been boys.

Good example. So your sister is not childless by choice. You know if she had a much wanted little boy, she'd call him "Jack". But that's not what life has dealt her. And now, she's at the point where she's discovered that "Jack" will never be. You're close, you know what it means to her.

So you pop out, buy a dog and call it Jack

SquirryTheSquirrel · 31/07/2021 13:55

@AmberIsACertainty

I can't imagine a conversation where someone who isn't pregnant goes on about their "favourite name" so much that the name forever after reminds me of them. It's bizarre.
I can - when a name you like comes up - e.g. on a television programme - you might well remark on how much you like it. Or if you hear someone else has named a baby with that name: 'Oh, that's one of my favourite names, if I'd have had a daughter I'd call her that.'

My sister and I are childfree/childless (my sister not by choice) and I know exactly what my sister would have called a girl or a boy if she'd been able to carry a pregnancy to term. I also know what names my mum would have used if we'd been boys.

chunderwunder · 31/07/2021 13:49

I have a girl's name that I use for the daughter I'll never have. I'm obsessed with it. It's the most beautiful name in the world. I think it would be quite sweet if my best mate used it. I don't own it, I'll never use it and it kinda gives it some life.

PrincessNutella · 31/07/2021 13:33

I think you are making the right choice. Yes, we are all individuals and can do what we want in the world. But the name would remind her of something sad every time you said it.

TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 13:27

I can't imagine a conversation where someone who isn't pregnant goes on about their "favourite name" so much that the name forever after reminds me of them. It's bizarre.

Yep.

In contrast to someone who's had a DS (but if it was a girl, he would have been "Jane") then a second DS (who, if it were a girl would have been Jane) then a third DS (who.... would have been Jane) and then states that they can't have any more children, so will never have "Jane." While she will love her 3 boys, I have no doubt that there will have been a part of her that is sad she will now never experience having a daughter. As she appears sensitive over the name her daughter would have been.

So, yeah, naming a dog the same thing, as if equally valid, so she has a constant reminder, is a thoughtless thing to do.

My great aunt had two boys and openly said she wished for a girl as well, but they had to stop at two. My friend has 7 (I know!) boys, and would have loved a daughter in the brood. Another friend has 3 daughters and they are openly trying for another in the hope they get a son, and whatever the child is, it will be their last. You don't love the actual child less, but I completely understand the almost mourning of a child that will never be.

The friend is not weird or insane. It's not just a name. This isn't "her first rabbit was called Poppy and now she doesn't want me to name my gerbil that."

AmberIsACertainty · 31/07/2021 12:40

I can't imagine a conversation where someone who isn't pregnant goes on about their "favourite name" so much that the name forever after reminds me of them. It's bizarre.

Abouttimemum · 31/07/2021 12:29

Your friend is being ridiculous but if you don’t want to upset her you’ll have to indulge her I’m afraid. Madness! I don’t understand all this nonsense about names.

PegasusReturns · 31/07/2021 12:27

The name is also special to the OP. Why oh why can’t she use it?!

She can use it but the consequence will be she upsets her friend and possibly loses a friendship. It doesn’t really matter whether the friends behaviour is bizarre or not it’s the way she feels. OP cannot change that.

TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 11:49

That's not the same at all.

NormanStangerson · 31/07/2021 11:44

Maybe I’m dismissive because I’m rational someone close to me has just named their first baby the same name as my 12-year-old horse, that I bred myself at home. It didn’t even occur to me to think anything of this as if they’re happy, I’m happy. They’ve ridden this horse many times by the way, including while pregnant 😂

Imcatmum · 31/07/2021 11:17

@LimeRedBanana

FGS. Cop onto yourself.

It’s a puppy. Just choose another name? Confused

Or, you know, fall out with your friend, if the name for the dog(??) is so important to you.

P.S. Confused

Totally agree with this. Don't be a twat.
TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 11:17

But surely it’s kinder to act normally in spite of a person’s odd behaviour, rather than enable it?

It's odd that the friend, who is having her 3rd son, won't be having more children, might have liked a DD, and could be sad knowing that she never will now.

The friend doesn’t own the name

Correct.

not only that, she’s not even using the name.

No, she's not. And she's coming to terms that she never will. It's not a flippant, "meh, useless name to me now". As evident from her sensitivity about it.

The name is also special to the OP.

It was her grandmother's favourite name? So loved that she didn't actually use it herself Hmm

Why oh why can’t she use it?!

Because a friend of 30 years, processing that they won't ever have a DD (or DS, if she'd had 3 DD instead), and that specific name knowingly assigned to that child, who they will now never have, trumps a puppy name! I can't believe that even needs to be said.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 31/07/2021 11:16

Her favourite name. That she didn't use herself at any opportunity.

She might not have had the opportunity - if it's a female name and she only had male offspring.

The OP's name would have been chosen by her parents, not a grandparent.

NormanStangerson · 31/07/2021 11:14

Have I missed the name somewhere in the thread? I bet it’s something really usual.

NormanStangerson · 31/07/2021 11:07

[quote PegasusReturns]@NormanStangerson

I cannot understand people taking the side of the insane friend. Use the name. Your friend will get over herself eventually

Are you someone who struggles to maintain friendships and relationships? Because that is an extraordinary statement. Friends support friends even when they are being crazy. Because we all have our moments.[/quote]
Not a bit of it, but surely it’s kinder to act normally in spite of a person’s odd behaviour, rather than enable it? The friend doesn’t own the name, not only that, she’s not even using the name. The name is also special to the OP. Why oh why can’t she use it?! Confused I may have put it bluntly but I stand by it.

TwinsandTrifle · 31/07/2021 11:06

Surely it's more a sensitivity at her not having a dd?

Well, yes.

So absolutely not the right thing to simultaneously buy a puppy and use that one, specific name.

"Because it was my grandmother's favourite name..." Her favourite name. That she didn't use herself at any opportunity.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 31/07/2021 11:03

@LindaEllen

Do it. If your friend does ever have a DD, when she grows up she will love the fact that she shares a name with the dog.
What a totally bizarre suggestion. Is there something in the DNA of girls that means you know that they all love to share their name with someone's dog. Where are you getting that from? Confused

I remember a previous thread on exactly this problem although I can't remember which side of the issue the OP was on

Have you posted this before, does anyone else remember?

PegasusReturns · 31/07/2021 11:03

@NormanStangerson

I cannot understand people taking the side of the insane friend. Use the name. Your friend will get over herself eventually

Are you someone who struggles to maintain friendships and relationships? Because that is an extraordinary statement. Friends support friends even when they are being crazy. Because we all have our moments.