Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you regret moving to a bigger house, or if it was the best decision you made?

63 replies

Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 08:50

My husband and I bought a small house when we were in our mid twenties. We have spent a huge amount of time and money making it into our home. We have a good sized garden, character features and as much space as the two of us need. What we don't have is parking (though on street is available) and at the weekend the local pub can be a bit noisy.

We have been talking about moving to a bigger property, maybe in a big village rather than the small town we live in now. Our house is worth probably around 230ish, a bigger house would be 350.

I'd be interested to hear from others who have faced the same dilemma. Is it worth financial stretch? At the moment we are able to save quite a bit with a good lifestyle so I worry that will go and we might not gain much.

Thank you for reading.

OP posts:
Letsrunabath · 31/07/2021 09:51

We have stayed in our average sized period home since moving 25 years ago and our earnings have tripled. I understand exactly where you are coming from, but being mortgage free in our late 40s and having lots of spare cash for holidays and experiences throughout our lives.
We have guests a lot as we are very sociable have a guest sofa bed in the study. People keep coming back so they must be ok with it.

Wjevtvha · 31/07/2021 09:47

For us it was the best decision but we have DC so chose space over more disposable income. When it was just two of us we preferred a smaller place and the money to go out more

hellcatspangle · 31/07/2021 09:47

It's a tricky one isn't it? We've stayed put for twenty years whilst our peers have all climbed the housing ladder and at times I've felt like a second class citizen visiting their country houses.

We could have afforded to move to something similar to our friends but wanted to A. Have plenty of disposable income to travel and not worry about money, and B. Pay off the mortgage (which we did by age 40)

I still don't know if we made the right decision to be honest - we never have to budget and have a very healthy savings/pension pot, can retire at 55, but I still feel inferior compared to our friends and it stops me from having them round very often as I (stupidly) feel embarrassed by our house. I know it's daft to feel like that as I have other friends with smaller houses and I never look down on them - it's just lovely to be invited somewhere and feel welcome and that's what's important.

I think your decision has to be based on your own lifestyle, and take everything about it into account.

Smallkeys · 31/07/2021 09:45

We moved to a much larger house I love the space but now the DC moved out most of the rooms lay empty and it’s a lot of work to keep clean. Like other people said everything else is more expensive bills and maintenance. I think we will down size at some point.

Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:38

Thanks so much everyone, some really good points. I hadn't really considered the knock on of more fuel, council tax, cleaning etc.

Tokyo, that's the thing. We earn a pretty good wage between us, so I feel it is expected but now I have some really good points to bring up if it is mentioned.

OP posts:
DoubleTweenQueen · 31/07/2021 09:37

@Movingonupnowww It sounds as though there's not much reason for you to move then - unless you are thinking of having a family at some point, in which case house and schools will need reviewing, and sooner rather than later as the price differential to upsize only seems to increase.

Don't move to 'keep up with the Jones' (your peer group).
(Also - 60's/70's houses are pretty good buy as plot and room size usually decent!)

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 31/07/2021 09:35

If you’re happy where you are don’t move! The housing market is crazy at the moment… not the time to move if you don’t have to, especially if you’re heart isn’t in it.

Don’t do something to try and keep up with the Jones! You said yourself you don’t even have overnight visitors so I guess people rarely even make it upstairs in your house to know the actual size…

ConstanceGracy · 31/07/2021 09:32

We moved from a 3 bed mid terrace to a 5 bed detached and just the lack of party wall noise has made the expense worth it!
Only thing that is a tiny downside is that it’s much colder in the winter and being cold blooded I’ve had to invest in fleecy pj’s! Saying that, the hot weather is bliss in this house, so much cooler

Gothichouse40 · 31/07/2021 09:30

I've got to be honest. As you get older(late 50s) , and if you develop long term health issues, a bigger house can become a chore. Beware of big gardens, they take alot of hard work, time and energy. Cleaning can be very difficult and don't start me on decorating. Yes, husband can be all for it, but in my general experience once husbands retire, there is a change. They are not as keen to do as much round the house as they get older, especially painting and decorating. Before I get jumped on, Im purely talking about my experience and those of friends in my circle. I would not move house just to be able to park my car. Unless you are moving to the middle of nowhere, there are parking issues everywhere. As you get older, you need amenities nearby, in my own case doctors and hospitals for various health issues. Good luck whatever you both decide.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 31/07/2021 09:28

@Movingonupnowww

Sorry all, haven't been on here a while, forgotten about quoting.

About what people think... most of my friends have bought their second houses now and all big, I worry they'll think there's something wrong with us if we don't move from our starter home. I grew up in the country where most of my family and friends had (have) country piles.

I totally get this. Most of our parents' generation in our familes on both sides bought massive detached homes in their 30s and I think are waiting for us to do the same!
JaninaDuszejko · 31/07/2021 09:28

We bought a bigger house because our family had grown. Very glad we had the extra room and bigger garden when lockdown started. The playroom became a schoolroom and the spare room an office. But in your situation I wouldn't move, I'd put the money into savings or pensions rather than investing more in a bigger property. If you do want to invest in property buy a small rental property instead.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 31/07/2021 09:27

We live in a 3 bed plus study townhouse, mid terrace, in a small town centre. There are 3 of us. The downstairs is probably going to be a squash if ever we have us plus DS plus a friend when he's older as it's a tall thin house but if we stay we'll be mortgage free in our mid-50s. It's not worth adding £100k on to the mortgage for a smallish detached or a big semi-detached on the outskirts, for us. Right now we can walk to the cinema, coffee shops etc.

Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:24

Sorry all, haven't been on here a while, forgotten about quoting.

About what people think... most of my friends have bought their second houses now and all big, I worry they'll think there's something wrong with us if we don't move from our starter home. I grew up in the country where most of my family and friends had (have) country piles.

OP posts:
Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:21

Because a similar size house with parking would mean a newish house, which I don't is us. I will definitely keep an eye out though, thanks. It's a very quaint old town with victorian terrace packed in the middle and then pretty much nothing but newer estates and a fair few mansions!

OP posts:
AnotherMarvellousThing · 31/07/2021 09:19

@Movingonupnowww

I think it's partly because we are worried what other people think.
What do you mean? That you think people think you should buy a bigger house you don’t need or want?
Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:18

Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences.

OP posts:
Neverrains · 31/07/2021 09:18

@Movingonupnowww

I think it's partly because we are worried what other people think.
About what? Moving, or staying?
AnotherMarvellousThing · 31/07/2021 09:18

But it doesn’t sound as if you need, or want, more space — why wouldn’t you keep an eye out for a similar sized house close to where you now live, but with off-street parking and further from a pub/noise sources?

Why would you move to a bigger house you don’t need in a village when your current location sounds perfect?

There is only DH and I and our 9 year old, and we moved to a big, 5-bed Victorian that needs a lot of work last year, but our situations aren’t similar.

Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:18

I think it's partly because we are worried what other people think.

OP posts:
Neverrains · 31/07/2021 09:17

Well we moved to a bigger house and didn’t regret it as we needed the extra space for our 3 children. We’ll go even bigger again when we can afford it.
In your situation, however, I’d stay put.

Proudboomer · 31/07/2021 09:17

I moved to a large house some years ago mainly as I have children and my mother needed care so came to live with us.
The children are now grown and will stick out on their own within a year or two and my mum won’t live for ever.
I will want then to downsize again as quite frankly I am fed up of the cost of running a large house and the never ending cost of maintaining it. Top rate of community charge, large gas and electric bills, high water charges and even things like a window cleaner cost twice as much.
I want to see out my days in a small two bed, with a small garden and parking. It will be enough for me with the added benefit of I will have a pot of cash I can use to help my adult children down pay their mortgages and still have money left.

Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:15

The problem is, the housing available which we both like is characterful properties - which are in short supply here, and almost never have parking. We could probably move to a 3 bed in the same area with parking for maybe 300, but it would be a 70s house, which provides a lot more space but not the same feel. Maybe I've answered my own question?

OP posts:
SmokeyDevil · 31/07/2021 09:14

@Movingonupnowww

No we wouldn't use the extra bedrooms, not regularly anyway. I guess we'd have a spare room but like I say we have never had a guest!
God no then. Extra outgoings for nothing. That's just stupid.
DoubleTweenQueen · 31/07/2021 09:14

.....but we moved with two young children and now a dog so our requirements changed and the additional space was necessary

Movingonupnowww · 31/07/2021 09:13

No we wouldn't use the extra bedrooms, not regularly anyway. I guess we'd have a spare room but like I say we have never had a guest!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread