Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret pregnancy

139 replies

hellomumma · 30/07/2021 23:54

My brother and his wife live with my parents.
Sil is pregnant and she practically hid from us for 9 months. Whenever myself or my dsis visited our parents, she would ensure she's not home. There is no back story, we've all always been civil with one another. Db told my mum not to tell my sister and I about the pregnancy, She of course told us as it's a ridiculous thing to keep a secret and he had no real reason as to why he didn't want us to know. We never said anything so he never knew that dm told us, also he would be very annoyed with dm if he knew she told us.
Fast forward to now the baby was born yesterday. My father sent a picture of the baby to me, just a picture, no explanation as to who that baby is.

6 hours after the baby was born db sent a group mssg just saying his daughter was born at X pm.
Am really annoyed at him, we were always so close growing up, he was a brilliant brother, then he got married and just changed. He became very different towards us after marriage. We allowed it and never brought it up. He was the first person I told when I was pregnant. So the fact that he didn't even want me to know he's having a baby makes me extremely sad.
Am happy for both of them. However I've ignored his group mssg, the way I see it is if your going to be all horrible forbidding our mother from telling us your news, you yourself aren't telling us and your wife hiding from us then no I don't want to know about your baby after it's born. Am going to my parents next week, I don't think I'll see the baby or the mother as most likely she will go to her mums after she comes out from hospital.
The most hurtful thing is everyone from our extended family Knew about the pregnancy and also knew the gender, it was very embarrassing to hear from relatives the gender and me being his own sister having no idea.
I don't know what my aibu is. Am just really sad and hurt.

OP posts:
HollowTalk · 31/07/2021 06:28

I'd send a message: congratulations. Why didn't you tell me you were having a baby?

Veronika13 · 31/07/2021 06:27

@hellomumma

If I see him next week. I'll be civil to his face and that's about it. It's been 5 years since he got married and changed towards us. I've allowed it and never said anything, I think this is it, am fed up and can't be bothered anymore. It's a shame.
'I've allowed this'...? You sound way too invested in their marriage.
Notonthestairs · 31/07/2021 06:24

I think there is a backstory. Nobody cuts out their siblings without something happening. And you don't sound like you particularly like your sister in law.

KatherineJaneway · 31/07/2021 06:22

There is no back story, we've all always been civil with one another.

'Civil' doesn't sound very nice

Sceptre86 · 31/07/2021 06:17

Blush so many typos, I blame swollen pregnant fingers!

Sceptre86 · 31/07/2021 06:15

I would leave it yet as they ate in a newborn bubble of joy but at some point I would ask your brother why you and your sister were excluded from knowing about the baby when extended family were told.

My sister had a miscarriage early on in her first pregnancy, she had told immediate family on both our and her dh's side she was pregnant and found it very hard. In her current pregnancy she only told me at 24 weeks and whilst her mil is aware she has not told any of her dh's siblings or dad. She doesn't feet on with them for a start and thinks they won't wish her a safe pregnancy, she is also very superstitious and incredibly anxious. I think it is daft and hurtful that her dh can't tell his own dad or siblings about the baby bit it is her choice and he supports his wife. I nor anybody else gets to tell her what to do and she feels this is the best way to protect her baby.

Sometimes you have to realise it isn't about you and act graciously. So I would send a present and raise it with your brother not sil another time.

PatchworkElmer · 31/07/2021 05:57

Ask him why he didn’t tell you? There’s clearly something going on here if everyone was told, apart from you and your sister.

Bananarice · 31/07/2021 05:50

I have never made an announcement of my pregnancies. I just told people who asked or if/ when needed. I found it awkward enough telling doctors.

Why do you need an announcement? What stopped you from asking when you saw her clearly pregnant?

You have a new addition to your family. That is exciting, send your niece a nice gift. Ask your brother for an explanation and remember your niece is not her parents.

badacorn · 31/07/2021 05:49

You say he changed after marriage but you “allow” it, you say you’ve always been “civil with one another”… you say there’s no backstory but it sounds tense. Like perhaps you and SIL don’t get on well at all. Obviously I don’t know you at all so I could be wrong, I was just struck by your wording.

Don’t get me wrong it’s still weird to cut family out of a big event like this. I don’t blame you for being hurt!

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 31/07/2021 05:48

That is so weird OP! And I don't blame you for being upset at all. I'm not as close but my cousin recently had a secret baby, none of us knew about the pregnancy and they wanted to keep it that way and I still can't figure out why. Weirdos.

I will say OP though is careful it to burn your bridges. This little girl is here to stay and if all your brother remembers for 18 years is you ignored her birth and didn't say congratulations, it could really affect your relationship.

I'd go down the faux shocked route and say "Hang on, SIL has had a baby?! Congratulations- did you not realise she was pregnant?!"

sbhydrogen · 31/07/2021 05:37

"Yo bro, why didn't you tell me?

tiredmama2020 · 31/07/2021 05:29

@hellomumma You say he changed after marriage - did you make an effort with his wife? I can’t imagine why he’d go from being a wonderful brother to cutting you off for no reason so perhaps he feels like you’ve not been very welcoming to her and maybe feels like YOU’VE changed since he got married? 🤷🏻‍♀️

I have barely any contact with my own brother. He had some issues around 16 years ago that he refused to take any accountability for and blamed on everyone else. He left members of my family in a pretty bad way financially and emotionally. I see him once a year when we I visit DP on Christmas Day and he’s usually there for the day. I didn’t tell him when I was pregnant and have no intention of him being around my DS.

Rest of my family I told about my pregnancy at 28 weeks

miltonj · 31/07/2021 05:28

I think you need to text/call/face to face say to him - gorgeous baby etc, congratulations, why didn't you tell me you were having a baby? And then you've asked. If you don't get a proper reply then at least you've tried. I'd probably ask in person.

QueenBee52 · 31/07/2021 05:06

@Misaki

We didn't tell any of my family (only mum and dad) until after our baby was born. We previously had a second trimester loss, which happened a few weeks after we told everyone. Telling everyone we lost the baby was horrific, so we agreed to only tell the absolute minimum amount of people until the baby was born safely.

They'll have their reasons for keeping it to themselves. Just be civil about it.

Completely understandable and I'm so sorry for you and your DH's loss..

however... it was only OP and her Sister excluded from this wonderful news.. so not quite the same situation as your own tragic situation. 🌸

Misaki · 31/07/2021 04:51

We didn't tell any of my family (only mum and dad) until after our baby was born. We previously had a second trimester loss, which happened a few weeks after we told everyone. Telling everyone we lost the baby was horrific, so we agreed to only tell the absolute minimum amount of people until the baby was born safely.

They'll have their reasons for keeping it to themselves. Just be civil about it.

QueenBee52 · 31/07/2021 04:33

Family Secrets... never end well..

it's a seedy business ...

joystir59 · 31/07/2021 04:32

Perhaps she was afraid the baby wouldn't be ok at birth? I'd be gracious and congratulate them and give them a gift. I wouldn't create a rift. They had their reasons.

MyOtherProfile · 31/07/2021 04:02

@slashlover

I'd be annoyed if I was SIL or your DB, obviously your mother can't be trusted.
Why should she? In her shoes, once the pregnancy was visible, I would have said no to keeping it secret. They are forcing her to choose between her children here and being very divisive.
MyOtherProfile · 31/07/2021 04:01

Sitting for you and your sister. I would send a card but also have to ask Db what is going on.

MindyStClaire · 31/07/2021 03:59

I mean, there's clearly a reason for what they've done. They clearly get on well enough with your parents to live with them, and with the extended family. So it's just the siblings that they don't want contact with.

So what's their version of the story? If you've been on here any length of time you'll have seen umpteen threads about not getting on with in-laws. What would SIL's say? Not do you think it's right or fair, what do you honestly think her view is? That might help you unpick what's going on.

cutebutscary · 31/07/2021 03:46

So now the baby is born and he's chosen to tell you , does he expect you to celebrate ? I have to admit , the hurt I would feel at this would lead me to probably just ignore the message ! I mean, what's he expecting !!! Or say 'what baby?' Seeing as you're not supposed to know . How will he explain that away without looking like a bell end

Just10moreminutesplease · 31/07/2021 03:25

That’s incredibly odd. Is it possible that they have suffered previous losses?

I can see someone choosing to keep their pregnancy secret if they are worried about losing their baby (granted keeping it a secret for the entire pregnancy seems extreme... but grief can do strange things to people).

QueenBee52 · 31/07/2021 03:18

They cut you and your Sister out OP..

So that works both ways.... now cut them out Flowers

Hyppogriff · 31/07/2021 03:00

How bizarre . Maybe take the high road - card and small gift then let it go.

DaisyChainsForever · 31/07/2021 02:56

To those saying that you also hid pregnancies, that's not the case here, as OP clearly said others knew about it including the gender!
It is very odd OP. I would be inclined to ask your Brother what's going on? Could it be that SIL has some misplaced jealousy over how close you were?