Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret pregnancy

139 replies

hellomumma · 30/07/2021 23:54

My brother and his wife live with my parents.
Sil is pregnant and she practically hid from us for 9 months. Whenever myself or my dsis visited our parents, she would ensure she's not home. There is no back story, we've all always been civil with one another. Db told my mum not to tell my sister and I about the pregnancy, She of course told us as it's a ridiculous thing to keep a secret and he had no real reason as to why he didn't want us to know. We never said anything so he never knew that dm told us, also he would be very annoyed with dm if he knew she told us.
Fast forward to now the baby was born yesterday. My father sent a picture of the baby to me, just a picture, no explanation as to who that baby is.

6 hours after the baby was born db sent a group mssg just saying his daughter was born at X pm.
Am really annoyed at him, we were always so close growing up, he was a brilliant brother, then he got married and just changed. He became very different towards us after marriage. We allowed it and never brought it up. He was the first person I told when I was pregnant. So the fact that he didn't even want me to know he's having a baby makes me extremely sad.
Am happy for both of them. However I've ignored his group mssg, the way I see it is if your going to be all horrible forbidding our mother from telling us your news, you yourself aren't telling us and your wife hiding from us then no I don't want to know about your baby after it's born. Am going to my parents next week, I don't think I'll see the baby or the mother as most likely she will go to her mums after she comes out from hospital.
The most hurtful thing is everyone from our extended family Knew about the pregnancy and also knew the gender, it was very embarrassing to hear from relatives the gender and me being his own sister having no idea.
I don't know what my aibu is. Am just really sad and hurt.

OP posts:
FrenchBoule · 31/07/2021 09:48

So SIL moves into her in laws with her husband and he tries to prevent his mother from telling her daughters about impending arrival.

Maybe SIL has had her reasons but they’re hugely upsetting the dynamics of the family they literally moved into.

Hope they won’t try to dictate who can or can’t come to house they are living in.

MadeOfStarStuff · 31/07/2021 09:29

It’s so strange there has to be a reason for it, even if you’re not aware what that is or just understandably don’t want to share it on MN.

Iwonder08 · 31/07/2021 08:45

There could be 3 reasons :

  1. previous dramatic pregnancy loss.. I think your mum would know if it happened given they live together. Ask her If it was the case you need to be understanding and civil
  2. she is psychotic manipulative person who bullies your brother to submision. It would highly unlikely she would agree to live with his family in this case. This attitude would definitely cover your parents too, not just you and your sister
  3. you and your sister are not as civil and nice as you paint here. If she gets out of the house every time you visit there must be the reason why she doesn't like you to that extent.
Grimacingfrog · 31/07/2021 08:32

@enoughforme

It is odd but she's possibly likely had losses. I've had losses and I promise you cannot truly understand unless you have - I've not had a child yet but two consecutive losses ask me and DH actually spoke about next time doing something similar, certainly with work colleagues for examples or at the very least we will likely wait until 16 weeks.

If I could het away with not telling a soul until nine months I would tbh.

So sorry for your losses.

I completely understand not telling anyone in that case but she's telling the extended family but not the siblings. That doesn't fit with your scenario.

enoughforme · 31/07/2021 08:25

It is odd but she's possibly likely had losses. I've had losses and I promise you cannot truly understand unless you have - I've not had a child yet but two consecutive losses ask me and DH actually spoke about next time doing something similar, certainly with work colleagues for examples or at the very least we will likely wait until 16 weeks.

If I could het away with not telling a soul until nine months I would tbh.

notanothertakeaway · 31/07/2021 08:14

Don't cut your nose to spite your face

It's simple to send a small gift and card

It seems odd they told everyone except you and your sister. There must be a reason for that

How you did your own pregnancy isn't really that relevant

Grimacingfrog · 31/07/2021 08:11

I would say 100% that SiL is insecure and didn't like you being close with your brother. It's really weird that someone would be jealous of a sibling relationship but it does happen. In fact I've heard a similar story very recently.

It's part of this keeping you distant that you're not allowed to share in her family news, i.e. the baby. Unfortunately it's only your brother that can change this dynamic, nothing you do can change her behaviour or your brother's reaction. I don't get this prioritising your wife idea, either. Prioritising your wife should not have to involve completely cutting yourself off from your siblings. There shouldn't be a side to take.

I'm really sorry OP but I wouldn't be bothered in trying to rekindle a family relationship that your brother doesn't reciprocate. I'd probably buy a present and card just to avoid drama and be the bigger person, but I don't think I could be emotionally invested in the baby because it's absolutely certain that you will not be allowed to get close to it.

Standrewsschool · 31/07/2021 08:09

Be bigger person and buy a card a present. Not doing so will cause more harm than good.

Jumpingintosummer · 31/07/2021 08:08

How very sad. I would have to tell my brother how much hurt he had caused then step away emotionally. Telling no one is odd but I could understand that, excluding two and telling extended family etc is just cruel.

Sapnupuas · 31/07/2021 08:04

YABU for writing "am" instead of "I am".

It's weird but it's their choice. My brother didn't tell me until his partner was 6 months, at least. I knew from the day they found out but he still hadn't told me because he hadn't wanted to tell our dad. It was bloody obvious and such a weird situation to be in, pretending I couldn't see her prominent bump.

Hereslurkingatyoukid · 31/07/2021 07:49

100% there is more to this.

slashlover · 31/07/2021 07:36

I would assume SIL is just someone who says she’s “private” but is actually into playing Information-is-Power

Why blame SIL?

OP says Db told my mum not to tell my sister and I about the pregnancy and he would be very annoyed with dm if he knew she told us.

lboogy · 31/07/2021 07:23

I don't blame you for being upset. ESP as you said you're very close to your brother. However, he's married now and his wife takes priority so if she didn't want to share the news then that's the decision they've made.

Try to be happy for them and move on. Knowing before hand would have made very little difference to your life.

Sometimeswinning · 31/07/2021 07:23

Well I read 'allowed it' to mean the op took a step back and accepted it. Bigger picture is that a baby was born and siblings are expected to go along and not question anything! Bizarre Confused

CrazyNeighbour · 31/07/2021 07:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Wanttocry · 31/07/2021 07:10

I’ll add that when I say you should ask, I think that should be in a non-confrontational way, after you’ve done the general congratulations etc. And I’d frame it as “I hope that if I’ve done something to upset you, you’ll let me know” because in this kind of situation I’d never assume that I was totally the innocent party, even if I had no idea of what was going on.

Wanttocry · 31/07/2021 07:06

He became very different towards us after marriage. We allowed it

How big of you.

It’s weird for them not to have told you, but it’s so weird that there must be at least a a small backstory. You don’t randomly choose two family members not to tell about a pregnancy so there must be a reason somewhere, even a totally ridiculous one. I would just ask, because it sounds like somehow you’ve really upset them and whether their feelings are completely justified or completely unjustified, I’d want to know what reason they had.

user47000000000 · 31/07/2021 07:02

Bloody hell OP get over yourself. Get the baby a present & congratulate your brother

Thewinterofdiscontent · 31/07/2021 07:02

Op are your family by any chance as rough as a bag of spanner’s? Potentially a bad influence.
Have you said anything hurtful to them/SIL in the past ?

There is something about you they aren’t comfortable with and as PP mentioned maybe it’s because of previous pregnancies and losses.

Let them be and stay friendly. You can find out the issue further down the line.

pegboardsu · 31/07/2021 07:01

@Jen123456789

Like others have said, it could be a history of pregnancy loss. I had two miscarriages before having my son recently. I found it hardest to tell the family members I am closest to because they had a “stake” in the outcome of the pregnancy. As in, it would be their grandchild, their niece/nephew etc. All I could imagine was that I was going to have to “let them down” and break bad news that the baby wasn’t ok in the future. Looking back it wasn’t healthy at all, and acquaintances knew long before my brother, and my favourite auntie and cousins. But I didn’t mind telling acquaintances because I knew that they wouldn’t be hard hit by any bad news. Does that make sense? As I say, it was an unhealthy way to behave and lots of people were surprised when I told them (actually asked my parents to tell them) that I was 36 weeks pregnant. As someone has previously said, grief does strange things to your psychology and makes you behave in odd ways xxx
This.

I would not add fuel to the fire by not acknowledging the baby or sending a gift. A cherry congratulations and sending an outfit might actually start a conversation between you and your DB.

Whatever happens, now is not the time to question his actions, but I would not be participating in this 'game' at all. I would congratulate, send a gift, coo over the baby and wait.

Things always come out in the wash...

OutOfTrousers · 31/07/2021 06:52

Wow, congratulations! Is all you need to say. Plus asking if mum is doing ok.
As others have said, there must be a reason that they kept this quiet, but now is not the time to ask.

Jen123456789 · 31/07/2021 06:40

Like others have said, it could be a history of pregnancy loss. I had two miscarriages before having my son recently. I found it hardest to tell the family members I am closest to because they had a “stake” in the outcome of the pregnancy. As in, it would be their grandchild, their niece/nephew etc. All I could imagine was that I was going to have to “let them down” and break bad news that the baby wasn’t ok in the future. Looking back it wasn’t healthy at all, and acquaintances knew long before my brother, and my favourite auntie and cousins. But I didn’t mind telling acquaintances because I knew that they wouldn’t be hard hit by any bad news. Does that make sense? As I say, it was an unhealthy way to behave and lots of people were surprised when I told them (actually asked my parents to tell them) that I was 36 weeks pregnant. As someone has previously said, grief does strange things to your psychology and makes you behave in odd ways xxx

WeAreTheHeroes · 31/07/2021 06:37

He became very different towards us after marriage. We allowed it and never brought it up.

This stood out to me: we allowed it. There's your answer - since he got married your DB has rightly prioritised his wife and whatever it was about your relationship with him which was perhaps overbearing has changed.

Congratulate them and give them/the baby a gift. Life is too short to hold grudges over perceived slights.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 31/07/2021 06:37

You said you were close with your brother, then he got married and changed. You accepted this and were civil. If you were close and he suddenly, without warning, dropped out of your life with no backstory I’m not sure you would just accept him changing his behaviour so suddenly.

I would make the effort with the baby. It’s not the baby’s fault that you and your brother are being civil to each other, with no backstory. If you ever want a relationship with your niece, this is one of those times you need to put your pride aside and at least try to congratulate your brother, at least try to build a relationship. He might not let you in but at least you can say you tried. At the moment, it sounds like you’re cutting your nose off to spite your face.

MayorGundersonsDogRufus · 31/07/2021 06:33

Sorry OP, I do think YABU. While their behaviour is odd, for sure, you've never discussed it with them so you have no idea why they've behaved like this and you've formed your own judgments. She may have extreme anxiety, maybe she had pregnancy loss in the past, there could be all kinds of reasons they wanted to keep this quiet and didn't want to discuss it and most of them likely have very little to do with you.

And you have a new, living, breathing member of your family who I'm sure would value a loving aunty in their life. You have a wonderful opportunity here for a rewarding relationship and to show you can be a loving supportive sister and aunt. You are not showing this at the moment. Take a deep breath, rise above it and buy the baby a damn present!