Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret pregnancy

139 replies

hellomumma · 30/07/2021 23:54

My brother and his wife live with my parents.
Sil is pregnant and she practically hid from us for 9 months. Whenever myself or my dsis visited our parents, she would ensure she's not home. There is no back story, we've all always been civil with one another. Db told my mum not to tell my sister and I about the pregnancy, She of course told us as it's a ridiculous thing to keep a secret and he had no real reason as to why he didn't want us to know. We never said anything so he never knew that dm told us, also he would be very annoyed with dm if he knew she told us.
Fast forward to now the baby was born yesterday. My father sent a picture of the baby to me, just a picture, no explanation as to who that baby is.

6 hours after the baby was born db sent a group mssg just saying his daughter was born at X pm.
Am really annoyed at him, we were always so close growing up, he was a brilliant brother, then he got married and just changed. He became very different towards us after marriage. We allowed it and never brought it up. He was the first person I told when I was pregnant. So the fact that he didn't even want me to know he's having a baby makes me extremely sad.
Am happy for both of them. However I've ignored his group mssg, the way I see it is if your going to be all horrible forbidding our mother from telling us your news, you yourself aren't telling us and your wife hiding from us then no I don't want to know about your baby after it's born. Am going to my parents next week, I don't think I'll see the baby or the mother as most likely she will go to her mums after she comes out from hospital.
The most hurtful thing is everyone from our extended family Knew about the pregnancy and also knew the gender, it was very embarrassing to hear from relatives the gender and me being his own sister having no idea.
I don't know what my aibu is. Am just really sad and hurt.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LionSGuard · 02/08/2021 08:52

If they do that then obviously she can't, that's why I said if you are able to. OP sounds like regardless of how her brother and SIL are, she's just going to ignore her nieces existence because she wasn't told about the pregnancy. Hardly fair on a child who's done nothing wrong.

burnoutbabe · 02/08/2021 08:08

@LionSGuard

And your niece hasn't actually done anything wrong either. So if you are able to have at least some kind of relationship with her I would, no matter how many other nieces and nephews you have so you're not "missing out". She's a baby, she hasn't done anything.
But how can she if sister in law leaves house when they are there and brother also won't speak to them. One assumes they won't be able to see niece.

This may not happen but seems likely from actions so far. At that point it clearly can't continue to be not discussed/acknowledged publicly.

Helspopje · 02/08/2021 07:13

We were ‘cut out’ and told how disappointed they were in us by my in laws when we didn’t tell them I was pregnant until we were passed the point we’d had a late loss in the previous pregnancy a handful of months earlier. Apparently we ‘denied them joy’.

Btw this isn’t a hidden pregnancy, this is deciding not to share pregnancy news. Different.

Whereland · 02/08/2021 07:10

The obvious first step is to ask your brother why he didn't tell you?

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 02/08/2021 07:05

Your mum must know why they have chosen to behave this way? What has she said about it all? This must be very sad for her.

LionSGuard · 02/08/2021 01:35

Also not sure why everyone is blaming the SIL. It was OPs brother who asked his Mum not tell OP. Are men not responsible for their own lives/choices/decisions or something?

If you were so close to your DB why can't you just ask him? Or your DH?

LionSGuard · 02/08/2021 01:33

And your niece hasn't actually done anything wrong either. So if you are able to have at least some kind of relationship with her I would, no matter how many other nieces and nephews you have so you're not "missing out". She's a baby, she hasn't done anything.

LionSGuard · 02/08/2021 01:31

You come across really badly in your posts imo OP. You allowed it, your 'civil' relationship, it would have been sufficient to tell you later on in the pregnancy, they 'kind of do' have to tell you (no they don't).

It might be odd to you but I'd bet my house your DBs and Sils story is different to yours. You sound so difficult, perhaps it's just the way you're coming across in messages but that's the vibe I get from your posts.

Maggiesfarm · 02/08/2021 00:58

Ask your mother what it is all about.

Pegasusmail · 02/08/2021 00:52

It's is really cruel.
I was hoping that a reason came out to explain but If they were having baby showers etc then that is really making it clear they didn't want you to know.. Not just people to know Sad
Pass yourself with them but take joy in your nieces and nephews. It's really strange from your mum too.

hellomumma · 02/08/2021 00:40

@candlelightsatdawn no it hasn't happened before. Thanks for your contribution....
your assumptions are all exactly that, you know nothing about our Iives.
and for all those saying they don't need to tell me, actually yes they kind of do if they are telling the whole world except me , you can make all the assumptions in the world, the fact of the matter is I haven't done anything, and had I done anything, the type of people they are they would've made a big deal about it. Anyways life goes on, I have plenty of nieces and nephews in my life so it's not like am missing out.

OP posts:
FunMcCool · 01/08/2021 20:47

That’s so hurtful. So hurtful.

candlelightsatdawn · 01/08/2021 20:14

@burnoutbabe

Well brother also refusing to chat to the sisters too and leaving the room when they are there.

I just think it needs publicly acknowledging. Else the parents are in a bad position of having to "warn" brother that sister is coming over and no actual family events? Be interesting to see what happens when op's sister goes over to see new baby and what excuses are given.

I mean if someone's going NC/LC with any family member believe me, they don't wait until be told. They will just leave if put in that position, which seems to be the case here.

You don't have to make excuses not to see certain family members. I used to avoid my "family friend" who was life and soul of the party, everyone loved him. I didn't want to or need to explain it was because he has been molesting me from age 5 frankly because I didn't want to think less of the people who would try and argue against my "excuses". Even now people will try to argue with me like they were in the room each time the abuse was happening.

I certainly got more heat to comply than he did, and he went on to do it to others sadly.

You get to decide as a adult who you engage or not engage with - this is the gift of adulting. This includes family because it's a two way street and no one is entitled to your time or affection because they effectively reproduced.

burnoutbabe · 01/08/2021 20:03

Well brother also refusing to chat to the sisters too and leaving the room when they are there.

I just think it needs publicly acknowledging. Else the parents are in a bad position of having to "warn" brother that sister is coming over and no actual family events? Be interesting to see what happens when op's sister goes over to see new baby and what excuses are given.

Dalooah · 01/08/2021 20:01

Maybe you could just asked your brother what's going on? Maybe there is something that you've missed?

Guavafish · 01/08/2021 19:53

She has been visiting throughout the pregnant and the sister-in-law has been actively avoiding them. Clearly she has the problem. They should just continue as they are and visit when they like to see their parents.

If the SIL and brother doesn’t want to engage then why should they?

Vivi0 · 01/08/2021 19:48

Oh dear, this reads like one of those Gransnet posts where they are adamant they have no idea why their son/daughter has went LC/NC, and they rationalise it by saying outrageous, nonsensical shit like this:

Well it's a common theme in our family, anytime a man from my mums side gets married, they change!

I don’t think you are as close to your brother as you would have us believe. Otherwise, this situation would not have went on as long as this because surely you would have just asked him if there was a problem, right?

GrimDamnFanjo · 01/08/2021 18:24

Did you ever have a relationship with SiL?

burnoutbabe · 01/08/2021 18:17

@Guavafish

Just leave it

There is no point in asking, they clearly didn’t want you to know. It’s very bizarre. Would knowing the reason change anything in your relationship?

It would at least be more honest and get things out in the open. Else how does op know if she cab even visit her parents house without causing offence to brother etc.
candlelightsatdawn · 01/08/2021 17:09

I get why other posters kept the pregnancies private, but the situation here is different.

Why ? No one had any right to be told about a pregnancy. You do not have any entitlement to be told anything. You have been told now though it's just you deem it to late 🤷🏼‍♀️. No one has to justify their behaviours to you since it's not about you it's about them and the choices they have made re a pregnancy.

Funny in one of your previous comments you says SL must like the family because she's lived with your parents. This maybe true, she just may not want to spend time with you for whatever reason. I think what you put was indicative that you know SL isn't comfortable around you. It sounds like it's LC/NC that doesn't apply to the family but you in general. I wonder if you can think about why that maybe without blaming some type of generation change that happens to all men on the family. That sounds as wild as a TV drama series.

You say the word civil ? I mean I'm civil to my ex but that doesn't mean stuff hasn't gone down to induce that.

Your blaming this change on BL getting married, so let's explore the option of maybe your right ? He's reassessed what his priority is in terms of hierarchy. Your thoughts and needs are less than his wife's. Your cool with that right ? Bar the fact you have actively got a score card of his wrongs and undermining those choices and blaming SL to boot.

Why do I think your going to show this whole thread to the family to throw a bomb in there ? Like "see look how wrong you are the internet agrees with me"

I know this behaviour of old. You already mentioned way on you weren't here for how to deal with this, you stated you won't be wishing them well or buy a gift. So I suspect your here for validation on this behaviour and enough ammunition to throw.

Bet you would describe your childhood with DB as great because you visited stately homes...

No sorry this doesn't pass the smell test. You not sharing any that would potentially have caused this on your side, it's everyone else's fault. It's a one sided story to provoke a one sided response

I feel sorry for him, I feel sorry for SL and actually I feel sorry for you. Being able to look inwards at your own actions and take ownership is a skill that makes you likeable and you would find that actually this will reduce the amount of people doing this. And money on it it's happened before

Guavafish · 01/08/2021 16:58

Just leave it

There is no point in asking, they clearly didn’t want you to know. It’s very bizarre. Would knowing the reason change anything in your relationship?

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 01/08/2021 13:18

Well it's a common theme in our family, anytime a man from my mums side gets married, they change!

If there's a common theme with all these people who come into your family through marriage, the problem is clearly something to do with your family.

If people are born and raised with certain attitudes and behaviour they won't question it, people coming into the family as adults will have a very different perspective.

safclass · 01/08/2021 13:06

They have the right to tell who they want, but for you and sis to be singled out and nit told is strange.
Think id send a personal mesaage to brother saying glad to hear their good news and happy that theyve got a healthy baby but i would ask him outright if there's issues you are unaware of because you would hate for there to be, esp if things could be improved .

hellomumma · 01/08/2021 10:37

My child was born way before db got married, so sil was not in the scene nor were they in a relationship when I had mine, I don't think she even knows I told him first unless he's told her, but I doubt he would even remember something like that. Men are not like women.
I am not the overbearing sil everyome seems to be assuming. Without knowing any of us I find it interesting that everyone thinks I can be the problem and not sil or db.

I get why other posters kept the pregnancies private, but the situation here is different.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 01/08/2021 10:32

@Just10moreminutesplease

That’s incredibly odd. Is it possible that they have suffered previous losses?

I can see someone choosing to keep their pregnancy secret if they are worried about losing their baby (granted keeping it a secret for the entire pregnancy seems extreme... but grief can do strange things to people).

Except the wider family were told