Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's cheaper to cook from scratch and what's cheaper to buy ready made?

105 replies

coodawoodashooda · 30/07/2021 23:05

I guess i mean more economival overall in terms of the time needed as well? Im batch cooking for next term and really questioning the value of baking all of these goodies. Im sure i could fill the cupboards cheaper on a trip around a supermarket.

OP posts:
Walkingbkwrm · 31/07/2021 09:58

@SchrodingersImmigrant

My basic tomato sauce🙈It's really nothing special. 1litre of passata 1.8kg of chopped tomatoes (can use 2kg. I get 2.5kg tin and use other 700 for something else) 10ml Worcestershire sauce 15ml dried mixed herbs nalearly 2 tablespoons. I use meazuring spoons 1.5tsp cinnamon 3 garlic cloves 15ml kucharyk 3tbsp balsamic vinegar
  • all of this goes into slowcooker, set it on high for 6 hours

1tbsp of oil and fry 400g of red onion. I fry half to really caramelise and half just a bit to soften.
Add to the slowcooker. Mix. Close, say bye for now.

It makes lovely and thick basic sauce and the long cooking get rid of the tin taste thing. Then i portion it and freeze and finish off, depending on a dish. So if you add more italian herbs and bits like olives if you like them, blueeeh, it makes nice pasta sauce. If you add chili, smoked paprika etc, you get spanish like flavours for meat and veg. Add cumin and chili, maybe bit more garlic and it's a shakshouka base. And so on. Really versatile. One of the most practical foods I have in a freezer.

Anx if you mix it with bit off fried mince, chopped chili, smoked paprika, bit more garlic and maybe chopped pepper, you can then put it on a toast, tope with cheese (melt) and it makes great beer accompaniment😂

Thanks for this but what is kucharyk? Not heard of it and googling just seems to get people’s names. Also how do people speedily defrost all this batch cooked stuff? By the time I’ve got precooked stuff out of the freezer and defrosted it never seems to save much time. Plus it needs ridiculously sized pans to batch cook as our family seems to eat loads. I agree on the bread - we have a bread maker but getting bread on every day before work/ school is too stressful so it tends just to be used at weekends/ holidays.
Belledan1 · 31/07/2021 09:53

Loving this. I do batch cook chilli, shepherds pie mince, tom mince etc. I am going to get a pastry case today and add my own filling. Never thought of doing this. I tried to make it from scratch before ie my own pastry. Disaster. Sometimes I will use frozen mash in week to add to batch cooked cottage pie mince. 1.00 for a pack, just cheap as a bag of spuds but normally do my own.

SimonJT · 31/07/2021 09:23

I guess it depends if you’re talking like for like? Most ready made things aren’t as high quality unless you buy very expensive ready made.

I cook a lot, I really enjoy cooking and I’m a bit of a feeder.

I make my own sauces, tomato based ones are very cheap, tinned toms (plum ones and mash them, chipped toms can be a bit watery), salt, pepper, garlic, onion and herbs. If you have freezer space you can make it in bulk but sticking it in freezer bags.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 31/07/2021 09:19

Making one lasagne from scratch is time consuming, but it’s so quick and easy if you already have frozen portions of ragu in the freezer. I make a huge ragu once a month and it’s a complete life saver. Lasagne prep time is approx 10-15 mins (which includes making the white sauce).

I love sourdough bread and I always buy that. Although it costs practically nothing to make, it’s a very time consuming process so I gladly pay someone else for their expertise on that one.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2021 09:09

I consider macaroni cheese as a bit of a faff and I can never remember how much sauce/macaroni to make. Plus it's much nicer if you grill/bake it after assembly, so not really that quick.

In my mind, 'very quick supper dishes' are things like cheese, egg or beans on toast, an omelette or something like garlic prawns and bread.

LemonRoses · 31/07/2021 08:57

I’d consider macaroni cheese as a very quick supper dish.

LemonRoses · 31/07/2021 08:56

I think most things can be obtained quite cheaply ready made. However, some ready made items are barely recognisable when compared to ones you make yourself.

I wouldn’t usually make my own puff pastry. Other than that I usually make from scratch. Even scotch eggs are incomparable compared to the gritty, yellow crumbed affairs sold in supermarkets. Much nicer to make home baked ones.

winewolfhowls · 31/07/2021 08:50

I can't be bothered with lasagne it takes an age and so much washing up, i agree, but 'mac' cheese is just a cheese roux sauce with frozen veg in it and the pasta put in oven. I think of it as get well soon food if someone is ill

winewolfhowls · 31/07/2021 08:47

I couldn't live without my lazy garlic, definitely a time safer.

I think homemade pizza is a good skint meal if you already have frozen peppers, sweetcorn, mushrooms etc in the freezer.
Tastes better than bought.

Crisps. You can't really make your own crisps and i love a ham and crisp butty.

I don't understand why frozen celery doesn't exist, I'm always trying to make cottage pie or soups and they need a bit of celery, but I don't like it on its own so then the rest of the bunch gets ignored in the fridge until it needs throwing away.

Manzanilla55 · 31/07/2021 08:46

Things like lasagne and macaroni cheese take so long to make. I dont have the patience all that standing up! Is it my age (57) or do others agree lol.

LizzieSiddal · 31/07/2021 08:42

I love a homemade tomato sauce but if you haven’t got time, I swear by the fresh tomato pasta sauces you find in the fridge bit of a supermarket, next to the fresh pasta/raveoli.

I just pour them onto cooked pasta and roasted veg, add grated cheese and bake for 10 mins.
I also make a cod dish, roasted veg (courgette, onion, red pepper) in a dish, add cod which you’ve cut into smaller pieces, pour over the tomato sauce, put a lid on it, and bake in the oven for 15/20 mins.

Fry prawns with garlic, add the tomato sauce which you’ve already heated, serve with rice.

I use the M&S or Waitrose fresh sauces and there are no nasties in there.

Tulipomania · 31/07/2021 08:41

Shortcrust pastry is very quick & easy to make.

I also buy ice-cream, but only premium brands (less additives) and only when they are on sale, which they often are.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 31/07/2021 08:40

Even Gordon Ramsey says not to bother with puff pastry😁 I listen to professionals sometimes

Tulipomania · 31/07/2021 08:38

I buy puff pastry, everyday meringues (for a party I would make my own), have ready made pesto on standby, oatcakes and bread, cold meats for quick sandwich fillings for DC, sausages, quiches (sometimes make at home but usually it's a quick lunch option).

But we cook all our main meals from scratch. I would never buy a ready-made lasagne, the texture is all gloopy and wrong.

notanothertakeaway · 31/07/2021 08:36

It's very quick and easy to make pastry in a food processor

doudouchouchou · 31/07/2021 08:34

Thank you @SchrodingersImmigrant

SchrodingersImmigrant · 31/07/2021 08:32

No problem @HouseIsOnFire
If you like atuff more vegetably, finely chopped or even grated veg should kind of dissolve in it. If it's hard bveg, I would add hour or 2 to cooking time so it melts nicely. I like just simplest form like this but it's very basic so can be easily pimped up and personalised😁

lljkk · 31/07/2021 08:30

The lasting longer thing is quite appealing supermarkets & consumers both like this. One thing I disliked about my breadmaker was it could only work if I made a very small loaf daily the bread didn't taste good after ~24 hours. Daily baking demanded a lot of time , and keeping track of which ingredients were in my cupboard, too. I don't even like bread that much.

Wildly more convenient to just buy shop loaves when required, it was cheaper, more versatile and it kept well.

No MNer but me seems to think that keeping track of stuff in the freezer is a total pain. In past my housemates were often pulling out stuff from the freezer they said they had forgotten about, maybe even needed to be binned they said it was too old.

HouseIsOnFire · 31/07/2021 08:29

@SchrodingersImmigrant

My basic tomato sauce🙈It's really nothing special. 1litre of passata 1.8kg of chopped tomatoes (can use 2kg. I get 2.5kg tin and use other 700 for something else) 10ml Worcestershire sauce 15ml dried mixed herbs nalearly 2 tablespoons. I use meazuring spoons 1.5tsp cinnamon 3 garlic cloves 15ml kucharyk 3tbsp balsamic vinegar
  • all of this goes into slowcooker, set it on high for 6 hours

1tbsp of oil and fry 400g of red onion. I fry half to really caramelise and half just a bit to soften.
Add to the slowcooker. Mix. Close, say bye for now.

It makes lovely and thick basic sauce and the long cooking get rid of the tin taste thing. Then i portion it and freeze and finish off, depending on a dish. So if you add more italian herbs and bits like olives if you like them, blueeeh, it makes nice pasta sauce. If you add chili, smoked paprika etc, you get spanish like flavours for meat and veg. Add cumin and chili, maybe bit more garlic and it's a shakshouka base. And so on. Really versatile. One of the most practical foods I have in a freezer.

Anx if you mix it with bit off fried mince, chopped chili, smoked paprika, bit more garlic and maybe chopped pepper, you can then put it on a toast, tope with cheese (melt) and it makes great beer accompaniment😂

Thank you!
LaurieFairyCake · 31/07/2021 08:28

The veggie lasagnes at COOK have no artificial anything's or preservatives

The serves 4 (absolutely massive 1.4kg) is £14.90

I think that's a bargain in time saving - I don't have hours to cook a lasagne - and I think the ingredients are about a tenner ? For me to buy (not in bulk like a COOK kitchen)

SchrodingersImmigrant · 31/07/2021 08:24

@Saggybaggyaggy

It's criminal that ultra processed shitty lasagne that is full of crap and not good for you is cheaper to buy than stuff to make one.

But of course anything made at scale in a factory will be cheap.

The food system needs turning on its head.

It's cheaper exactly because it's ultra proccessed so lasts longer and the ingredients will not be in the amount and quality you would use at home cooking. Also if you bake 4 trays of lasagna at once, it will also cost you less due to bulk buy and energy savings. So that's another saving for them. On top of quantity discounts etc, they end up spending pennies basically. Hence the cheap price vs homemade price.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 31/07/2021 08:21

My basic tomato sauce🙈It's really nothing special.
1litre of passata
1.8kg of chopped tomatoes (can use 2kg. I get 2.5kg tin and use other 700 for something else)
10ml Worcestershire sauce
15ml dried mixed herbs nalearly 2 tablespoons. I use meazuring spoons
1.5tsp cinnamon
3 garlic cloves
15ml kucharyk
3tbsp balsamic vinegar

  • all of this goes into slowcooker, set it on high for 6 hours

1tbsp of oil and fry 400g of red onion. I fry half to really caramelise and half just a bit to soften.
Add to the slowcooker. Mix. Close, say bye for now.

It makes lovely and thick basic sauce and the long cooking get rid of the tin taste thing. Then i portion it and freeze and finish off, depending on a dish. So if you add more italian herbs and bits like olives if you like them, blueeeh, it makes nice pasta sauce. If you add chili, smoked paprika etc, you get spanish like flavours for meat and veg. Add cumin and chili, maybe bit more garlic and it's a shakshouka base. And so on. Really versatile. One of the most practical foods I have in a freezer.

Anx if you mix it with bit off fried mince, chopped chili, smoked paprika, bit more garlic and maybe chopped pepper, you can then put it on a toast, tope with cheese (melt) and it makes great beer accompaniment😂

Zorinindustries · 31/07/2021 07:57

HelgaDownUnder thanks, I'll definitely try those suggestions

reprehensibleme · 31/07/2021 07:57

Lasagne is cheap to buy premade because you wouldn't make it at home with the same quantities - Tesco 400g lasagne has about 70g of beef in it - if I was making a lasagne for 4 people at home I'd use 500g of beef.

I've costed out a homemade pizza and they are pennies.

But, as people have pointed out, I'm not buying the herbs and spices/oils etc every time because I have a good store cupboard.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 31/07/2021 07:49

I don't know about freezing Mac n cheese. I've frozen fish pie and lasagne, but I imagine Macaroni cheese might end up gluggy

I slightly undercook the pasta , its going to sit in the sauce then get reheated so cooks without going too soft .

My DS was very judgey when I bought a breadmaker , he was "You can buy a loaf for 50p" (you can tel he doesn't go shopping very often)

A fresh made loaf costs about 40p in ingredients ( plus add electricity and the overall cost of the machine) it is far far nicer than a doughy ,tasteless how-long-has-it-sat-there loaf .

.