Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving test fail.

111 replies

Mybabysmylife · 30/07/2021 22:26

Should I complain about my examiner? So I took my 1st test on Wednesday and failed. There was major roadworks everywhere one being were they was ready to repaint the floor as there was no markings. This meaning I didn't no where to stop as I hadn't drove there before he said I failed on that part but i didn't know till the end of the test. With Covid he's supposed to say I failed straight away and take me back but he didn't. He was very rude and moody. He took the sat nav off the dashboard and threw it on the floor then at the end all he said was " well today you failed bye" then got out the car? My instructor argued on my behalf that I wasn't to no where to stop if there was no road markings and that's what they was supposed to do( road works) he said. She's a good driver but failed on that. I got an arsehole of a examiner that day he was very rude and made me feel like shit to be honest. I came home and I've cried since as test are so backlogged due to Covid I don't want to run into having to do my theory next year in September again. I got another test for DECEMEBER! Which is over 20 weeks away!😭

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brefugee · 31/07/2021 12:00

OP is right to be 💯 disappointed that she's been failed on something out of the ordinary.

But as pp have said it isn't out of the ordinary at all, it is horribly ordinary. And the thing is that to be a safe driver you have to anticipate etc and handle situations you don't expect.

Chalk it up to experience and practice as much as you can in a variety of situations before the next test, OP, and you'll be fine.

Clocktopus · 31/07/2021 11:43

Also, my friend had a lovely instructor and she hit the curb and he still passed her it just shows how some examiners do slide things.

Hitting the curb isn't an automatic fail. If you hit it slightly or bump against it you don't fail, you'd get a minor and the examiner would probably tell you at the end of the test to be more aware of where the curb is. It becomes a major if you hit it with force or you mount it as they're both dangerous actions.

eightyfourandahalf · 31/07/2021 11:38

We knew where the driving centre was, but with up to 3 students in the car, 2 in the back with instructors, and taking turn, it was a rather large area that could be covered in the test.

Marmitemarinaded · 31/07/2021 11:32

Don’t waste your time op

You stand no chance. Absolutely NO chance in being successful.

The DVLA will never ever overrule an instructor retrospectively based on a failed candidates complaint

NEVER

Junkmail · 31/07/2021 11:30

During my (second) test (MAJOR faults on my first 🙈) my examiner took me down roads I had never seen and there was a really weird situation with a bus driving on the wrong side of the road and I honestly didn’t know what to do. I got through it safely but genuinely believed I had failed. I actually passed without any faults as the examiner said I handled it well. You don’t know what you’ll encounter either during the test or once you have passed so you need to be prepared to tackle potentially difficult and unfamiliar scenarios. I’m sorry but if you couldn’t deal with figuring out the roadworks you weren’t ready to pass.

EBearhug · 31/07/2021 11:23

I am just envious when in my old days you had no idea where you would end up.

I'm not sure that's entirely true - we couldn't look up the routes, but I took my test in a fairly small town, and we all knew where the test centre was and which roads were likely to be used for reversing round the corner, emergency stops and so on, because there was a limited choice. I guess it might have been different in larger centres. Mind you, it might have been more realistic to drive out of town, have to manage a herd of cows across the road, following a tractor on a narrow road with high banks and so on...

Thefaceofboe · 31/07/2021 11:21

It’s really shit but I think he was right to fail you as once you’ve passed your test, you are faced with situations like unexpected roadworks all the time. I came across temporary road traffic lights on my driving test, which were stuck on green on both sides so it was chaos with cars trying to push through a one way section. I had absolutely no idea what to do so just put my hand break on with hazards until it was clear of cars both ways, it was a horrible feeling Sad luckily I passed!

AngryWhompingWillow · 31/07/2021 11:20

@Mybabysmylife

I'm so sorry for your experience ... Sounds awful. The examiner sounds soooo rude!

I had a nasty examiner once. So rude and grumpy and a total curmudgeon. This was the late 1990s and he was around 30 years older than me. (I was mid 20s.) Thing is, his attitude was so bad towards me, that I was nervous and anxious before I started.

He kept commenting negatively on everything I was doing, and said 'WHY are you driving so SLOWLY?!' when I was doing 25 in a 30 zone! Confused And he said - and this is the truth - though it's hard to believe now 'THIS is why I am so against WOMEN driving!' and sighed heavily, and turned away from me. He then proceeded to look out of the passenger window and not look at me, or what I was doing for the other 50% of the test.

When we got to the driving school, he sat there and scribbled on a sheet for a few minutes, and then said 'you have FAILED the test of competence to drive!' and practically threw the FAIL sheet at me.

I was too shocked to be upset. It was my 4th test, and the worst examiner I had had. When I got back to my instructor, she said 'On noooo, I wanted to CRY when I saw you had got Smithy! He is HORRIBLE. He shouldn't be allowed to do this job. He is SO rude and he does NOT think women should be driving.'

I passed the fifth test 3 months later!!!

Don't worry Mybabymylife I am sure you will be able to get a cancellation.

Good luck next time! Smile

RollaCola84 · 31/07/2021 11:06

@Mybabysmylife
I don't know why people think because someone made one mistake that there a danger and not ready

I would suggest your read the definition of a major fault. You did something potential dangerous and are not ready to be allowed to drive unsupervised. Going into your next test with the attitude that you did nothing wrong and mistakes are inevitable will not help you.

Proudboomer · 31/07/2021 11:01

I have already accepted that I didn’t know that sat navs were now part of the test but we’re not when I passed. But in any event that is pretty ill relevant to the ops fail as she failed on her driving and nothing to do with having a sat nav or not. I was just curious as to why it was mentioned and then someone pointed out it was part of the test.

There are still drivers who don’t use them. I rarely do and usually only if going somewhere unknown at night.

HalzTangz · 31/07/2021 10:59

[quote Mybabysmylife]@RollaCola84.

I got 4 minors 1 major. I was 6 minutes away from my test finishing anyway. The examiner said to my instructor that other than the pause waiting in the road works I would of passed and that I can drive fine. I was shocked by this as he was such an arse before hand. Your telling me I'm a danger to the road and I didn't pass for this. There was one person infront of me no-one behind me I was causing and obstruction I wasn't in anyone's way. I was waiting for the first person to go ( he shouldn't of stopped) my own fault for copying him but in my own defence there wasn't anyone there to be a danger to.[/quote]
You got a major, you failed because of a major, so although most of your driving was fine, you still performed a section dangerously, so no you aren't safe driver.
Instead of complaining make sure your instructor teaches you what you should have done in that scenario so you pass next time round

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 31/07/2021 10:59

Look on the bright side - after more practice you’ll be that much safer to drive when you do pass.

That’s what I told dds anyway - it took them both 3 goes to pass.

feelingmehtoday · 31/07/2021 10:54

@CounsellorTroi

Why did you have a sat nag on during a driving test?

Love the sound of a sat nag.

“Turn left in 500 yards on to x road”
“Don’t forget to turn left after 400 yards”
“Remember you have to turn left after 300 yards and you should have your indicator on by now”

😂
LumpyandBumps · 31/07/2021 10:52

@Mybabysmylife

My daughter passed her test earlier this month.

Mybabysmylife · 31/07/2021 10:52

@MsHardy hi!! Thankyou for your
Comment, I have paid for 2 different websites that get cancellations. It's gone from 13th December to 17th novemeber so far. Hoping to
Get a lot closer I'm wanting to get it as soon as possible due to my daughter starting school September.

OP posts:
Mybabysmylife · 31/07/2021 10:50

@LumpyandBumps Thankyou so much! It's disgraceful the comments on here such as " glad you didn't pass" absolutely vile people. But yes my instructor said the same about this certain instructor! Also, my friend had a lovely instructor and she hit the curb and he still passed her it just shows how some examiners do slide things.

I have paid for the Driving cancellations NOW app my test has gone from December 13th to November 17th! Can you tell me when you last used the app? Was it recently during Covid? Thankyou:)

OP posts:
MsHardy · 31/07/2021 10:47

You can download apps which automatically check for cancellations for you so that you can rebook your test for sooner if a slot comes up. I was in same boat as you and desperate as needed to pass sooner got work purposes - managed to get a test 3 weeks away instead of 3 months!

Clocktopus · 31/07/2021 10:45

*test

Clocktopus · 31/07/2021 10:45

Part of driving is dealing with unexpected hazards like roadworks or accidents that force you to divert elsewhere or do things differently.

Exactly this. You need to show that you can react appropriately to evolving situations because that's safe driving. On my driving test I took a wrong turning, I went off a roundabout at the third exit instead of the fourth but I did the roundabout and exiting it correctly and then followed the new road (which was unfamiliar to me) correctly so didn't fail for it.

When driving you have to be able to quickly evaluate a situation, plan what action you'll take, and then safely execute it all within a short space of time, often within seconds. If you don't demonstrate that on the test then they're not going to pass you. They don't know that you're ordinarily a good driver, they just have to base it off that short window where they do see you drive. I know it's disappointing but you probably need to chalk it up to experience and try again, at least your next yest can't be any worse.

LumpyandBumps · 31/07/2021 10:45

You have my sympathy.

My daughter had a bad experience on her first test.

I don’t think her instructor realised she was going to get a particular examiner as when he walked by her instructor said ‘that one is a misery’

She did get him and the examiner turned in his seat and stared at her and kept twitching near the brake. She felt so uncomfortable and it seemed to start a bit of a chain reaction. She hit the kerb when parking, and the test was cut short due to a ‘major’ fault.

Her instructor had described her as one of the best he had ever taught. Whilst we wanted to point out how uncomfortable the examiner had made her to possibly help others, we decided to wait until after she had passed another test.

Of all the bad luck she got him again. He was like a different person, friendly, chatty and much more helpful. She passed.

Maybe he had had a bad day, maybe she was being a bit too confident for a learner on the first occasion, we’ll never know.

The additional stress caused by the backlog in tests makes it even more nerve wracking as so much rests on those 37 minutes.

In answer to your question about whether to complain, I would say no.

Even if it isn’t it sounds like ‘sour grapes’ it can’t change the outcome, it will cause you even more stress in the long run, and would make things awkward if you got the same examiner again.

We used ‘Driving Test Now’ app, enabled auto re booking, and my daughter was lucky enough to get a second test 5 weeks after the first.

Good luck.

Guavafish · 31/07/2021 10:44

Hard luck. It’s frustrating, I’m sure you’ll pass the next time and you learn from your mistakes.

Some people spent hours pressing refresh on the driving test booking page and sometime get luck on booking a test sooner! Good luck to you

Mybabysmylife · 31/07/2021 10:43

@HalzTangz I was very much ready Thankyou. I don't know why people think because someone made one mistake that there a danger and not ready. My mums been driving 25 years and still makes little mistakes it's normal. Doesn't mean I'm not ready?! I've been doing lessons for 1.5 years now 6 months off with Covid. But I did 2hr lessons every week. Sometimes more! Please don't tell me I'm not ready I wouldn't of been told to move my test up if I was such a danger.

OP posts:
Mybabysmylife · 31/07/2021 10:41

@Battleofwhocouldcareless

Don't let it get you down. Lots of people fail their test, keep practising and you'll get there. I had no major faults in my first test but examiner said I was hesitant and unobservant. He was right, I needed more time behind the wheel before I took my test. I passed in the end.
Thank you so much for the kind words. I'm back on my lessons now hopefully pass second time round 🙏🏻
OP posts:
HalzTangz · 31/07/2021 10:40

[quote Mybabysmylife]@MrsFin I understand. But you cannot cover 21 test routes when Covid hit every couple of months and forced lockdown so then I was having over 6 month of no lessons etc.[/quote]
Which again demonstrates you weren't ready for your test

Battleofwhocouldcareless · 31/07/2021 10:40

Don't let it get you down. Lots of people fail their test, keep practising and you'll get there. I had no major faults in my first test but examiner said I was hesitant and unobservant. He was right, I needed more time behind the wheel before I took my test. I passed in the end.