Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Think You Don’t Need Carbs With Shepherds Pie?

115 replies

CurryLover55 · 30/07/2021 21:43

Looking at a thread on Facebook asking for accompaniments to shepherds pie and loads of people were suggesting things like garlic bread, roast potatoes, chips, Yorkies etc. All quite heavy when the dish already has mash on top. Somebody even suggested coleslaw! ( And yes I know that’s not carbs!) If I have shepherd’s pie, all I serve with it is peas or another green vegetable.

OP posts:
TheUnexpectedPickle · 31/07/2021 00:50

I really REALLY want shephards pie now.

For me, the pie is topped with cheddar mash and served with savoy cabbage an loads of gravy, to be mopped up with buttered bread at the end.

I do get Yorkshires though- its just the same as having them on a roast dinner with potatoes.

Never had it with pickled cabbage, I'm all over that suggestion!!

I love a carb, but I can never get my head around chips with pasta. Frankie and Bennys always offer chips or salad with their pasta. No way could I eat a load of chips with pasta! And as a teen I worked in the BHS canteen- people wound get macaroni cheese with chips and garlic bread! Same with lasagne or cottage pie. Madness!

JohnnyLuLus · 31/07/2021 00:38

Definitely don't need more carbs with shepherd's pie.

But I knew someone who ate lasagne sandwiched between two slices of white bread. Grim.

Totallydefeated · 31/07/2021 00:36

Coleslaw?! Completely the wrong register.

I like it with a green veg like broccoli or runner beans or green beans, to liven it up a bit. I find it a bit dull by itself.

PattyPan · 31/07/2021 00:31

Yanbu, cabbage or something like that on the side but garlic bread, chips, and roast potatoes belong nowhere near a shepherds/cottage pie and I say that as an otherwise big fan of all of them. And people who think it goes with coleslaw should be banned from cooking 🤢

Pieceofpurplesky · 31/07/2021 00:30

Has to be topped with potato, carrot and swede mash and a sprinkle of cheese too. Peas on the side as they get too squishy cooked in it.

I have had chips with it in a pub once and it was delicious. Wouldn't do it at home though.

CorvusPurpureus · 31/07/2021 00:25

I'd go with green veg - steamed broccoli or spinach.

Admittedly I'd probably be the only one eating the sides. I'd probably add frozen peas for the greens refusers.

There's shitloads of stealth veg in my shepherd's pie to start with, mind you! I'm probably blurring the cottage pie boundaries here because it's generally made from left over beef chilli, which is made with homemade tomato sauce, which incorporates the contents of the fridge.

Notonthestairs · 31/07/2021 00:17

Salad with Shepherds Pie?

Timetoreflect · 31/07/2021 00:16

For my son I’d do a couple of Yorkies too but the only other side i’d serve is buttered and braised cabbage

SpindleWhorl · 31/07/2021 00:13

People have lost sight of what normal portions of food-related clichés look like in this country.

WingingItSince1973 · 31/07/2021 00:02

@Xmassprout

My husband sometimes has buttered bread with his, i don't normally have anything else
Oh yes thats delicious 😋
PizzaPiePizzaPie · 30/07/2021 23:52

I’d have broccoli. More for the change in the texture. It’s all too soft otherwise.

DHs family would have chips and bread with it 🤢

Dogoodfeelgood · 30/07/2021 23:44

Totally agree with you! I like it with a simple salad like iceberg lettuce and cherry tomatoes.

Maskless · 30/07/2021 23:42

Whilst broadly correct, you lack knowledge.

Peas are not a vegetable. They are legumes and they are carbs.

Coleslaw is mainly carbs -- cabbage, carrots and onions are all carbs.

mafted · 30/07/2021 23:26

Garlic bread?! The dirty bastards Grin

I just serve greens with Shepherds pie. Although I make roast and mashed potatoes with a roast dinner because just roast potato is stingy and disappointing IMO.

KingdomScrolls · 30/07/2021 23:22

I either put. Finely diced carrots , mushrooms, leeks/onions in with the mince with a mashed potato top or forego the carrots and top it with carrot swede and potato mash. Always served with green veg. My DF loves it with COLD baked beans and a slice of bread. That's not how it gets served up and he'll happily eat the veg, but if there are leftovers in the freezer and DM's out for the evening I can guarantee that's what he'll have for dinner.

shas19 · 30/07/2021 23:19

I could eat potatoes till the sun was splitting the trees but not with shepherds pie. Crusty buttered bread tho!

TheLoveOfMoney · 30/07/2021 23:16

There are carbs in every food, peas are quite carby, if you want zero carbs you're left with water.

hellcatspangle · 30/07/2021 23:13

Just have veg with mine

Titsywoo · 30/07/2021 23:05

@MockneyReject

I don't get the no roast potatoes with mashed, thing. Surely, you don't have just roast potatoes with, say, a big Sunday dinner? I always do both roast and mashed. I thought that was perfectly normal. Similarly, I would do roast potatoes with (vegetarian version) of Shepherd's/cottage pie. And veg, of course.
I think that is quite unusual - I would only do roast potatoes with a roast dinner. Mash I do with stews or something like beef wellington. I know quite a lot of people do roasties and mash for a special occasion like xmas.
Belledan1 · 30/07/2021 22:59

I put onions, mushrooms, carrots and peas with the mince. If I am trying to not to have too much carbs I make my portion with a small bit of mash mixed with carrots and swede on top. Normally serve it with broccoli. Family have normal mash. . Dont like it with beans but each to own. Friend does it with beans and makes mash really cheesy.

Looubylou · 30/07/2021 22:47

Carrots and peas and extra gravy. However, I have had it with chips in a canteen and it was divine.

StevieNix · 30/07/2021 22:42

Ynbu, I bloody love carbs but I wouldn’t have any extra with shepherds/cottage pie as there is mash on top obviously. I usually do something like broccoli on the side as there’s peas and carrots in the filling.
Husband likes baked beans with his, and if he’s starving he has been known to grab a slice of buttered bread with it but I wouldn’t serve bread with it as standard.

MartyHart · 30/07/2021 22:42

Pickled red cabbage and carrot and swede. Also gravy.

MockneyReject · 30/07/2021 22:38

I don't get the no roast potatoes with mashed, thing. Surely, you don't have just roast potatoes with, say, a big Sunday dinner? I always do both roast and mashed. I thought that was perfectly normal. Similarly, I would do roast potatoes with (vegetarian version) of Shepherd's/cottage pie. And veg, of course.

NotMyCat · 30/07/2021 22:33

HP sauce, pickled cabbage. Maybe a slice of crusty bread and butter for mopping