Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Think You Don’t Need Carbs With Shepherds Pie?

115 replies

CurryLover55 · 30/07/2021 21:43

Looking at a thread on Facebook asking for accompaniments to shepherds pie and loads of people were suggesting things like garlic bread, roast potatoes, chips, Yorkies etc. All quite heavy when the dish already has mash on top. Somebody even suggested coleslaw! ( And yes I know that’s not carbs!) If I have shepherd’s pie, all I serve with it is peas or another green vegetable.

OP posts:
CurryLover55 · 31/07/2021 07:47

I love baked beans in a cottage pie

OP posts:
Uyli · 31/07/2021 07:28

@MrsClatterbuck

No to any extra carbs but just green veg like peas or cabbage etc. Never understood why people have bread and butter with fish and chips when you already have 2 carbs with the chips and the batter. Though I do like chips with my lasagne
Bread or bun on the side to make a chip butty is a life essential with fish and chips!
BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2021 07:11

Maybe it's not about what people 'need' and more about what they like to eat?

It doesn't necessarily mean that people are eating more or it's going to make them overweight. Plus some people have active jobs or lifestyles and need the carbs/calories.

Also chips and cottage pie or lasagne and garlic bread just add variety and its nice to have something to mop up gravy, sauce etc.

People seem to forget that cottage/shepherds pie are traditional meals made to use up the end of the Sunday roast and you need extras to make it go round. It comes from a time where people couldn't afford a meal made mostly of meat.

Vicliz24 · 31/07/2021 06:34

You definitely don't need to but I confess that the once or twice a year I do shepherds pie it's served with home made chips and lathered In gravy. That's just the way we like it and as we have it so rarely it's the way I'm sticking with Smile

itsgettingwierd · 31/07/2021 06:25

I don't make shepherds pie.

But for all those sniffing at coleslaw - I have it with lasagne!

It's Devine 😋

Lampzade · 31/07/2021 06:16

YanBU
Should be eaten with vegetables

MrsClatterbuck · 31/07/2021 06:14

No to any extra carbs but just green veg like peas or cabbage etc. Never understood why people have bread and butter with fish and chips when you already have 2 carbs with the chips and the batter.
Though I do like chips with my lasagne

Aprilx · 31/07/2021 06:12

I have it by itself. If I were to have something with it, then it would be a vegetable (but not more potato).

sashh · 31/07/2021 05:56

No carbs.

I made one yesterday, it had peas and corn in it so I had nothing on the side. If I'd not added veg then I would put them as a side.

I mix the veg in the pie so sometimes it's carrots and peas.

HyacinthsHydrangeas · 31/07/2021 05:28

Another pairing that similarly makes me go “wtf” is serving pasta with garlic bread. People always seem to be serving garlic bread alongside spaghetti or lasagna or whatever and I just think…was this meal brought to us by wheat lobbyists?

Feather12 · 31/07/2021 04:20

If I have shepherd’s pie, all I serve with it is peas or another green vegetable.
Peas have a similar amount of carbs as bread though.

Mockolate · 31/07/2021 03:42

Yorkshire puddings belong on Sunday dinners, not with Shepherds pie and also Northern lol
Shepherds pie belongs with peas.

IJustLikeBiscuitsOK · 31/07/2021 03:38

We have Yorkshire puddings and extra gravy with ours, we are Northern Heathens tho.

notangelinajolie · 31/07/2021 03:14

Shepherd's Pie = lamb. I always serve lamb with peas

Hydrate · 31/07/2021 03:14

@Blinkingheckythump

Who the f has salad with cottage pie?! Salad with gravy? No I refuse to accept this. It's on par with coleslaw and gravy. Nope no no. I usually serve mine without a side as it's got meat, veg and potato in it. It's an entire meal. Always with cheese on and extra gravy mind. I'm bloody hungry now 😹
We have the salad first, in a salad bowl, not on the same plate with the hot food. Grin
RatsolutelyFabulous · 31/07/2021 03:11

The veg gets mixed in with the mince, it’s an all in one meal? Why add veg on the side when you can just include it? I always add peas, carrots, broccoli and cauliflower in mine.

If I was having anything on the side, it would be Yorkshire puddings. Although, my dad once made a banging Shepard’s pie for my birthday and put cauli cheese on top of the mash, it was unreal and you can’t forget lots of thick gravy either Grin

Blinkingheckythump · 31/07/2021 03:01

Who the f has salad with cottage pie?! Salad with gravy? No I refuse to accept this. It's on par with coleslaw and gravy. Nope no no.
I usually serve mine without a side as it's got meat, veg and potato in it. It's an entire meal. Always with cheese on and extra gravy mind. I'm bloody hungry now 😹

Spidey66 · 31/07/2021 02:46

No you just need veg. The mash is the carb.

noodlezoodle · 31/07/2021 02:38

@NeverDropYourMooncup

If they need to add extra carbs, they've completely failed at the Sufficient Mash stage.

Should be carrots, steamed swede, peas, cabbage or any other veg to provide a counterpoint to the rich, oniony, thick gravy, meat and the mounds of billowing, fluffy mashed potatoes.

That description makes me think you're either Nigella or Dervla Kirwen using her best M&S advert voice.

It also made me very hungry Grin

Mockolate · 31/07/2021 02:29

If we have shepherds pie here it's usually with peas and salad.

alibongo5 · 31/07/2021 01:08

@Notonthestairs

Salad with Shepherds Pie?
Totally agree. Absolute heresy.
Grenlei · 31/07/2021 01:05

DP likes to put his in a sandwich 😂 but aside from that no other carbs.

In fact when I'm eating more healthily than I am now, I make the top from a mix of swede, carrot and squashes rather than potato. Served with lots of leafy green veg.

PlasticEgg · 31/07/2021 01:04

Unacceptable eating choices such as this is exactly why the glorious + heroic NHS is on its knees. ON ITS KNEES.

echt · 31/07/2021 00:59

Not RTFT, but vegetables of all kinds are carbs.

WineInTheBlood · 31/07/2021 00:53

Yeah YANBU - it's already pure delicious stodge, it would never occur to me to add more carbs.