Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compulsory lids in public toilets?

36 replies

ChinkBlink · 30/07/2021 21:10

I don't know if this is a Covid legacy, or if it started earlier, but motorway service stations, shopping centres, etc have been installing compulsory toilet lids ... compulsory because you can't flush the toilet unless the lid is down. This is apparently to protect our delicate health from those pesky 'aerosols' that threaten us whenever we flush our pee away with fresh water. Anyone else hate these, or just me?

  1. I can't see whether the toilet is clean or not before I commit to a cubicle ... who knows what horrors will lurk beneath the lid when I open it!
  2. A lot of people use tissue to flush public loos, not their fingers, then throw the tissue into the loo as it flushes. But now they can't because the lid is closed so there are increased piles of tissue on the floor.
  3. If the lid is closed, how do you know if it flushed properly? Unless they somehow managed to invent a toilet that flushes succesfully every time, will you be lifting the lid to check before you leave? Hmm
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
troobleflooble · 31/07/2021 15:40

I was really fastidious about shutting the lid before flushing and still am about toilet hygiene in general. To the extent that even as a child I would refuse to use a toilet I deemed too dirty much to my mom's embarrassment

But I watched a programme a few years back that did tests on toothbrushes to see if they really did contain faecal particles or if it's an urban myth. It's not, and there are particles that come out when you flush but this happens with lid up or down. They also found faecal particles on a control toothbrush, fresh out of the packet and never used, in another room down the hallway from the test toilet. So apparently the buggers are everywhere and you can't really avoid them 😂

TheSmallAssassin · 31/07/2021 15:21

People do poo in public toilets too, you know. This stops faecal matter being sprayed around the cubicle, so I think it's a step forward, especially in service stations which are travel hubs, lots of people coming from different directions and travelling to other places. I think they mostly have non touch flushes, too?

Createdjustforthis · 31/07/2021 11:23

But why, given the evidence of particles being propelled would you leave the lid up in a shared toilet? It’s absolutely disgusting.

Spidey66 · 31/07/2021 11:02

@Createdjustforthis

Only dirty sods flush with the lid up. It’s disgusting.

And the faffing around with bits of tissue is ridiculous. Just wash your hands properly.

That'll be me then!

I'm happy to be a dirty sod, thanks, as I said 55 years of flushing without the lid down has resulted in a strong immunity. I'm not going to start now.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2021 10:35

I think the point with these toilets is that they're far less likely to be blocked, due to the pressure used to remove the waste.

I've certainly never found one. And I've probably used more service station toilets this month than many people on here in the last five years.

LindaEllen · 31/07/2021 10:31

@XenoBitch

YANBU How on earth did we survive as a species before toilet lids? I don't recall ever seeing one on a public loo, especially the metal ones. I like to have a glance to see the toilet is not blocked etc before parking my arse on it.
I mean, you do realise that as we've developed hygiene systems, health and life span have both improved, right? Think back to Tudor times when people just threw excrement from their windows into the street .. it wasn't the healthiest, was it? Plagues galore!
Createdjustforthis · 31/07/2021 10:18

Only dirty sods flush with the lid up. It’s disgusting.

And the faffing around with bits of tissue is ridiculous. Just wash your hands properly.

CarnationCat · 31/07/2021 10:13

I hate public toilets, before COVID and now. Shopping centre toilets are always filthy and you're guaranteed to find an absolute state in the cubicle you choose. Touching the lid to open it makes me want to heave. Someone has just wiped them self and closed the lid. I want to touch as little as possible.

CounsellorTroi · 31/07/2021 10:07

And with the new ones I think they are vacuum flushed like on aircraft so there is no spray.

CounsellorTroi · 31/07/2021 10:05

@ChinkBlink

I don't know if this is a Covid legacy, or if it started earlier, but motorway service stations, shopping centres, etc have been installing compulsory toilet lids ... compulsory because you can't flush the toilet unless the lid is down. This is apparently to protect our delicate health from those pesky 'aerosols' that threaten us whenever we flush our pee away with fresh water. Anyone else hate these, or just me?
  1. I can't see whether the toilet is clean or not before I commit to a cubicle ... who knows what horrors will lurk beneath the lid when I open it!
  2. A lot of people use tissue to flush public loos, not their fingers, then throw the tissue into the loo as it flushes. But now they can't because the lid is closed so there are increased piles of tissue on the floor.
  3. If the lid is closed, how do you know if it flushed properly? Unless they somehow managed to invent a toilet that flushes succesfully every time, will you be lifting the lid to check before you leave? Hmm
Re your fist point, I always lift the lid after flushing to check it’s clean, and leave it open so the next user can see it’s clean.
ActonSquirrel · 31/07/2021 10:01

Your hand bag is more at risk if the loo has been flushed with the lid up

ActonSquirrel · 31/07/2021 10:00

@k1233

If the loo has been flushed with the lid down, the lid and seat are covered in the maximum amount of aerosolised human waste. You touch that before sitting down and wiping. I don't know anyone who lifts the lid, goes and washes their hands, then goes back to the cubicle. So you pretty much have ground zero, stranger microwaste on your hands and on your butt cheeks. Hope you don't touch your face while you're sitting down, lord help you if you have a handbag with you.
And yet no one died from touching a toilet seat lid. You wash your hands after. You don't put your butt cheeks in your mouth or touch anything with them.

You shower later. What's the issue

k1233 · 31/07/2021 09:54

If the loo has been flushed with the lid down, the lid and seat are covered in the maximum amount of aerosolised human waste. You touch that before sitting down and wiping. I don't know anyone who lifts the lid, goes and washes their hands, then goes back to the cubicle. So you pretty much have ground zero, stranger microwaste on your hands and on your butt cheeks. Hope you don't touch your face while you're sitting down, lord help you if you have a handbag with you.

ActonSquirrel · 31/07/2021 08:24

@NiceGerbil

I hate compulsory lid down.

In s public bog I want to see if it's covered in shit/ blocked with bog roll without having to touch then!

I have no idea why this has become a thing.

If the loo has been flushed with the lid up then everything you touch and sit on is covered on particles of other people's shit and piss as the flush sprays it everywhere.

It's widely known and hasn't become a thing recently. Enjoy.

NiceGerbil · 31/07/2021 02:57

I hate compulsory lid down.

In s public bog I want to see if it's covered in shit/ blocked with bog roll without having to touch then!

I have no idea why this has become a thing.

Toesies · 31/07/2021 02:51

This shouldn't be an issue. Lids are better for everyone's health. You won't be hit with icky particles when you flush! If you need to check if it's clean before you sit, simply lift the lid first.

I've always closed the lid before I flush. I can't imagine doing otherwise. THERE IS A REASON FOR THEM.

user1473878824 · 31/07/2021 02:46

I hate the lifting the seat in case of a surprise but you should always put the lid down on any loo before flushing. If you WASH YOUR HANDS AFTER YOU USE THE LOO like an adult then problem solved on the germs front.

Spidey66 · 31/07/2021 02:40

They've been there ages.

Those are the only loos I put the lid down to flush. I'm not a candidate for How Clean is Your House, but I don't worry too much about germs. I'm one of those who subscribes to the school of thought that believes a few germs are good for your immunity. My health isn't perfect-im having my gallbladder out next week and I've recently had the first of two cataracts out. But I very rarely have infectious diseases. The last time I had a cold for instance was nearly 2 years ago!

Stompythedinosaur · 31/07/2021 02:24

Having the lid down is much more hygienic.

Notebooksarefabulous · 31/07/2021 02:21

I dont get it - why do people use tissue just to press the flush? Arent you straight away going to exit the cubicle (touching the lock with those fingers you so carefully protected just seconds ago) and wash your hands?

I do get the need to be able to see under the lid though......... ewwww what might be underneath!!
Not the fretting about the spread of fecal matter though - if its such a major problem people who dont fuss about closing the lid to prevent fecal spread......... would be ill frequently which is definately not the case ime.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2021 02:12

These toilets have been service stations for years, I've never found one that's not clean and I've used them a lot because I travel for work and sometimes need them multiple times a day.

They save water and reduce aerosols but still the Mumsnet hygiene crazies find fault with them.

As long as you wash your hands after flushing, how does it matter if you touch the lid or the flush?

And those wasteful people who are unnecessarily using toilet paper as a barrier and throwing it on the floor should be ashamed of themselves. Just why?

Half the world doesn't even have access to modern flushing toilets and there are people in this country who take them for granted to the degree that they get this precious over using them. Embarrassing.

How about next time you're in there, instead of fretting about such a non issue, you have a good read of the charity poster on the back of the door that's in many service station toilet about the young African girl dealing with having a period with no clean underwear, sanitary protection, or clean, safe, private facilities and appreciate how privileged we are compared to her.

k1233 · 31/07/2021 01:37

And the 4th issue to me us actually touching the germ laden lid. Ok in your own home but who knows what germs are in public toilets.

The flushing. Fuck me, it can take walking in and out of 4 cubicles at work until a clean toilet is found. Makes me so angry. It's not hard to make sure the toilet is clean before you walk out.

mustlovegin · 30/07/2021 23:02

YANBU, but I'm happy just to have public toilets Confused

PopAyetheSailorMam · 30/07/2021 22:48

The water savings are considerable for the operating sites. propelair.com/

wantmorenow · 30/07/2021 22:37

Aerosol reduction is a great leap forward in hygiene

YABU.