Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be inspired by the 'you can have it all' mums

166 replies

user6767 · 30/07/2021 15:29

Sorry my title sounds very negative this is not to have a go at other mums. It's come from me hearing a lot about Helen Glover who has done great at the Olympics recently and has 3 children under 3 and also worked as a junior doctor. I have seen quit afew comments about it shows mums you can do anything you want/the you can have it all comments etc.

I am not having a go at Helen Glover she has done amazing! But it's almost like that is the 'ideal'. That mums should all inspire to. I just don't agree. In order for her to do that she has spent a lot of time away from her children. I quite simply do not want to be away from my children so much. I work part time as it's a good balance for my situation. But I have often had comments about how I have stalled my career. I quite simply don't care I want that time with my children.

I am not having a go at others mothers nor do I think there is nothing wrong with working full time as a mum. I just wish my situation wasn't seen as a negative and that I'm not achieving my full potential.

I'm not articulating myself very well and will probably get flamed for this Blush. AIBU?

OP posts:
Waveafterwaveslowlydrifting · 30/07/2021 17:57

Having it all = doing it all.

No thanks

Comedycook · 30/07/2021 17:54

Someone has to do all the jobs associated with caring for children. If you are highly successful in your career, male or female it just means you're paying someone else to do it

Yes exactly

ZombieEthel · 30/07/2021 17:52

I think people are really misinterpreting the PR about Helen Glover and why people find her inspiring. It's not 'mums can be Olympians too', which one PP has stated. It's more like 'Olympians can be mums too'.

She's not a mum who became an Olympian. She's an Olympian who became a mum and then trained hard to go back, which is a rare and incredible achievement.

doadeer · 30/07/2021 17:52

The thing is... Someone has to do all the jobs associated with caring for children. If you are highly successful in your career, male or female it just means you're paying someone else to do it... And for many of this I'm not sure this is always aspirational. I want to (as does DH) care for my child. I don't want to miss all those little moments. I have taken a big career stagnation as I care for my son who had additional needs, but I wouldn't choose it another way. So... No im not hugely inspired by these stories because it's not the way I would want to parent.

Echobelly · 30/07/2021 17:42

YANBU - and I don't think you're having a go at all Helen Glover, you're just saying that how she's done things in her life can't suit every mum and you don't like it being suggested that every mum can do what she did. And it is annoying when someone is held up (and it's not their fault) as though 'anyone could do this', just the same as when you get 'This family lives on 3p a week and uses vouchers and special offers to buy everything'. I mean, one can do that, but it's one hell of a lot of work.

EssentialHummus · 30/07/2021 17:37

It's self-evident to me that being an Olympian in any sport requires enormous sacrifice / moulding your own and perhaps your family's life around training and competitions. I'm not a sportsperson in the slightest but I'm delighted for everyone (of both sexes) who's won a medal or "just" had the chance to represent their country.

But I'm not sure that inspires me tbh. In much the same way that seeing friends who live their lives/allocate their resources very differently from me doesn't inspire me. Sometime they pique my interest or curiosity, but for the most part I feel like there are so many ways to live one's life, and so many different individual and family circumstances going on in the background, that there's no point getting out the cat o' nine tails because someone else has won an Olympic medal after having three kids or (more prosaically) spent the summer crafting with their children, or earning ££££ running a multi-national, or whatever else.

And this:

We also need to recognise that our society still tends to admire this ‘selfishness’ in male athletes — and to see their wives picking up the slack as natural — but is far more ambivalent about women prioritising achievement in any field above their offspring, and correspondingly magnifies the sacrifice of their husbands.

TooStressyTooMessy · 30/07/2021 17:37

Totally agree OP. It’s hard enough to be a mum and now we have a media narrative that we should all be able to be Olympic athletes. As if there wasn’t enough pressure on us. Having it all is bollocks. You can have it all (maybe, I’m not even sure I believe that actually) just not at the same time. Anyone who ‘has it all’ either has a ridiculously flexible job, incredible childcare or is sacrificing a vast amount of sleep.

Langy654321 · 30/07/2021 17:35

Userchange - Yours sounds like my ideal have it all envy - but maybe not for those that like to work alongside others, work one to one in a people facing role.

Teacupsandtoast · 30/07/2021 17:25

This article is quite balanced. She basically sacrificed the first half of the year to be at the Olympics - www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/sport/2021/jul/29/no-fairytale-finish-but-helen-glover-focuses-on-reward-of-giving-her-all

Comedycook · 30/07/2021 17:22

@Twokitstwokats

Have you seen the documentary on iplayer? She explains how she gets up to train while the kids are still in bed, and again in their naptime.
Fair enough and good for her. When my DC napped I used that time to catch up on housework!
userchange902 · 30/07/2021 17:21

I was talking about mothers/fathers in general......that it’s impossible to have it all in situations where one works 50 hours a week (as a random example) because time with their children is sacrificed for that. And vice versa.

Which is why I think my flexible, WFH, 37 hour a week senior management role is a really good balance. Whenever people want to say "you can't have it all" they always dramatise the working parent, as if the only way to have a successful is career is to work 50 hours a week.

Langy654321 · 30/07/2021 17:21

Just do you, I feel this pressure to but it’s best to do a 360 and wonder if their version of being content is your own.

For example you’d have to be very adaptable to networking in some areas of success but that would burn me out as it does not fit with my personality. Best to just say ‘good for them’ and look at what you are happy with in your own life and take parts you admire which you can apply to yourself.

Twokitstwokats · 30/07/2021 17:20

Have you seen the documentary on iplayer? She explains how she gets up to train while the kids are still in bed, and again in their naptime.

Mum21031608 · 30/07/2021 17:19

where did the 50hr week come from?

I wasn’t referring to her specifically.

I was talking about mothers/fathers in general......that it’s impossible to have it all in situations where one works 50 hours a week (as a random example) because time with their children is sacrificed for that. And vice versa.

Jangle33 · 30/07/2021 17:18

I think she is fantastic. Good on her for achieving so much. We should been aspiring for our daughters to have everything they want!

Comedycook · 30/07/2021 17:18

where did the 50hr week come from? I'd be surprised if she trained more than about four hours a day. I know most professional runners do about that

Ok but if this hypothetical four hours is true, you need childcare for fours hours then. You can't look after multiple children while doing that. No one can do everything at once

museumum · 30/07/2021 17:15

@Mum21031608

YANBU.

You cannot want to spend as much time with your children as possible alongside working a 50 hour week.

It’s not possible.

I have worked part time since my first son was born (he’s now almost 8) so I could be present in his life, and I have a four year old son too.

I’ve recently got a new job which will mean increasing my hours and I’m already dreading the thought of seeing my children less.

Work and children.....in some ways, one always has to suffer for the sake of the other.

where did the 50hr week come from? I'd be surprised if she trained more than about four hours a day. I know most professional runners do about that.
Mum21031608 · 30/07/2021 17:07

YANBU.

You cannot want to spend as much time with your children as possible alongside working a 50 hour week.

It’s not possible.

I have worked part time since my first son was born (he’s now almost 8) so I could be present in his life, and I have a four year old son too.

I’ve recently got a new job which will mean increasing my hours and I’m already dreading the thought of seeing my children less.

Work and children.....in some ways, one always has to suffer for the sake of the other.

Scottishskifun · 30/07/2021 17:05

Personally I think women should do what they want and not have to worry about the judgement but that's an ideal world.

For some reason people feel it's acceptable to comment on other people's family life and their set up whatever that is and whatever they are doing.

I don't know if its because for some people they have a level of insecurity so feel the need to defend themselves or judge others. The one I hate the most is "it's the kids I feel sorry for" or "I could never let strangers raise my child 🙄"

I don't give a toss what someone's family set up is as long as they are happy and their children are happy/content. What works for one doesn't work for another!

My DH works PT and loves it I work FT yet its only me that gets the comments..... I usually reply with isn't his dad a parent too with childcare responsibilities..... They soon get flustered and shut up!

Comedycook · 30/07/2021 17:04

This reminds me of a couple we are friends with. They had twins and mum was back to working full time a couple of months after they were born. She wfh. DH was telling me all about it saying how amazing it was. So I asked him "who is looking after the twins?". He said that he presumed she was Hmm. I said nonsense, you can't work full time and look after twin babies... someone must be looking after them. The mum doesn't have super powers...he was insistent she must have been. What a load of crap...she must have had some form of childcare in place. Nothing wrong with that but I was mightily pissed off at my DHS assumption that she was doing it all.

Pieceofpurplesky · 30/07/2021 17:04

She is able as she has a supportive family, a husband who is in a career where he can be flexible around filming etc, they are clearly quite well off which allows her to take time off work. Yet she has been amazing to get back to the Olympics. A real family team effort.

To me the star of the show has been Beth Shriever who worked as a TA and had to raise money, crowdfund etc. as women's BMX riders do not get funding. She won gold.

I admire all of these women. Some have it easier than others - but all no doubt give it their all. We are all different, with different priorities. Doesn't mean we love our kids more or less

DingDongThongs · 30/07/2021 17:00

I've 3 kids. I'm never alone. Can't remember being alone. Can't even have a bath let alone have a swim. Sigh...Fair play to Helen Glover.

Need babysitter.

user6767 · 30/07/2021 16:56

@GoodVibesHere

If a man had achieved this I don't think the media would make such a huge thing of the home life/kids situation.

What she has done is amazing, but it does feel a little bit like the media are trying to make out that there is 'no excuse' for mums. Like holding her up as an example as if to say 'you can all get fit just weeks after childbirth, if only you make the effort'.

This is what I'm trying to say. You have worded it so much better.
OP posts:
Formaldeheidi · 30/07/2021 16:55

[quote MrsTerryPratchett]Do yourself a favour and Google Man Who Has It All. It shows the utter nonsense of this. manwhohasitallshop.com/[/quote]
I bought DH a t-shirt from there.
He was thrilled Grin

user6767 · 30/07/2021 16:55

@Dyrne

“I’m not having a go”

[Insert 3 separate digs about a woman daring to spend some time apart from her children]

I think that's the issue there isn't a way of saying it without sounding like I am calling someone else I'm not.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread