Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be inspired by the 'you can have it all' mums

166 replies

user6767 · 30/07/2021 15:29

Sorry my title sounds very negative this is not to have a go at other mums. It's come from me hearing a lot about Helen Glover who has done great at the Olympics recently and has 3 children under 3 and also worked as a junior doctor. I have seen quit afew comments about it shows mums you can do anything you want/the you can have it all comments etc.

I am not having a go at Helen Glover she has done amazing! But it's almost like that is the 'ideal'. That mums should all inspire to. I just don't agree. In order for her to do that she has spent a lot of time away from her children. I quite simply do not want to be away from my children so much. I work part time as it's a good balance for my situation. But I have often had comments about how I have stalled my career. I quite simply don't care I want that time with my children.

I am not having a go at others mothers nor do I think there is nothing wrong with working full time as a mum. I just wish my situation wasn't seen as a negative and that I'm not achieving my full potential.

I'm not articulating myself very well and will probably get flamed for this Blush. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cleocleo16 · 02/08/2021 22:35

I think you're reading too much into it. God- everything offends someone these days.

Qwerty789 · 02/08/2021 20:26

! But it's almost like that is the 'ideal'. That mums should all inspire to. I just don't agree

Why are you trying to pretend anyone has said this? Is it just so you can argue against it?
It's inane.

cleocleo16 · 02/08/2021 20:03

I think it's more you can have it all for those who want it. You can have dcs and a career and achieve other goals if you want to. For many years that wasn't an option.

Sandinmyknickers · 02/08/2021 19:55

Praising someone for their achievements is not a criticism of anyone else.
Are you happy with your life? That's all that matters.
Praising Helen Glover and recognising her achievements does not take away from you and your choices/life happiness

twinklestar2 · 02/08/2021 18:49

@AnotherMarvellousThing I know no one is saying that I can't. I'm just saying what I want 😂😂

Waveafterwaveslowlydrifting · 02/08/2021 18:39

OK I meant fitness instructors really. Mine work really hard doing the full workout at maximum intensity. Never had a PT so I shouldn't have referenced them!

eightyfourandahalf · 02/08/2021 18:35

It's a bit like personal trainers saying it's so easy to fit exercise into your life. Well it is for them, it's their job!

not really, their job is not to exercise themselves, it's to make others exercise. Really not the same at all, and in most cases they can barely do anything.

Waveafterwaveslowlydrifting · 02/08/2021 18:31

Good point.

It's a bit like personal trainers saying it's so easy to fit exercise into your life. Well it is for them, it's their job!

I do quite a bit of exercise BTW. But it's only possible because I work locally to home and can walk, DH works from home and cooks every night, the DCs are old enough to entertain themselves for an hour on weekend mornings or evenings and I have pretty low standards with housework. No show home here.

BlithePilgrim · 02/08/2021 16:07

@Mistressofnone

I'm not the sort who enjoys exercising for fun but wish I was. Helen Glover is. I am content hanging out at home and taking the kids to the park.

DH however, always finds a reason to get stressed on his days off. He goes stir crazy at home, sometimes I send him to work for a few hours to he comes back happier. Some people have energy to burn but my energy is more like kindling.

Horses for courses and all that.

Well, she’s mot, though, is she? Rowing is her job, so it’s not like she’s coming home from working and heading out to train for a triathlon for fun, on top of her day job!
Mistressofnone · 02/08/2021 16:01

I'm not the sort who enjoys exercising for fun but wish I was. Helen Glover is. I am content hanging out at home and taking the kids to the park.

DH however, always finds a reason to get stressed on his days off. He goes stir crazy at home, sometimes I send him to work for a few hours to he comes back happier. Some people have energy to burn but my energy is more like kindling.

Horses for courses and all that.

Moonface123 · 02/08/2021 15:44

But who knows if she has got it all ?

Away from the cameras when she has a gruelling early start is she even thinking " Yes, lucky old me, l have it all ? "
Maybe she is, but to be honest her life sounds like a complete nightmare to me, l prefer the simple, peaceful life, but each to their own.

BettyCarver · 02/08/2021 15:20

Good for Helen Glover. She's achieved remarkable things. I doubt she cares a jot whether the OP finds her inspiring! Do what works for your own family and don't worry about anyone else's.

thepeopleversuswork · 02/08/2021 15:12

It’s weird and dispiriting how people on the thread seem to get some kind of perverse satisfaction from saying they couldn’t leave their children like Helen Glover

Quite. Some of us don't have any choice in the matter.

Globally, its a real privilege to say you couldn't leave your children. Around the world, millions of women have to leave their children in order to work to support their families.

Of course not everyone has to be an Olympian to feel like a success. But I really wish people who are privileged enough to have the choice to not leave their children would have enough nous to realise that some of us don't have that choice.

gogohm · 02/08/2021 15:10

The reality is that you cannot have it all because there's only so many hours in a day and you can't do 2 things at once. Plenty of women have fulfilling careers after having dc but that means either their partner staying home/working around school hours when older or using childcare, this is fine it's a personal choice but it means you have less time with dc. What Helen glover did was return to the sport she was a champion in pre kids with her husband looking after the dc, along with family support and I suspect paid help though Steve backshall didn't mention whether they had a nanny - impressive from a fitness point of view but she made lots of sacrifices, she didn't have it all!

AnotherMarvellousThing · 02/08/2021 14:38

@twinklestar2

I'm not inspired either. Other people can do what they want but I want to spend that time with my DC.
But absolutely no one is stopping you from spending 24/7 with your children. It’s weird and dispiriting how people on the thread seem to get some kind of perverse satisfaction from saying they couldn’t leave their children like Helen Glover, especially when she’s said in interviews she was breastfeeding her twins until April and was only training at home (like every athlete during COVID) until February, so I imagine she saw as much of her children as most working parents with preschoolers this weird year, where everyone’s been largely working from home. Her partner in the boat was training at home and working as a doctor.
twinklestar2 · 02/08/2021 14:22

I'm not inspired either. Other people can do what they want but I want to spend that time with my DC.

eightyfourandahalf · 02/08/2021 14:06

There was a particularly vicious thread a while back against mothers in the military. The problem is people so insecure about their own choices they have to be nasty towards others.

Instead of judging Helen Glover, just use your kids as the excuse for not being an Olympian Grin

eightyfourandahalf · 02/08/2021 14:02

YABU

the key is can.

I quite simply do not want to be away from my children so much and it's fine, you can stay close to your children.

I just wish my situation wasn't seen as a negative and that I'm not achieving my full potential.

everything can be a negative, you just proved it by blaming her for spending a lot of time "away from her children". MN especially is vile against SAHM, working mums are shamed for neglecting their kids.
There's always someone who will comment and be negative.

Who cares.

Seesawmummadaw · 02/08/2021 13:46

I think Helen Glover is amazing. I admire her.

AnotherMarvellousThing · 02/08/2021 13:29

I don't think it's a bad thing to acknowledge that another mother who has no family support, no ability to pay for a nanny or childcare, wouldn't have a chance of achieving what she has. That doesn't detract from her achievements.

But she achieved the financial support (which I assume in her case will have involved funds to help with childcare) because of her sporting achievements, which considerably predate her having children.

Once she was selected for the national team, she was funded by government and lottery sports funding to train. Rowing was her FT job, just as teaching had been before that. She retired to have her children after the last Olympics, but when she flagged herself as available again when the Olympics were postponed, the extremely hard-headed world of elite GB sport (which concentrates funding on those it views as the best medal bets), backed her again because they thought she was a good prospect and funded her again to train FT.

It's a very different situation to Beth Shriever, whose Olympic funding was cut (they decided only to support male riders, as no women had won medals in the last Olympics), so she crowdfunded herself to Tokyo and won gold. Which will (one hopes) mean that future female BMX competitors will be funded like Helen Glover.

ElliottSmithsfingers · 02/08/2021 13:25

I wouldn't worry about it OP. No doubt (like 99.99% of the population) you could spend the rest of your life training for the Olympics or going for that CEO position and not get there. So there's no need to be so angsty.

Twokitstwokats · 02/08/2021 13:20

Here are some facts in case anyone is interested

  • HG is married to Steve Backshall and has sponsorship deals with Petit Filous, Whole Earth, Cotswold Outdoor. She is not short of money.
  • however, she does not work or have a career outside of rowing. She did train as a teacher but has not taught since before the 2012 Olympics. Since having her children and retiring from rowing she is a SAHM. She did have many commitments with the media when her children were small, and her mum accompanied her on the majority of them as a nanny, so she could still breastfeed etc
  • her mum helps out a lot when Steve is away
  • until the European Championships in Italy this year she had never spent a night away from her children
  • she does not get funding for childcare as she is almost always with her children
  • she went to a comprehensive school, no scholarship needed. She excelled in sport and later took up rowing after responding to a talent spotting ad ahead of London 2012
LavenderAskew · 02/08/2021 13:00

I don't aspire to be Helen but I do admire her. That sheer determination and dedication - I don't have it in me.

As for women "having it all" I don't think it's a case of having three under three, being an oymloan and a junior doctor (which she's not, but let's throw it I'm there) but a case of being happy with your lot.

Also (and crucial) not being surrounded by people who expect you to do things with no support.

So in other words if you were working and training and have children you need childcare and not have a husband who expects it to be your responsibility to ensure the children are cared and also you can't expect to be able to spend all your time with your children

thepeopleversuswork · 02/08/2021 12:29

Maybe I'm being over-sensitive but I really hate the "you can't have it all" line of thought.

Partly because, as many people have pointed out, men don't get told they can't "have it all".

But also because I'm a single parent and work FT so I have to "have it all". If I don't have it all my life would unravel. Because there's no-one who can take any of the slack -- financial or otherwise - for me.

When people tut at women that they can't have it all its basically a coded way of saying "you should work less". It makes us single parents feel a bit Hmm. Because some of us don't have the luxury of worrying about whether its bad for our kids to be ambitious. Ambition and hard work is the only way we can survive and provide the best we can for our kids.

Possibly a bit of a derail, but it sticks in the craw when people judge you for wanting to provide for your kids and also care for them. I sometimes wish people would stop and think about this before moralising about whether women are working too much.

Monday26July · 02/08/2021 12:27

@AnotherMarvellousThing

I don't mean she has been born into privilege necessarily, just that she has privilege if she's able to balance having her children cared for alongside training, alongside making an income (which if it's from the rowing is great, it takes away one extra source of stress not having to work at an additional job too, but is also a privilege, being paid to train).

And I don't for a moment expect she's 'unthinking' about her privilege, I suspect she's well aware. She'll have had access to childcare, support and financial backing to achieve what she has and I would be surprised if she doesn't acknowledge that.

I don't think it's a bad thing to acknowledge that another mother who has no family support, no ability to pay for a nanny or childcare, wouldn't have a chance of achieving what she has. That doesn't detract from her achievements.