Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how you deal with foreign names?

279 replies

pocpocpoc · 30/07/2021 14:25

I am going through a bit of soul searching and just trying to understand...

I have a foreign name, which is very short and pretty meaningful to me (I guess all names are meaningful to their owners). I've been with my English DH for over 20 years and no one in his family can get my name right.

Imagine my name was Bjork. The Christmas cards would say: Bork, Biork, Bok, Barca, Orca, Karma, Beth, some random Icelandic-sounding words. Not Bjork. To make it worse, same people use different spellings at different times.

My name is not Bjork, but it is only five letters. It is very easy to check on FB, Whatsapp, LinkedIn, even google. Obviously, I always sign with my correct name when I message them.

To prevent potential lines of questioning, I don't know any of them to be dyslexic, most of them are at least degree educated, most of them work in the types of organisations, where unconscious bias training is compulsory. Many speak foreign (European) languages, they have European cousins and most are reasonably well-travelled. Also, I have observed the family taking spellings very seriously when it comes to Western names. For instance, when DS was born and we gave him a Western name, there was a lot of interest in what specific spelling we would use for him.

We challenged a couple of friendlier relatives. One said that they just find it very very difficult to 'comprehend' my name, because it is so foreign and exotic and just 'doesn't roll off the tongue'. Another one said it was DH's fault for not teaching my name to them properly - DH tried in earlier years and then gave up. Apparently, they didn't realise I took it so personally. Recently, I messaged back a person who yet again got my name wrong giving them the right spelling- I received no response.

Can someone please give me an insight? What do you think is going on? Do you find foreign names difficult? Is it a huge drag to check and potentially copy a spelling of a foreign name? Would you just use a random combination of letters or random foreign-sounding words to address someone?

I want to understand before I judge.

AIBU to find this upsetting?

OP posts:
hulahooper2 · 30/07/2021 16:13

Tbh I find it hard enough to remember familiar names so ‘foreign’ names are even harder to get right

Nengineer · 30/07/2021 16:13

[quote pocpocpoc]@Nengineer

Cripes I think the use of discrimination is a bit loose. Yes thoughtless, obviously irritating but discrimination means me deliberately using the wrong name at a meeting because surely every Muslim is called M. This is why the far left and far right are winning FFSbiscuit

I am trying to not reveal too much here, but what would you say if I told you I am Muslim and 'random foreign words' that are used are actually random Arabic words? Does it change your assessment?

Not trying to stir shit here, really trying to understand.[/quote]
Living in a truly inclusive and respectful Islamic state, I stand by my comment. I would never leave here if I had a choice. It's not a badge, it doesn't trump your opinion.

pocpocpoc · 30/07/2021 16:12

@reluctantbrit

My name is French and also a not that usual French name so even if people speak French or have visited France a lot may not have come across it. In handwriting it can often seen as a totally different spelling.

It is also difficult to say if I am male or female. I lost count of letter and emails address to Mr. to me. Americans also pronounce it in a way I don’t particular like.

I don’t like it but I gave up, I do blame my mum for choosing a name even if I understand her reasoning. I think I just grew a very thick skin.

We took particular care naming DD to avoid all these issues.

I can't blame my family. I have the easiest, most common name in my culture. I never expected it to be a problem here. To be fair, I correspond with a large number of people from different cultures and it is extremely rare for anyone to get my name wrong. I would say 1 out of 300 emails I receive my name is spelt wrongly - and even then it often still makes sense, just an alternative spelling.

I find that it is only my English family that struggle. To think about it, plenty of English people (mums at school, people I met through my hobbies, colleagues, gym buddies) get my name right, so I guess it is not an "English" thing actually.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 30/07/2021 16:12

To think about it, their names are just as random and foreign to me and I learnt them all together with their unique spellings.

Well exactly! Unfortunately I think this kind of attitude is probably more prevalent in native English speakers, because lots of us seem to just consider English to be 'normal' or the default language. And everything else us weird, unpronounceable and therefore far too much effort to bother trying to get right. Hmm

SchrodingersImmigrant · 30/07/2021 16:10

To think about it, their names are just as random and foreign to me and I learnt them all together with their unique spellings.

This is very often missed out in these discussions!

BiBabbles · 30/07/2021 16:07

I can understand some may need more practice at certain names, but especially in writing - even more in texts and emails where we can literally copy-paste a name - it's ridiculously disrespectful to just put in random words and names.

I always check written correspodance and use the name there, even if on the rare occasion someone changes it, I'll start the next one with however they signed off the last one (once had a guy named Edward who used a different variant every time). I don't find it a drag, as I'll likely refer back to the letters or emails from before anyways.

Most annoying for me are the ones that seem to just add in a bunch of letters - random vowels and h usually - or they'll use my actual name until they see it written down, and then use a vaguely similar looking English name that sounds nothing like my name.

EBearhug I've had the same as your story of Antoine so many times that I include a pronunciation guide on my zoom and my Microsoft Teams avatar is a pronunciation guide of the two syllables my 4 letter name.

People still call me an entirely different name (usually starting with the same first letter, but goes wild from there), but it seems to cut down to usually just the obnoxious people.

reluctantbrit · 30/07/2021 16:06

My name is French and also a not that usual French name so even if people speak French or have visited France a lot may not have come across it. In handwriting it can often seen as a totally different spelling.

It is also difficult to say if I am male or female. I lost count of letter and emails address to Mr. to me. Americans also pronounce it in a way I don’t particular like.

I don’t like it but I gave up, I do blame my mum for choosing a name even if I understand her reasoning. I think I just grew a very thick skin.

We took particular care naming DD to avoid all these issues.

pocpocpoc · 30/07/2021 16:04

@cabingirl

I have one of those English names which is easy to misspell in a minor way - think Ann vs Anne.

So, if strangers on one-off emails put Ann and miss the e off then I don't care at all.

But there's one friend of the family who does it consistently and in emails where my email address has the right spelling or in return to an email where I had signed my name the correct way.

I suspect she does it on purpose or perhaps she's that careless with all her correspondence - I find it rude. I always double check the spelling of people's names - Betty is not the same as Bettie, Lizzie is not the same as Lissie etc.

I can imagine how upsetting and annoying it is that people are not even getting close the right spelling of your name - it's very lazy and not very kind. You'd think you'd try extra hard at Christmas to get the name of your relative right - season of goodwill and all!

For those people you have already asked several times and they've started making excuses about how hard it is - start addressing their cards to random names too. Do it every time they do it to you.

But I'm petty and passive aggressive like that.

To think about it, their names are just as random and foreign to me and I learnt them all together with their unique spellings. I think I know all of their middle names too... And they can be very particular how their DCs' names have 'classy' spellings.

But me - no. I think they were quite surprised when they were told that I get upset when they use the wrong name for me, I don't think they realise I can be attached to my name and that it is actually meaningful to me. Why random combination of letters would not do?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 30/07/2021 16:03

I used to get this. Soi spelt their names wrong too. Every time. (I am Queen Petty from the Land of the Petty People, though)

Some them started paying attention and spelling my name correctly. So I do too. Others carry on so do I. 1 never spoke to me again and so - meh. Didn't she'd any tears about it when they died.

It is exceedingly rude

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 30/07/2021 16:01

If it helps I have an extremely English name which I go by a shortening of, and this shortening is rarely if ever spelt right on cards. I let it go now.

Namechangeforthisquestion7 · 30/07/2021 16:01

Your name only has 5 letters? How difficult can it be for them to pick that up?! Even if it was a random combination of five symbols that made a confusing sound, if you were my friend/family member I would make the effort to learn it correctly. They all sound lazy and weird.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 30/07/2021 16:00

@cabingirl

Or I'd get a packet of small stickers and print my name on each one and send a sheet of the stickers to each offender with a note to say I've decided to make it easier for you as after two decades you still seem incapable of getting my name right.
I can recommend Instantprint for that😂

I like you

cabingirl · 30/07/2021 15:59

Or I'd get a packet of small stickers and print my name on each one and send a sheet of the stickers to each offender with a note to say I've decided to make it easier for you as after two decades you still seem incapable of getting my name right.

lazylinguist · 30/07/2021 15:59

YANBU. They are rude, thoughtless and lazy for not making the effort to get it right.

You need to spell all their names wrong. Repeatedly. With variations every time you write it.

^ This. Although actually, I don't think I could bring myself to do that, as I'm a stickler for spelling. Grin

Sympathies, OP, it must drive you nuts. I have a name that can be spelled two ways, but one of them is the male version which people often use for me although I'm female. It's annoying, but not as annoying as your situation!

Vallmo47 · 30/07/2021 15:59

I understand Op, I’m Scandinavian with a surname my nan made up back in the day when that was still allowed. Even Swedish people have to use their brains to spell it - I stand no hope in hell here. ;) But it doesn’t offend me, I just laugh it off.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 30/07/2021 15:56

@ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba

I'm Hungarian. my name in short form is 4 letters. it's like "Kati" instead of the English "Katie".

you'd think that's easy to remember, especially after 20 odd years.
but nope. FOUR letters are impossible to remember.
it doesn't matter that everything that I order has my name stated as "Kati" either, people are incapable of copying 4 letters correctly when writing name & address on a package!🙄🤷‍♀️

Mail & christmas cards are a rich source of entertainment so, for my own amusement, I have kept versions of my name as written by others.
I call it the Hallmark of Shame and my favourite one is the blank space where my name should be, so the inside of the card is addressed to:
Ben , and children

🤣

I use the best mess ups as usernames for my various accounts like netflix and prime 😁 Did the same for DH. I like you Hallmark of Shame😂
RisingSunn · 30/07/2021 15:55

It’s ignorance and arrogance.

pocpocpoc · 30/07/2021 15:55

@Nengineer

Cripes I think the use of discrimination is a bit loose. Yes thoughtless, obviously irritating but discrimination means me deliberately using the wrong name at a meeting because surely every Muslim is called M. This is why the far left and far right are winning FFSbiscuit

I am trying to not reveal too much here, but what would you say if I told you I am Muslim and 'random foreign words' that are used are actually random Arabic words? Does it change your assessment?

Not trying to stir shit here, really trying to understand.

OP posts:
cabingirl · 30/07/2021 15:52

I have one of those English names which is easy to misspell in a minor way - think Ann vs Anne.

So, if strangers on one-off emails put Ann and miss the e off then I don't care at all.

But there's one friend of the family who does it consistently and in emails where my email address has the right spelling or in return to an email where I had signed my name the correct way.

I suspect she does it on purpose or perhaps she's that careless with all her correspondence - I find it rude. I always double check the spelling of people's names - Betty is not the same as Bettie, Lizzie is not the same as Lissie etc.

I can imagine how upsetting and annoying it is that people are not even getting close the right spelling of your name - it's very lazy and not very kind. You'd think you'd try extra hard at Christmas to get the name of your relative right - season of goodwill and all!

For those people you have already asked several times and they've started making excuses about how hard it is - start addressing their cards to random names too. Do it every time they do it to you.

But I'm petty and passive aggressive like that.

Nengineer · 30/07/2021 15:51

Also imagine 20 years time when adults are called DaeisieeMay and Konnorrr. Many names will be either spellable or the person able to fathom the pronounciation from the 'different' spelling. I know a meisiee Maisie ffs

pocpocpoc · 30/07/2021 15:50

@ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba

I'm Hungarian. my name in short form is 4 letters. it's like "Kati" instead of the English "Katie".

you'd think that's easy to remember, especially after 20 odd years.
but nope. FOUR letters are impossible to remember.
it doesn't matter that everything that I order has my name stated as "Kati" either, people are incapable of copying 4 letters correctly when writing name & address on a package!🙄🤷‍♀️

Mail & christmas cards are a rich source of entertainment so, for my own amusement, I have kept versions of my name as written by others.
I call it the Hallmark of Shame and my favourite one is the blank space where my name should be, so the inside of the card is addressed to:
Ben , and children

🤣

I wish I did this! it would have been fun! You have a much better sense of humour than me!
OP posts:
igelkott2021 · 30/07/2021 15:49

It's laziness OP and it's easy enough to check. If someone has an English names with several options like Katherine/Kathryn/Catherine I will double-check how the person spells it if I can't remember. And I write down eg people's childrens' names so I can write them correctly the following year.

I remember getting quite annoyed with my mum when I had a German friend to stay with an unusual but eminently pronounceable (Scandinavian) name. My mum insisted on shortening it and when we saw friends of hers she said "oh it's easier for them". It really wasn't and I found it quite embarrassing but my friend was more forgiving than I would have been.

It's also annoying with the Olympics when the commentators pronounce names wrong. They get all the info in advance and get told how to pronounce the names.

I also got a bit annoyed with a colleague at work the other day - we were dealing with a Finnish lady whose name is Milja with the j pronounced like a y. He kept saying Meeha.

OP your DH should tell his relatives to stop being so f-in lazy and call you by your name - people can learn 5 letters! I'd be annoyed with him for not sorting it out.

Nengineer · 30/07/2021 15:48

@Procrastatron

Judge them, it’s rude and it’s a form of discrimination because they are treating you differently (not bothering to learn your name) because of your nationality/race.

Their excuses are shite by the way, your name has one character more than a PIN number and six fewer than a mobile number and I bet they remember those.

Cripes I think the use of discrimination is a bit loose. Yes thoughtless, obviously irritating but discrimination means me deliberately using the wrong name at a meeting because surely every Muslim is called M. This is why the far left and far right are winning FFSBiscuit
Coulddowithanap · 30/07/2021 15:47

I get this with my name that is very common in UK, I get people spelling it in all kinds of ways. I'd be annoyed if they wrote a random name though, that would be like they don't know what I'm called.

MareofBeasttown · 30/07/2021 15:47

I am Asian. My name has 3 syllables, not hard to say. I was at an event with another Asian who said her also 3 syllable name, then when people looked baffled, immediately said "Just call me K." Then the same people asked "Can we call you P". I said no. Probably came across as rude.

Long story short, I expect people to try to pronounce my name properly and not call me by a shorter version or an initiial, no matter how unfamiliar it is to them.