Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell off someone else's child?

159 replies

Wingingit573 · 30/07/2021 12:03

There's a little boy at my daughter's playgroup who is 3 years old, My daughter is 17months.

He's obviously going through a phase of hitting, 3 weeks in a row he's hit my daughter and other children in the face with toys that are quite heavy.

His mum does absolutely nothing and just says oh dear in a sing song voice... while sitting on her phone Hmm Today I told him no, that wasn't kind and he can't be hitting other children after he hit my daughter around the head with a scuttlebug.

His mum picked up on the fact that I'd told him no and was absolutely livid.
I wouldn't like to overstep and I know that all kids and probably my own will go through this phase.

Was I wrong to tell him no? I can just see his behaviour becoming worse and him really hurting another child!

OP posts:
Paddling654 · 30/07/2021 13:26

and I think and it's a shame that if it carries on he needs removed,

It does sound like you thinking of it.

MizMoonshine · 30/07/2021 13:25

You should have held your ground and told her to look after her kid instead of at her phone or you will continue to protect your child by telling hers off.

maddening · 30/07/2021 13:24

The leader needs to take her to one side at the start of the next session, explaining the policies and that if she does not want others to intervene when her son hurts other dc then she will need to monitor closely and if it continues whilst she is monitoring, or if she fails to monitor then she will not be welcome.

Greenrubber · 30/07/2021 13:23

Phase not face obviously

memberofthewedding · 30/07/2021 13:23

Any parent is entitled to discipline any badly behaved child if their own parents are incapable of doing it.

Greenrubber · 30/07/2021 13:23

Not all children go through a hitting face I think you did the right thing and of the mum feels like you were out of order maybe you should point out that if she had been paying more attention she could of avoided it

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 30/07/2021 13:20

YANBU at all and the other mother is bloody useless by the sound of it.

I used to take my 2 DSs (separately as they are 5 years apart) to playgroups where ALL the mothers would take joint responsibility for the welfare of ALL the kids - so if any mum saw any kid hitting another, that mum would tell the child "No, hitting isn't nice" or whatever. And no one complained - in fact, many appreciated the back up, that it wasn't just them always telling off their own child for whatever infraction. If anyone didn't like the set up, then they didn't come back - but most people were fine with it.

I can't be doing with parents who think their children are "free spirits" who should "learn independently" how to behave - no, fuck off, they need to be TAUGHT how to behave.

Wingingit573 · 30/07/2021 13:19

@Sssloou

Maybe her proactively volunteering to set up next week following her flounce is a sort of non-verbal acknowledgment/apology?

I suspect she needs this outlet more than you realise. You sound like a very compassionate person but as PP have said boundaries are important for everyone especially her DC who potentially looks to be vulnerable if he is not being attended to.

It's my week to set up next week, So I'll see if she comes early and I think I'm going to speak to her, I wouldn't like her to feel like she's being jumped on if she's struggling.
OP posts:
Sssloou · 30/07/2021 13:17

Maybe her proactively volunteering to set up next week following her flounce is a sort of non-verbal acknowledgment/apology?

I suspect she needs this outlet more than you realise. You sound like a very compassionate person but as PP have said boundaries are important for everyone especially her DC who potentially looks to be vulnerable if he is not being attended to.

1forAll74 · 30/07/2021 13:17

I would always tell off a small child in a situation like this, precious Mothers can be very irritating.

Wingingit573 · 30/07/2021 13:11

@Paddling654

I don't think you can ban the child because he hit the DD of someone on the committee (that's how it will look) and you haven't tried speaking to her, banning phones, supporting her to parent etc.
Oh no, I would never just try and get him banned, Sorry if it came across that way. I have intended to try and deal with the issue first but I think that's kind of an end of the line option. I mean if it continues after she's spoken to and after we've put things in place maybe but not straight off the bat.

Although I'm not going to lie I really did hope when she stormed out she maybe wouldn't return of her own accord Blush

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 30/07/2021 13:10

You did the right thing. I’ve done the same before - and got a similar angry response from the child’s mother who’d been ignoring her DS’s poor behaviour. I stood up to her and told her I wouldn’t have had to reprimand her child if she’d been supervising them properly. I was so outraged at what had happened to my DD. I don’t usually stand up for myself at all but I Ed more than happy to stand up for my child.

You did the right thing, and you actually did the child a favour. Children need boundaries and won’t learn if they’re not guided.

Sssloou · 30/07/2021 13:08

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

I don't understand why you haven't taken this 'Mum' to task over her son's behaviour, and her lack of giving a shit Don't take it out on a 3-year old. You need to take it up with her.
I think that this is an important principle. Approach it like you would an unruly dog in the park - it’s the owners responsibility to control their dog - no point berating the dog if it has never been trained to behave or respond.
Paddling654 · 30/07/2021 13:08

I don't think you can ban the child because he hit the DD of someone on the committee (that's how it will look) and you haven't tried speaking to her, banning phones, supporting her to parent etc.

Wingingit573 · 30/07/2021 13:07

@Sssloou

You did the right thing.

Don’t worry about her kicking off and flouncing off. That’s the usual standard of inadequate behaviour from that kind of parent. We should never hold back on doing the right thing because someone else will make a scene.

I feel v sorry for her DC - he will be subtly socially excluded all the way through his childhood - as every other parent watches out for behaviour and swerves these types of DC which just exacerbates his social development.

I am interested in the Mum being withdrawn from the group. I am not excusing her behaviour but she may have confidence issues, MH issues, a stressful, challenging and chaotic home life.

If this is a community group maybe it could be flagged that someone else try’s to engage her and encourage her to join in and guide / support her parenting. That intervention could have an important ripple effect on everyone.

Of course if she continues to be verbally abusive and negligent then there are consequences as well if her DC poses a risk to others.

Does the group have any “charter” for expected behaviour for DCs and parents. Eg Phones off, be close by and reasonable for your own DC etc. She might think this is “time off” for her. Is she younger than others in the group?

See I've worried about this and I think it's partly the reason I've not said anything to her, She's very withdrawn and she doesn't Interact with anyone parent or child. We all have tried to engage in conversation but she just cuts off all conversation etc. I have really bad anxiety and this is the only group I've stayed at as before I felt like I couldn't join in etc, I'd hate for anyone else to feel how I did which is why previously we have really tried to include her. I think we maybe need to update the ' rules of group' in regards to phones etc, that might help bring her out of her shell and she'll have to engage a wee bit.

I'd say she's mid thirties? Her first child though, I'd hate to think she's really struggling and is kind of just disengaging when she's at playgroup for a break from his behaviour and then she feels like people are jumping on her. Definitely feel it needs to be handled carefully.

OP posts:
GoldBar · 30/07/2021 13:06

Tell off the mum next time.

pinkcircustop · 30/07/2021 13:03

YANBU. If she doesn’t like it she can parent her own child.

Sssloou · 30/07/2021 13:02

You did the right thing.

Don’t worry about her kicking off and flouncing off. That’s the usual standard of inadequate behaviour from that kind of parent. We should never hold back on doing the right thing because someone else will make a scene.

I feel v sorry for her DC - he will be subtly socially excluded all the way through his childhood - as every other parent watches out for behaviour and swerves these types of DC which just exacerbates his social development.

I am interested in the Mum being withdrawn from the group. I am not excusing her behaviour but she may have confidence issues, MH issues, a stressful, challenging and chaotic home life.

If this is a community group maybe it could be flagged that someone else try’s to engage her and encourage her to join in and guide / support her parenting. That intervention could have an important ripple effect on everyone.

Of course if she continues to be verbally abusive and negligent then there are consequences as well if her DC poses a risk to others.

Does the group have any “charter” for expected behaviour for DCs and parents. Eg Phones off, be close by and reasonable for your own DC etc. She might think this is “time off” for her. Is she younger than others in the group?

Wingingit573 · 30/07/2021 12:58

@workwoes123

So none of the committee have pulled the mum up on her lack of interaction / supervision of her child? YANBU to tell him off as you did, but personally I'd be telling her off too! Not publicly, but privately. If there are community-agreed guidelines about behaviour and supervising your own children then you can direct her towards these - and if there aren't maybe you need some?

I used to run a community playgroup, and they really do depend on everyone pulling their weight and abiding by whatever rules have been agreed. Maybe the committee could do a reminder to all members about supervision of children and behaviour? Then it wouldn't be singling her out.

I think this is a good idea, I'll maybe put something together and pop it into the group.
OP posts:
eandz13 · 30/07/2021 12:57

I'd have done the same too, if my child hit another I'd tell my child off, and if I didn't notice for some reason I'd thumbs up the other mum for telling my child off too.
She ruined her own day. You did the right thing!

Wingingit573 · 30/07/2021 12:57

@Tiana4

I think her exact words were "Don't you dare speak to my son like that, he's a child" Then she followed it up by taking her child and leaving saying she couldn't believe someone had spoken to him like that and stormed out.

Yanbu
Next time reply, "well supervise your child and intervene when he is hitting other younger children then. We are not here to parent your child because you aren't watching"

I thought we'd maybe not see her again but she has just put a post up in the group saying she'll help tidy up next week 🙄

You said you're in the committee. If she consistently fail to supervise her child and it makes it unsafe for other children, you absolutely should ban her. Tidying up afterwards doesn't absolve her of the need to watch her child.

Childcare nurseries get in trouble with Ofsted for failing to supervise and care plan, if a child is a known regular hitter or biter etc

At play groups parents are expected to supervise their own children

Maybe you should write up your policies to show this - "parents are expected up supervise their children and intervene if their child is hurting others or running/ climbing in unauthorised areas. If parents fail to do ao, they may be asked to leave and if consistently failing to do so, they may be banned from attending the group"

So it is in the policies, But I think we need to add in that last bit 😬
OP posts:
Veggiepotamus · 30/07/2021 12:57

I would have done the same!

EssentialHummus · 30/07/2021 12:53

I'd have done the same. Her DC harming my child + not intervening herself? Totally justified.

RedMarauder · 30/07/2021 12:49

Get your committee to ban the use of mobile phones while at playgroup.

Some of the children's playgroups I've taken my DD along to ban parents from using their mobile phones.

Oh and you did the right thing.

workwoes123 · 30/07/2021 12:48

So none of the committee have pulled the mum up on her lack of interaction / supervision of her child? YANBU to tell him off as you did, but personally I'd be telling her off too! Not publicly, but privately. If there are community-agreed guidelines about behaviour and supervising your own children then you can direct her towards these - and if there aren't maybe you need some?

I used to run a community playgroup, and they really do depend on everyone pulling their weight and abiding by whatever rules have been agreed. Maybe the committee could do a reminder to all members about supervision of children and behaviour? Then it wouldn't be singling her out.