Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what the hell I just saw?

240 replies

QuestionableMouse · 30/07/2021 00:25

Looking at the moon through some new binoculars and it had a line (shadow) across the bottom bit. I've never seen anything like it!

My sister is staying atm and she saw it too so I wasn't imaging things. Nothing wrong with the binoculars and the line doesn't show up when looking at other light things.

It was very clear and distinct, looked like something was casting a shadow over the surface. I've attached a very terrible diagram 😂

(black is just where the moon is in shadow, red line is where the line/shadow was)

To wonder what the hell I just saw?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
notimagain · 31/07/2021 17:57

More than likely a satellite in front of it/direct line of sight making it appear as a shadow

More than very very likely not…

Satellites in orbit around the Moon don’t produce shadows visible from earth..the largest satellite in orbit around the Earth only ever appears a a dot to use down here (see the previous posted video of ISS crossing the face of the Moon).

notimagain · 31/07/2021 17:54

Clouds don’t produce a straight line like that (if that’s what the OP saw) TBH It would be great if they would drop in again to clarify a couple of questions.

For a couple of reasons (possible time of moonrise, orientation of the line as drawn) I’m coming back to the line being being due to distant wires/cables, perhaps several kilometers from the OP and the sister, or the other possibility is the previously mentioned aircraft’s contrail.

It’s pretty much impossible to sensibly rationalize it as being anything more exotic than one of those two but we’ll probably never know which one for sure.

ChelleMum85 · 31/07/2021 17:45

@QuestionableMouse

Looking at the moon through some new binoculars and it had a line (shadow) across the bottom bit. I've never seen anything like it!

My sister is staying atm and she saw it too so I wasn't imaging things. Nothing wrong with the binoculars and the line doesn't show up when looking at other light things.

It was very clear and distinct, looked like something was casting a shadow over the surface. I've attached a very terrible diagram 😂

(black is just where the moon is in shadow, red line is where the line/shadow was)

More than likely a satellite in front of it/direct line of sight making it appear as a shadow.
linsey2581 · 31/07/2021 17:37

its probably the markings from the craters.

MollyMinniesMum · 31/07/2021 17:26

Clouds?

Changemaname1 · 31/07/2021 13:13

My lord some of the responses on here , really not that hard to understand what op is saying . Fml

Sorry tho op no idea what the line could be

rainbowunicorn · 31/07/2021 12:42

@H8H8H8

This is bonkers 🤣🤣🤣

OP no one can see a shadow - just the ms paint style lines you have drawn all over the picture. How can anyone comment?

At least take the time to read the OP's posts and updates before trying to be a smart arse. You are not funny or original. There are at least 50 other people before you who think they are dead clever with the sneary comments.
clickychicky · 31/07/2021 12:19

@H8H8H8

This is bonkers 🤣🤣🤣

OP no one can see a shadow - just the ms paint style lines you have drawn all over the picture. How can anyone comment?

Have you RTFT?
H8H8H8 · 31/07/2021 12:09

This is bonkers 🤣🤣🤣

OP no one can see a shadow - just the ms paint style lines you have drawn all over the picture. How can anyone comment?

Jackgrealishscurtains · 31/07/2021 11:13

@QuestionableMouse

I don't think it was a contrail - it was very crisp and sharp and every pic of contrails I've seen looks more fluffy/blurred.

There are no cables or power lines in that direction and the moon was much higher than the trees.

Not my first time using binoculars, by a long shot. They're just a new pair I picked up for the kids so they don't use my good ones.

But you understand that it must be something between you and the moon, not something on the moon? Because if it were actually on the moon, even as a shadow, and had gone all the way across, it would have been curved to follow the curvature of the moon?

If the plane had just passed, the contrail would be very thin and crisp.

notimagain · 31/07/2021 10:58

P.S. Open to having sums checked and corrections on timings but I’m aware too much info from the OP could be outing….

notimagain · 31/07/2021 10:52

Because I love a good puzzle I’ve put astronomy (hobby) hat down and picks up hat from former job in aviation….

Winding back to the start of the thread it looks like the OP posted at around 0025 uk local time Friday, and the flight radar app screen snapshot taken about 20 minutes later would indicate that they are located maybe north of Newcastle on Tyne….

If you run the Planefinder app (not “flight radar”) back to the night if I’ve got it right at about 0025 UK time there was an Aegean airlines flight out of Edinburgh overflying that part of the world heading south eastwards. The aircraft itself tracked just south of Morpeth but the winds at altitude that would probably make any contrails move southwards in the direction of Newcastle.

That could well take them across the line of sight of anybody looking at the Moon from the part of the world the OP seems to be in.

Some contrails can and do remain sharp edged and well defined for quite some time.

Given we can rule out anything extra terrestrial (I’m open minded but not that much) and given the OP has ruled out cables and wires then if those times and rough locations I have worked on are correct I’d suggest Occam’s razor would suggest the line was an aircraft contrail.

Mrstreehouse · 31/07/2021 09:19

What do you think it is OP? If not a contrail? What’s your explanation?

notimagain · 31/07/2021 07:46

Hi

Thanks for that.

Can I check my understanding of the description/drawing?

You saw a thin, sharply defined line that appeared to run across the whole illuminated portion of the Moon’s face, about a third/quarter of the way from the bottom?

MyShoelaceIsUndone · 30/07/2021 19:29

The moon is as flat as the earth and the sun

QuestionableMouse · 30/07/2021 19:10

I don't think it was a contrail - it was very crisp and sharp and every pic of contrails I've seen looks more fluffy/blurred.

There are no cables or power lines in that direction and the moon was much higher than the trees.

Not my first time using binoculars, by a long shot. They're just a new pair I picked up for the kids so they don't use my good ones.

OP posts:
notimagain · 30/07/2021 18:40

@Thewinterofdiscontent

notimagain

The Op has repeatedly said she moved the binoculars round to look at the street light etc and not line. So not a hair/crack or fault.

Dooh…silly me she did indeed…

So failing further details from the OP we’re stuck with stuff like contrails etc..

Thewinterofdiscontent · 30/07/2021 15:20

notimagain

The Op has repeatedly said she moved the binoculars round to look at the street light etc and not line. So not a hair/crack or fault.

warmandtoasty2day · 30/07/2021 14:59

It's in the news, nasa reckons the brittle crust is breaking as the interior cools down, ie the moon is shrinking.

notimagain · 30/07/2021 14:48

@me4real

Most likely it is something on your equipment; a hair or whatever.
That possibility could be ruled in/out if the line/smudge/whatever was seen shifted relative to the background as the binoculars were moved around….

It’s another Q for the OP,

me4real · 30/07/2021 14:33

Most likely it is something on your equipment; a hair or whatever.

Monestera · 30/07/2021 14:23

She said the red line is where the shadow was!!!!

But it was a red arrow, not a red line.

Saisong · 30/07/2021 14:18

@Goingdriving

Maybe ask this question on an internet amateur agronomy forum
Grin Grin Not a bad idea - all those farmers out there probably have a good understanding of the workings of the moon
DroopyClematis · 30/07/2021 14:10

Despite some rudeness, this is an interesting thread.
Never heard of rupus recta or brinicles before.

I can't offer any explanation OP but I've certainly learned something new.

notimagain · 30/07/2021 14:06

[quote Dodie66]Read the post on this forum www.thescienceforum.com/general-discussion/31946-moon-line.html[/quote]
Sadly some replies there are a bit Hmm.

I totally get that the OP and relative saw something.

The Moon is visible from roughly half of the world at any moment been no reports of lines from elsewhere in the world.

Unless the laws of Physics/optics/geometry have been suspended nothing can can be sat on the left hand side of the Moon ‘s face with the Sun where it was last night and cast a shadow down sun maybe a thousand kilometers long..(probably can’t be done anyway, regardless of the Sun’s position because of the size of the Moon..)

Satellites don’t leave linear shadows or contrails.

So we’re back again to something closer to home, e.g. contrails, local atmospheric effects, or dare say it again, wires..fault in the binoculars?

Unless the OP comes back with more info we’re not being nasty but we’re stuck for an answer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread