Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my mum to just lay off about this

93 replies

LaraDecouvrie · 30/07/2021 00:20

My parents split up 20 years ago.

My dad didn’t behave well and was really quite shit to my mum and my sisters and I about it. Not physically abusive or anything, but just left mum for another woman.

Since then my relationship with my dad hasn’t been great, but we are on speaking terms and meet up a few times a year.

But my mum is a nightmare if she hears that I’m meeting up with him and has a massive rant about how bad he treated us etc....

If I meet him without mentioning it to her she goes on and on about it.

But honestly, I can’t be arsed hating him forever just because she can’t move on.

Again this weekend I am visiting her and popping to his for a cuppa on the way home. She went on a massive rant and I honestly felt like I was taking an anxiety attack listening to her.

I’m so angry with her just now and I’m actually worried i will end up arguing with her and falling out with her this weekend: I just cannot bear to listen to her go on about it anymore

OP posts:
EvilPea · 30/07/2021 14:51

DH’s mum is like this.
I get it, having had shit head boyfriends and helped friends through divorces and their kids with shit dads. I get it. I really do. I can see how she would feel that he doesn’t get the good stuff of spending time with the wonderful adult you’ve become because of her hard work when you were little. I can see how she feels he doesn’t deserve it.

However, it’s not fair. You are part of your dad, your relationship with your dad is your own. Not hers. You can understand and recognise her hurt, but it’s not a betrayal of her to want that relationship with him. 20 years is a long time and I have no doubt he regrets his actions now seeing the woman you’ve become.
Ultimately it’s not about her, it’s nothing to do with what he deserves. It’s you and your dads relationship, she isn’t involved.

MagnoliaBeige · 30/07/2021 14:49

I’d speak to her about this in advance of the weekend, maybe by text, to let her know your plans and make it clear you don’t want to discuss it with her. Then if she raises it again when you see her, you walk away from the conversation - show her know your boundaries and stick to them.

SeeYaBeYa · 30/07/2021 14:38

I think you are both being a bit unreasonable tbh. I mean yeah obviously it's not nice to listen to her but having a panic attack over it, really?

Up to her if she "can't get over" (to use your words) having her life ripped apart by someone she loved and trusted, similarly up to you if you "can't get over" her being angry about it.

I mean she's a grown up but so are you and she doesn't have to shield you from anything that might upset you.

You both need to find a way to work matters out so that she feels acknowledged and you feel able to make your own decisions.

AlternativePerspective · 30/07/2021 13:38

I have a family member who left his partner for an OW. I don’t know the details, what I do know though is that his parents went out of their way to look out for her and her kids, and were disgusted by his actions.

However, a couple of years on they started speaking to their DS again, and despite everything they had done for her and her DC, she cut them off entirely and told the children that they could no longer see their grandparents because they were once again speaking to their dad.

About a year on the eldest child has cut his mother off and is living with his dad, and a year after that the youngest is seeing both her dad and the grandparents on the sly, and is waiting until she is 16 so she can move out.

Betrayed spouses need to think very carefully before they start projecting their bitterness on to their kids, because they do stand to lose everything, and that won’t be the fault of the cheating partner, it will be theirs.

melj1213 · 30/07/2021 13:32

Next time you visit you need to get in ahead of her asking to tell her how you feel. If you wait until she asks about your dad then it will inevitably end in an argument but if you speak to her about it before she brings it up then you are the one I control of the situation.

"Mum, before you ask yes I am going to be seeing my dad soon and I want to talk to you about this situation. Every time I visit you ask if I am going to visit him and put me in a position where I either have to tell the truth and listen to you disparage him again or lie to keep the peace and I do not want to have to do that any more. My relationship with my father is separate to the one you have with your exhusband and you need to respect the fact that I wish to have a civil relationship with him as my father. Please do not ask me about him again. If you do then I will leave as I have made my wishes very clear and I will not stay when I am being disrespected."

LaraDecouvrie · 30/07/2021 13:31

Apart from this she is a great mother.... she is like the gestapo with questions though... always has been, with everyone. An ex boyfriend was terrified of her with all her questions when he first met her (where do you work? How do you get to work? What does your mum do? Oh, she’s a cleaner at the school: does she know Aggie McBagii)

But yeah, the bitterness is getting me down. I thought it had calmed down a bit, but something has triggered it again. It’s impacted me and my sisters weddings (dad didn’t come to mine, and Mum threw a tantrum at my sisters wedding due to order of receiving line). One sister actually won’t talk at all about dad and if anyone mentions him she just blanks them as if they didn’t say anything. Her wife said that she’s the same at home, dad is never mentioned

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 30/07/2021 13:30

20 years on there is absolutely 0 reason for bringing up what a shit he was etc etc etc. These bitter women bring about their own downfall as far as I’m concerned, in fact when someone is as bitter as all that so far along it makes me wonder what the marriage was like and whether perhaps the man was justified in leaving, even if it was for someone else.

What’s that saying?

Bitterness is like drinking poison and waiting for someone else to die.

If she asks again I would say that it was 20 years ago and frankly you don’t care about what happened then, you’re all adults and should act as such and you no longer want to hear about it.

longtompot · 30/07/2021 13:29

You could answer with a question. If she asks just say why do you want to know?

Or just say, as others have suggested, you will not discuss it with her. Change the subject.

Or tell her just because they aren't together doesn't stop him being your dad. Just because you visit him doesn't mean you have forgotten about his behaviour.

memberofthewedding · 30/07/2021 13:26

My grandmother used to say "What the eye does not see the heart does not grieve over". Dont tell her.

Yahtze · 30/07/2021 13:20

I think you need to be blunt. She's a huge hypocrite. She's hurting her own children by repeating to indulge her own vitriol. She's asking you to carry that burden. He made one decision 20 years ago. She's repeatedly chosen to hurt her children over and over again. It doesn't paint a pretty picture! It does make it seem like your dad had a lucky escape.

Fernando072020 · 30/07/2021 12:58

Your mum is being selfish. Yes your dad cheated (also selfish), but he wants a relationship with you now regardless of what's happened and if you want that too then it's really none of your mum's business

Shodan · 30/07/2021 12:55

Quite honestly that level of vitriol would make me wonder why he left in the first place and if she had anything to do with it.

It must have been present in the relationship. It doesn't just come from nowhere.

Indeed. Something I came to realise as an adult, listening to my mother's complaints about more or less everyone in her life. It made me sad for her, tbh - the only person whose life was still being ruined by her attitude was her own. She wasted her life in bitterness and bile.

Peccary · 30/07/2021 12:54

Deal with this now before it impacts the next generation. I am your DD in this situation. My mum's dad left for another woman, my gran never got over it. We had to pretend he didn't exist, children asked to lie if we went to visit him. It was almost a relief that one of them died before I was married so I didn't have to choose (it was usually him that missed all the occasions as the "wrongdoer")

Iwonder08 · 30/07/2021 12:40

OP, shut it down very firmly. It took me 15 years.. I tried listening to my mum thinking perhaps she just need to get it off her chest, tried explaining that perhaps he was a bad husband, but he is still a good dad for me, tried explaining how hard it is for me to listen to her endless recaps of how horrible he was to her, that he is a half of who i am.. Nothing worked, she never stopped. As a result I hardly speak to her. She now hates me almost as much as she hates my dad

househousehousefox · 30/07/2021 12:11

@MrsTerryPratchett

Something someone said to me years ago may be something to share, "mum, my dad is half of who I am. When you say these things to me about him, I feel them about myself".
I really needed to kear this about my mil. Thanks you really changed my outlook in a single sentence
RedHelenB · 30/07/2021 11:57

@MrsTerryPratchett

Something someone said to me years ago may be something to share, "mum, my dad is half of who I am. When you say these things to me about him, I feel them about myself".
See, I don't agree with th at. You're dads a racist, a racist , a murderer. But I do agree that a child has 2 parents and it's their right to choose how often they see them.
ActonSquirrel · 30/07/2021 11:39

@shouldistop

My mum was / is the same. Absolutely poisonous about my dad . He died in Dec 2019 and she still likes to get a bitch in. She's been vile about him since they split up when I was 15. I don't think she realises quite how hard it was to listen to as a teenager.
Quite honestly that level of vitriol would make me wonder why he left in the first place and if she had anything to do with it.

It must have been present in the relationship. It doesn't just come from nowhere.

I know I quoted your post but it was a good example but mean it about anyone's situation.

Just stop engaging her. Deprive her of her opportunity to have a bitch fest.

Theoldcuriosityshop · 30/07/2021 11:34

Mine was the same. I was not allowed to have him at my wedding, I then didn't see him for years and when I did I never told my mother. She never knew that he had another child either. I lost touch with my lovely grandmother as well and she died without me ever seeing her again. We were cut off from my dads side of the family completely because of the bitterness that she felt. That's why when my marriage broke up I made sure that my DC kept in touch with grandparents, cousins and aunts and uncles.

Tlollj · 30/07/2021 11:18

I hate my ex with every part of me I wish he was dead.
My grown up kids know this. We just don’t talk about him or anyone remotely connected with him.

AmyDudley · 30/07/2021 11:13

My XH was a real piece of work and I have absolutely no contact with him and never want to see him again.

However my tow adult children do keep in contact with him (a bit sporadic, and on my Daughter side more of a duty thing. But my son has a reasonable relationship with him).
I've always seen this as their choice. They have a different relationship with him from me. They respect the fact I don;t like him, and I respect the fact that they want to keep him in their lives. Unwritten rule is that I don't bad mouth him, and they don't tell me anything about him as they know I am not interested.

I don;t see it as disloyalty because children (young or adult) should never be put in the position of having to take sides. The fact is, he is your blood relation, you will always have some sort of connection with him, whether by choice or by birth. Your Mum isn't related to him and she can cut him completely out of her life. It's more complicated for children, even if he is a bit of a shit.

I would just tell your Mum that you respect her choice to have nothing to do with him, and she needs to respect your choice to see him occasionally and you don't appreciate being put in the position of being made to feel guilty if you see him. So she either needs to stop asking you about it, or if she asks and you say you are seeing him, she needs to accept your answer and change the topic of conversation.

You are an adult - you don't need her to tell you he is (in her opinion) an arsehole, - you will decide that for yourself and act accordingly.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 30/07/2021 11:04

This is parental alienation, and pure selfishness. My husband ran off with my best friend, and I did everything I could to protect my son from any fallout, and he continued to have a close relationship with them both. Harming your child like this is just wicked.

Can you arrange a time to talk to your mum? She needs to hear from you that venting her opinions on him, doesn't hurt him in the slightest. But her wanting you to feel bad about seeing your father, hurts you, and is damaging your relationship with her. That you understand she views your seeing him as disloyal. What he did was wrong. But children shouldn't be forced to cut off one of their parents.

And then tell her you don't want to see her hurt, so you will never discuss him with her again. Next time she starts, say, this conversation is upsetting you, so I'd better go now, and leave.

statetrooperstacey · 30/07/2021 10:59

Try this op,

Mum- are you visiting your dad?
Op- yes we’re dropping in for an hour
Mum- well I hope he’s there you know how unreliable he is the oxygen thieving waste of space……
Op- yeah well you shagged him mum so stfu

FreeBritnee · 30/07/2021 10:52

So every time she asks you, tell her that you will no longer discuss your father with her, because she can’t keep a handle on her emotions/anger when you do. Make it a topic of conversation that’s out of bounds. If down the line you relent, answer her question truthfully and she kicks off again, you can tell her that is the reason you will no longer discuss it with her. Then shut the door on any reference to your father again.

If she wants to act like a child then treat her like a child.

Recessed · 30/07/2021 10:50

Oh that's tough. She really should put her feelings aside when she's talking to her children about him. I've been on both sides of this and now have huge admiration for my mother who had every reason to be bitter and hateful about my dad but never was/is. Even when I bitch about him she won't, her stoicism is admirable and really is an underrated trait! Try as a I may I find it immensely difficult to be as neutral about my STBXH, but you have to try your best for your DCs sake as the children (you in this case) didn't ask for or cause this situation.

You need to have a frank but calm conversation with her. Tell her how upsetting you find it, empathise and validate her feelings but tell her firmly that your relationship with your dad is separate to hers and you don't want to discuss it with her anymore as you find her reactions upsetting.

Flamingo49 · 30/07/2021 10:48

My sympathies OP. My mum is just like this. My parents divorced over 30 years ago and she still can't say his name, will call my dad "him" with such venom and bitterness. She seems to have no awareness of how uncomfortable it is for me, and I find it sad that she still holds such bitterness and anger.

Swipe left for the next trending thread