Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for an maternal choice elective C-section?

259 replies

Miphy · 29/07/2021 20:23

I am 20 weeks with first baby- name changed for this thread.

Prior to pregnancy I was already leaning towards requesting a section. I am a doctor, not working in anything related to it now but obviously spent time in obs & gynae placements.
In my obstetric placement we had to spend a week with the midwifery team so that we had a chance to see ‘normal’ birth. Without exception every single birth I attended went ‘wrong’ and either ended with assisted delivery- forceps, episiotomy, in one case horrendous tearing, or emergency section and massive postpartum haemorrhage.
In contrast elective section list was lovely- but wham bam baby out, happy well rested mums.
Then later in gynaecology saw clinic lists full of women with birth injuries and PTSD.
This massively influenced my perception of birth.

I had thought more more about water births, hypo birthing etc and thought I may as well give it a go vaginally.

However the more reading I do now about birth the more I read about horrendous birth injuries, and of my friends the ones who had sections all fully recommend it whereas some of my friends who have had a vaginal birth have told me some pretty horrendous stories. One still can’t have sex two years later. I know there’s a recovery after section but somehow surgical recovery seems more straightforward and I’m not short of hands on help and support- both our mums are retired, husband works from home, all very keen to provide hands on help.

It feels to me like an elective section involves known small risks, I know what I’m getting. Whereas with a vaginal birth I can have some lovely water birth, minimal tearing, quick recovery, or I can end up exhausted from a prolonged labour maybe with a wrecked undercarriage, maybe a distressed baby and then even potentially a high chance of needing an emergency section with even higher risks. And it seems I won’t know which way it will go until it literally happens. It really feels like the injuries by women after vaginal birth are minimised and you’re just supposed to deal- so they aren’t treated as ‘risks’ in the same way.

I find myself hoping the baby is breech so my decision is made for me. I’m thinking Of asking about maternal choice section at my antenatal clinic appointment. I wondered if anyone had any experiences or any advice?

OP posts:
Nat6999 · 30/07/2021 15:16

Like your friend I was in labour for nearly 3 days before my emcs, I'd had no sleep & then in HDU they were constantly waking me up to monitor me so I didn't have any proper sleep for over 5 nights. I was hallucinating at the end, when I got home I tried to just sleep at night but with the broken nights for feeds etc after 2 days I collapsed & my BP shot up to dangerous levels again, my lovely GP kept me at home instead of sending me back in hospital & told me to stay in bed until it settled & get as much sleep as I could, I slept for 72 hours except for being woken for food, my mum & my husband cared for me & ds in shifts until I was back on my feet. It's really no wonder so many new mums end up with PTSD after things go wrong & how many have to be treated for PND.

Puppysharness · 30/07/2021 15:08

@RedHelenB

A natural birth is the best possible outcome. After intervention with my other births I didn't think I could have one, but I did and it was exactly as the books ssaidd, my body told me what to do. Me personally wouldn't have surgery unless necessary, surely as a Dr you'd realise the possible risks of surgery?
What a patronising comment! I’m sure the OP understands plenty about what surgery involves. Perhaps she’d like to avoid future surgeries necessitated by birth injuries?

Do whatever you feel is right for you, OP. Nobody should be telling you what to do. Some women are comfortable with the physical and emotional risks of vaginal birth and feel it’s worth the benefits; others are not.

My personal view is that if there was any other natural human process with such high rates of physical injury and long-term impact, surgery would be a no-brainer. But too often, women’s reproductive health issues get ignored and instead we are told to just ‘get on with it.’

Mum21031608 · 30/07/2021 14:54

If I had known that having interventions like induction & epidural increased the likelihood of ending up with an emcs I would have gone straight for a Cs but nobody ever tells you that when they tell you that you have to be induced & it is never discussed at birth classes

When I was discussing birthing options with my Consultant with my first birth we were deciding whether to go straight to c-section or be induced/have epidurals (this was in specific relation to my chronic health condition).

She told me that for the majority of women who are induced/have epidurals generally need some other form of intervention (forceps etc) which often results in a c-section anyway so I may as well just cut out the middle man and go straight for a section.

I appreciated her honesty and went straight for a section.

My friend in very similar circumstances chose the other option and after a 3 day slow labour following induction, she ended up having an emergency section due to having a very distressed baby. She was very traumatised by the whole thing.

There are risks to surgery, but there are also risks with vaginal births.

My friend said that when she thinks of the risks of vaginal birth she thinks about her baby coming to harm, whereas when she thinks about risks of a CS, the risks are to the mother whereas the baby is most likely to be born healthy and well.

She said she would rather risk her own health with a c-section than risk the health/life of her baby with a vaginal birth.

IonaLeg · 30/07/2021 14:40

It sounds like you’re really informed and have thought this through very carefully. You’re the best person to make the decision for you!

The only thing I would say is don’t underestimate c-section recovery. It took me a long time to feel fully healed, and I subsequently developed a hernia related to my c-section which will require further surgical repair. But I totally appreciate that I could have had a similarly difficult recovery from a vaginal birth.

You know your own mind, you clearly know the risks and advantages - I say do what feels right for you. Every woman should have a full suite of choices when it comes to giving birth.

AryaStarkWolf · 30/07/2021 14:04

If it had been an option when I had mine I would have done it too.

Nat6999 · 30/07/2021 14:02

If I had known that having interventions like induction & epidural increased the likelihood of ending up with an emcs I would have gone straight for a Cs but nobody ever tells you that when they tell you that you have to be induced & it is never discussed at birth classes, quite frankly they never really tell you anything about Cs as well as nothing about pnd, all you get told is you may have the baby blues for a couple of days, not that you could feel suicidal & like you are going out of your mind.

KiwiDramaQueen · 30/07/2021 13:58

I should have qualified that - “a STRAIGHTFORWARD natural birth”

KiwiDramaQueen · 30/07/2021 13:57

I completely agree a natural birth is the best possible outcome but it really depends on your approach to risk. Are you:
A) aiming for the best possible likely outcome; or
B) aiming to avoid the worst likely outcomes.

For me it’s B. So although I’ve got about a 50-60% chance of a natural unassisted birth at my age, what I really want to do is avoid the most likely adverse outcomes which are: emergency c section; forceps; ventouse; major tearing.

So that rules out vaginal birth for me.

Obviously what I view as a worst likely outcome is based on my personal preferences and personal risk tolerances.

Drivingmeupthewall · 30/07/2021 13:40

@RedHelenB

A natural birth is the best possible outcome. After intervention with my other births I didn't think I could have one, but I did and it was exactly as the books ssaidd, my body told me what to do. Me personally wouldn't have surgery unless necessary, surely as a Dr you'd realise the possible risks of surgery?
The best possible outcome is whatever the mother chooses to have. No birth is without risk, but I chose an ELCS because it reduced the mystery of birth. So many people wind up with intervention and lots go on to have birth injuries. I didn’t want that. Labour frightened me, so I chose not to have it. My CS was textbook and I recovered really well and really quickly. So many people I know wound up having EMCS and then chose ELCS subsequently and say how wonderfully calm and different it was. If that’s what the mother wants, that’s her best possible outcome. You having a natural Labour was yours.
RedHelenB · 30/07/2021 12:58

A natural birth is the best possible outcome. After intervention with my other births I didn't think I could have one, but I did and it was exactly as the books ssaidd, my body told me what to do. Me personally wouldn't have surgery unless necessary, surely as a Dr you'd realise the possible risks of surgery?

Soverymuchfruit · 30/07/2021 12:52

Aha: here are the detailed stats. I see NICE guidance is for doctors to go through this with us, but I for one prefer to read it in my own time in advance.

www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng192/evidence/a-the-benefits-and-risks-of-planned-caesarean-birth-pdf-9071941646

juryquery · 30/07/2021 11:43

I'm a section advocate for those reasons

Ive had two. They are great.

Pesimistic · 30/07/2021 11:41

I've had two vaginal births, 2nd degree tear first, 1st degree tear with second. Everything is normal as as it should be.
My friend had two c sections and her scar hasn't healed and has a constant open wound and has done for 12 years !

yikesanotherbooboo · 30/07/2021 11:11

Nothing wrong with going for planned section. I had two very straightforward nvds and then a planned section. No problems or pain or trauma from any of them but the section inevitably took a bit longer to get over physically. My DC were not born in the era of partners taking time off work so you would need some assistance after the section ; my DM popped round to help with shopping and school run etc.

LittleGwyneth · 30/07/2021 11:11

You should have whatever makes you feel best and safest. You don't have to justify your feelings. Lots of people have great c-sections and bad vaginal births, and the other way around. The main thing is that you feel respected, heard, and like you had a choice.

Anonapapple · 30/07/2021 11:04

I really felt I was missold my vbac! My recovery after my EMCS (after long labour) was fine. With my second, although it was my choice, the consultant and midwives were really pushing the vbac, especially from a 'low risk' and 'back on your feet right after' point of view. The forceps, tear, haemorrhage and blood transfusion meant that I couldn't walk for days and felt like I had been hit by a bus for weeks afterwards. Months later I still felt dreadful as a result of the anaemia caused by the blood loss and almost 4 years later, my scar tissue gets inflamed during my period or if I stand for too long, like a PP said. I also had a prolapse which was fun! I remember lying in bed about 3 weeks after I had the baby and feeling so confused as to why I felt so terrible and even feeling nostalgic about my super fast recovery after the major surgery that was my C section first time around. For every "horror story" someone sneezes a baby out and there is no way of knowing what will happen. I feel that this decision is very much a heart decision. I'm pregnant again and a big part of me still yearns for that wonderful, straightforward experience of vb that other women have, but it didnt happen in 2 out of 2 of my births so am going straight to CS with this one. You have to follow your instincts on this one. You are literally the only person that will have to deal with the consequences, physical or mental.

megletthesecond · 30/07/2021 11:00

Yanbu.

worktrip · 30/07/2021 10:37

@Miphy FWIW, and from my extensive research into birth injury, problems are mainly delay to CSection and not able to interpret the CTG readings.

Also the statistics re VB and CS need to be looked at carefully and only those relating the elective sections used as comparisons. I've not done this, but know that many csections are done as emergencies which may affect the statistics?

worktrip · 30/07/2021 10:28

YANBU and I would ask for an elective. My child is seriously disabled due to a birth injury. It was not actually giving birth related (delay) and an ECS would have made no difference, but I am in a group and some of the horrendous stories I hear, make me horrified and angry about the poor maternity services in this country. My second baby was an elective and calm lovely and a healthy child.

I know statistically c sections are not as problem free but have not examined the reasons for this, and recovery usually longer, but I advise you to take the surgery. It does limit the size of your family though with increasing risk if you have more than 2-3 babies.

Needapoodle · 30/07/2021 10:26

Maybe the complications are rarer but to me they seem so much worse.

People don't tend to talk about birth injuries (serious tears, incontinence, ptsd, infections) though. Especially if you go on about your lovely easy birth. Loads of people don't feel like you can talk about this stuff because you're fear mongering. So a lot of women are completely ignorant of how dangerous childbirth can be, and if things do go wrong you feel like it must be something you did because birth is supposed to be a lovely "experience". Ultimately it's a medical procedure and all the candles and positive thinking in the world won't make a difference if things go wrong.

Soverymuchfruit · 30/07/2021 10:12

Thanks for the link to the paper @FartnissEverbeans

As there seem to be a lot of professionals on this thread, anyone else got links to the relevant stats? I would really like to know not only what proportion of vaginal births go to plan and heal easily, but also the relative risks of increasingly bad outcomes up the scale. (I'm asking about the probability density function in terms of adverse maternal outcome, if that is something that would be referred to in your discipline?). And of course the same for elective C section. TIA.

Starlight86 · 30/07/2021 10:11

YANBU but.......

ANY unnecessary intervention leads to more intervention therefor more risks.

Birth outcomes are far more positive when they start spontaneously and remain intervention free, these includes epidurals, inductions etc.

Im very pro natural birth and applaud people who can make informed decisions and choices based on research and not fear mongering and "doctors orders" but on the flip side i am also pro choice.

FWIW i had 3 natural births that went beautifully and one was breech. My pregnancies were fucking horrific tho.

JustWonderingIfYou · 30/07/2021 09:54

I wouldn't unless you have medical reason. If you are young, fit and healthy then there's no reason to.

Everyone I know who had vaginal birth complications were not in the best way to begin with. All of my active, younger friends and myself had pretty easy labours. I'm sure your psychological state makes a massive difference too though, stress does inhibit the right hormones during birth so if you think you can't do it then get a section.

I worked with a man whose wife was left permanently paralysed following her c section. All planned as she had twins. He was in pieces, 2 newborn babies and his wife left broken. Signed off for a year and then left.

I also had a girl in my ante natal whose c sections scar got horrifically infected and was still open when I saw her 9 month post partum! Still unable to lift her baby, drive or really do much at all.

Maybe the complications are rarer but to me they seem so much worse.

Toomuch2019 · 30/07/2021 08:53

I haven't even RTFT but YANBU to request. They may try and push you to go natural but stay strong if that's what you want. Good luck!

Lastnamefirst · 30/07/2021 08:48

I’m about to start TTC. Also a doctor. No obs experience but a lot of friends/colleagues I know who have had a vaginal deliveries have had really bad care - perhaps they are also more aware of it because they are doctors and know what is and isn’t acceptable. It seems like the system is so overstretched and therefore not safe, but also a culture where listening to the patient does not seem to be a priority - despite their medical backgrounds. Pain relief never seems prioritised in any way either. For this reason, and also concerns regarding potential pelvic floor damage, I would choose an Caesarean section. Anecdotally, friends who have chosen Caesarean are happy with their choice but not all those have chosen vaginal delivery are.

I have thought about perhaps a vaginal delivery on the private wing of a NHS unit, as this may be better staffed with better access to anaesthetists. However I would have to do more research on that as private doesn’t always equate to better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread