Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for an maternal choice elective C-section?

259 replies

Miphy · 29/07/2021 20:23

I am 20 weeks with first baby- name changed for this thread.

Prior to pregnancy I was already leaning towards requesting a section. I am a doctor, not working in anything related to it now but obviously spent time in obs & gynae placements.
In my obstetric placement we had to spend a week with the midwifery team so that we had a chance to see ‘normal’ birth. Without exception every single birth I attended went ‘wrong’ and either ended with assisted delivery- forceps, episiotomy, in one case horrendous tearing, or emergency section and massive postpartum haemorrhage.
In contrast elective section list was lovely- but wham bam baby out, happy well rested mums.
Then later in gynaecology saw clinic lists full of women with birth injuries and PTSD.
This massively influenced my perception of birth.

I had thought more more about water births, hypo birthing etc and thought I may as well give it a go vaginally.

However the more reading I do now about birth the more I read about horrendous birth injuries, and of my friends the ones who had sections all fully recommend it whereas some of my friends who have had a vaginal birth have told me some pretty horrendous stories. One still can’t have sex two years later. I know there’s a recovery after section but somehow surgical recovery seems more straightforward and I’m not short of hands on help and support- both our mums are retired, husband works from home, all very keen to provide hands on help.

It feels to me like an elective section involves known small risks, I know what I’m getting. Whereas with a vaginal birth I can have some lovely water birth, minimal tearing, quick recovery, or I can end up exhausted from a prolonged labour maybe with a wrecked undercarriage, maybe a distressed baby and then even potentially a high chance of needing an emergency section with even higher risks. And it seems I won’t know which way it will go until it literally happens. It really feels like the injuries by women after vaginal birth are minimised and you’re just supposed to deal- so they aren’t treated as ‘risks’ in the same way.

I find myself hoping the baby is breech so my decision is made for me. I’m thinking Of asking about maternal choice section at my antenatal clinic appointment. I wondered if anyone had any experiences or any advice?

OP posts:
itsjuly · 30/07/2021 22:05
  • to clarify my last post - I’m mentally scarred from the birth going wrong, resulting in instruments which failed and then the stress of racing against the clock to get the baby out quickly. If I’d had an ELCS I wouldn’t have had any of that trauma. I’ve since heard that hospitals push women to have natural births solely to keep costs down.
FartnissEverbeans · 30/07/2021 22:01

@Draineddraineddrained - so, is the OP supposed to use statistics to help her make this decision or not? Because basically what you’ve said is that all the statistics regarding VD are useless and unrepresentative.

Which is beside the point anyway. The fact is that less than half of VDs do not receive intervention. Maybe some of that intervention is unnecessary, but it still happens, and OP has to make her decision in the context of actual reality and not in the context of some utopia in which only necessary interventions are ever applied.

itsjuly · 30/07/2021 22:00

I was also swayed by the ‘c-section is major surgery’ argument, which I now realize is greatly exaggerated. I ended up having an (emergency) c-section anyway when my birth went wrong and instruments didn’t work. Physically I actually recovered from the c-section part very quickly, even though it was an EMCS. So it certainly didn’t feel like ‘major surgery’. Mentally though I’m scarred for life - in a way I know I wouldn’t be if I’d had a calm and controlled section.

catsjammies · 30/07/2021 21:56

YANBU. My 'easy' water north left me with injuries which were overlooked for months because 'no you can't have that problem, you had an easy delivery!' Turns out I did have that problem and physio has done wonders, but it ruined my first year of parenthood.

ELCS with second and it was a much nicer experience (but giving birth just isn't fun). I felt more normal at 6 weeks PP from my ELCS than I did at 14 months after my vaginal delivery.

itsjuly · 30/07/2021 21:54

The problem is there’s no way of knowing. You may have a section which may have complications.

The likelihood of having serious complications from a controlled elective c-section (both to you and your baby) feels minimal compared to those that can result from a natural birth or induction that goes wrong.

I still kick myself several times a day for listening to the ‘natural is best’ propaganda - I truly feel that natural birth is unsafe and induction is downright dangerous.

MissChanandlerBong22 · 30/07/2021 21:42

No, I don’t think any woman is ever unreasonable for weighing up the risks (and benefits) of vaginal birth against the risks of a c-section and deciding which risks she prefers.

My experience was that once a vaginal birth goes tits up, some of the risks are the same. I needed surgery (twice) to repair my tear. So I had the risk of blood clots (had to wear surgical stockings and take blood thinning injections, just like a mum who’d had a c section would); infection (had to take prophylactic antibiotics; catheter (had a catheter in for over 24 hours); and anaesthetic (needed a spinal for the first surgery, GA for the next).

itsjuly · 30/07/2021 20:46

I would have an ELCS every time. I allowed my doctor to talk me into having a natural birth the first time round and it was an absolute nightmare. Every day I thank my lucky stars that my child made it out alive. Natural childbirth is a total lottery IMO and so much can go wrong. Elective caesareans feel so much more controlled and safer.

altiara · 30/07/2021 20:32

From what I hear from doctors is they all go for c sections (sample size of doctors is small!!)

NorthernStarss · 30/07/2021 20:31

I had an ELCS, be prepared for the consultant to try to talk you out of it & offer you the moon on a stick instead. I stuck to my guns & she signed it off, had a fantastic birth & recovery. No regrets. Wishing you the very best of luck.

notapanday · 30/07/2021 20:27

Also I would say that a tear is not necessarily bad. I had a small one & they debated whether I needed stitches or not & in the end I had a few. No discomfort at all.

mishmash13 · 30/07/2021 20:26

Yanbu. I had full on traumatic birth and emergency csection. Awful. Had ptsd.ruined my first year with my child. Elective section second time round a total doddle in comparison. If I knew then what I know now. I would have definitely gone elective. But then I suppose some people have good natural births.. I don't know who those people are because I haven't met one yet but they must exist. You just never know. Good luck with whatever you choose. It's your choice after all.

Carboholic · 30/07/2021 20:17

You could probably look up the stats for the bad vaginal births, rather than rely on the small number of ones you saw. It’s not a good sample. The C section will always come with a recovery - it’s surgery (routine, frequenty done, but still abdominal surgery). The vaginal birth can and often is easy and natural and often leaves no permanent damage. What you don’t see in the hospital doing rounds is how these women are 1,2, 6 weeks post partum - the breastfeeding, the healing, the stiches. So aside from a small sample you are also getting a very limited picture.

For the record (anecdata again), I’ve had 2 vaginal births, one complicated and one easy. The first one was complicated, and ended in an episiotomy with lots of stiches. I still chose vaginal birth for the second, and would again.

Peach01 · 30/07/2021 20:08

I had VD with my first. Ended in induction, red button, forceps and a terrible recovery. I'm pregnant again and in pain everyday where I had the epesiotomy. The pain gets increasingly worse with the pressure.
ELCS has been offered, as well as birth psychology. Now I'm further on it's bringing back the memories of the first time.
I don't regret having a VD. However, I had an epidural, didn’t experience the feeling of "birth", cut open, stitched up, couldn't walk for weeks. If I'd have had an ELCS I would've cut out the exhausting days leading up to the birth, constant monitoring and worrying about the condition of baby. That being said if this was my first I would try VD because the way I see it is I wouldn't know unless I tried.

Sorry my post may not be helpful. You need to trust your gut. It doesn't matter if your experience with birth trauma is first or second hand, everyone has their reasons. I know those who work in birth theatre who've chosen ELCS through maternal choice.

Panickingpavlova · 30/07/2021 20:04

Your body your choice.

notapanday · 30/07/2021 19:56

but post maternal care regardless of delivery is pretty shit.

notapanday · 30/07/2021 19:55

I was induced with my first & was terrified of more intervention but only needed the pessary & that was it. My CS they needed a ventouse which apparently is not uncommon. I personally would rather not have had a CS as the way my skin doesn't lie flat on my stomach annoys me (vain!) but defo the right choice for my dc. You need to do what's best for you.

Schrutesbeets · 30/07/2021 19:53

YANBU!

gwenneh · 30/07/2021 19:49

@Miphy

Thanks for all the responses, most of which have been very helpful.

Not that I have to defend myself but a few weeks ago I thought I’d gotten over this and enthusiastically ordered stuff for perineal massage etc but then it doesn’t take much and I’m right back there again fearing the unknown.

I might be accused of drip feeding but I’m already under consultant led care because I have pre- existing conditions which are risk factors and it’s likely I won’t have a choice of where to give birth- it will probably be on the obstetric labour ward rather than the lovely midwife led unit on the same site with pools and birthing couches. This then in turn as some have pointed out means I’m more likely to end up with interventions and effectively being forced to give birth on my back in a bed- which is not how I wanted to attempt VD and makes me feel very anxious.

I’ve found antenatal care pretty lacking thus far- hard to contact, tick box exercises, unable to answer questions I have. I even got told to make sure I lie to the pharmacist 😳

I’m going to ask about my delivery options on Monday - I am willing to give VD a go if I can go in the active birthing suite if I go into spontaneous labour. I’m pretty against induction as a choice for me and would probably rather a CS still in that circumstance.

Knowing this, I would definitely say go for the C-section.

I was under consultant led care with pre-existing conditions and the insistence on a vaginal birth (by me, supported by the consultant and the midwife team although they had offered a C-section) had consequences which could have been avoided. They didn't let me anywhere NEAR the birthing centre, which is good because I ended up needed every bit of care the obstetric ward provided.

By contrast, the elective c-section with my third was lovely and relaxed, apart from not having the impetus of labour pains to encourage me to get the epidural!

Namenic · 30/07/2021 19:41

I’ve had a vaginal birth in obstetric unit and midwife-led birthing unit. Both were fine, about the same length. I think the birthing pool (nice though it was) - prolonged labour for me as it removed the effect of gravity.

Just because you are on obstetric unit doesn’t mean you have to be on your back. People move around. I’m pretty sure there would have been space for a big ball to sit on in mine. But different units are different - could you ask to visit a unit or see pictures of what the room is like?

The choice is yours. As this thread has shown - people have good and bad experiences with both these modes. Like you I’m nervous of induction and would consider c section. Talk to your your consultant and try and figure out what things are most important to you

notapanday · 30/07/2021 19:24

I had both a VB & a ECS & was quite shocked at the recovery tbh. Same for my friends who have experienced both. One could feel it so had to be knocked out.

Miphy · 30/07/2021 19:12

Thanks for all the responses, most of which have been very helpful.

Not that I have to defend myself but a few weeks ago I thought I’d gotten over this and enthusiastically ordered stuff for perineal massage etc but then it doesn’t take much and I’m right back there again fearing the unknown.

I might be accused of drip feeding but I’m already under consultant led care because I have pre- existing conditions which are risk factors and it’s likely I won’t have a choice of where to give birth- it will probably be on the obstetric labour ward rather than the lovely midwife led unit on the same site with pools and birthing couches. This then in turn as some have pointed out means I’m more likely to end up with interventions and effectively being forced to give birth on my back in a bed- which is not how I wanted to attempt VD and makes me feel very anxious.

I’ve found antenatal care pretty lacking thus far- hard to contact, tick box exercises, unable to answer questions I have. I even got told to make sure I lie to the pharmacist 😳

I’m going to ask about my delivery options on Monday - I am willing to give VD a go if I can go in the active birthing suite if I go into spontaneous labour. I’m pretty against induction as a choice for me and would probably rather a CS still in that circumstance.

OP posts:
1FootInTheRave · 30/07/2021 18:56

Your body and your choice.

Do the research on risk vs benefits of both and make an informed decision that suits you.

Do be conscious that your rl experiences will influence you. If you spent a few weeks observing pool deliveries etc then you may feel differently.

RedHelenB · 30/07/2021 18:16

@08Puppysharness not patronising at all The OP asked for opinions. As I said my natural birth with no pain relief was miles away from what I thought I could have after complications with the others. A c section takes more staff, ties up anaethetists, it's not as simple as saying every mother should have the choice on the NHS.

Laney79 · 30/07/2021 15:30

I had a MRCS. Absolutely right choice for me. I have a deep rooted fear of all things medical and as a result never thought I'd have children. I did hours and hours of research, including an foi to my trust looking at birth outcomes and interventions for first time moms over the age of 35. I poured over nice guidelines and evidence and loads of articles and studies.
In the end I concluded the more controlled/planned nature of a c section was best. I could prepare mentally for what was about to happen and put mitigations in place to help me cope. A VD was just too many variables. And longer term I was concerned about the impact emergency interventions and tears etc could have on me physically and mentally. In my trusts case over three years only 7% of first time moms over 35 made it through labour with no interventions, and no tearing. Those odds just weren't good enough for me!

It was the best choice and I thought before hand I'd only be able to handle having one baby. As it is it went so well I would dearly love to have a second, but age is not on my side. But if that wasn't the case I wouldn't hesitate and it would be another MRCS (in the hope it went as well second time round!)

TurquoiseDress · 30/07/2021 15:24

YANBU

I agree with all the reasons you've stated and echo your experiences in obstetrics & gynaecology

There are things you cannot un-see or erase from your memory, no matter how many hypno birthing books/resources that you read!

For me, I had an elective section for maternal request with baby number 1

Freely admit there was no clinical indication and it was mainly based on the experiences/knowledge like you have described

It was the right decision for me and no regrets

Baby number 2 also an elective CS

I would say go for, open the conversation with your midwife about a CS, if you get resistance I'd suggest trying your GP & see if you can be referred to consultant at hospital where you are booked

Swipe left for the next trending thread