Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for an maternal choice elective C-section?

259 replies

Miphy · 29/07/2021 20:23

I am 20 weeks with first baby- name changed for this thread.

Prior to pregnancy I was already leaning towards requesting a section. I am a doctor, not working in anything related to it now but obviously spent time in obs & gynae placements.
In my obstetric placement we had to spend a week with the midwifery team so that we had a chance to see ‘normal’ birth. Without exception every single birth I attended went ‘wrong’ and either ended with assisted delivery- forceps, episiotomy, in one case horrendous tearing, or emergency section and massive postpartum haemorrhage.
In contrast elective section list was lovely- but wham bam baby out, happy well rested mums.
Then later in gynaecology saw clinic lists full of women with birth injuries and PTSD.
This massively influenced my perception of birth.

I had thought more more about water births, hypo birthing etc and thought I may as well give it a go vaginally.

However the more reading I do now about birth the more I read about horrendous birth injuries, and of my friends the ones who had sections all fully recommend it whereas some of my friends who have had a vaginal birth have told me some pretty horrendous stories. One still can’t have sex two years later. I know there’s a recovery after section but somehow surgical recovery seems more straightforward and I’m not short of hands on help and support- both our mums are retired, husband works from home, all very keen to provide hands on help.

It feels to me like an elective section involves known small risks, I know what I’m getting. Whereas with a vaginal birth I can have some lovely water birth, minimal tearing, quick recovery, or I can end up exhausted from a prolonged labour maybe with a wrecked undercarriage, maybe a distressed baby and then even potentially a high chance of needing an emergency section with even higher risks. And it seems I won’t know which way it will go until it literally happens. It really feels like the injuries by women after vaginal birth are minimised and you’re just supposed to deal- so they aren’t treated as ‘risks’ in the same way.

I find myself hoping the baby is breech so my decision is made for me. I’m thinking Of asking about maternal choice section at my antenatal clinic appointment. I wondered if anyone had any experiences or any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bee38 · 04/08/2021 13:32

@Terrazzo

YANBU! But I had an ELCS and lost half my blood so it’s not necessarily flawless. But definitely more controlled.
Same here! Massive pph with an elective section. Elective sections very commonly have the perception of very little can go wrong but this is far from the truth.
milkieway · 04/08/2021 12:59

@Monday26July

The course I did actually wasn't like that though it wasn't pressure to have a "natural" birth, it just armed me with information about my options which enabled me to communicate better with my care providers and feel more positive about the process of giving birth whatever route this ended up being. I think feeling more informed and less anxious about the process is never a bad thing.

EarringsandLipstick · 04/08/2021 11:36

[quote MissChanandlerBong22]@EarringsandLipstick

And I’ve no idea about Ireland but in England that fact that the standard of care - both in maternity and elsewhere in the health service - dips out of hours, and particularly at weekends, has been extremely well-publicised.[/quote]
Happily that's not the case in Ireland. Sorry to hear that in the UK.

No need for the 🤷🏻‍♀️either. You provided some reasons, I countered with a post saying that an EMCS per se didn't mean there was an emergency. Just a response, that's all.

MissChanandlerBong22 · 04/08/2021 10:18

@EarringsandLipstick

And I’ve no idea about Ireland but in England that fact that the standard of care - both in maternity and elsewhere in the health service - dips out of hours, and particularly at weekends, has been extremely well-publicised.

MissChanandlerBong22 · 04/08/2021 10:12

@EarringsandLipstick

🤷‍♀️ Of course everything’s contingent on the situation. You asked why there would be an increase in morbidity associated with emergency sections. There is (it’s well-documented - you can just Google it). I’ve given some of the broad factors that explain why - I’m not saying they apply to every situation.

Monday26July · 04/08/2021 09:26

[quote KiwiDramaQueen]@Monday26July

But I do want to highlight that no amount of preparation of educating yourself on 'how to avoid interventions' is going to remove the need for those interventions if that's how it goes on the day. So much of birth is about luck: your body shape, your baby's positioning and size, your skin elasticity, none of which are things you have any control over.

This!!! Unless a positive birthing course or other preparation is going to change my risk profile, then I don’t see what good it will do for me.[/quote]
There's a real push I've noticed to promote 'natural birth' aka vaginal without pain medication or intervention, and a whole industry dedicated to telling women that if they just do these exercises, buy this course, buy this book, watch these breathing videos, they'll be able to have the birth they want (which invariably seems to be a vaginal unmedicated no intervention birth).

It's so exploitative. It might give someone a slight reduction in anxiety if they perceive that they have some control over whether they will end up needing intervention or not. But it's a facade. It's scary to realise that how you birth is largely out of your hands and stuff like hypnobirthing, spinning babies etc. give people the illusion that it'll all be okay as long as they do the right things.

And it of course has the effect of ensuring that women who required intervention or had a c section feel inferior and like they just didn't try hard enough or prepare enough. So much of it is down to luck and that's a scary thing to realise!

KiwiDramaQueen · 04/08/2021 09:15

@Monday26July

But I do want to highlight that no amount of preparation of educating yourself on 'how to avoid interventions' is going to remove the need for those interventions if that's how it goes on the day. So much of birth is about luck: your body shape, your baby's positioning and size, your skin elasticity, none of which are things you have any control over.

This!!! Unless a positive birthing course or other preparation is going to change my risk profile, then I don’t see what good it will do for me.

Lavender24 · 04/08/2021 08:58

It's your body and your choice but I'd always go with naturally if I could as I think the recovery from a c section looks so difficult. I had to have an episiotomy and ventouse delivery and I have quite a lot of scar tissue from being cut that still bothers me three years later but I'm still so glad that I didn't need a c section. I was so grateful to be up and about straight after the birth even though it was sore.

Thehighlandcoo · 04/08/2021 08:57

[quote Monday26July]@Thehighlandcoo

I had a straightforward water birth with gas and air and no stitches. Recovery was a breeze and genuinely felt back to normal after a week. I did soooooo much research on how to avoid interventions and did all the spinning babies activities to increase the chances of my daughter being in the best position for labour.

I'm really pleased that you got the birth you wanted! But I do want to highlight that no amount of preparation of educating yourself on 'how to avoid interventions' is going to remove the need for those interventions if that's how it goes on the day. So much of birth is about luck: your body shape, your baby's positioning and size, your skin elasticity, none of which are things you have any control over.

It was such a positive experience. I know that things do go wrong (in both vaginal and c section births) but ultimately, a straightforward vaginal birth is undeniably the best option for your body than major abdominal surgery - and there's nothing at this stage to suggest you won't have a straightforward vaginal birth.

Unfortunately short of a fortune teller there's no way for any of us to know which type of birth is the best option for OP, it's an informed gamble either way. It's really time we stopped telling women one form of birth is 'undeniably better' than another, and instead gave information about the risks and benefits of both and let people decide for themselves.

I'm not trying to be critical of you personally so I'm sorry if it comes across that way, I just see birth stories shared very frequently where a mother has 'done all the preparation' and 'had a straightforward birth with good recovery' as if the latter is a direct consequence of the former.[/quote]
Just giving my experience, like everyone else here.

EarringsandLipstick · 04/08/2021 08:50

They’re also more likely to be performed by less experienced doctors because they’re more likely to be performed out of hours, and more likely to be conducted under time pressure.

This is entirely untrue, certainly in Ireland, not sure why the UK would be different.
Plus the time pressure you describe is entirely contingent on the situation - an EMCS is simply one that wasn't planned, but there may not necessarily be any emergency.

Monday26July · 04/08/2021 08:43

@Thehighlandcoo

I had a straightforward water birth with gas and air and no stitches. Recovery was a breeze and genuinely felt back to normal after a week. I did soooooo much research on how to avoid interventions and did all the spinning babies activities to increase the chances of my daughter being in the best position for labour.

I'm really pleased that you got the birth you wanted! But I do want to highlight that no amount of preparation of educating yourself on 'how to avoid interventions' is going to remove the need for those interventions if that's how it goes on the day. So much of birth is about luck: your body shape, your baby's positioning and size, your skin elasticity, none of which are things you have any control over.

It was such a positive experience. I know that things do go wrong (in both vaginal and c section births) but ultimately, a straightforward vaginal birth is undeniably the best option for your body than major abdominal surgery - and there's nothing at this stage to suggest you won't have a straightforward vaginal birth.

Unfortunately short of a fortune teller there's no way for any of us to know which type of birth is the best option for OP, it's an informed gamble either way. It's really time we stopped telling women one form of birth is 'undeniably better' than another, and instead gave information about the risks and benefits of both and let people decide for themselves.

I'm not trying to be critical of you personally so I'm sorry if it comes across that way, I just see birth stories shared very frequently where a mother has 'done all the preparation' and 'had a straightforward birth with good recovery' as if the latter is a direct consequence of the former.

Thehighlandcoo · 04/08/2021 08:31

I think it's definitely based on the stories you hear. Based on my mum's experience with my brother and I (one emergency section, one elective section - both horrendous recoveries) and a friend who had an elective section and had infection after infection after infection meaning she couldn't hold or bond with her baby for months, I knew 100% that I did not want a c section.

I had a straightforward water birth with gas and air and no stitches. Recovery was a breeze and genuinely felt back to normal after a week. I did soooooo much research on how to avoid interventions and did all the spinning babies activities to increase the chances of my daughter being in the best position for labour.

It was such a positive experience. I know that things do go wrong (in both vaginal and c section births) but ultimately, a straightforward vaginal birth is undeniably the best option for your body than major abdominal surgery - and there's nothing at this stage to suggest you won't have a straightforward vaginal birth.

AntiSocialDistancer · 04/08/2021 08:02

YANBU

ame88 · 04/08/2021 08:01

@SmidgenofaPigeon

Your birth, your choice.

For what it’s worth however, at 32 weeks pregnant and about to go for a natural birth (hopefully) myself, I do find some of the things you’ve said scaremongering- and coming from quite a biased perspective.

Same! I'm 36 weeks and wish I'd never opened this thread
MissChanandlerBong22 · 04/08/2021 07:54

@EarringsandLipstick

As Monday says, EMCSs are usually performed where there’s already a concern about the baby or mother which obviously raises the risk of adverse outcomes. They’re also more likely to be performed by less experienced doctors because they’re more likely to be performed out of hours, and more likely to be conducted under time pressure. Also, the baby’s position is likely to be much lower (this is rare but I had a friend who had a failed forceps delivery - they pushed the baby back up the birth canal to perform the caesarean, so she was left with the worst of both worlds). Also I understand it’s more challenging to perform the surgery on a uterus that’s already contracting.

Monday26July · 04/08/2021 07:45

@EarringsandLipstick

an emergency caesarean would be associated with an increase in morbidity and mortality compared to a planned caesarean.

Why so?

What would happen in an emergency section that would differ from a planned one?

Just a hunch but I’d suspect it’s because the cases where an emergency c section is needed mean the baby or mother are already in trouble, whereas a planned c section there hasn’t been that birth process for things to go wrong. Not that the c section in either case causes an increase in problems, but the nature of the patients presenting to each will be very different.
milkieway · 04/08/2021 07:42

I did this course online and really found it helped my decision making with my birth and just made me feel more positive in general about the options and that I had some control over them thepositivebirthcompany.co.uk

EarringsandLipstick · 04/08/2021 06:48

In your OP you didn't mention pre-existing conditions that might lead to complications in labour.

Obviously if this is the case it makes sense to consider a planned section and of course you'll have that conversation with your obstetrician in good time.

EarringsandLipstick · 04/08/2021 06:46

an emergency caesarean would be associated with an increase in morbidity and mortality compared to a planned caesarean.

Why so?

What would happen in an emergency section that would differ from a planned one?

Miphy · 02/08/2021 23:49

I went for my appointment today only to find out I’d only been put down for scan and not to see obstetrician.
I was surprised and pointed out one of the consultants I’m under for joint care because of my pre- existing conditions had asked for bloods to be done.
They did bloods once they realised and I asked if I could speak to someone about options- I got told they wouldn’t entertain a discussion about it until 31-34 weeks. I suppose at least by then I’ll know better what the situation is with babies growth and also as I’m at high risk of developing pre- eclampsia that would really impact on the management. I do understand why- the community midwives won’t discuss birth options with me either so I don’t have any option but to hang on and see.
For me because of my pre existing conditions Im at increased risk of having complications during a vaginal delivery and an emergency caesarean would be associated with an increase in morbidity and mortality compared to a planned caesarean.
It’s all well and good saying making an evidence based decision and trust me I’m trying! However if I go for VD I could end up with fewer risks and better recovery than an elective section all being well, or if things go wrong because I am high risk anyway I face being stacked with a plethora of risks to my life and my baby’s life that would dwarf the risks of an elective section. I need to personally decide what my risk tolerance is and there is no ‘right’ answer.

I think I’ve made my decision that I will refuse induction if it is recommended, and request a section. However if I go into spontaneous labour then I may give it a crack….

OP posts:
FartnissEverbeans · 02/08/2021 22:01

@jgjgjgjgjg

I suggest you go away and read some actual research on the potential risks and complications of both vaginal and caesarean birth and make an evidence-based decision

You’re telling the OP, who is a qualified dr, to do her research? I really hope you’re also a dr or else this comment is the most patronising one in the entire thread.

FartnissEverbeans · 02/08/2021 21:56

@Draineddraineddrained Please let me know if I’m reading your comment incorrectly.

OP is a dr with an understanding of potential risks and interventions that we can safely say is well above average. Based on her knowledge and experiences, her instinct is to go for ELCS.

You’re saying that because she is a dr, a vaginal delivery will be less of a risk and require potentially fewer interventions.

However, the dr in question has witnessed vaginal deliveries with intervention, the necessity or otherwise of which she would have been able to assess presumably in a similar way to possible interventions presented during the birth of her own child (if anything, I imagine it would be easier to be objective about the former than the latter).

This is a really bizarre line of reasoning. She’s not saying ‘I saw unnecessary interventions and want to avoid that for myself’ - there’s no indication that she saw anything unnecessary. Perhaps natural childbirth is just, for the most part, shit?

Ziegfeld · 02/08/2021 20:47

ELCS all the way, for all the reasons you say. Your choice, don’t be bullied or shamed. Don’t dwell on the horror stories from people who’ve had emergency CSs - completely different scenarios.

nildesparandum · 02/08/2021 20:24

rantymcrantface66

I had both of my caesarean sections before bikini cuts were invented.
One long line descending from just below my belly button . It is still there right in the middle of my tummy a big indent.My babies are 51 and 49 now, the younger one is a grandfather!.
I know what you mean about being proud of the scars.Without them I would not have my sons and five grandchildren and two great grandchildren now.

Draineddraineddrained · 31/07/2021 19:50

Ooh another top tip from me is to ask for antenatal care from home birth team. Same midwife every time, in your own home which makes a colossal difference in terms of how you relate to them - coming and presenting yourself in a clinic in a hospital or similar place you are automatically on the back foot, as if you're being assessed and evaluated, whereas when the midwife comes to your home it is a reminder to both of you each time they are providing a service to you, the service user. I absolutely loved my antenatal care, which I had not expected as was going for an HBAC AMA so was expecting a lot of scolding and pressure. I wouldn't go for s home birth if I were to have a third baby as clearly my body just doesn't like getting babies out of it 😆 but I would definitely request antenatal care from the home birth team.

Swipe left for the next trending thread