Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask what is so special about blond hair

456 replies

pocpocpoc · 29/07/2021 18:20

My husband is white and English, I am not white and foreign. I have dark hair and my genetics pretty much guarantee that my children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren are almost 100% likely to have dark hair too.

DH's brother is married to a white English woman and their daughter is the same age as DD. She is taller than DD and has blond hair. Both are nice young ladies, reasonably attractive, but in different ways.

Something that bothered me for a long time, but I could only put a finger on recently, is how MIL (and others in the family) talk about DD's cousin's blond hair and height, almost as a counter-point to anything DD does that is of mention. For instance: "Well done for getting 12 A* GCSEs (saving a child from fire, winning Olympics, getting a Nobel prize), so proud of you being so academic/brave/athletic/hard-working and also of your cousin, who is a tall blond". I find it strange that DD is typically praised for something she has done and worked hard for, while her cousin is praised only for her looks.

Where it is getting ridiculous is that I noticed DH's sister doing the same thing, this time with our boys. Not long ago she said to me "aren't you lucky that your son has such a good friend to play with, with his beautiful head of blond hair" - the sentence really didn't make sense to me. Thinking back I realised that the blond hair has been brought up every time we met in the last couple of years.

In my culture we don't attribute any special value to blond hair. It is very rare, usually means that the blond person is of another ethnicity. Some people get their hair bleached, but it does not confer any superiority or praise. So help me to understand: what is so special about blond hair? AIBU to be bothered? AIBU to detect a hint of racism?

OP posts:
Kalvinette · 31/07/2021 12:20

I've never seen blonde Marys, Josephs or Jesuses before. They've always been brunette but rosy cheeked which does exist in the ME...

Kokeshi123 · 31/07/2021 12:12

Jesus and Mary are nearly always portrayed in art as fair and blue eyed when as Middle Easteners they would have been dark.

www.google.co.jp/search?sxsrf=ALeKk01U2SrQTPzJ3kfBRgC3bLYzpfvKTQ:1627729863933&source=univ&tbm=isch&q=mary+and+jesus+paintings&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwijsNGilo3yAhU9L6YKHVhQC_kQ7Al6BAgIEEM&biw=1116&bih=648

Google images suggest brownish coloring is commoner even in historic depictions. In modern renditions, they are invariably shown as Middle Eastern in appearance IME.

AlexaShutUp · 31/07/2021 12:09

@Peachee

I agree children with blonde curly hair are usually showered with compliments also..I don’t understand it either.
But children with curly hair of any colour get showered with compliments, don't they? My dd had dark ringlets as a toddler, and people commented on them all the time. Maybe people just find curls cute?
Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 12:09

@Comedycook

Sorry but it really irritates me when people just dismiss this as simply a preference. It really isn't that simple. It's hugely tied up with sub conscious racism, religious imagery, colourism, western beauty standards that we are exposed to all our lives
If a preference for blond is racist, is a preference for brown (tanned) skin also racist?
pocpocpoc · 31/07/2021 12:07

@whatthejiggeries
Not sure where you saw jealousy. I specifically said both girls are equally attractive, in different ways. I don’t think anyone, not even MIL suggested that one is more attractive than the other, that’s why I was trying to figure out what the fuss was about.
Blondes can be considered attractive in my country, but not based on hair colour alone. No one would make any extra fuss just on account of blonde hair alone, and it is much more rare than here.
I genuinely appreciate this thread as it explained a lot to me. As a foreigner I had no idea blonde (or any colour) hair carried so much significance. To my foreign eye, Kate Middleton was the idea of classic English beauty and I didn’t know that blondness was so prized.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 12:04

"when as Middle Easteners they would have been dark."

Apparently, there are fair-skinned people in that part of the world so we don't know. (not sure I'm totally convinced of this, but is what I've been told).

Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 12:02

"Yet skin that’s too pale isn’t seen as desirable either to some, hence the zillion different fake tabs available and places offering sun-bed sessions. That’s so dangerous and can cause cancer. All because they want to be brown."

Yep and now lip fillers to make our lips look more like African than European lips.
Beauty standards are not as clear cut as white being favoured.

Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 12:01

@Rinoachicken

Wonder if it’s rooted way further back for this country, so black hair = celt, red hair = soft or viking, blonde hair = european/germanic.

The Celts/Scots were (and still are?) looked down upon so that colour hair less prized perhaps as suggests Celt/Scot ancestry?

You're right, but I'd argue that red hair has now come to be seen as Celtic.
Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 11:59

@Icecreamsoda99

Interesting that your SIL gushes over the blonde hair on her son, it's usually the dark hair for boys and the blonde for girls - tall dark and handsome, looking at the Disney Princes - all black/brown hair bar one, while the Disney Princesses are majority blonde. It would pee me off as well OP.
I think blond is still sees as attractive in small boys, even if dark is seen as the ideal for grown men. (Probably because we don't value youth in men as much as we do in women in evolutionary terms).
PrincessNutella · 31/07/2021 11:58

Well, I love black hair. It is so beautiful.

Peachee · 31/07/2021 11:57

I agree children with blonde curly hair are usually showered with compliments also..I don’t understand it either.

Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 11:51

"It’s an unwritten law that Mary must be brunette!"

It wasn't when I was growing up. A primary school Mary doesn't have to look Israeli.

Gwenhwyfar · 31/07/2021 11:49

[quote whatthejiggeries]@Comedycook you were probably more attractive than your friend. No one would say an ugly blonde woman is more attractive than a beautiful brunette and lady gags is a case in point however two equally attractive people the blonde will get more attention. It's a fact [/quote]
I think blonde might be seen from further away so might get more heads being turned from eg men in cars. Also, a rarer hair colour as people have noted and the rarity factor might also work for very dark hair, but not for the average kind of mousy brown.
I had a colleague with long blonde hair who didn't get much flirting from the men at work who knew her, but was constantly pestered if she went to a nightclub.

whatthejiggeries · 31/07/2021 11:37

@AiyaNapawithmorenaps not really a good comparison. Lady GAga is not renowned for her beauty and Beyoncé whilst very beautiful arguably does fit western standards of beauty. We can debate whether this is right or wrong forever but Someone like Denise Van Outen in her heyday will always turn more heads than her brunette equivalent

whatthejiggeries · 31/07/2021 11:30

@Comedycook you were probably more attractive than your friend. No one would say an ugly blonde woman is more attractive than a beautiful brunette and lady gags is a case in point however two equally attractive people the blonde will get more attention. It's a fact

AiyaNapawithmorenaps · 31/07/2021 11:02

@Comedycook it's ludicrous. Think of Lady Gaga and Beyoncé, who would most people say is more conventionally attractive?

AlexaShutUp · 31/07/2021 10:52

@Anyother

I personally find bias in people who describe being gushed over/ their children being gushed over for having blond hair. How do you know this attention you have received wouldn't have come anyway had you had different hair colour? Why assume it's because of your superior blond status? I have blond and dark-haired dc blue eyed and brown eyed. They've all had their share of comments and are often called 'the children with the eyes' for their beautiful eyes. I personally find blond hair a bit boring and washed out looking and prefer the defined eyebrows and eyelashes that come with brown hair. But I appreciate true beauty whatever the shade. Humans come in all shapes and colours and I think part of embracing this diversity is appreciating beauty in all its forms.
I also wondered about this. My dark haired, dark eyed mixed race dd has also had tons of comments over the years and plenty of gushing - about her hair, about her eyes, even about her eyelashes ffs!

I have never assumed that any gushing was related to the colour of her hair/eyes/skin etc, but rather just because people like cute little kids/bubbly smiley teenagers and tend to comment on them!

Comedycook · 31/07/2021 10:41

Put two girls side by side one blonde one dark and the blonde will get more attention

This is absolute nonsense. Attractiveness is based on far more than just hair colour. Years ago when I was single and going out clubbing with my blonde friend I'd get far more male attention

boogiewithasuitcase · 31/07/2021 10:36

It's one thing to admire someone's blonde hair while also assessing their ability to be a good friend, do a good job, work hard at school, etc.

But it's clear that some people only see blonde hair as a magical spell that automatically gives the blonde person exceptional qualities in all walks of life!

This thread has been quite enlightening (and a bit depressing, tbh).

Anyother · 31/07/2021 10:31

I personally find bias in people who describe being gushed over/ their children being gushed over for having blond hair. How do you know this attention you have received wouldn't have come anyway had you had different hair colour? Why assume it's because of your superior blond status? I have blond and dark-haired dc blue eyed and brown eyed. They've all had their share of comments and are often called 'the children with the eyes' for their beautiful eyes. I personally find blond hair a bit boring and washed out looking and prefer the defined eyebrows and eyelashes that come with brown hair. But I appreciate true beauty whatever the shade. Humans come in all shapes and colours and I think part of embracing this diversity is appreciating beauty in all its forms.

AiyaNapawithmorenaps · 31/07/2021 10:07

@whatthejiggeries read your post back. Very offensive to say 'blondes are attractive, because of Western beauty standards and that's just the way it is.' What about challenging these standards?
Beauty is based on so many factors. Think of all the models who if you described on paper wouldn't sound beautiful but in real life are stunning. Just off the top of my head women I think of as beautiful are Lupita, Naomi Osaka, Penelope Cruz, Gemma Chan, Kate Winslet, Nadiya Hussein, Shakira, Jenelle Monae. As far as I know, beautiful people aren't based on just hair colour and skin colour alone, it's the whole package. Therefore any idea of a beauty 'standard' is complete tosh.

whatthejiggeries · 31/07/2021 09:56

The fact is, you can raise your kids not to be hung up in looks but in society looks do matter. Blonde hair is attractive. Maybe because it's unusual but also I think because it is an attractive colour. Mousy hair is also light and restricted to white people but not considered attractive. Put two girls side by side one blonde one dark and the blonde will get more attention. I am not blonde. It doesn't bother me and I can admire a nice blonde head of hair without any resentment. And yes it may be a western ideal of beauty but err ... that's where we live. The OP has said where she comes from blondes are not considered attractive. Here they are. I don't get the issue and to me it does seem that there's some underlying jealousy here that the other grandchildren are more attractive- hers are clearly more intelligent. Both will have advantages in life for different reasons. It would be nice to be both but not many of us have it all. We just have to make the most of what we have.

Novelusername · 31/07/2021 07:42

That's so true, PepperPrig, I have to stop myself always calling my friend's child a 'little princess' because I don't want to always talk about a little girl's looks, but it's just what we've learned as children is affectionate and when done in this way perhaps pretty harmless.

Sunshineandalltherainbows · 31/07/2021 01:05

My children are very blonde, my ten year old in particular. They get really annoyed because people ruffle their hair a lot and they don't like it. I have no idea why people do this to them because I know this never happened to me when I was younger.

headintheproverbial · 30/07/2021 23:26

I am blond and I can 100% relate to OP's comments. I had people gush at me as a child because of it, speak to my mum about it and generally admire my hair. I also think that facially I'm not that attractive but that o always, always had more attention from men than a similar looking person with different coloured hair. I don't know why, but it just is. Even now as an adult I still have naturally blond hair and if it ever comes up that I don't dye it people rave about it. It's bizarre.